10 Dumb Video Game Heroes With The WORST Motivations
Clearly marked no-entry zone? Better go inside!
The Hero's Journey is an important narrative device that frames a story. During the beginning of many games, there is an inciting incident where a village may be burned to the ground, or the would-be hero learns of a prophecy they are destined to fulfil. This is the "Call to Adventure".
However, just because a hero gets the opportunity to save the world, there are some that should have stayed at home, had a cup of tea and waited for the troubles to go away.
Sometimes the decisions that these heroes make is with the best of intentions, but thinking about them for just a minute or two would spare everyone a headache. But then there are the world-class morons, those that are selfish and won't stop at nothing until they get what they want.
And even if they achieve their goal, what then? Of course it gets worse, and if they had thought about it for a few minutes they might have worked that one out for themselves.
10. Rescuing The Daughter He Sold To Pay A Debt - Bioshock Infinite
Main character Booker is a private investigator who is sent to an island in the sky to rescue a girl. However, there are plenty of ulterior motives at work throughout the story.
Bioshock Infinite Booker should never have even contemplated sold his daughter to pay off his debts. I get why he wasn't acting rationally - after all, his partner died and he was in desperate need of cash. People do irrational things when they feel that they have no other options.
At least he instantly regretted selling his daughter, but it' s still a deplorable action that should never have happened. It had a consequence too, since the child loses a finger during the subsequent violent exchange as Booker attempts to get his daughter back from Comstock.
Oh, and the only reason he's on the job to find the girl in the first place is because he's landed himself in even more debt. Evidently, Booker didn't learn from his mistakes.
9. Becoming The Lich King Because His Mentor Didn't Want To Slaughter A Village - Warcraft III
Prince Arthas was evidently a cocky, snot-nosed brat growing up. Spoiled by a privileged upbringing as a member of the royal family, he's inducted into the Knights of the Silver Hand at the young age of 19.
He is suddenly brought back down to Earth when a town is fed contaminated food and begins turning into undead hordes. I certainly get the ideology behind his decision to purge the town to stop the spread, and his mentor's personal choice to stand down is also an understandable one.
Where Arthas loses us, is how he reacts to Uther's refusal to slaughter an entire village. He disbands the order and sets out to find a cursed sword. Initially he is triumphant against the demon Mal'ganis, but Arthas is no longer the ignorant boy he once was.
By drawing Frostmourne from its resting place, he has corrupted his mind. He kills the king and becomes one of the most powerful beings in the World of Warcraft: The Lich King.
If only he had taken a breath, and had forgiven his mentor instead. They would likely have stood a chance at defeating Mal'ganis's zombie hordes by themselves.
8. Mass Extinction Of A Sacred Species To Save One Person - Shadow Of The Colossus
Shadow of the Colossus is one of the most upsetting games ever when you think about it. Above all else though, it's a game about one man's selfish desires at the cost of an entire ecosystem.
If the Wanderer had thought about what he was about to do for even a second, he would have clocked onto the fact that what he was doing was morally wrong. To break the curse on the girl, he is trespassing on sacred land that is CLEARLY marked off by the local people, hunting endangered creatures vital to the ecosystem, and casting a forbidden spell.
But Wander didn't think.
This so-called hero felt compelled to do what he wanted no matter the cost. Heck, he even injured Argo, his lovely horse, by making him jump onto a rickety bridge!
Yes, the girl is cursed and that is a horrible thing, but this is one hero that never learned the scale of destruction he would leave in his wake. At least he gets his just deserts in the end.
In a cruel twist of irony, both the girl and Argo are alive, but I'll never forgive the Wanderer for his part in the accident caused the horse such an injury.
7. He Fell Asleep Next To A Cargo Crate - Lester The Unlikely
It's easy to rag on Lester. He's the stereotypical nerd in how he looks, and also how he acts. But I'd argue that the reason Lester is on the island in the first place is the worst bit about the character.
During the introduction that takes a decade to play out, we see Lester walking across a pier with a comic book in hand. He soon becomes a little sleepy and decides that the best place to sleep, on the coast, is next to a cargo crate that's about to be loaded onto a ship.
Bonus fact: as soon as Lester is kissed by one of the native girls, he gains confidence! Suddenly he no longer shivers at the thought of jumping from a ledge or seeing an enemy for the first time.
When he eventually saves the tribe from pirates and makes it back to civilisation, Lester is seen telling his story to two very sceptical girls, who don't seem to believe him. I'm pretty sure he lied to them about how he became stranded on the island in the first place..
6. Going To A Spooky Town To Find His Deceased Wife - Silent Hill 2
Hang on, how is this a "bad" motivation?
Getting a letter from your supposedly deceased wife - if the last thing you knew was that she went missing and her death was presumed - is a justifiable reason to travel to a haunted town where monsters do unspeakable things.
But this is Silent Hill 2. James knows how his wife died, and that's what makes him so dumb. I'd give a spoiler warning, but this game is several decades old so here it goes: James killed his wife.
So what is the true motivation then? Guilt? Perhaps he feels bad for his deeds in the past and wants to make amends. I can sort of get that, but why wade through hordes of gibbering monstrosities, manifestations of your own psyche, and a being that represents your darkest desires, just to say that he was sorry?
Don't get me wrong, Silent Hill 2 is one of the best horror games ever made and James's dumb motivation is the driving force behind the most imaginative game in the series. But as a "hero", or even a villain, James is being incredibly thick.
5. Condemning An Entire Town To White Phosphorus Just To Capture One Man - Spec Ops: The Line
It's no secret that Spec Ops: The Line is a parallel to Heart of Darkness.
The entire mission begins when Colonel Konrad's platoon goes rogue and your small squad is sent to capture him. As a soldier, Captain Walker's duty is so focused on completing the mission that he's blind to anything else.
Things are not quite as they initially seem and before long we get to a pivotal moment where the squad receive intelligence that the location ahead is heavily guarded. Realising that they would not be able to make it through alone, Walker orders that they use the mortars to launch white phosphorus on the enemy's position.
This is despite the fact that not only are both of his companions are horrified that Walker would even contemplate such a barbaric suggestion, but that the use of chemicals in weapons is banned under several articles of the Geneva conventions.
If that's not bad enough, Walker accidentally breaks a second article of the Geneva convention by murdering civilians. All of this because he didn't want to wait for backup.
4. Punching The Master Emerald So Hard It Shattered - Sonic Adventure 2
Knuckles probably thought he was being smart when he broke the Master Emerald. It's particularly silly that he had been instructed by his elders to protect this jewel for all time. During a confrontation where both Dr. Eggman and Rouge are trying to take the oversized rare mineral to either use as part of their doomsday device, or as the latest fashion accessory.
Since it broke into tiny pieces, Knuckles must now gather all of the Master Emerald shards. However, he's not the only one looking for the missing pieces, as Rouge's levels also have her looking for the jewel bits. It's clear that Knuckles didn't think his plan through and was incredibly lucky that everything works out in the end.
All it took was for Rouge to decide that one or two pieces was enough bling to add to her collection and seal it away in a vault. Knuckles would never have reunited all the pieces of the Master Emerald.
He's incredibly lucky then that Rouge is particularly greedy about jewels.
3. Participating In A Tournament To Promote His Failing Martial Arts Dojo - Super Street Fighter IV
There's merit to taking pride in your work. After tens or hundreds of hours, you've created something, you want to show it off to the world.
Unfortunately for Dan Hibiki in Super Street Fighter IV, his brand of martial arts is mostly about showboating and is about as useful as flailing your fists in the air. So quite rightly, his dojo is failing. Instead of looking deeply to see what can be improved, he decides that marketing his dojo is the lead cause of all of his problems!
What's worse is that if Dan does win the tournament, he has no clue how to make an advert! He makes an advert that tells people to go to his dojo to apply. This is smart as he doesn't have a phone line, but not only does the broadcast go out while people are asleep, it takes a teenager to tell him what he missed: the address of the dojo! He somehow squandered an opportunity he didn't deserve in the first place!
2. Keeping His Affair A Secret - Catherine
Vincent Brooks gets into a drunken state at the beginning of Atlus's tower climbing puzzle game. Upon discovering that he did indeed sleep with that girl he met at the bar that one night, he chooses to hide his dastardly deed from his fiance.
Vincent is a coward.
As he struggles to work out how best to resolve the crisis he himself created, he is plagued with nightmares that he must physically climb out of. He's also regularly pursued by manifestations of his worries. These take the form of some rather disturbing creatures, none more so than a child with a chainsaw for an arm.
All Vincent had to do to not have these nightmares was stop drinking with his buddies, have a good long think about what he'd done, and potentially break it off with Katherine to spare her unnecessary pain.
Yes, doing the right thing might have meant he would be alone for the rest of his life, but leading two women on is a bit of a d*ck move. He could at the very least give his fiance some closure and the chance to move on. But he doesn't do this because he's being incredibly selfish.
1. Choosing The Wrong Decision Just To See Every Ending - Anything With Moral Choices
Surprise! Didn't think we'd go after you, did you?
Think about it though. Every game character has a motivation and while plenty are justifiable, there are those that aren't. A game gives you the call to go on a digital adventure.
Sometimes you even get to choose your own character, meaning they are a manifestation of your own choices and desires. It's only fair then that if a game features character creation and morale choices So what's your motivation for playing the game? To have fun.
Okay short stuff. You have your fun.
But let's put this into context then. In Assassin's Creed Odyssey, did you choose to save the family that may have had an infectious disease, then many hours later go back to see what would have happened if you killed them instead?
Chances are that you have condemned as many civilisations to ruin as civilisations you have saved. People lived, died, or had worse things happen to them and it's all because you wanted to get all the endings.
Those things are all on you, and you are the worst.