10 Video Game Crossovers That Went Too Far
Fortnite finally lost its mind.
In 1993, the worlds of Double Dragon and Battletoads came together to release one of the earliest examples of video game franchises intersecting with each other. It was an exciting moment that showed young gamers that developers were just as keen as players to see wild, dream scenarios play out on screen.
Crossovers must be handled with care which is a pretty big determining factor in whether they happen at all. With multiple license holders in the mix, all very protective of their property and it's image, it can be hard to come to decisions that make everyone happy. More than just slapping one thing against another and presenting it to an audience, there has to be measure and restraint.
Some things aren't meant to crossover and, if they are, it needs to be done with some degree subtlety to make sure the value of combining the two (or more) IPs isn't diminished.
Perhaps they were just the wrong collaborations entirely or perhaps they simply didn't click together in a satisfying way, be they crossovers with other game franchises or outside parties, the titles on this list lost their way somewhere along the way.
10. Soul Calibur IV Is Just A Star Wars Game
Out of all Star Wars media, there is only one place to find the fight between Yoda and Darth Vader and it’s, bizarrely, in Soul Calibur IV. That’s a big deal. So big in fact, does anyone remember anything else about the game?
Of course, the Star Wars collaboration was a huge get and clearly Namco Bandai wanted to make a big deal out of it as they so should. However, it became a gigantic shadow over the rest of the title. Seriously, ask most casual viewers of Soul Calibur as a franchise about the fourth entry and they’ll remark that it was “the Star Wars one” and little else.
Yoda and Vader were on all the posters, on the box in fact and they were huge selling points for the game in the sense that the Jedi master was originally exclusive to Xbox and the Sith lord was only on PS3 (until later DLC). Almost every other major Soul Calibur character faded into the background and the game became essentially marketed as the place for a unique Star Wars showdown… and that wasn’t really fair at all to the complete package.
Soul Calibur IV was not marketed as the upcoming sequel in the franchise, it was now a Star Wars vehicle.
9. Final Fantasy Brave Exvius’ Pop Stars
As one of the longest running and most successful JRPG franchises of all time, Final Fantasy has had plenty of time and money to get involved in some pretty weird cross-promotions. Moogles playing basketball alongside Mario, Cloud and Aerith in LittleBigPlanet and… a spinoff that features Grammy award nominated pop stars.
Final Fantasy Brave Exvius is one of Square-Enix’s forays into mobile game territory. To be expected, it features gacha style mechanics as you can acquire Final Fantasy characters from across the ages to use as summons in a series of classic pixel-art style turn-based battles.
The game also features many guest spots for characters from Square’s other properties like Sword of Mana, Bravely Default and Kingdom Hearts. They are also joined by, of all people, Katy Perry and Ariana Grande.
Contributing music to the game, two of the most powerful and richest women in music have also been immortalised alongside Cloud and Sora. Both are described as visiting from a “distant world” and have several different jobs they can take on to give them adaptability in battle, with outfits based on real life looks.
Music stars pairing with video games isn’t unheard of but some of the biggest pop sensations of the Western world appearing in a Japanese role playing mobile game doesn’t compute even if you see it with your own eyes.
8. Mortal Kombat Vs. DC Universe Kills The Entire Point
The mid-2000s were a bad time for the fighting game genre and in particular they were nearly a disaster for Midway. Their flagship franchise Mortal Kombat was treading water and needed to do something big to claw back interest and generate the income needed to save itself. Enter: DC Comics.
Mortal Kombat vs DC Universe was a shocking crossover fighter released in 2008 which, at first glance, seemed quite exciting due to how fresh it was. At this point, Mortal Kombat had never had a crossover but it unfortunately presented several issues which led to a largely negative response.
DC had the mandate that their heroes wouldn’t be disembowelled by the likes of Scorpion and Sub-Zero and nor would Superman, Batman and company take a life as per their moral codes. As such, characters had embarrassing “heroic brutalities” instead of fatalities.
If you’re going to partner with Mortal Kombat, shouldn't you be aware of what the draw of it is?
Of course, what set the franchise apart from its contemporaries was its brutal violence and fatalities. Heck, the first title was instrumental in the mere invention of a video games ratings board. So for Mortal Kombat’s first Xbox 360 and PS3 outing to be rated Teen instead of Mature for the first time ever just felt wrong.
7. Black Desert Online And The Bugatti Logo
Black Desert Online is a solid mediaeval fantasy MMORPG from Korean developers Pearl Abyss that, despite launching all the way back in 2015, is still very active today.
The game’s earliest promotional tie-ins made plenty of sense, the most prominent of which was the dark fantasy manga hit Berserk. This featured a new quest, new weapons and coolest of all the Berserker armour. It was a surprising but perfect fit. Then, the developers lost their damn minds in 2021.
Remember when Mercedes-Benz collaborated with Nintendo to feature a few vehicles in Mario Kart 8? It was weird but it clearly didn’t take itself too seriously and it was cute to see the likes of Yoshi’s head poking out from the sunroof of a GLA.
The trailer that announced Black Desert was partnering with Bugatti just felt so forced, overly earnest and left players with many questions. Were cars coming Black Desert Online? No, logos were. You could kit your mount and character up with hideous outfits sporting the bold Bugatti symbol.
Pearl Abyss’ CEO said that the connection between the brands was that they both strived for complete customer satisfaction. Most would wager they themselves were striving for a discount on their next supercar purchase.
6. Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing Transformed's Bizarre Guests
The Sega All-Star series is a weird one, consisting of two kart racers and a tennis game. However, what ties them together is their celebration of Sega’s history, featuring characters from Sonic, Crazy Taxi, Super Monkey Ball and so on. The first racing title also had a few surprise characters join the starting line such as Nintendo’s Mii’s and Microsoft's Xbox Avatars.
It was the follow-up - Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing Transformed - where things got progressively weirder.
Even though it was before the release of the sequel (which featured Sonic), Wreck-It Ralph wasn’t too far off a stretch. That being said, Team Fortress characters are a little out there, as is adding a fictional Roman general called Willemus to represent Total War. At this stage it felt like Sega were picking names out of a hat.
But rest assured the weirdness had yet to truly begin as next up was Danica Patrick. Amongst this smorgasbord of gaming characters, we suddenly have a real-life NASCAR driver for some unknown reason. Then, to top it all off, members of Yogscast, the gaming YouTube channel, were also added as downloadable content. What?!
It’s a good thing Sega put an end to the DLC for this game because if it kept up by now we’d have Nicolas Cage, Brum and the old lady who lives at the end of your road.
5. Gears Pop! Is Best Forgotten
At E3 2018, the Coalition broke their silence since Gears of War 4 to announce a slew of new titles: not only the next mainline entry but the first real spinoffs that the franchise had ever had in Tactics and Gears Pop! which, if there was an award for “weirdest in show” would’ve run away with it.
Suddenly, the series of grotesque monsters being split in half with chainsaws and tough soldiers who swear a lot was being shrunk down into the world of Funko. Sure, the Gears of War franchise isn’t without its sense of humour and its most machismo moments are at least a little tounge-in-cheek, but pairing it up with this mass market appeal giant was unthinkably stupid.
You know what Gears of War needs? A boring Clash Royale clone where we turn all of the characters into squat, plastic collectibles all with the same soulless eyes and face. Appropriate then that all of the personality of Gears is sapped away by association with Funko.
This is actually Funko’s first dip into the video game pool… and they picked Gears of War? It seems so impossibly arbitrary. Thankfully, with Gears 5 launching soon after, Gears Pop! was easy to forget… almost like it was planned that way.
4. Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Is Barely A Crossover
Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE is a rather bold attempt at combining Nintendo’s fantastical war titles Fire Emblem with Atlus’ dark JRPG series Shin Megami Tensei.
Two huge franchises in Japan with growing popularity internationally, it was a truly intriguing prospect to take the two, stick them in a blender and see what came out. The result was a frankly bizarre roleplaying game that focuses on the world of idol music in modern day Japan.
Now, Tokyo Mirage Sessions isn’t a bad game by any means and there are some things it absolutely does right… but it would be basically the same game if you took the inspiring franchises out of it. Fire Emblem fans were put off immediately by how the characters from the last two games were just dragged and dropped from mediaeval fantasy into a modern Tokyo with literal regard.
On the Atlus side of things, TMS uses some of Shin Megami Tensei’s battle system style but ditches the dark and dystopian tone of the series for bright and colourful lights and high energy J-pop.
In fact, when marketing the Switch port, the trailer described the game as a collaboration between Fire Emblem and “the world of Atlus”, perhaps to soften the blow that, whilst a decent game, it wasn’t much of a crossover.
3. MultiVersus Has No Limit
Nintendo’s Super Smash Brothers, perhaps the king of crossovers, takes extreme care when respecting and representing all first and third party characters.
And whilst a couple of these are tonally odd - after all, Smash is a series that features kid-friendly Pokémon alongside the much more mature Solid Snake - Nintendo does its best to retain a consistency for its audience.
Technically, this is also true of MultiVersus… but it’s also nuts. From the game’s first announcement, gamers were losing their heads at the pure idea of Scooby Doo’s Shaggy getting into a scrap with Arya Stark from Game of Thrones. Using the full depth of Warner Bros’ intellectual property meant mascots from kids shows like Jake the Dog appearing alongside - and beating the snot out of - the swearing drunkard nihilist Rick of Rick and Morty.
Leaks have revealed upcoming characters to include the Mother of Dragons Daenerys Targaryen and, uh, college football coach Ted Lasso.
Which begs the question. How far is too far? Yes, it’s fun that the game seems to have no boundaries but it also means they’re near-impossible to define. At least with Smash we knew it was video game characters only and no matter how much some pined for Goku it wasn’t happening.
Warner Bros Discovery owns CNN and at this point seeing news anchors in MultiVersus seems entirely plausible.
2. Fortnite X Junji Ito Is Just Wrong
No list about crossovers is complete without mentioning the gargantuan Fortnite. Where else can you see Aquaman hitting Daryl from The Walking Dead with a kamehameha?
The once humble survival game exploded when it changed gears and became the #1 battle royale game of all time, capitalising on this further with more merchandise than you can possibly imagine and signing a bunch of contracts with other licence holders.
However, it must be said Fortnite knew that its audience of young kids with internet connections meant that nothing was really off limits. John Wick, Kratos and Master Chief might be intended for mature audiences but that fact alone would be interesting to kids with access to their parents’ wallets.
However, a collaboration with legendary Japanese master of horror Junji Ito might be a step beyond.
Five maps are available based on different Ito stories including Hanging Balloon which, by the way, is about children being hung and strangled by balloons with human faces. Just looking at the damn things is enough to make me feel uncomfortable as an adult. Skins are one thing but this is a level of nightmare fuel yet unchartered by the game.
At any point Fornite’s wild array of crossovers could be enough for you. But this one? As a famous Ito piece once said: “This hole is mine”.
1. PlayStation Move Heroes’ Wasted Potential
The PlayStation 2’s library had plenty of games for every type of player and it certainly wasn’t short on platformers.
Jak & Daxter, Ratchet & Clank and Sly Cooper were big successes in their time, becoming fondly remembered in the ensuing years for gamers who loved to explore detail-rich 3D worlds. And, considering Sony owned all three, the possibility of them colliding wasn’t out of the question.
And in 2011 it happened - but in the most vapid sense possible.
Before they all duked it out in PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale, there was the awkwardly titled PlayStation Move Heroes. In itself the name tells you this is little more than an advertisement for the PS3’s motion controllers.
The problem is all three franchises were expertly handled by their own teams and so Nihilistic Studios stepping up to the plate had the hard job of balancing all three and failed tremendously. There is a distinct lack of charm and personality, all six playable characters might as well be interchangeable and the repetitive design and gameplay are only counter-balanced by the game’s short runtime.
A crossover between these characters could’ve been special and a great selling point for the Move if it didn’t feel like it was rushed right out of the door. All three series' were the poster boys for Sony platforming at one point, but the lesson is that combining name value alone does not a good game make.