10 Actors Who Had Awesome Directorial Debuts

Ryan Gosling's directorial debut fell flat on its face at Cannes this past week but thankfully these thesps had better luck with their filmmaking firsts.

How many times have we heard actors pull out that old line about how they love acting, but what they really want to do is direct? It seems like an inevitable progression for a lot of actors, borne either out of a desire to exert greater creative control over the process, or simply as a way to maintain active in the industry after their looks aren't enough to sell tickets anymore. Regardless, it's a very common goal in Hollywood to finally be in the position of running an entire film. But is every actor cut out for that role? After Ryan Gosling, an actor who seems determined to try his hand at everything, was met with a less than enthusiastic response to his directorial debut Lost River at the Cannes Film Festival, it became easy to see that even for good actors it isn't always an easy road to work behind the camera. But then there are some actors that seem to transition seamlessly into a directorial role, and really find a niche for themselves right off the bat. Some, we dare say, are better at directing than they ever were at acting.

10. Robert Redford - Ordinary People

Despite Robert Redford's status as one of America's most beloved actors, he's never actually won an Oscar for his performances. In fact, his first and only competitive Oscar came in 1981, when he directed Ordinary People. That's how good his film debut was. Since then, he's gone on to a celebrated behind the scenes career, directing films such as A River Runs Through It, Quiz Show, The Horse Whisperer, and The Legend of Baggar Vance. His efforts behind the camera prove once and for all that Robert Redford is incredibly talented at three things (at least): looking gorgeous, acting, and coaxing great performances out of his stars. His directorial debut Ordinary People was not only acknowledged for his filmmaking, but won a Best Actor Oscar for Timothy Hutton as well as two nominations for Mary Tyler Moore and Judd Hirsch (Best Actress and Best Supporting Actor, respectively). His films all feature more than a touch of sentimentality, but he has a real artist's eye for storytelling that keeps them from veering too far into the world of melodrama.

9. Rob Reiner - This Is Spinal Tap

Rob Reiner has cultivated such a well-respected career for himself as a director that a lot of people don't even realize that when he first got started in Hollywood, he was primarily known as an actor. He was just the lovable meathead on All in the Family that Archie Bunker loved to abuse. But then, in the early 1980s, he came out with This is Spinal Tap, which totally changed his career forever. It was the story of an eccentric English rock band way past their Sell By date and fighting the inevitable onslaught of irrelevancy with darkly comedic results. This is Spinal Tap revolutionized the genre of mockumentary filmmaking, and turned Rob Reiner from a B-list television actor into an incredibly sought after director. He didn't squander his big opportunity either -- he followed Spinal Tap with When Harry Met Sally, The Sure Thing, The Princess Bride, and Stand by Me, in what is probably one of the biggest hot streaks in terms of popular filmmaking.

8. Zach Braff - Garden State

For a brief, shining moment, Zach Braff was the future of the mainstream independent film movement. His film debut Garden State shows a natural flair for setting up visually interesting shots as well as creating a fantastic soundtrack, and it certainly struck a chord with audiences. Garden State is the story of an actor, heavily doped up on lithium since an incident in his childhood, who returns to his hometown after the death of his mother. It touches on themes that twenty-somethings were able to relate to, the pain and awkwardness of trying to return to the home of your childhood that doesn't really exist anymore. It was a major success, and although he hasn't followed it up with another cinematic achievement as of yet, early buzz for his new film Wish I Was Here, it seems like he might have another winner on his hands. Hopefully he's able to recreate some of the magic from Garden State and do for people in their mid-30s what he did for twenty-somethings.

7. Joseph Gordon-Levitt - Don Jon

At this point, we have to just throw our hands up in the air and admit that it just might be possible that Joseph Gordon-Levitt can do no wrong. He's always stood out among his peers for picking interesting and complex projects, even when he was a teenager trying to transition from a child star to an adult career. So it stands to reason that when he decided to direct his first film, it would be something with a little bit more substance than your average rom com. On the surface, Don Jon was basically about a sex-obsessed dude bro and his relationships. But there's also an interesting commentary on masculinity and pornography, as explored by the main character. It's too early to tell if he'll return to the director's chair in the future, as his dance card is pretty full with acting roles for the next few years, but even if he doesn't, Don Jon was an impressive outing for a young director.

6. Richard Ayoade - Submarine

Richard Ayoade is probably one of the smartest actors of his generation in the industry today (he even went to Cambridge and performed with Footlights), so it makes sense that he would be eager to experiment with other aspects of filmmaking. He's well known these days for a slightly subversive sense of humor as seen in The Mighty Boosh and The IT Crowd, but it's been clear for quite some time that he has an interest in working behind the camera as well. For a number of years now, he's been directing music videos for Arctic Monkeys, Super Furry Animals, and Vampire Weekend, each displaying a natural skill and a dynamic use of the camera. It was inevitable that he would transition into feature films at some point, which he did in 2010 with Submarine. The film is characteristically eccentric, centering around a Welsh teenager who wants to lose his virginity and see his struggling parents reconcile. We can't wait to see what Ayoade comes out with next.

5. Charles Dance - Ladies In Lavender

It seems that Charles Dance, who currently stars as the cruelly ambitious Tywin Lannister on Game of Thrones, has a bit of a sentimental streak. How else do you explain Ladies in Lavender? Sure, it doesn't have the most promising title, but it's actually a surprisingly interesting film. It's the story of two elderly sister who live in a remote manor in Cornwall during the 1930s, when a mysterious foreigner washes up on shore, adapted from a short story by William J. Locke. They take the mysterious young man into their home while he recuperates, and over time, they become increasingly attached to him in their own ways. To be fair, when you've got Judi Dench, Maggie Smith, and the underrated German actor Daniel Brühl, you don't have a ton to worry about as a director. But still, Charles Dance works with his talented actors to coax out on pervasive feeling of melancholy and longing that elevates Ladies in Lavender above what some people might derisively refer to as a chick flick.

4. Ben Affleck - Gone Baby Gone

Ben Affleck has to have had one of the most turbulent careers in Hollywood history. His love/hate relationship with the media and audiences in general is enough to give a casual bystander whiplash. For many years, he was an incredibly in-demand actor, a handsome matinee idol who may not have been the strongest actor, but could certainly put butts in seats. Then he had his ill-fated relationship with Jennifer Lopez, and everything changed. Viewers began to tire of the media blitzkreig that was Bennifer, and unfortunately this loss of favor occurred at the same time as the release of Gigli and Jersey Girl, two of the worst films in recent memories. He went from the top of the world to being a Hollywood laughingstock. But he pulled an unbelievably smart move -- he laid low for a little while, and let everyone move on. Then when he came back, it was behind the camera, where he could reinvent himself as a director with the gritty crime drama Gone Baby Gone. As a debut film, it caught the attention of audiences and Hollywood insiders alike, earning a Best Supporting Actress nod for Amy Ryan. Since then, he hasn't disappointed us yet, releasing The Town and Argo, and proving that maybe the director's chair is where he really belongs.

3. Ben Stiller - Reality Bites

Despite the fact that Ben Stiller is primarily known as an actor, usually the straight man who is constantly overwhelmed by his ridiculous surroundings, he's actually been directing for quite some time. His first feature length film came in 1994, when he directed and starred in Reality Bites with Gen X icons Ethan Hawke and Winona Ryder. It was a movie that a lot of people immediately felt a kinship to, that they could see themselves in these cynical and disillusioned young adults -- in short, it was a film that had a soul. He's been sporadically directing since then, and his films tend to fall into a certain niche of dark comedies that aren't always fully appreciated after being released, but usually develop a cult following. His hits include The Cable Guy, Tropic Thunder, and Zoolander, films that subscribe to the basic tenets of comedic filmmaking but somehow have this weird, unique perspective that make them simultaneously less accessible and more rewarding for audiences who are willing to ruminate on them for a little while.

2. Tom Hanks - That Thing You Do

Tom Hanks strikes us as less of an actor who wanted to transition into directing (as so many do, as sort of a fallback for when their looks begin to fade), and more of a man who had a story that he really wanted to tell. That Thing You Do isn't just a film that he directed, he was involved in pretty much every aspect of the filmmaking process. It charts the rise and fall of a fictional band during the early 1960s, from their humble beginnings in small town Pennsylvania to their massive implosion after a historical appearance on The Hollywood Television Showcase (an homage to the Ed Sullivan Show). And it's Tom Hanks' baby from start to finish. He not only directed the film, but he also wrote the screenplay and several songs featured in the movies (Loving You Lots and Lots and Guy's I Am Spartacus drum solo) as well as co-starring in it as the band's manager, Mr White. Since then, he's worked closely with directors on many projects, but didn't direct again until 2011's Larry Crowne, a film he also co-wrote with My Big Fat Greek Wedding's Nia Vardalos.

1. Dennis Hopper - Easy Rider

When your very first film is Easy Rider, a film that defined the counterculture movement in the late 1960s and sparked the New Hollywood style of filmmaking, capturing the imagination of an entire generation in the process, you can pretty much just pack up and go home, because you're never going to be able to top it. Such is Dennis Hopper's story. Back in 1969, he made a movie about two bikers (himself and Peter Fonda) who went on a road trip through the American Southwest. Easy Rider depicted with frankness all the ins and outs of the hippie lifestyle, including actual drug use on camera, which was shocking for suburban audiences, who had likely never seen anything like it. The film shined a light on all of the societal issues that plagued the time period, and created a realistic portrayal of people who just wanted to get out and do things their own way. As an actor, Dennis Hopper had many other strong performances, but in terms of directing, he never topped the success or the significance of that first film, Easy Rider.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.