10 Biggest Gaming Controversies Of 2017 (So Far)

Cultural appropriation, religious outrage, bad animation - we've had it all this year.

2017 Video Games
Bioware/Sony/Ubisoft

2017 has been a great year for games. Between new console launches, bombastic E3 announcements and GOTY candidates dropping every other week, there's been a surprising amount of positive news in this first half of the year, and we've still got the biggest months to come.

But just because there's been a lot to enjoy so far doesn't mean that 2017 has been any less controversial than any of the years that came before it. The industry is still plagued by the same problems that have haunted the entire console generation so far, and botched releases, questionable developer actions and fan outrage has still dominated the news over these past seven months.

Also it hasn't helped that in the current political and social climate any little thing can be transformed into a sensational controversy seemingly overnight. Hell, even a journalist breaking a story about a game delay before it's official can lead to drama and death threats these days. Outrage over anything and everything has become commonplace, and it's only made the already over-the-top gaming industry even more volatile in 2017.

10. Everything About Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare Remastered

Call Of Duty Modern Warfare Remastered
Activision

Modern Warfare Remastered is reflective of everything that's wrong with the video game industry today.

The remaster of one of the most beloved shooters of all time was released last year bundled with the collector's edition of Infinite Warfare, meaning that you had to pay almost double the price if you wanted to get your hands on it. Oh, and they made sure that nobody could pick up the game separately without also owning Infinite Warfare, as you needed to have that disc inserted to even boot up MW Remastered.

That's bad enough, but the game released lacking some of the original multiplayer maps, with the remainder of these levels being added in a few months later. Even then though Modern Warfare's DLC maps were nowhere to be seen - at least until Activison revealed that they were re-selling them on top of the base game for even more money than when they were originally released nearly 10 years ago.

And the saga still continues today, with an individual release of the remastered title (without DLC of course) being made available to PlayStation 4 owners, and PlayStation 4 owners only.

By being greedy, Activision ruined what could have been the most successful remaster ever.


9. Take-Two Removes Mod Support For Grand Theft Auto V

Mario Kart GTA Mod
YouTube

The GTA series has been home to one of the most vibrant and active modding communities on the internet for years now, giving players the pleasure of being able to make some crazy alterations and additions to both the fourth and fifth game in the series.

The popularity of the GTA modding scene was particularly thanks to Open IV, an accessible modding tool for the games that became hugely popular within the community. But after years of operating fairly and ensuring that the mods didn't break any of the terms and conditions tied to the game's software, the people behind the site were hit with a cease and desist order that threatened legal action if they didn't remove their tools and resources.

Even though they tolerated it until now - and even promoted it themselves on multiple occasions - Take-Two decided that modding was illegal and unethical - probably because they were worried that it would somehow stop people from buying endless shark cards in GTA Online.

Take-Two have since relented and came to a compromise on the situation, but the way they went about it, seemingly deciding out the blue that mods were wrong while shunting a community that had shown them nothing but admiration over the years, won't do them any favours in the future.


8. Mass Effect Andromeda's Botched Animations

Andromeda animation badness
Electronic Arts

Becoming a meme overnight (and being almost as terrifying as the faceless character glitch from Assassin's Creed: Unity), videos of Mass Effect Andromeda's creepy, lifeless animations were the first sign that the highly anticipated sequel had gone very, very wrong.

In the run up to release the internet was flooded with hilarious videos and ridiculous gifs of the game's animation and physics system going completely haywire. Obviously what should have been a funny couple of days completely span out of control, with one developer who worked on the game receiving death threats over social media - even though she wasn't the one to blame.

In the end it turned out that the problems ran deeper than shoddy animations and technical shortcomings though. The entire development of the game was in turmoil up to its official release, with the Andromeda that hit shelves resembling nothing of the original concept the developers started working towards four years ago.


7. Friday The 13th Developers Get Death Threats For Banning A Player

Friday The 13th
Paramount

People get banned from online games all the time, so when a player was restricted from accessing the multiplayer of Friday the 13th earlier this year for sexually harassing two female players over the party chat, it wasn't enough to make the news.

However what came afterwards was. Instead of condemning the aggressive behaviour of the player after hearing the statement of what provoked the response, fans pointed out that the other players themselves should have also been banned because they collaborated to help Jason find and kill the other characters, something which is against the game's official rules.

In response to kicking the guy for harassing the two women (and a child) online, the title's developers received death threats and had their servers attacked over the decision, only adding more controversy onto this already divisive and volatile release.


6. Call Of Duty: WWII's Lack Of Diversity (And Nazi Censorship)

Call of duty WW2
Activision

Although it's successfully avoided controversy for a few years now (we've come a long way from the media frenzy surrounding the "No Russian" scene in Modern Warfare 2), the reveal of the upcoming Call of Duty: WWII once again landed the popular series in hot water earlier this year.

In one camp we had those who were outraged that the developers had talked about the inclusion of minority and women characters as if they were back-of-the-box features, reduced to a checklist of things to include in a game out of obligation rather than with a desire to accurately represent their lives and issues in the narrative.

In the other camp however there were people screaming "censorship!" because images of swastikas had been removed from the game's multiplayer modes and the developers revealed that you could play as non-white Nazis.

Both controversies launched Call of Duty back into the public discussion for all the wrong reasons - but hey, at least they got people talking about the ageing series once again.


5. Horizon Zero Dawn Is Criticised For Cultural Appropriation

Horizon Aloy
Sony

An otherwise universally revered title, this year's Horizon Zero Dawn came under fire from a Native American writer for the game's cultural appropriation and insensitive use of language that that has degrading and negative connotations.

In an essay for Medium, the writer called out not only Horizon's cultural appropriation of Native American culture but the prevalence of it more generally in the industry, damning the medium as a whole for perpetuating archaic and damaging cultural representations.

The developers responded by explaining that they never intended to cause any offence, and actually based the tribal culture of Horizon on multiple different groups from throughout history. The explanation didn't go down too well though, and they were again criticised for not taking ownership of the situation.


4. Nintendo Ends Support For The NES Classic

Nes Classic
Nintendo

Last year the NES Classic was one of the most difficult products to get your hands on. Despite the overwhelming demand for the console, Nintendo supplied barely any to retailers, deciding to instead stagger out the release with a small smattering of machines at a time.

That was a problem in and of itself, but most people at least assumed that they'd be able to pick one up at some some point, even if Nintendo refused to get their act together to release enough of them to actually satisfy the demand.

Of course Nintendo is a company that seemingly hates making money and responded in the only reasonable manner - by discontinuing the product altogether after only five months and announcing a brand new console, the SNES Classic, instead.


3. Persona 5's Publisher Threatens To Ban Streamers Showing Their Game

Persona 5
Atlus

All publishers want to avoid spoilers from leaking before a game is officially released, and it's not uncommon for those receiving early copies of a title to be asked by companies not to show specific scenes or moments from an upcoming game.

The publisher of Persona 5, Atlus, was no different in wanting to keep spoilers under wraps. However, instead of politely asking video makers and streamers to refrain from using certain footage, they instead threatened them with copyright strikes and account bans if they screened any video from the game past a certain date.

Obviously threatening the livelihood of hundreds, if not thousands, of people in an attempt to avoid spoilers only ensured that the people targeted would break the rules in an attempt to fight back.

Atlus received even more criticism from fans and players once the threats were revealed to the public, leading to the company responding with an apology a little while later that was too little, too late.


2. Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy Is Too Hard

Crash Bandicoot N Sane Uka Uka
Activision

One of the less ugly controversies on this list, players went crazy when they got their hands on the Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy earlier this month because they couldn't remember the games being so damn hard.

Sure, the original trilogy always had its difficult moments, but it was never this punishing. There was a collective feeling that something was off, but nobody could quite put their finger on what was making them come face to face with the game-over screen over and over again.

It turned out that time hadn't played tricks on people, but in remaking the games from scratch the developers inadvertently made the releases more difficult by subtly changing some of the physics and hit-boxes in the levels. While they were originally quiet on the changes, the studio recently flat-out admitted that they'd messed up and made everything harder.

This meant certain jumps were much more difficult to pull off than they ever were before and that enemies could hit you from a little further away - so you can blame that the next time you give up trying to get past The High Road.


1. Far Cry 5's Religious Setting

Far Cry 5
Ubisoft

For the first time ever in the series, Far Cry 5 is taking place on American soil - and not everyone is happy about it.

Although the franchise has always acted as a sort of criticism of American bravado, Far Cry has managed to avoid any major backlash thanks to its exotic settings and locations. But now that it's chosen to cast its villains as being part of a gun-running religious cult occupying a town in Montana, the developers have come under fire for targeting a particularly sensitive aspect of American culture.

It's all been overblown as nobody can really know how political the game is going to be until it's released next year, and the studio itself has been very careful to not publicly acknowledge the impact that any contemporary issues may have had on the game during its development.

But that hasn't been enough to squash the controversy surrounding the title, and the constant barrage of think pieces about Far Cry 5's provocative setting don't seem to be stopping anytime soon.


Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.