10 Gimmick Bosses In Dark Souls

A new and novel approach to a Dark Souls boss experience? Or just weirdness for its own sake?

Dark Souls Ancient wyvern
FromSoftware

Throughout the Dark Souls series, there is a relatively straightforward pattern that is repeated for normal enemies, areas and bosses. You encounter them for the first time, you get utterly destroyed by them and then you gradually learn from your mistakes until you've recognised enough of their patterns and tells to emerge victorious.

While this holds true for most boss encounters, there are a few outliers. There are some that whether it be by luck, by chance, or just from previous skillset and game knowledge you can beat them the first time you lay eyes on them.

For other encounters, none of that will matter. These are referred to as "gimmick" bosses. Not an exact definition by any means, but generally some boss that relies on a mechanic or a scenario that is specific to them or to their arena to conquer.

The players of this series are generally divided on these encounters, with some enjoying the break from the norm and others viewing it as lazy, confusing or just plain unfair. Choosing from Dark Souls 1, 2 and 3, what are the gimmicky bosses that we encountered? And did it make them better or worse?

10. Ancient Wyvern - Dark Souls 3

Dark Souls Ancient wyvern
FromSoftware

Found in Archdragon Peak, when you open a huge portcullis and enter the fog the player is greeted by the sight of this enormous enemy landing in front of you.

Whether you get taken out by its fire breath immediately or dodge and roll your way in, the first time that your weapon lands against its scaly hide and you see the pitiful amount of health that comes off its health bar, you should realise something is up.

Unlike most other boss areas, the player should notice that there is a path to your left that lets you run past the boss and fight your way through mobs of enemies. By working your way through them and climbing ever upwards, you'll find yourself directly above the Ancient Wyvern's head. All that is left now is to drop down and perform a plunging attack for a one hit kill.

It could be argued that the gimmick here is the arena itself and the mobs being the real enemy, but while taking out such a monster in one hit is rewarding (provided you don't glitch straight through it) it can feel cheap and almost as though the real fight has been missed.


9. Royal Rat Vanguard - Dark Souls 2

Royal Rat Vanguard
FromSoftware

Found in The Grave of Saints in Dark Souls 2, as soon as you enter the arena, rats will start pouring out of the walls. Using the statues for cover and doing your best to not get surrounded and beaten down, after the player kill a few you may notice that there isn't a health bar.

While this might seem strange, keep up the dodging and eliminating of rats and after enough have been dispatched, the Royal Rat Vanguard's bar will appear.

While many first time players might have discovered it by accident, the only rat that you need to damage at this point has a little mohican on his head and back, and once you focus your attention on him, the health bar will melt away in short order.

Not the last time that this idea and design choice that basically consists of "mob enemies where you need to focus on one" is seen in this series, there were more complaints about this due to how the bosses in Dark Souls 2 were viewed - some lazy repeats and boring design choices just to pump the numbers up, arguably at the cost of quality.


8. Mytha - Dark Souls 2

Dark souls 2
FromSoftware

Mytha, the Baneful Queen is not a bad boss fight - unlike a few entries on this list there was no sort of huge outcry as to her inclusion, her quality or her mechanics. The gimmick concerning her arena, however, was an odd combination of obscure and illogical.

If a player fought through the level as normal and entered the boss fog, they would face the Queen in a room where the ground was full of poison. This otherwise fair fight would become a balancing act between healing, curing your poisoned status, and actually fighting the boss in front of you.

If, for reasons better known to themselves, a player chose to light a torch at a bonfire earlier in the level and walk up to the spindle of an otherwise unmarked and unremarkable windmill, there would be a command prompt to set fire to it. Once it was alight, the boss arena would be changed, with most of the poison removed and solid ground to fight on.

Why this in-game function that was never hinted at and not repeated was included here and here alone is a truly baffling design choice. And how anyone found it by accident is equally confusing.


7. Ceaseless Discharge - Dark Souls 1

ceaseless discharge dark souls
FromSoftware

In the original game, this lava-creature would not attack you when you entered his arena. In fact, you were free to wander around to your hearts content - until you chose to loot the clothing that was on an altar in front of him.

Lore-wise, these were the garments of his sister and once you had shamelessly stolen them, he would erupt in a fiery rage, assaulting you with blows and strikes. It was possible to dodge these attacks and get your retaliation in to whittle down his health, but a far easier option existed.

If the player sprinted back to the fog gate at the start of the area, Ceaseless Discharge was so desperate to stop you that he would leap across the chasm, holding onto the clifftop by just his "fingertips". Attacking his "hands" would cause him to lose his grip and fall with all of his HP disappearing at once.

Although initially though to be an oversight, there is a specific animation for his fall, so it must have been intended. But for this one hit kill and his docile nature before you rob what he his guarding, he may actually have two gimmicks - both of which work well.


6. Yhorm The Giant - Dark Souls 3

DARK SOULS 3 Yhorm
FromSoftware

One of the Lords of Cinder in Dark Souls 3, this enormous adversary is found in the Profaned Capital, waiting for you. If you follow Siegward of Catarina's quest line all the way through, this is not a boss you have to face alone and for new players, seeing the weapon choice of the onion knight will give you a hint as to what the gimmick here is.

Similarly to the Wyvern, it is entirely possible to kill him "normally" provided you have patience, repair powder or a lot of spare weapons but the key is the Storm Ruler hidden behind his throne. By using its charged special attack, you can take him down in a short time with each blow dealing a large chunk of his health bar.

Lore wise, lonely Yhorm entrusted this weapon which he knew could kill him to the people who asked him to rule over them, ensuring that if they ever changed their mind, they could topple him from power.

The nostalgia value of this weapon from Demon's Souls elevated it in a lot of players minds more than the fight itself did. While not particularly bad, there wasn't much to make it memorable.


5. Moonlight Butterfly - Dark Souls 1

dark souls moonlight butterfly
FromSoftware

Depending on your build, there is a fair chance that playing through the first game or the remaster, you might not even notice that this boss had a "gimmick" so to speak. If you were equipped to use ranged attacks or spells, then the Moonlight Butterfly (found in the Darkroot Garden) shouldn't have caused you much difficulty.

If you were a melee build, then chances are that you will have encountered what makes this boss a little unusual. Forced to fight only on a narrow bridge-like walkway, the player without a long-range option would find themselves dodging or blocking the attacks of the Butterfly as it floated painfully out of reach.

After what most would argue was a little too long, it would glide gently in to where the player was standing in order to feed on moss that grew on the bridge. If you were sufficiently geared, this one opening would be enough to see it off. If not, better get ready for more tedious dodging and rolling until it came back in to recharge.

Not a bad boss and not a bad gimmick, the main complaint was the length of time you were forced to wait before getting your hits in.


4. High Lord Wolnir - Dark Souls 3

dark souls 3 high lord wolnir
FomSoftware

Found in the Catacombs of Carthus, Lord Wolnir is a huge enemy who wears oddly shining bracelets. In one of Fromsoft's most obvious "hit the weak point" endeavours, damaging these bracelets enough to destroy them will take enormous chunks of health away from him.

While he can summon enemy skeletons (which he usually takes out by himself with long, sweeping arm attacks) the main danger that you'll find yourself in as a player is getting overly-zealous attacking his jewellery and becoming caught in the smog that he breathes out.

This can lead to a cheap and quick death, but the enormous sword he pulls from the ground which increases his attack range is the only other real concern during this fight. As long as you are patient and don't over commit, you will soon be sending the High Lord tumbling down into the abyss.

A minor note is that you can't re-enter this boss arena once you have killed him but if you forgot to grab the Grave Warden Pyromancy Tome, it will spawn in the corner of the bonfire room.

The fight is not considered difficult and as with the other "weak point" gimmicks, was met with a lukewarm reaction at best.


3. Bed Of Chaos - Dark Souls 1

Dark Souls Bed Of Chaos
Namco Bandai Games

It has been stated many times before, but it does bear mentioning again: the most infamous boss of the first Dark Souls game is downright unfair. As well as that, it is loaded with strange gimmicks that go against everything we've encountered before.

Firstly, you have a version of the "glowing weak spot" where there are roots on the far left and right sides of the arena that must be destroyed before it can be beaten. Getting to them between the sniping fireball attacks, collapsing floors and sweeping limbs can be a nightmare in and of itself, but mercifully, they do stay destroyed should you die and have to re-fight the boss.

The floor falling away and the attacks that sweep you down to your death can feel more like a platforming or memorisation challenge (alongside sheer luck) rather than the Dark Souls gameplay you've come to expect and the final jump down to the centre of the boss can be easily interrupted or deflected.

The fact that to destroy the boss, you need only swing your weapon at a small and insignificant looking core is cold comfort when you've taken so many unfair deaths. Not well remembered or enjoyed.


2. Deacon's Of The Deep - Dark Souls 3

Dark souls 3 deacons of the deep
FromSoftware

Found in the Cathedral of the Deep, this is another mob enemy where a horde of Deacons all rise once you enter the arena and slowly amble towards you. They're not very difficult they counter, as they do low damage and are easily distracted by alluring skulls, but you can still find yourself cursed if you don't pay close enough attention.

The gimmick is that a single deacon at a time will glow red, and only damaging that particular one will decrease their shared health bar. After each has been dispatched or enough time has passed, the red light will jump to the next enemy and the process repeats.

At half health, a final "boss" deacon spawns and only he needs to be attacked to finish them all off. Although he is surrounded by the larger variation of the mob enemies that can deflect you away with their force castings, for anyone at an appropriate soul or skill level, they should serve as nothing more than a speed bump.

While generally poorly received due to lack of difficulty and mob bosses being considered lazy in the series as a whole, this was compounded by the fact that players were expecting to face Aldrich here. A severe letdown.


1. Executioner's Chariot - Dark Souls 2

Executioners Chariot
From Software

Although there have been many complaints laid at the feet of Dark Souls 2 for its bosses, the Executioner's Chariot is an example of a gimmick boss done well.

Located in a tight track with infinitely re-spawning skeletons, the Chariot runs loops around the arena taking out players and mobs equally.

The trick is to take out the mages that revive the skeleton enemies, and then race to the end of the track and drop the gate which the Chariot will crash into. This "intended" method drops the Executioner to his death, and leaves you to fight his ghostly horses, who can pack a surprising punch.

The second option is to take out the mages as before so that the skeletons no longer respawn and then hide in an alcove and snipe at the Chariot as it passes. Shooting it with spells or arrows will reduce its HP until it is too weakened to make the jump at the end of each loop and is stuck, grasping the ledge. A single hit will see it off.

Generally accepted as being a new idea and not bad in and of itself, the lengthy run back should you die is the only downside to this boss.


Watch Next


How Well Do You Remember Dark Souls?

Oscar Of Astora
From Software

1. Which Knight Gives You His Estus Flask In The Undead Asylum?

In this post: 
Dark Souls
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Matthew is a Marine Engineer to trade who writes sub-standard Scottish crime fiction in his spare time that can be found here:- https://mmacleodwriting.uk/ Originally brought up in the Western Isles of Scotland, he lived in Edinburgh for 18 years but now stay in Aberdeenshire with his partner, sons and dog.