10 Divisive Video Games You Either Love Or Hate
No two people will ever agree on GTA IV. Ever.
Gaming is a largely subjective medium, with objectively great games finding hate amongst the populace and objectively horrible games finding die-hard fans to defend them. Most of the time there is a general majority that defines the quality of the game, but sometimes gamers are split down the middle and are completely divided.
These are the types of games that inspire devotion in one half and disgust in the other, games that are either hated or loved, games whose flaws are deplorable in one person's eyes and endearing in another and games that so divisive that they inspire wars between fans and haters that span forum after forum.
And it's easy to see why some of these games are loved and hated. A lot of them come down to personal preference, but a fair few are objectively good games that have attached stigmas that make them appear bad in some people's eyes. Even some games are fundamentally broken, but the gameplay can be enough for players to fall in love. Regardless, here are ten divisive video games you either love or hate. Let us know which side you're on!
10. Heavy Rain
Heavy Rain was a rather bizarre game in the sense that it focussed less on the game aspect of the game and more so on the story, selling itself more as an interactive movie than a game. In doing so it inspired an entire subgenre of game that blew up quickly with several games following in its footsteps.
And a lot of people loved that aspect and found the story to be engaging and interesting. However, a lot of people disliked the game based purely on the fact that it wasn't focussed on the game aspect. The game-play was largely quick time events interspersed with explorative portions in which you inspected objects in an environment to uncover clues.
It was largely down to personal preference because the game really wasn't for everyone. The lack of gameplay turned a lot of hardcore gamers away, as the game itself required a huge time investment to complete. And if you weren't invested in the story, then it became an immense slog to work through. But those who loved the slow paced action found it to be an excellent game!
9. Final Fantasy
You might be wondering why Final Fantasy as a series earns its own spot on this list instead of a specific game. And chances are you have your own idea as to which game is the most divisive, but when it comes down to it, you could literally pick any game in the series and there would be die-hard fans that would love it and die-hard haters who would condemn it as the game that ruined the series.
This one largely comes down to personal preference as there hasn't really been a universally acclaimed Final Fantasy game since Final Fantasy VII with every title receiving backlash and praise for a multitude of aspects. Some for their characters, some for the story, some for the changes to gameplay and some just out of principle.
The series itself could stand here on its own, considering how a lot of people love the franchise as a whole and others don't like due to the scope and sheer size of its universe. It can often seem daunting and of putting even trying to dip your toes in the water, with the fantasy/future/Japanese style being quite jarring to new players.
Either way, Final Fantasy is easily one of the most divisive series out there and nearly every game could fill this spot on the list.
8. League of Legends/DOTA
Games like League of Legends and Dota are almost entirely based on preference. People who love the style of game absolutely love it and sink days of time into playing the game and becoming great at it. And while the games inspire devotion in their fans, they inspire a lot of disdain from other gamers who see them as a general waste of time with little to no gameplay, a rabidly obsessive fanbase and a steep learning curve to even access the game.
That's not to mention the fact that each game inspires their own love it or hate it attitudes, with the fanbases of both games heralding their one as the best and the other as the bane of all things good in the world, despite being fundamentally equal games. Sure they have their differences, but they aren't enough to inspire a major shift in opinion.
However, people love their one and hate the other despite their comparable similarities. Either that or you hate the genre entirely and find it to be a completely bizarre type of gaming.
7. Online Games
Overwatch, Evolve, Battlefront, For Honor all have one thing in common. They are all pretty much multiplayer oriented experiences. (For Honor as a single player, but it's not the main focus). They all devote the entire game to online matches against other players and sometimes bots and thus make themselves some of the most divisive games out there.
For a lot of people, a forty pound game devoted entirely to an online set of game modes is a waste of money with little to no replayability. The idea that games that rely solely on multiplayer with little to no singleplayer experience can be seen as a blight on the gaming landscape.
However, online games cater to a specific type of person. The more competitive in nature who are open to playing the same game modes over and over again to become better and better at the game can find online only games to be a huge steal. It is down to preference, though people who dislike online games often do so with an avid passion seeing them as a trend that needs to end.
6. Destiny
Destiny was met with a fair bit of critical response. A lot of people found the game to be lacking in a lot of areas and was ultimately a disappointment when held up against the immense hype the game had acclaimed. The areas were samey and repetitive, the combat was a little wonky, the story near non-existant and the ever famous dull voice performances all led to a general 'meh' in regard to the game.
But that didn't stop fans from falling in love with the game. The game garnered a fairly large group of fans that absolutely adored the gameplay and disregarded any other criticism against the game, instead choosing to enjoy the gameplay for what it was in the multitude of raids.
Over time, the game began to fix its many problems and managed to draw a few players back, but even then a lot of people didn't like the game and found it to be lacking in a lot of areas.
5. The Division
The Division, like Destiny, was met with a lot of critical responses and a lot of them mirrored the ones that Destiny got. The story was weak, the gameplay was a little rocky, the areas were detailed yet not really outstanding and the shooting mechanics worked in bizarre ways requiring hundreds of headshots to down a human enemy that was a few levels higher than you. It was a little off-putting.
But much the same as Destiny, the game got a lot of fans who loved the gameplay and sank hundreds of hours into the online portion of the game, doing everything they could to get higher level gear. For a lot of people, the gameplay was enough to sell them on the game.
Unlike Destiny though, the game never really managed to draw many people back in after time and had to rely on its hardcore fans as general gamers passed it off as a mediocre shooter that had you collecting different coloured puffer jackets.
4. Ratchet: Deadlocked
IMAGE: https://en.ratchet-galaxy.com/images/rg/artworks/Unknown/characters/Ratchet_and_Bots.jpg
Ratchet and Clank have been the most prevailing Playstation mascots the console has ever had and has had its fair share of divisive titles. Whilst the original trilogy are held in high regard and are almost universally loved, nearly every other game has split the crowd. But none more than Ratchet: Deadlocked.
A lot of people had criticisms about the game, namely the fact that the famous duo of Ratchet and Clank was stripped down to a solo adventure. Whilst Clank was in the background, he was never on the same level as Ratchet as he was in previous titles. Combine that with somewhat repetitive missions, limited weapon variety and god awful Landstalker missions and you had a lot of disappointed fans.
But a lot of fans took the game for what it was and instead of heralding it as the next great Ratchet and Clank game, instead found what was enjoyable with what was there. The environments were expansive, the weapons were highly customisable mitigating their limited number and there were only a few god awful Landstalker missions. (They were horrible no matter which side you took.)
3. GTA IV
GTA IV really split the fans and ultimately paid the price for it. Some fans praised the grittier, down to earth gameplay and how the game felt a lot more real than previous instalments, whilst others felt the game took the wrong approach to open world sandboxes and favoured the cathartic destruction Saint's Row provided.
It boiled down to which aspects of the previous games you found entertaining. Either the realism of the world and the story aspects, or the bombastic destruction of simply being let loose on the world. There were, of course, other technical issues that were prevalent with the driving and shooting mechanics feeling a bit clunky, but what divided fans was the different approach the game took.
And coming off the success of the previous instalments, the game had a lot to live up too and for a lot of people, it didn't hit that mark. However, the game still did well commercially and had people praising the game as the best in series, leaving the general consensus on the game's quality largely skewed.
2. Minecraft
Minecraft has fallen far from grace over the years as its reputation has been influenced by the largely young player base. But as a game, it's fundamentally sound with some pretty fulfilling survival and building mechanics. Not only that the limits of creativity are limitless. Unless you want to build a perfect circle...
However, due to the player base being largely children and the overall impression the games makes in the media, the game has been branded a kid's game, thus making it divisive. The association of the younger audience is enough to turn some people away, as well the fact the game relies largely on self-motivation to be enjoyable. Some people often prefer a set goal provided by the game instead of having to 'make your own fun'.
On top of that, there is the notorious fact that the game is unbelievably obtuse with its mechanics, requiring access to the wiki just to understand the basic fundamentals of the game.
All in all, the game provides a fun open world full of limitless opportunities for creativity, but some find the game to be too open ended to be enjoyable with far too many hurdles to jump through just to play. That and all the eight-year-olds playing it...
1. Dark Souls
Dark Souls divided people from the offset and while it's slowly grown in popularity over the years, with the later instalments becoming more accessible, the original game still divides people to this day.
The fans who adored it adored it to an almost fanatical degree and it's easy to see why. On a technical scale, the game is incredible. The level and world design are like no other, the combat is weighty and feels great and the characters are loveable and brilliantly written.
However, the part of the game that split the crowds was the difficulty. Actually getting into the game often required outside help, with frequent trips to the wiki becoming necessary just to find out where you had to go next. The game's devotion to immersion left a lot of players alienated and stumbling into high-level areas or making the game inadvertently harder for themselves just by trying to figure out the mechanics.
The learning curve ultimately turned the majority of people away and the somewhat elitist fanbase telling people simply to 'Git Gud' didn't exactly help people get into the game.
--
On which side do you stand when it comes to these games: Love them or hate them? Any other divisive games we missed from our list? Let us know in the comments down below!