10 Unintentionally Hilarious 90s Horror Video Games

Horror has never been so... bad.

Alone in the dark
Infogrames

Much like comedy, horror is often subjective. While those of lesser constitution may still shy away from the totally lame haunted mansion ride at the local fair, horror veterans remain unmoved by all but the most grotesque examples of the genre. That said, there are a few pieces of media out there which absolutely no one finds scary.

Crafting a compelling atmosphere of terror can be a difficult undertaking. If done correctly, a movie, book or game can be so shocking as to be utterly unforgettable. Mess it up, though, and everyone associated with the project will look like a total idiot.

There are, of course, a few movies and games which have blended the realms of horror and comedy to great effect, though they're relatively few and far between. For every one truly frightening experience, there are likely another ten that don't come even close.

Well-done scares capture the imagination, compelling audiences to laugh at their own fear. Bad horror, on the other hand, usually has people laughing for an entirely different reason. The 1990's, for whatever reason, seems to have been a prime time for shlocky horror, particularly in video games...

10. Dark Seed (1992)

dark seed
Cyberdreams

Dark Seed was an interesting PC exclusive notable for the inclusion of artwork created by none other than notorious weirdo artist H. R. Geiger. It was a delightfully bizarre romp through a world split in half by an eldritch alien force seemingly intent on corrupting middle American life.

It would have been a relatively compelling horror experience were it not for the downright horrendous voice acting. Some of the voice lines present here are legendarily bad, and—very much in keeping with many horror games of the early 90's—the protagonist is nothing short of a total dork.

The sequel, which relied pretty heavily on now painfully outdated FMV technology, was perhaps even more cringe-worthy. The protagonist approaches McLovin levels of nerdy, and the whole thing is so incredibly off-kilter that it's outright hilarious.

The best line of dialogue in this duology also comes from the second game: upon approaching a mannequin in a storage room, the protagonist remarks "I don't really expect this mannequin to talk to me, but it's a nice fantasy." Already little more than a walking social faux pas, this line, though incredibly funny, makes the series difficult to take seriously.


9. Nitemare 3D (1994)

nitemare 3d
Gray Design

1994's FPS Doom clone Nitemare 3D likely wasn't intended to shock anyone to their very core or keep anyone awake at night. Plus, it was an offshoot of an already cartoony series of early DOS games known as Hugo's House of Horrors which poked fun at a litany of classic horror cliches. Altogether inoffensive, this Doom wannabe does deserve some criticism for its unabashed aping of mid-90's video game trends.

While Id software's Doom was a landmark title that doubtlessly scared the pants off of the younger members of its massive audience, Nitemare 3D is by no means similar in that regard. In fact, in direct comparison to the game it tried so hard to emulate, Nitemare 3D seems positively ridiculous.

At the end of the day, though, Nitemare 3D is an overall lighthearted title which never sought to take itself all that seriously. In fact, the game inclues a very tongue-in-cheek moment during which one of the game's skeleton enemies pops out of a closet. That's about as meta as a joke about horror tropes could possibly be.

It may have scared a few young kids back in the day, but, twenty-dd years on, Nitemare 3D is more hilarious than anything.


8. D (1995)

d game
WARP

D, a 1995 Sega Saturn and PlayStation horror title, is one of a handful of underrated classics from the underappreciated Japanese video game auteur Kenji Eno. More of an interactive experience than a true video game, D clearly took some cues from the at-the-time super popular point-and-click puzzle title Myst.

D—an obscure game released on an already obscure console—was perhaps a bit too far ahead of its time. Succeeded spiritually by modern titles like Until Dawn or the Penumbra series, D asked players to prioritize slow-paced decision making and riddle solving over minute-to-minute, high-octane horror thrills.

While this might have been a fondly-remembered gem, it is ultimately brought down by its blatant overuse of terrible CG FMV cut-scenes. Large portions of the game appear to have been developed by a team of students in an Intro to 3D Modeling 101 community college course, and it makes the experience much more outlandish and slapstick than it should be.

D may have been a commendable effort at the time, but its hilariously awful reliance on bargain bin computer generated imagery leaves it as a borderline comedic experience these days.


7. Blue Stinger (1999)

1348427

Blue Stinger plays and feels very much like an early demo of Sega's 2014 horror titan Alien: Isolation. Released during a time in which Sega seemed like it may be able to recover from the tragedy that was the Saturn, Blue Stinger sought to reel in a more mature crowd without totally compromising the DreamCast's child-friendly aesthetic.

The result was a hilarious and totally bizarre combination of otherworldly horror and abhorrent gameplay decisions. In some ways, this Resident Evil wannabe almost feels like it sought introduce the gameplay of Shenmue to Raccoon City, though it really only manages to come off as a poor mans' version of both of these titles.

Despite being visually competent for the console generation in which it was released, it falls laughably flat in terms of mechanics. Resident Evil's tank controls may have been clunky, but this escalates those issues to the nth degree.

Blue Stinger has becomes something of a cult hit in recent years. Much like a bad B horror flick, it is perhaps admired more for its cheesy elements than for any genuinely well-developed ideas it may put forth.


6. Phantasmagoria 2: A Puzzle Of Flesh (1996)

phantasmagoria game
Sierra

Phantasmagoria 2 may well be the creme de la creme of cheesy mid-90's FMV horror titles. Featuring a protagonist strong in the running for geekiest man in the world and exploring a plot so incredibly over-the-top as to be far-past ridiculous, this weird gem is a must play for fans of off-kilter scares.

An outlandish adventure spurred by a series of suspicious workplace murders surrounding the protagonist, things eventually spiral so far out of control that the player ends up encountering nefarious doppelgangers and escaping alternate dimensions. That's to say nothing of the insane gore and fetishistic brutality present in the game: while many titles of its ilk were careful not to tread into ridiculous, unbelievable territory, Phantasmagoria 2 proudly and deliberately jumps the shark while juggling a set of flaming chainsaws.

It may still seem unnerving to some, but the hammy acting and overall inanity of this piece of software makes it much funnier than it really should be. This may be a subjective viewpoint, but 1996's Phantasmagoria 2: A Puzzle of Flesh is more memorable for its deliberately dramatic, idiosyncratic nature than it is for any real scares.


5. Resident Evil (1996)

Resident Evil 1
Capcom

The original Resident Evil game is a classic horror title in every sense of the word, and fans of modern horror video game experiences owe just about everything to this revolutionary release. Praise for this game is wide-spread and well-recognized, though its faults are perhaps often a bit understated.

Released during the height of the mid-90s FMV craze, the original PlayStation disc included a series of fully-acted video sequences. Capcom clearly wasted no time in dragging their actors out of the dumpster behind their studio, and these brief clips are so incredibly funny that they nearly ruin the tone of the entire game. Often considered to be a masterclass in atmosphere building otherwise, it isn't surprising to see these goofy little segments axed in subsequent releases.

The original Resident Evil title has been re-released and remastered nearly more times than anyone would care to count, and many of these quirks and oddities have since been expunged. That said, few will ever forget the weird missteps present in the PlayStation version, and twenty-two years after release, there are still plenty of laughing fits caused by the legendarily-bad "Jill sandwich" line.


4. Isle Of The Dead (1993)

Isle Of The Dead
Rainmaker

Revived partially due to its potential for YouTube virality, 1993's Isle of the Dead was a Doom clone which attempted to emphasize the concept's horror elements without establishing a firm grasp of what horror even is in the first place.

Isle of the Dead is a notoriously cheesy, nearly unplayable early FPS game saved only by its incredibly funny animated sequences and likely unintentional witticisms. It certainly doesn't seek to provide an out-and-out horror experience, though its subtle nods to games like Wolfenstein 3D and movies like Night of the Living Dead only serve to make it seem worse in comparison.

The title also makes a bewildering attempt to merge the two totally separate gameplay spheres of first person shooting and point-and-click puzzle solving. As a result, Isle of the Dead is a sub-par example of both, and it really only deserves to be played by those who get their kicks from bottom-of-the-barrel horror experiences.

Not dissimilar in tone to the dozens upon dozens of shark movies which sought to ape the success of 1975's cinematic masterpiece Jaws, Isle of the Dead is a quick cash-in on a popular property which fails so miraculously that it is deserving of nothing but ridicule.


3. Harvester (1996)

Harvester game
DigiFX

1996's otherworldly PC exclusive point-and-click horror title Harvester is perhaps the only video game on this list which might still manage to unnerve the average player, though the game's heavy use of FMV material would likely significantly hamper that probability. Filled to the brim with cannibalistic children, ruckus inhumanity, and alarmingly chipper 1950's mothers, Harvester is almost too bizarre to accurately explain.

That said, much in the vain of the Phantasmagoria games, Harvester is about as over-the-top as it could possibly be. Most gamers casually aware of the property will probably think of the segment in which a bisected cop shoots the protagonist in the head with a machine gun, but that is only the very tip of the Harvester iceberg. It only gets weirder from there, and its almost hilarious.

Much like other horror titles unafraid to cross the threshold into unabashed unreality, laughter is sometimes the only appropriate reaction to the game's eldritch on-goings. In fact, this title has likely never been matched in terms of sheer madness, and it probably never will. From the uncanny overtones to the eyebrow raising town citizens, Harvester can be downright hilarious. You always were a kidder, Steve.


2. House Of The Dead 2 (1998)

House Of The Dead 2
Sega

Originally developed as an on-rails light gun shooter for Sega's ill-fated DreamCast console, 1998's House of the Dead 2 and its subsequent typing-tutor spin-off has gone down in history as perhaps the funniest horror shooter ever to be created. While the minute-to-minute gameplay present in this title is often scary enough, the whole experience is dramatically let down by the overwhelmingly terrible voice acting on offer. Bill Belichick or Ben Stein could probably deliver more convincing line reads while asleep—its that bad.

Though the gameplay is, on the whole, pretty good, this game loses all credibility once the first character utters their first line, which is about five seconds into the first level. Worse still is the downright hilarious Typing of the Dead, which was an odd take on the genre intended to help players brush up on their keyboarding abilities. In this version, each character now has a Sega DreamCast with a keyboard strapped to their backs, and it's unabashedly funny.

It may have genuinely helped someone to learn how to type—and the original title may actually have scared someone at some point—but House of the Dead 2 and its weird spin-off are way too funny to ever take seriously now.


1. Night Trap (1992)

Night Trap ReVamped
Night Trap LLC

1992's Sega CD exclusive Night Trap is perhaps more let down by its legacy than by its actual gameplay. A simple pseudo-puzzle title that only vaguely represents anything related to horror, it was once considered to be so totally heinous that it was quite literally brought on trial for corruption of the nation's youth: a modern day Socrates, just with way more pillow fighting and tennis racket air guitar.

While Night Trap can be funny in it sown right, it is downright hilarious when discussed by politicians amid a hearing concerning an apparent disturbing media consumption crisis. It may be a pretty bad game, but not for the reasons Tipper Gore may have thought.

Worse still is that the game's total reliance on an underdeveloped FMV technology meant that players had to squint at a tiny, pixelated box to follow what was going on in-game. Plus, with content that could hardly be stretched past the two hour mark, Night Trap is only worth a mocking playthrough in the modern era.

That said, the game has recently been re-released for the Nintendo Switch, of all consoles, so those still hoping to offend their soccer mom parents may want to check it out.


Contributor

Sometimes I like to write in between sessions of Rocket League.