10 Major Problems With 2018's Biggest Video Games

Could Red Dead Redemption 2 be Rockstar's first big mistake?

Video Games 2018
Sony/Rockstar/Ubisoft

The games industry is in a very weird spot right now. Though we've got access to more types of games across all sorts of budgets, the 'triple-A' market is dominated by identikit genres and mechanics. Think mandated DLC, loot grinds, microtransactions, blind boxes and multiple currencies.

Something like Agents of Mayhem is the most obvious example of all these systems made into a soulless - and yet functioning - product, but what does that mean going forward? Will we ever get to the point where such homogenous approaches to game design are rolled out across the majority of what's on offer?

It is true that to get many of gaming's most innovative titles, you need to look away from the top sellers list - and Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice proved that there can be a middle-ground between budget and a head-turning aesthetic - but for the most part, 2018 is a whole ton of sequels, and a whole ton of recycled ideas.

Not to say the following titles will 'fail' in any major respect, but there are plenty of outstanding issues that I guarantee are already on your mind - they just need a little prodding...


10. David Cage Has Nowhere Near The Appropriate Chops To Write About Racial Segregation

DETROIT become human
Quantic Dream

Although I have the greatest faith in Mr. Cage when it comes to innovative concepts and facial technology that brings them to life, we're yet to see a truly brilliant game from the divisive auteur.

Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy went from being a gritty murder mystery to a ridiculous scenario where you fought the living embodiment of the internet, and besides having some good acting from Ellen Page, Beyond: Two Souls saw you battling a giant wall of sand with a face. Even Heavy Rain is the nearest we came to a genuinely recommendable game, but its naff ("Jason!") voice acting and forced final twist stick out with every mention.

All of which is to say: Is David Cage - and by extension, are Quantic Dream - really the people to tackle a game about race and slavery? Framed as a tale surrounding the sorts of human rights issues prevalent in fiction such as Blade Runner, Star Trek: The Next Generation and Fallout 4, Detroit: Become Human will attempt to explore the very ramifications of sentience in tandem with an entire 'race' of androids gaining consciousness and escaping a life of servitude.

On paper it's a great concept to marry with a branching narrative, but in the hands of David Cage?

Don't be surprised if this ends with us fighting a giant metal face the size of a house.


9. Crackdown 3 Doesn't Have A Single Original Hook

Crackdown 3
Microsoft

Let's not beat around the agility orb - Crackdown 3 is being released to die.

Even with the Xbox One X potentially ensnaring more consumers across the Xmas period, there's not a single thing about its marketing, 'new' game features or overall aesthetic that looks worthwhile. Yes, you can argue that "more Crackdown" is a good thing, but that was the mandate for the utterly threadbare Crackdown 2 in 2010, which led to the seven year hiatus in the first place.

Indeed, Crackdown worked because it dropped in an era before superheroes dominated the culture-sphere, before open-world games would become one of gaming's most prominent genres in the medium, and before the Saints Row franchise would go hog-wild with various overblown abilities of their own.

Crackdown 3 has nothing to offer than a "fully destructible world", which when the base gameplay will be more plain high-jumping and float-shooting, just isn't enough.


8. The Last Of Us 2 Elongates A Story That Has Nowhere To Go

The last of us 2
Naughty Dog

Contentious, sure, but even Naughty Dog's own Neil Druckmann had to speak out after the announcement of TLoU 2 with the words "Trust us", as a way of allaying features the sequel immediately felt tacked on.

Yes, there's ground to be explored in regards to the idea that Ellie continues to question how much of Joel's Firefly story was true - or what the world around her will do when they find out she IS the cure to the zombie apocalypse - but isn't all of this besides the point? The entirety of The Last of Us was set up to provoke the question: How far would you go, to save someone you love?

Druckmann himself has posited different readings as to how the game is also a comment on feminism and independence, being Ellie grows to know that she could survive without Joel at the end, but regardless, the very nature of posing those questions and cutting to black ended the project in the best way possible.

Dredging up more motivations to keep going almost feels like there's nothing worthwhile to excavate, and when Uncharted 4's story - alongside still being enjoyable enough - had to fall back on "Actually, there was a secret brother we never addressed before", it's not the most reassuring state of affairs going into next year.


7. Spider-Man Is Playing It Too Safe

Spider Man PS4 Combat
Insomniac

Spidey certainly looks glossy enough, and with Insomniac at the helm I'm sure it'll play just fine - but is there anything new here that we haven't seen before?

A few quickfire context prompts have Spidey bringing in parts of the environment to clobber foes, sure, but for the vast majority of the two gameplay demos we've seen, this looks to be aping the Arkham series to a fault. Hiding in designated contextual spots, fighting enemies with "watch for the icon" combat and indulging in quick-time events for the biggest set-pieces - it's all going to play well enough, but when this is THE big exclusive Spider-Man game on PS4, it's falling short in the gameplay department.

Here's hoping there's something more to the swinging mechanics or overall feel of hurtling Spidey through New York than what we've had for the last decade-plus, because if not, this isn't going to land in anywhere near the same way as Rocksteady's 2009 masterpiece.


6. Shenmue III Genuinely Can't Live Up To Expectations

Shenmue Ryo Hazuki
Sega

Why does Shenmue matter?

For all but the most specific audience (those who owned a Dreamcast and stuck around to play Shenmue 1 and 2), the answer to that question is a mystery, but I'll tell you why: Because creator Yu Suzuki and developers YS Net were doing something genuinely unprecedented. Something that is nigh-on impossible to replicate in the modern climate.

See, back in the 90s we'd never seen video games that imitated the 'feel' of a big Hollywood production. Voice acting, 'directed' cutscenes, an epic story and real characters you could empathise with - Metal Gear Solid perfected this and had the reach of PlayStation to boot, but Shenmue was doing its best on Dreamcast, too.

Alongside the sensation of the game being an 'epic story' were all sorts of interactions with the environment itself. Things like picking up random items to inspect them, playing arcade games, winning at capsule machines and more would probably be left out of modern titles as "pointless", but back then it helped create an unprecedented sensation of interaction and escapism. And that, is why Shenmue mattered - that quintessential sensation of gaming growing as a medium right in front of you.

There is almost no way that Shenmue III can 'work' in a games industry that has no meaningful barriers of interaction left to break down.


5. There's Not A Soul On Earth That Wants Metal Gear Survive

Metal Gear Survive
Konami

It's "the next Metal Gear" and it's backed by Kojima Productions' immaculate FOX Engine, but... Hideo Kojima and his team are nowhere to be seen.

Following the fallout between Kojima-san and the higher-ups at Konami, Hideo jumped ship to Sony, leaving the Metal Gear IP in the destructive hands of his former employer. Their first port of call was to create another entry in the franchise sans Kojima, and with Konami being Konami (the studio who canned Silent Hills and made pachinko machines out of their most valued IP) we're now getting a 'zombie survival' Metal Gear.

Yup - it's just about the most generic framework you could apply to any action-focused franchise, being paired with a canon that's one of the richest, most beloved and most multifaceted in gaming history. Sufficed to say that despite the marketing power behind how it's sure to be shown off in 2018, nobody wants a Metal Gear where a wormhole takes your former Mother Base soldiers and pits them against hordes of the undead.


4. God Of War's Combat Can't Be Another Dark Souls

god of war 4
Sony

"Oh, they're rebooting God of War?! That's kinda cool!"

"Hmm, the feel of this is very Last of Us, I guess they're trying to make Naughty Dog's approach a Sony trait?"

"Well the combat looks... fine... I guess?"

Such was the response to Sony's unveiling of the 'all-new' Kratos and his foray into fatherhood. The concept is brilliant: Take a character often parodied for being overly aggressive to a fault and make it so he's actually getting over real anger issues, and factor in a small child to take care of - one who'll probably remember your actions and replicate in tow.

The problem comes with combat that - like everything from Hellblade to Assassin's Creed Origins - is now going down the "Dark Souls route".

Aiming to make any duel more immediately weighty and impactful as the camera is right down there with Kratos when he's under attack, there really needs to be something more than just this to God of War's rebooted action. Being the original series pioneered quick-time events (that went on to change the face of controllable action for a decade thereafter), this franchise cannot be the one copycatting someone else's innovations.


3. Anthem Is Already "Generic Space Shooter: The Game"

Anthem Squad
Bioware

The Bioware of today are nowhere near the Bioware that many of us grew up genuinely adoring. Going from releasing some of the finest RPGs in gaming history like Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, Mass Effect 1-3 and Neverwinter Nights, this decade they've been more closely associated with train wrecks like Mass Effect Andromeda, or the thoroughly badly paced Dragon Age Inquisition.

Looking at Anthem it's very clear that their latest new IP isn't going to come with the same sense of purpose we first had in the likes of Mass Effect, as though it was just a quick demo, Anthem is yet another loot-shooter. That means multiple currencies, a 'shared online world', the apparent need to grind out loot with your raid team and everything else.

Where we once associated Bioware with being on the cutting edge of sci-fi game design - whether it be their own creation or someone else's - there's a marked feeling of "Erm... sure?" to Anthem that will remain a problem until we see something more original.


2. Far Cry 5 Can't Help Coming Out At The Worst Possible Time

Far Cry 5
Ubisoft

Far Cry 5's upcoming issues are not the fault of Ubisoft - at least not outside of choosing to centre a game around a small hyper right-wing cult of extremists cordoning off a chunk of the American Bible belt to stage a coup, anyway.

Sadly, in the time Far Cry 5 has been in development we've seen increasingly violent unrest across America. Left and right political ideologies are more fractured than ever, the 'Alt-Right' and 'Antifa' both feel like something from a fictional context in the first place, and outside of many left-wingers associating the cartoonish depiction of the right with the "Project at Eden's Gate" cult in-game, we have the recent travesty in Las Vegas overtop.

Releasing a game based on gunning down Americans that's so politically-charged - intentionally or not, depending on which facet you're analysing - can only result in a melting pot of reactionary opinions and twisted intent - one that is a major problem for Far Cry 5's messaging no matter which way you look at it.


1. Red Dead Redemption 2 Has Had A Ton Of Behind-The-Scenes Problems

Red dead redemption 2
Rockstar

You can read all about Red Dead 2's entire list of leaks over here, but one of the most disastrous comes from Rockstar having a ton of trouble across Redemption 2's development. The story goes that Rockstar San Diego put together a number of 'versions' of what could be a Red Dead Redemption 2, only for the top brass to knock their pitches back for being "not innovative enough". This is apparently why the game was a no-show at E3, why we still don't have a release date despite two trailers - and why even within that second trailer, the general feeling was 'more of the same.'

Looking at the game's second trailer this is certainly quite apparent, as over time it looks like all facets of Rockstar eventually decided to release a more basic sequel, rather than something that upends expectations in a way the original did.

Time will tell how it all shakes out - and of course, even 'more Red Dead' will be f'ing awesome - but sadly RDR2 isn't the "all hands on deck" effort it perhaps could have been.


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.