10 Brilliant Video Games That Surprised Everyone - Commenter Edition

Another round of unexpected digital pleasures - this time chosen by you.

metal gear rising revengeance
Konami

By now, we're all depressingly familiar with the hype that publishers have managed to build for video games that subsequently fail to deliver.

We've known for a long time never to trust titles that are marketed on pre-rendered cinematics alone, and more recently have learned not to even trust gameplay trailers showcased at events such as E3.

Heavily scripted "gameplay" sequences for games such as Assassin's Creed: Unity and Rainbow Six: Siege have taught us that Ubisoft and plenty of other companies are not above outright lying about the content of their future titles, and what we're eventually sold can just be embarrassing.

However, this isn't always the case. Sometimes, a game comes along to very little fanfare or amongst intense skepticism and... well, it's good. Really good, in fact.

Sometimes a developer has had a bad run of titles, or a dramatic shift from established formulas has made a fanbase worry about an upcoming sequel, but those designers programmers and testers manage to pull it out the bag and deliver a hit that gives us further hope for the industry.

We've already gushed about several of these titles in the past, and were greeted with a whole host of others from commenters - all great suggestions that deserve some acknowledgement!

10. Alien: Isolation

Alien Isolation
Sega

Alien: Isolation was met with a mixture of caution and dread from the get-go for one very depressing reason - Aliens: Colonial Marines. As that game's disastrous development cycle and release is now more well documented than the Second World War, it'll suffice to say that it was truly, madly, garment-rendingly awful in every respect, especially considering the hype that had built around it over several years.

Isolation developers Creative Assembly, however, were unperturbed by the worry that was beginning to set in. While Colonial Marines took after James Cameron's 1986 action sequel, Isolation was based firmly on Ridley Scott's original (and far superior) horror classic. Their vision was delivered impeccably. The Sevastopol space station captured that same spirit of grimy, 1970s sci-fi - all clunky machinery and CRT monitors - and the horror aspect was front and centre.

Alien: Isolation is terrifying. An excruciatingly tense, unforgiving struggle between woman and beast, the single Alien that remorselessly stalks Amanda Ripley through Sevastopol is unmatched in its hostility, waiting for that one wrong move that will surely mean instant death. Compared to Colonial Marines' hordes of dopey Xenomorph cannon fodder, this monster - and indeed the entire game - was structural perfection.


9. Titanfall 2

titanfall 2
Electronic Arts

After the original Titanfall's serviceable-yet-forgettable entry as a multiplayer-only Xbox One system seller, no one expected its sequel not only to be fantastic, but to present one of the finest single-player shooter campaigns in an entire decade.

Centring around the surprisingly effective relationship between a soldier and his giant stompy robot, Titanfall 2's story sees an entire star system at war, with both primary factions displaying a great deal of nuance and moral ambiguity. Protagonist Jack Cooper, a low-level rifleman for the Frontier Militia - a noble resistance or terrorist organisation depending on who you ask - inherits a titan from a fallen Militia member, also taking on its final mission.

The gameplay accompanying the gripping plot is also stellar, with an interesting dichotomy between 2 gameplay styles. On-foot sections as Cooper are highly mobile and fast-paced, with levels offering a great deal of verticality, exploration and classic first-person-shooter combat.

These segue into destructive, cathartic set-pieces aboard BT-7274, the aforementioned titan, launching salvos of miles and all manner of heavy munitions against swarms of infantry and hostile mechs alike. Its execution was polished and thrilling, especially after the game's predecessor failed to set the world alight.


8. Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance

metal gear rising
Konami

Please bear with me here, as I can already see the glint of torches and clanking of raised pitchforks. Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance may be seen by many as a stain on the venerable Metal Gear legacy, but to judge it purely on its relationship to the stealth behemoth. In fact, it's truly fascinating that the game managed to be such a success given the context in which it exists.

Revengeance's protagonist Raiden was introduced in 2001's Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty to widespread derision. Despite being central to the game's overarching themes, fans hated the willowy blonde replacement for their beloved hero Solid Snake.

Upon his redesign in Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots as an overpowered cyborg ninja, it was interpreted by many as a cringeworthy attempt to garner some popularity for the character.

Alarm bells began blaring when Revengeance was announced - a fast-paced hack-and-slasher from PlatinumGames starring Raiden, it was the logical opposite of the introspective, methodical stealth titles that came before. The game was excellent, however - a campy, exciting action title with all the gloriously refined high-octane combat that PlatinumGames are renowned for. It was different, but in all the right ways.


7. Dying Light

Dying Light Night Time
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Despite Dying Light's impressive trailers and marketing material, players were understandably skeptical.

After all, they had been burned before by the profound and mysterious trailer for Techland's previous Zombie RPG Dead Island, and what did they end up with?

Well... they ended up with Dead Island - a shallow grind plagued by uninspired, repetitive combat and AI so poor it wore a sack with holes cut in it. The thought of another zombie RPG with a suspiciously pre-rendered cinematic trailer hardly boded well.

Concerns were unfounded, however, when Dying Light turned out to be absolutely excellent. The fictional Middle Eastern city of Haran was a joy to traverse, offering limitless climbing potential and elegant travelling through use of the game's central parkour mechanics. The combat was also vastly improved, with protagonist Kyle Crane able to cut through waves of shambling undead, and confrontations with human enemies that were contrastingly challenging and tactical.

Of course, the game's biggest draw was its day to night transition: once the sun had set, out came the Volatiles. These near-invincible infected enemies, faster, stronger, smarter and more aggressive than regular zombies, reduced the player from predator to prey in an instant.

Scrambling for relative safety to wait out the sunrise was both exhilarating and terrifying.


6. Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice

Hellblade SenuaS Sacrifice
Ninja Theory

Hellblade: Seuna's Sacrifice is not without its flaws. The game is a little linear, and that bloody blindness trial sequence was a legendary p*sstake, but overall it is a work of wonderful imagination, beautifully presented and profoundly told.

All this coming from Ninja Theory, whose previous output had been action-oriented and only ever hitting the dizzying heights of quite good.

Heavenly Sword and Enslaved: Odyssey To The West were solid 3 star titles which struggled to deliver the epic, sweeping stories they promised, and DMC: Devil May Cry (presumably short for Devil May Cry: Devil May Cry) was unpopular with series fans due to its divergence from the core series.

When Hellblade was announced as an "Independent AAA" title made by a team of 15 people, it was impossible not to be skeptical.

However, the game was a marvel. Its story, revolving around mental illness through the filter of grim Norse mythology was stunning, thanks to a spellbinding central performance from Melina Juergens.

The various set pieces throughout the game were memorable and uniquely realised, and made for an unexpected hit that looks set to further impress with its upcoming sequel.


5. Sleeping Dogs

Sleeping Dogs Kick
Square Enix

Sleeping Dogs, the oddly-titled spiritual successor to the abysmal True Crime series, had no right to be as good as it was.

For starters, it began its life as an entry the True Crime series - the first of which, Streets Of LA, was a mediocre open-world shooter, and the second, New York City, was a dismal experience riddled with bugs and boilerplate gameplay. Secondly, developer United Front had only developed one game prior - ModNation Racers, a user-generated content cart racer. Oh goody.

When True Crime: Hong Kong as it was then known was cancelled, United Front weathered a storm of staff layoffs and other difficulties until being bought out by Square Enix, who recognised the potential of the unfinished title.

Finally completed and released as an entirely new IP, Sleeping Dogs was a surprising gem, capturing the look and feel of both Eastern gangster and martial arts movies admirably. Its core melee combat was depthy and visceral, and the writing, whilst no masterpiece was solid and gripping.

Riding round a lovingly-rendered Hong Kong and kicking that guy in the face every time he shouted "takes guts to wear that!" was an absolute barrel of fun.


4. Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Second Sister
EA

Star Wars video games, while not universally terrible, have not had a particularly great run. Sure there are some great titles, such as Dark Forces, the original Battlefront series and the legendary Knights Of The Old Republic - but there have been many, many more rushed, cynical and gimmicky tie-ins relegated to the Star Wars wasteland over the 40-plus years that they have existed.

Most recently, Electronic "Arts", having acquired the Star Wars licence, set about ruining the IP with their usual gusto, first by rebooting the Battlefront series as extortion racket first and playable game second. They then cancelled Visceral Studios' Project Ragtag, a title which actually showed some promise.

Then Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order followed, and much to the surprise of just about everyone, it's great. Admittedly you can't score points on the basis of the game simply not being a live-service cash grab, but Fallen Order stands on its own merits.

Utilising a slightly more accessible variation on Souls-like combat, Metroidvania influences and rewarding exploration, it's a standout title that succeeds in fleshing out the galaxy far, far away. Also, true to Star Wars tradition, the protagonist gets upstaged by a droid.


3. God Of War (2018)

God Of War 2018
Sony Interactive Entertainment

2018's soft reboot of the successful God Of War franchise came as surprise not for following a bad series - quite the opposite, in fact. The original trilogy of games on the PS2 and PS3 had seen wild success, being cited as some of the best action games of all time.

Their camp, ultra-violent rampage through Greek mythology had a great deal of charm to accompany some rip-roaring gameplay.

With this in mind, when the PS4 sequel-cum-reboot was trailed, fan were perplexed - a hammy hack-and-slasher set in Ancient Greece was now a serious-hairy-dad-game centring on Norse Mythology. Kratos' naive young son Atreus was met with derision, and an ageing, bearded, grumpy Kratos seemed similarly out of place.

The result, however, was simply perfect. Santa Monica Studios' retooling of the franchise worked not only on a gameplay level, but narratively most of all. Kratos' remorse over his abhorrent past, his closed off, taciturn demeanour and believable relationship with Atreus spoke to the maturing of not just the character but the game's writers as well.

Its emotional journey, coupled with a wonderfully tear-jerking ending, makes for one of the current generation's most memorable titles.


2. Bioshock Infinite

Bioshock infinite
2K

Bioshock Infinite's departure from the original titles' doomed underwater setting was an understandable cause for concern for many of the series' fans.

Despite the fact that Bioshock 2 was a lazy, surface-level rehash of the first game which fundamentally missed the point of the series, the decision to set Infinite in the opposite setting - a city in the sky - was unwelcome. Coupled with rumours of a trouble development cycle and meddling from publisher 2K Games, it seemed bound to fail.

On the contrary, Bioshock Infinite was an outstanding title and the perfect true successor to the peerless original. Irrational Games built upon the mechanics they had at their disposal and created a game that was distinct from, yet complementary to its predecessor.

The tense survival horror was replaced with a swashbuckling action epic, and tight, claustrophobic environments made way for large open arenas with opportunities for fast-paced, highly mobile combat - something that was in short supply in 2013, when just about every shooter was a plodding military yawn-fest.

Infinite's story was also a step up from the original Bioshock. Deuteragonists Booker and Elizabeth lent a solid emotional core to the experience, and their ultimate fates were simply heartbreaking.


1. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The Witcher 3 blood and wine
CD Projekt RED

"How could you say The Witcher 3 was a surprise," I hear you yell. "The first 2 games were flawless masterpieces, and PC gamers have known that for years!"

Therein lies the point.

The original 2 Witcher titles, released exclusively for PC (save for a later Xbox 360 port of The Witcher 2), are hugely influential games but remain very much geared towards a niche audience. PC gamers were rightly excited for the conclusion to the trilogy, but a great deal of console gamers, myself included, had very little to go on.

As we all know by now, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is considered one of the greatest video games of all time - and for good reason. Its world is expansive and gorgeous to behold, and its mechanics are refined and streamlined, yet still have enough depth not to feel watered down.

Most noteworthy, however, is its story and characterisation. Very rarely does a game come along with such nuance in every facet of its storytelling, and such engaging characters inhabiting the entire moral spectrum. Its drama is devastating, its moments of levity all the more effective.

Standing ovation, CD Projekt Red.


Watch Next


Contributor

A self-taught video editor with nearly 25 years of experience, Joe worked in freelance videography for many years before joining WhatCulture in 2018. During that time, he has expanded his work to include both writing and presenting, and has been at the forefront of several new channel launches including WhatCulture Horror and WhatCulture Star Wars, largely defining their visual identity through the design and curation of their bespoke assets. As a dedicated WhatCulture Gaming staff member, he has spearheaded numerous new content strategies and formats, and has taken the lead on various charitable projects that have raised large sums of money for charities close to his heart. Bluesky and Instagram: @jjpinwheel