How Batman Would Defeat Every Spider-Man Villain
Batman has a famous rogues gallery, but how would the hero handle the worst foes of Spider-Man?
On the surface, Batman and Spider-Man are very different heroes. Batman is a sombre and determined man who spent years training his body to fight crime. He learned most of the world’s martial arts and fighting styles. Bruce is terse, quiet, and guarded. Batman operates best in the dark and would prefer that the world thinks of him as a myth.
Spider-Man is a younger, seemingly happier man who received his powers from a freak spider bite as a teen. Peter constantly uses humor as a defense mechanism to keep opponents and friends off guard. Spider-Man thrives in the public eye. Peter makes his money making sure that Spidey is seen being heroic. But if you look deeper, you’ll see two brilliant men with incredible scientific minds that were pushed toward heroism by the tragedy in their lives.
Another similarity is that both heroes have eclectic rogues galleries. They both have had to deal with gangsters and thugs, seemingly untouchable crime bosses, costumed and super-powered bad guys, and actual monsters.
It’s interesting to imagine what would happen when you pull someone like the Dark Knight from a completely different universe and put him in harm's way in Spider-Man’s world.
15. Black Cat
Felicia Hardy was the daughter of a world-renowned cat burglar who was trained by his mentor, the White Fox. She initially donned the persona of the Black Cat to break her father out of prison when she encountered Spider-Man, who she quickly became infatuated with. Drawn into his world of super-heroics, she wanted powers to make her his equal. The procedure gave her an aura of “bad luck”. Her relationship with Spider-Man has waxed and waned as has her status as a hero or a villain.
With his years of experience dealing with his own cat-themed female of shifting morality, one would think that Black Cat would be easy for Batman to deal with. It’s important to remember that Felicia’s speed, strength, agility, and reflexes are all at Olympic levels and are augmented by her costume to near-superhuman levels.
The biggest problem dealing with Black Cat is not her skills or her claws but her Tychokinesis, or bad luck powers. This power directly effects the probability within her line of sight, causing unlikely, improbable, but not impossible things to happen. The only way for Batman to combat this is to do the unexpected and hope to catch the Cat by surprise.
14. Prowler
Hobart “Hobie” Brown grew up one of nine children to an alcoholic mother causing the children had to fend for themselves. To make money, Hobie became a window cleaner. After being in the middle of a fight between Daredevil and Stilt-Man, Hobie decided to create a costumed identity of his own… to aid in his window washing. Originally his wrists and ankle bracelets were filled with cleaning fluid and his clawed gloves and boots aided him in climbing. When he lost his job, he added a mask and glider cape and replaced the washer fluid with sleeping gas pellets. He embarked on his life of crime under the name The Prowler.
Despite being a genius-level inventor, an Olympic-level athlete, and an expert martial artist, The Prowler has spent most of his career getting his stolen Prowler costume back from various other criminals and helping Spider-Man keep his secret identity intact by portraying the hero in costume.
On paper, the Prowler looks like a Batman without the vast fortune, a belt full of gadgets, and a massive cave. They have similar skills, use similar equipment and wear specialized costumes. But the Prowler wouldn’t last a minute against the Batman in any serious fight.
13. Shocker
Herman Schultz was a pathetically bad criminal who spent most of his youth in and out of prison. During one stint, he worked in the prison machine shop and created his Vibro-Shock Gauntlets and a specially insulated costume to take the costumed identity of the Shocker. With these devices, he could shock opponents, deflect blows, and crack open safes. He even beat Spider-Man on his first outing, although the hero did have a broken arm.
Given that Batman was a gifted designer and inventor himself, it seems very likely that he would be able to create a device that would match or overcome the resonance frequency of the shock gauntlets. Even without the additional preparation time, defeating the gauntlets is the key to defeating the Shocker. A Batarang in the right place would short out or potentially overload the gauntlets.
Despite his claims that he is the world’s greatest safecracker, Shocker has had severe bouts of low self-esteem and a lack of confidence in his life. This is something that Batman could use against the villain to end the fight before it ever starts. Playing into Schultz’s history of constant failure and defeat would possibly be enough to get the Shocker to just give up.
12. Chameleon
Dmitri Nikolaievich Smerdyakov used his natural skills as a mimic and an impersonator to try to gain the love of his abusive stepfamily, including half brother Sergei Kravinoff, the future Kraven the Hunter. His skills brought him to the attention of a man called the Finisher and he gained such skill in disguise and impersonation that he earned the name The Chameleon. He first came on Spider-Man’s radar when he tried to frame the hero for stealing plans for a new missile defense system.
As a master of disguise himself, Batman is likely to not be fooled by anything less than the most perfect impersonation, especially if it is someone that Bruce knows well. Batman would know most of the skills that Chameleon employs and his observation skills would spot something that was out of place. Batman would notice a slip in accent or a mole out of place.
There wouldn’t even be a problem with a physical altercation. Because of the abuse that Dmitri suffered early in life, the normally scary Dark Knight might be enough to make the Chameleon quit immediately. The least bit of aggressive behavior on Batman’s part would see the Chameleon crumble to the floor.
11. Rhino
Aleksei Sytsevich was a Russian thug of low intelligence who was desperate to take care of his family. To do that, he underwent a series of procedures to bond him into a powerful suit of armor resembling a rhinoceros. Aleksei’s first assignment was to kidnap astronaut John Jameson for ransom. This brought him into contact with Spider-Man, who defeated Rhino with relative ease. Aleksei would find defeat at Spider-Man's hands repeatedly and make several attempts to shed the Rhino armor but circumstances continually pulled him back in.
Batman has a long history of dealing with larger-than-life foes that did not exactly tax the Dark Knight Detective’s intellect. This is one of those occasions where Batman’s long years of learning nearly every fighting style that exists on Earth (and a few that are literally out of this world) comes in handy.
The fact that Rhino is unable to change directions or stop quickly once he gets up to speed is an advantage that Batman could easily use, especially in the jagged and quickly turned streets of Gotham. If not running headlong into a building, Rhino could easily find himself running straight into the Gotham River or off one of Gotham’s many high rooftops.
10. Scorpion
Private investigator Mac Gargan was paid by J. Jonah Jameson to undergo a procedure to create a foe for Spider-Man. Dr. Farley Stillwell created an experiment that endowed Gargan with a variety of powers and a costume with a devastating mechanical tail. The experiment cost Gargan his sanity, though, and while he happily attacked Spider-Man, he also attacked Jameson. Gargan came to believe that the experiment had trapped him in the Scorpion suit and, more often than not, ol' Web-head had to save Jameson’s life.
Scorpion possessed a level of speed, strength, and agility that would make a physical confrontation extremely dangerous for Batman. Scorpion’s tail can strike at 90 miles an hour and he possesses the ability to lift 15 tonnes. Even though it would limit his agility greatly, meeting Scorpion in battle from inside one of his armored Batsuits would be the smarter tactical move for Bats.
An even smarter move would be to reach out to some of his colleagues in the Justice League. Wonder Woman or any member of the Superman family would have the speed and invulnerability to deal with Scorpion’s hybrid nature and deadly tail. Batman could also call Vixen or Animal Man and use “scorpion against scorpion” to win the day.
9. Sandman
William Baker, aka Flint Marko, was a child of poverty who learned to steal at an early age. After years as a petty criminal, Marko was in the vicinity of a nuclear accident that affected a body-wide change which gave him the ability to transform his body. Flint has flipped between being a villain, a mercenary hero with Silver Sable’s Wild Pack, and a brief stint as an Avenger in training.
Sandman has never been a villain of the “world domination” variety. He just wanted to get rich. Batman may be able to appeal to Marko’s better nature or his greed. Either way would prevent the fight that the Caped Crusader would rather not have against a foe he would have a difficult time defeating.
Using water to dissipate his form or heat to fuse his form into glass has been the way of dealing with Sandman’s villainous actions previously. Batman has used extreme cold similar to what Mr. Freeze generates to deal with Clayface. It is possible this approach could work with Sandman if he is caught with a significant amount of his form intact. If Marko is too spread out, the single grain that holds his consciousness may escape the cold.
8. Kingpin
Growing up a poor child, Wilson Fisk went on a mission of self-improvement, and extensive reading, and gained strength, and physical power through bodybuilding. He used business techniques to organize the juvenile gangs, earning him the mocking nickname of “Kingpin”. Fisk worked as a bodyguard and an enforcer in the Maggia crime families and advanced through the ranks until he controlled larger areas of organized crime. Wilson invested the money from those crimes in legitimate businesses. He organized all the crime on the Eastern Seaboard and used the name the Kingpin of Crime.
Batman takes a special interest in “untouchable” crime bosses, especially when these corrupt individuals achieve political office as Fisk did as Mayor of New York City. Perhaps, it is because his family essentially built Gotham and he has spent so much effort improving it, Bruce takes their actions personally.
Batman might make the mistake of assuming Kingpin is fat instead of solid muscle. And, as sumo was not one of the disciplines that Wayne delved into in his studies, it might give Fisk a brief advantage if he gets Batman in a bear hug. However, Batman’s array of martial arts skills will no doubt send the larger man reeling in no time.
7. Electro
Electric company lineman Max Dillon was struck by lightning while holding onto an electrical line. This caused a body-wide change that turned him into a living electrostatic generator. Donning a costume and using his electrical powers to rob banks and accumulate the wealth the perpetually poor man always desired. This brought him into conflict with Spider-Man, who beat him on a regular basis, either alone or as part of various incarnations of the Sinister Six.
It’s important that Batman kept Electro from recharging from any source. The Dark Knight would also have to keep any of his equipment from being disrupted by either electrical or electromagnetic discharge from Dillon’s powers. Max could even disrupt the electrical currents of Batman’s brain if he got close enough. Clearly, this would be a challenging fight for the World's Greatest Detective.
With water and overloading his powers being two of the few ways to overcome Electro, Batman will have a fight on his hands, even in a suitably grounded Batsuit. One of the things that will work in Batman’s favor is that Dillon is not a very intelligent man. Secondly, he is an extremely greedy one. Batman could simply give him a better offer.
6. Lizard
Gifted surgeon Dr. Curt Connors lost his right arm while saving soldiers in a war-torn region. Connors began experimenting with lizards that had the capabilities to regenerate limbs to create a serum that he might use to regrow his own. Connors created a serum and used himself as the first subject. His arm began to regrow but he began to mutate into a vicious reptile creature called the Lizard. Over time, Conner’s mind has controlled his Lizard form, while his Lizard mind has likewise controlled his human form.
Batman’s adventures with members of his own rogues' gallery could help him with dealing with the Lizard. Helping Dr. Kurt Langstrom’s alter ego, Man-Bat, may turn Batman toward working with Connors to finally cure his transformations into the Lizard and perhaps even refine it enough that it could replace the doctor’s arm.
If Batman has to fight the Lizard, his altercations with his own reptilian menace, Killer Croc, will come in handy. While the Lizard is smaller and more agile, he possesses super strength that makes him Croc’s superior. The Lizard's speed, while not superhuman, will require Batman to either take his foe by surprise or utilize one of his many vehicles to bridge the gap.
5. Mysterio
Quentin Beck was a movie special effects artist and a stunt man that initially committed his first crime on a dare. But after an accident on one of his sets got him blackballed from the industry, Beck pursued crime in earnest as Mysterio. He's suffered numerous defeats at the hands of Spider-Man, causing Beck bouts of depression, but he continued to plague Spidey, both solo and as part of the Sinister Six.
Although Mysterio is unlike most villains Bruce Wayne has ever faced, some of his methods mirror those of several Batman villains. Mysterio’s hallucinogenic gas is not unlike the Scarecrow’s fear toxin. His use of philological mind controlling methods is similar to those employed by Hugo Strange, and the minor villain Film Freak has trapped the Caped Crusader and others in seemingly lifelike but invented scenarios.
Mysterio will ultimately have a very hard time fooling Batman. Bats is obsessive about details and is the most observant man in the world. If their fight was in Gotham, it would have to be perfect down to the slightest detail. Bruce knows Gotham’s every street and alley, meaning if the villain got even the smallest detail wrong, the illusion would literally be shattered with one well placed Batarang.
4. Venom
Spider-Man acquired the alien symbiote on Battleworld during the Secret Wars event. When Peter discovered it was a sentient being that had been controlling him in his sleep, he tried to remove it. It took the bells at Our Lady of Saints Church to make the creature retreat from Parker’s body. Failed photographer Eddie Brook was in the Church below and the creature bonded with him. Having absorbed Spider-Man’s powers, the pair became Venom.
Batman would be in trouble if it comes down to a purely physical altercation. With Venom able to lift 70 tonnes and having Spider-Man’s powers, Bats' athleticism and fighting skills might fall short. If any of the symbiote broke off and infected the Dark Knight, it’s hopeful that his indomitable will would be enough to allow him to break free.
Given the symbiote's susceptibility to loud noises and sonic blasts, Batman may want to ask Black Canary for her assistance, or he could create a gadget that mimics Dinah’s Canary Cry. Once the symbiote has left Brock’s body, it wouldn’t be too hard to contain it in a vessel with a sonic emitter built in. Although getting the creature off planet would be the best bet.
3. Dr. Octopus
Dr. Otto Octavius was a brilliant if arrogant scientist who created a harness with four mechanical arms to better handle dangerous materials. An accident bathed him in radiation that fused the harness to his body and made the connection to the arms a mental one and turned the doctor into a criminal. “Doc Ock” almost married Peter’s Aunt May once and took over Peter’s body for a time but was pushed to become a “superior” Spider-Man.
If Batman has one “superpower”, it’s his incredible mind. Bruce Wayne has such a strong mind and will that it is unlikely Dr. Octopus would be able to switch minds with him unless Bruce was caught completely by surprise. And if he did, Batman would fight viciously to get control of his own mind back. Even if Otto had succeeded, it's unlikely that he could have done much to make a "superior" Batman.
Otto’s arrogance and assumption that he is always the smartest person in the room is an easy target for Batman to attack. It will immediately cause him to make mistakes. Also, if the Caped Crusader can keep Ock's mechanical arms otherwise engaged, it would only take a single punch to deal with the pudgy doctor.
2. J. Jonah Jameson
There is no single person to have a greater effect on the life of Spider-Man than J. Jonah Jameson. The Daily Bugle publisher has allowed Spidey's alter-ego of Peter Parker to continue to live interdependently in New York City, but did so at the expense of the costumed identity of Spider-Man. Jameson has turned public opinion against the Wall-crawler from the beginning of his career. JJ claims that he distrusts all vigilantes, but he has particular ire for Spider-Man.
It is possible that Batman would completely ignore the loud-mouth Jameson. Historically, Bats would prefer that he be thought of as an urban myth or as some kind of inhuman monster to the criminal community, so it is highly possible that he would just let Jameson rant on while the Dark Knight continued his mission.
Alternately, Bruce might grow tired of the noise and buy the entire paper and the building that houses it. Then, he’d kick Jameson out and promote Robbie Robertson as Editor of the Daily Bugle. It is likely that when Batman discovered that Jameson paid for the creation of several villains and Spider-Slayer robots, he'd would treat him like any other criminal and send him to prison.
1. Green Goblin
No costumed villain has had as much of an impact on Peter Parker than the Green Goblin.
Norman Osborn threw Peter’s girlfriend from the George Washington Bridge, leading to her death. Norman’s son Harry, Peter’s best friend, donned his own villainous costume to make the hero pay for his father’s death. Going further, Norman had actually lived and engineered the cloning of Peter - and these are just a handful of things the Goblin has done.
Batman would probably try to reach Norman Osborn first. Bruce would try to speak to him as a fellow scientist and meet Norman on an intellectual level to try to defuse the fight before it even starts. He would probably play on Norman’s heroic accomplishments and make Osborn think he is helping Batman.
If it does come down to a fight, the Dark Knight needs to get the Goblin down to his level. In the comics, Batman doesn’t have any flying equipment that equals the manoeuvrability of the Goblin Glider. Once that is dealt with, the Pumpkin Bombs aren’t much more than overpowered explosive Batarangs, and Batman’s fighting prowess is a match for the increase in strength his formula provides Osborn.