10 Hugely Anticipated Video Game Sequels (That Probably Aren't Happening)
Not getting a sequel to Doom Eternal is a tragedy.
If we told you Dead Island 2 got delayed yet again, you'd probably believe us.
What an absolute development journey that title has been on. Originally scheduled for 2015, going MIA, being re-revealed and then almost instantly pushed back yet again. It seems like a video game that might never happen.
It's not alone in that feeling either. There are several franchises that, despite their previous successes and fan demand, seem to be struggling. In the era of instant information, fans are privy to a lot of rumours and backstage hearsay. However, it also means that we hear worrying truths about video games stalling or, worse yet, nothing at all... implying that the title has hit a brick wall.
There can be any number of reasons a game doesn't find its way into the hands of consumers but its heart-breaking when fans are desperate for a follow-up to a title they loved that never comes. It could be a case of poor sales numbers, internal conflict or simply that the team have nothing more to give to a particular franchise.
The video games on this list are the sequels that fans are patiently waiting for, and might be wasting their time in doing so.
10. Alien Isolation 2
As a series of video games adapted from a cinematic franchise, Alien titles have run the full gambit of quality over the last forty years.
Even as the franchise continues to tick over with squad based shooter Fireteam: Elite and RTS title Dark Descent due in 2023, an insider report from November 2022 about another new game caught quite a bit of attention. It said that Sega, who have owned the rights to the franchise for over 10 years, are working on an Alien survival horror title based on the likes of Dead Space and Resident Evil.
Of course, this conjured thoughts in many that the game might be the long awaited follow-up to Alien Isolation. Not just narratively brilliant, offering a wealth of new information to Alien lore, Isolation was a stand-out modern survival horror masterpiece that made the classic cinema monster scary in whole new ways.
Despite brief considerations, a sequel did not come and most of the core team from Creative Assembly moved on quickly after finishing their work on the game. With this in mind, whatever this Alien title is and however great it might be, it will not be Isolation 2.
It’s better to keep an open mind with this one. Hopefully, if nothing else, it will be a worthy spiritual successor.
9. Oddworld 3
Once one of the many recognisable and promising faces of the future of PlayStation, Abe and his merry band of weirdo aliens became, for a time, little more than nostalgia and a sign of squandered potential.
Despite praise from most who played them, both Munch’s Odyssey and Stranger’s Wrath failed to garner much sales success. Thankfully, Just Add Water’s remake of the original Abe’s Odyssey was able to kickstart what the company referred to as the “Oddworld Quintology”.
Lorne Lanning, co-founder of Oddworld Inhabitants and general face of the brand, was always keen to share his excitement about building upon the series. Many great Oddworld proposals, including a canned strategy title called Hand of Odd, have been teased because of Lanning’s upfront nature.
In May 2021, after the success of Oddworld: SoulStorm, Lanning said that he had ideas for the follow-up but didn’t want to talk about them because a “third game hadn’t even been financed”.
That right there is a worrying sign for a proposed series of five titles, especially considering SoulStorm’s protracted development and multiple delays surely would have affected the game’s final budget. Considering that financial troubles within the industry was the reason that Oddworld Inhabitants shut their doors back in 2005 and left the industry for a long time… it’s not looking good.
8. Half-Life 3
It can’t be a list of long awaited video game sequels without Half-Life 3. It’s almost too obvious. That being said, despite the neverending wait, fans of the world of Black Mesa got closer to hope than ever before in 2020.
After 13 years of silence since Half-Life 2: Episode Two, Valve shocked the world by announcing a VR-exclusive spin-off. Some argued that Half-Life: Alyx was a gimmicky direction for the series to take after so much time away. However, most fans were just excited that there was any new life being breathed into Half-Life at all.
The true follow-up to Half-Life 2 has been infamously delayed due to the studio never settling on a direction for its gameplay nor its story after its famous shocking cliffhanger.
By setting Alyx between the events of Half-Life and its sequel, Valve were able to avoid digging themselves out of that hole and continue their trend of never making games that end in “3”.
Reviews for Alyx itself were incredibly strong so, if anything, it seems like this VR experiment might wind up getting a follow-up long before Gordon Freeman’s mainline adventure. At the very least this means the immortal “Half-Life 3 confirmed” memes can continue… but at what cost?
7. Days Gone 2
Bend Studio, for a long time, really only had Syphon Filter on their portfolio so for them to design a new franchise for the PlayStation 4 was an intriguing prospect. The end result was Days Gone, a game that firmly split opinion which, funnily enough, is exactly why it fits into this list.
Many of those who played it found it to be an exciting, if flawed, open-world zombie survival adventure. However, ultimately not enough people were sold on the tired premise that it really mattered. Days Gone’s potential as a franchise was ultimately stunted by underwhelming sales.
Outspoken director John Garvin was understandably frustrated with this but went a little too far to blame consumers, saying on a podcast appearance “if you like a game, buy it a full !*$% price”. A recent, subsequently deleted tweet, also put the onus on so-called “woke” reviewers.
In actuality, Days Gone’s fate was a combination of bad marketing from Sony and the concept simply feeling overplayed. Sure, defeating hordes of zombies felt great but the post-apocalyptic zombie shooter was truly exhausted by this point by the TV shows that had inspired Days Gone, not to mention frankly better video games.
Deacon St. John and company, it seems, will not be rising from the dead for another go-around.
6. The Evil Within 3
The original The Evil Within was a chance for survival horror maestro Shinji Mikami to try his hand at a fresh palette. He had regretted the more action-heavy direction that the genre had gone in since his time working on Resident Evil 4, and PsychoBreak, as it’s known in Japan, was his attempt to restore balance.
A new IP is always a gamble but largely The Evil Within paid off. It wasn’t without its faults but it caught enough interest that a sequel was greenlit and delivered three years later.
The Evil Within 2, almost expertly, improved on the first in every way, including a pseudo open world and a 15-hour campaign stuffed with spooks and frights. With Mikami in the producer chair, it allowed new director John Johanas and his team to really push the franchise forward instead of being a more straight-forward follow-up.
However, Mikami is famously not a fan of sequels, having only ever directed one in his entire career (the aforementioned Resi 4) which might be one contributing factor to why the studio’s most recent project became a new IP. Despite starting out as The Evil Within 3, the final product was Ghostwire Tokyo, which released earlier this year to positive reviews, leaving The Evil Within in the figurative dark for around five years now.
5. Star Wars Battlefront 3
In terms of video games notoriously cancelled late into development, you don’t get many as disappointing as Star Wars Battlefront 3 for the PS2.
However, after years of laying dormant, the franchise got a new lease on life in 2015 when EA Games partnered with famed Battlefield franchise developers DICE. With the great difference in era there were major changes to the gameplay, of course, but the core principle of taking part in some of the most important battles in the galaxy far, far away remained the same.
Despite issues, and massive microtransactions controversy (what do you expect, it’s Electronic Arts), both 2015’s Battlefront and its 2017 sequel were solid multiplayer shooters, as was to be expected out of DICE. Better yet, the beautiful visuals and brilliant sound made it the closest players would get to actually being in the middle of a Rebel Alliance vs Empire blaster battle.
Would this relaunch, at least, make it to a third entry?
Insider reports in 2021 said that EA had butted heads with Disney over the expensive licensing for Star Wars and things got even more unsure when there was a changeover in management. In December 2021, EA announced that Ripple Effect Studios (the former DICE LA) would handle what was described as "new experiences" in the Battlefront series.
Meaning, whilst the next game might bear the name, it could be very different indeed.
4. Beyond Good & Evil 2
The original Beyond Good and Evil was a labour of love for Rayman creator Michel Ancel who spent three years with his team crafting the cult hit action-adventure. Originally envisioned as at least a trilogy, it’s now been 15 years since the sequel was officially greenlit - making it the longest development time for a game ever.
The last time we fans got a look at Beyond Good and Evil 2 was a cinematic at E3 2017 which was a beautiful, riveting tease that felt as though the wheels were finally on the track. And then… nothing.
In 2020, Ancel came under fire as a pretty terrible boss to work for who was known for scrapping work and restarting projects numerous times. After departing the team in the wake of this, perhaps now the sequel could finally pick a path and walk it. In February 2022 Ubisoft said that the game “remains in pre-production after at least five years of development”.
What?!
Fans had wasted years of their lives waiting and hoping for this sequel which seems to be trapped forever in development hell. By the same metric, Ubisoft had wasted 10 years on the project with multiple versions that presumably were worked on and then discarded.
How much more development time will they pay for before calling it quits? Every studio has their limits on how much money they’ll throw away…
3. Viewtiful Joe 3
Hideki Kamiya is a strange enigma of a man. Cutting his teeth in a directorial debut on survival horror classic Resident Evil 2, he has gone to be known for crafting some of the best action games to come out of Japan (and for his never ending crusade of blocking people on Twitter).
Some of Kamiya’s most underrated works are the Viewtiful Joe games, a comic book style beat-em-up series with a lot of heart and buckets of wackiness and fourth wall breaking.
The short-lived series built a cult following with some speed but, ultimately, poor sales put the franchise on ice. Most painfully, this meant that the sequel’s cliffhanger has gone unanswered for 15 years.
At San Diego Comic-Con in 2016, Capcom producer Jun Takeuchi was asked about Viewtiful Joe and, after praising the work of his former colleague, admitted that it was pretty unlikely there would ever be another.
By this point, Kamiya had long since departed the company to work at Platinum Games. However, it seems that, like the fans, he hadn’t forgotten about his Viewtiful creation. In 2020, he admitted that he would love to finish the trilogy but that such decisions were out of his hands.
2. Bloodborne 2
Whilst the Dark Souls trilogy might be the purest example of FromSoftware’s style, Bloodborne caught the imagination of many that much more. With its dark fantasy vibe and amazing monster designs, Bloodborne screams for wider recognition.
Famously, auteur Hidetaka Miyazaki passed on directing duties for the sequel to Dark Souls to work on other projects but did return to the franchise for the third game. This marks the only direct sequel he’s ever made. Furthermore, it makes Dark Souls the only IP that FromSoftware has sequelised in the last decade and a half.
From the off-set this already makes things a pretty unlikely situation for fans of Yharnam but Miyazaki spelt out rather precisely in a GameSpot interview in 2016:
“I'm not thinking about making any sequels or spin-offs. That applies to Bloodborne as well.”
Dark Souls remains an outlier in this way but if FromSoftware was going to be convinced to craft a sequel of any kind it would undoubtedly be for the sea change that was Elden Ring. For the Soulsborne style, it transformed the formula by taking it out into the open-world. For the industry, Elden Ring was without a doubt the biggest game of 2022.
If you’re not really a Bloodborne fan and instead are waiting to hear about more from Sekiro, you can pretty much reread this entry with Sekiro in mind instead for all the same (heartbreaking) reasons.
1. Doom 3
After a long absence from the industry, it was a heart-warming success story that Doom’s 2016 relaunch and subsequent sequel Eternal were universally praised.
However, controversies have begun to swirl around the soundtrack for the second game that might have a serious impact on its future. There’s a lot of accusations between id Software’s Marty Stratton and Doom guitar smith Mick Gordon about their working agreements, pay disputes and so on that put the future of the franchise in doubt.
You might think that losing a composer shouldn’t have quite that level of ramifications but the soundtracks for the recent Doom outings have been a huge contributing factor to their success. The juddering combination of metal and glitch-hop amps up the momentum-based gameplay and adds so much to the intensity, whether you’re doing the demon slaying or being the slain.
Without Gordon’s work, the games would’ve been far lesser.
Moreover, this online war of statements has made the whole situation exceptionally muddy. Whatever the level of truth to either side’s claims, it’s not a good look for Bethesda and id Software. Doom Eternal launched two years ago and in that time we’ve heard nary a whisper about a follow-up.
Doom, as a franchise, will never die but it may have to mutate once more to survive.