10 Seriously Twisted Quests In Video Games

Cyberpunk 2077 GOES places.

Video games are capable of making you feel all sorts of things. Elated, surprised, depressed, or completely and utterly creeped out.

Today we’re focussing on the video game quests that truly disturbed us. The video game industry is huge right now meaning there are more games than ever and those games are taking us to places that we’ve never been before and depending on how squeamish you are, they might be places you didn’t necessarily want to go.

For the rest of us who love a bit of nastiness in our video games, these quests are frankly stunning.

Albeit a little stomach churning and likely to keep you up at night.

--

10. Sinnerman - Cyberpunk 2077

cyberpunk 2077 sinnerman
CD Projekt RED

Spoiler alert, you’ll be seeing a lot of CD Projekt Red entries on this list because for some reason nobody does horrifically messed up quests quite like they do.

Cyberpunk 2077 in particular is a playground for all kinds of disturbing side missions and one of the most notable is unfortunately extremely missable. You’ll have no problem finding this quest but it continues to give you opportunities to nope out of it so there’s a chance you won’t see it through to its conclusion which would be a shame because it really goes places. You’ll run into one of Night City’s most colourful characters on a routine escort to help a guy get revenge. Things go sideways and the guy you’re supposed to be helping gets shot but into your life walks Joshua, a death row inmate being accompanied by a film executive and an officer.

Joshua is after redemption for doing a lot of murdering and he’s decided he wants to be literally crucified.

Night City being awful has enabled this and the aforementioned exec wants to get it on camera. You’re given a multitude of opportunities to nope out but stick with this one to the bitter end and Joshua will ask you to nail him to the cross. You do so, if you want to, watch him be hoisted up, and witness his final moments.


9. Questionable Contract - The Elder Scrolls Online

Questionable Contract - The Elder Scrolls Online
Bethesda

This is the only quest on this list from ESO but not the only Elder Scrolls entry because if there’s one other studio that knows how to mess your day up with a truly twisted quest it’s Bethesda.

Questionable Contract involved a mage who has been brought on to help a village expand their beehives by clearing the forest. Which, I know, doesn’t sound all that dramatic, bear with me. See, the village are stoked for the help but they aren’t a big fan of mages so in a totally rational move they kidnap the guy’s wife and hold her hostage so that just in case he fails at the task they have retribution. Will they kill him? Will they kill the wife? Oh no, these crazy bastards are going to make him eat his wife as punishment. Turns out there’s a Daedric twist in there messing things up even more and you need to get to the bottom of it before things really unravel.

Of course, you show up and save the day being the hero that you are but the whole thing is really touch and go for a bit there.


8. A Towerful Of Mice - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

the witcher 3 towerful of mice
CD Projekt RED

Whittling The Witcher 3 down to just one horrific quest that’ll keep you up at night is a fool’s errand and while The Bloody Baron and his Botchling unborn child is the most popular example, we’re sidestepping that to give this entry to another unsettling quest, A Towerful Of Mice. Venture to the rat-riddled tower on Fyke Isle and you can use the lantern to watch conversations between spirits in their final moments to give you clues as to what has gone down here.

You eventually meet Anabelle who tells you a mage had been experimenting on rats, essentially giving them the Bubonic plague.

Peasants revolted and stormed the tower intending to do a lot of murdering so Anabelle took a potion from the mage assuming it would kill her peacefully but instead it simply put her into a deathless paralysis. The peasants were fooled into thinking she killed herself, as was her lover Graham who left her there, but when she awoke she was still unable to move and the plague-ridden rats slowly ate her alive. This has turned her into a Plague Maiden which honestly, fair enough, and you can help break the curse or let her and the plague loose on the mainland.


7. Flowers For A Lady - Red Dead Redemption

red dead redemption flowers for a lady
Rockstar

Red Dead Redemption II has plenty of quests that leave a chilling mark on you but let's not forget the horrors that preceded it and the Red Dead Redemption stranger side mission Flowers for a Lady is a great example.

This one starts off super tame, an old man wants your help in picking flowers that he can present to his wife as a gift for their 50th anniversary. Cute, right? Well lots of players got bored of this one because you’re a cool cowboy who doesn't want to waste time picking flowers all over the map but you would have missed out on the conclusion which is a shame. Or a great call. Depending on whether or not you want to be traumatised. You see, once the job is done you enter the man’s cabin and realise his dear wife is actually a desiccated corpse.

Yeah… it seems this guy is in massive denial and it’s particularly chilling since the man seems completely calm and collected about it and talks to his wife like she’s alive.

Your stomach drops as soon as Marston enters the cabin and while he’s plenty polite about the whole thing, there’s an undercurrent of deep sadness to this one that makes the whole thing even more unsettling.


6. The Gilding - The Forgotten City

the forgotten city
Modern Storyteller

The Forgotten City is a phenomenal little game that launched in 2021 and while it’s already weird that you’ve fallen into a Roman city stuck in a time loop, the quest at the game’s core is probably its most disturbing.

I have to do a bit of spoiling here so if you haven’t played this one yet and you’re keen to get into it come meet me over at number five.

The thing you need to know is that the titular city is filled with golden statues. Which is weird. And you know that when a ‘golden rule’ is broken, like murdering or stealing, the statues come alive and start killing people and everyone in the city turns to gold. At one point you find yourself in a sprawling underground palace riddled with statues and while they’re certainly trying to take you out you realise they’re only doing so so that you’ll retaliate and kill them.

The statues are creepy enough as it is but it’s all the more distressing when you discover they’re in permanent torment which is why they thank you for ending their suffering. You discover that these statues are people, trapped in gold forever for having broken the city’s rule in its earlier iterations. As if that isn’t bad enough a woman named Naevia has decided to try and cure the statues by ripping apart the gold shell to get to the person beneath which in short did not work.

And in a slightly longer explanation, she was essentially flaying these people alive in the hopes of finding a cure to save her lover.

There’s plenty more to the story and your journey through it but to sum up it’s pretty incredibly messed up.


5. The Sad Sorcerer - The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

elder scrolls III morrowind the sad sorceror
Bethesda

Let me tell you about the story of the wizard Inwold, another pretty bloody unfortunate mage in the Elder Scrolls universe if we’re being honest.

In a side quest aptly named The Sad Sorcerer, Inwold finds himself in a bit of a pickle having been taken prisoner by his own magical creations. When you rock up they’ve forced him to wear a funny hat and a skirt which is pretty entertaining, but then you find out one of his spells failed catastrophically and killed all his smuggler crew friends which is less entertaining. Worse still, his scamp creations have been force feeding him soup made out of his dead friends so that’s really, really bad.

Even if you get him out of there you can’t make up for the horrors he’s already experienced. You can let him keep his skirt and hat though which seems like the least you can do.


4. Overlord - Mass Effect 2

Mass Effect 2 Overlord
Electronic Arts

The Mass Effect trilogy has plenty of stand out DLCs and it's probably for that reason alone that the incredible Overlord DLC for Mass Effect 2 really isn’t discussed enough. While it’s worth pointing out this content does some fairly awkward and borderline offensive things with its representation of autism, it’s still a really fascinating story. Essentially the DLC stars David Archer, a mathematical genius who you discover is the unwilling mind behind the Overlord VI who has been wreaking havoc across the planet.

Unwilling as in his own brother has physically hooked David up to the machines to communicate with the geth and yes, it looks exactly as gross as you think.

It’s one of the most arresting images in all of Mass Effect and while saving David from his predicament and psychotic brother is a no-brainer, the psychological torment of exploring the station and horrifying visuals are impossible to shake. As a small mercy, you can send David to Grissom Academy at the end of the quest and he pops up again in Mass Effect 3 so that’s nice.


3. All That Remains - Dragon Age 2

dragon age 2 all that remains
Bioware

Dragon Age 2 might not be the most popular Dragon Age game or even the second most popular Dragon Age game but it does some really interesting things and the nasty All That Remains quest is one of them.

Hawke is hunting a serial killer through Kirkwall who leaves white lilies at his victims homes as a calling card. Things get personal when Hawke’s own mother Leandra receives the threatening flowers and then goes missing. Your chase leads you to eventually discover your own mother has been cut to pieces in a bloodmage’s sickening plan to revive his dead wife. The reveal where she slowly turns around and you’re hoping against hope she’s somehow okay is incredibly rough and killing off the mage means losing your mother once again. The entire sequence is frankly heartbreaking.

It’s not particularly gory but it’s so disturbing and horrifying, it’s a tough one to get out of your mind.


2. The Taste Of Death - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

The Taste Of Death - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Bethesda

If there’s mischief and twisted business about in any Elder Scrolls game there’s a pretty good chance a Daedric Prince or Lord is behind it and The Taste Of Death is no exception.

Venture into the Hall of the Dead in Markarth after following rumours that it’s been shut due to bodies being defiled and you’ll meet Eola. Eola is a bit of a weirdo to put it really, really lightly as you find out she worships the Daedric Lord Namira and she’s been eating the bodies in the crypt. She asks if you can help her out by killing off some Draugr which seems acceptable but then she asks if you can bring a priest to her cool cannibal initiation feast so they can kill and eat him.

You can then go ahead and decide if that’s something you want to do or not. No judgement.


1. The Hunt - Cyberpunk 2077

cyberpunk 2077 the hunt
CD Projekt RED

I’ve put this one at number one because it’s the quest I did recently that inspired me to write this list in the first place and it felt like I was literally playing through an episode of Hannibal so strap in because this one is extra nasty.

For this quest you’ll join forces with River Ward, a former detective and incidentally my V’s main squeeze in Night City. You’re on the search for his missing nephew Randy who you discover has been groomed online by a man called Peter Pan. The further you get down the rabbit hole of this one the more awful it gets and just when you think things can’t get worse you remember this game is written by CD Projekt Red and of course it can.

Your frantic chase brings you to an old cattle farm where you find the bodies of multiple drugged up and deceased young men.

You race from body to body trying to find River’s nephew Randy and save any of the boys who aren’t too far gone. It’s a gut-wrenching series of missions as things continue to get more insidious and in a game riddled with unforgettable horrors, this one probably tops them all.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.