10 Video Game Fan Theories That Change EVERYTHING
Who knew there were so many hidden apocalypses in the world of gaming?
It's amazing what one small comment, reference or item can do to send a fan's imagination into pandemonium. For as long as video games have been a source of entertainment, fans and players have looked for details left behind by developers that point to a bigger picture going on behind the scenes. Intentional to begin with or not, some of these speculations and theories have even found a way of becoming fact.
After a fan theory surrounding the character went viral, Blizzard Entertainment confirmed via a fan letter that Symmetra from Overwatch was indeed autistic, it was revealed that Michael Jackson did indeed help produce some of the music for Sonic the Hedgehog 3 and James Sunderland's wife really was buried in the boot of his Silent Hill 2 car.
As a result, when it comes to a mind-blowing fan theory, there are times when the actual imagination and piecing together can be more exciting than the title itself.
From entire apocalypses hidden off screen, to hidden family tragedies that only eagle eyed players could have uncovered, here are ten of the best video game fan theories that literally change everything about their respective titles.
10. Trevor Was The Target - Grand Theft Auto V
Grand Theft Auto V begins with a prologue mission that everyone who has played through the game is familiar with by now. Michael, Trevor (simply named 'M' and 'T' during the level) and their colleague Brad hold up a cash storage facility in North Yankton, and are then ambushed by the police.
As well as being the opening guide to the game's basic mechanics such as movement and shooting, the prologue proves to be the cornerstone of everything that goes on to happen to Michael and Trevor.
During the course of the prologue in North Yankton, things begin to go awry for the crew and Brad ends up being killed by a sniper shot. It's later revealed that Michael had brokered a deal between himself and the authorities that involved selling out his crew in exchange for a life in witness protection, and that Brad had gotten in the way.
However, one theory suggests that it wasn't Brad who was supposed to die during the deal at all but Trevor. The main evidence for this is a scene during the prologue where Brad steps in front of Trevor right before the fatal shot is fired, and then later on during the game where Trevor is routinely described by feds such as Agent Norton as a 'loose end'.
Given how influential this one moment proves to become, the whole GTA V universe could have changed completely had Brad not stepped across at that last second.
9. Jumpman Is Mario's Father And Was Killed By Donkey Kong - Super Mario
The Super Mario universe kicked off with 1981's arcade classic Donkey Kong. The game revolves around Jumpman, a New York city native who climbs up ladders and jumps over barrels on his way to saving his love interest, Pauline. However, despite what most people might assume, Jumpman isn't Super Mario.
The truth behind the Mario Bros.' origins has always been a mystery, but this particular theory explains that Jumpman is in fact their true father. The moustache, outfit, damsel in distress love interest and obsession for jumping aside, the two men also share a pretty hefty feud with the Donkey Kong family.
This particular theory also has a slightly sinister twist to it. At the end of Donkey Kong Junior, Jumpman, who is actually the evil antagonist during the game, is killed by the baby Kong in the family.
Thanks to this one fan theory, a whole load of shade is suddenly cast over the relationship between Super Mario and Donkey Kong going forward. On top of the sudden blood feuding between families now plaguing the Mushroom Kingdom, there's also the added strangeness of seeing these enemies putting their differences aside for the odd round of golf or kart racing.
8. The Assassins Always Losing Proves Abstergo Was Right - Assassin's Creed
The Assassin's Creed series revolves around the continued struggle between the Assassins and their ideological enemies the Templars, known as Abstergo in today's world. It's a war that has existed for thousands of years on every single continent and has led to countless atrocities on both sides over the course of the series. However, it's also a conflict born out of more similarities than differences.
Both factions believe in freedom and liberty, the key distinction between them being the fact that the Templars believe in freedom through control of the people, which has led to a few sinister individuals in need of a good assassination rising up through the years.
However, it doesn't seem to matter how many crazed Templars come and go, they always come back on top and even stronger than before. In the words of Haytham Kenway from Assassin's Creed III:
"The people never have the power, only the illusion of it. And here is the real secret: they don't want it. The responsibility is too great to bear. It's why they are so quick to fall in line as soon as someone else takes charge."
If this theory is to be believed, then it really changes how players see both factions in each one of the games, and how hapless the Assassins' struggle really is in reality.
7. The Player Is The Last Human - Minecraft
On the surface of things, Minecraft looks like one of the most lighthearted games going, thanks mainly to its bright colours, open world and pixel art style.
But is this colourful world hiding a more sinister secret under its surface?
One theory suggests that each and every Minecraft world a player loads up is set in a post-apocalyptic land. As the theory goes, there was a terrible virus that has claimed the lives of every single person on the planet and left behind only the native animals and villager species.
The zombies found in the game are the last remaining remnants of the old civilisation and become a skeleton once they've been killed, and the creepers are an evolved mutant species from exposure to the virus.
The player controlled character of Steve now finds himself wandering through his baron world, forced to start again and begin rebuilding from scratch. Having this theory in mind every time a new world boots up is sure to add in an extra layer of depth to each playthrough, and will definitely change the way players look at the zombies, skeletons and creepers crawling around the world.
6. Each Leader Is In The Afterlife - Civilization
Sid Meier's Civilization series is the go-to for fans of the digital strategy genre. The game sees players take control of a famous empire from history and make their way through the ages, developing technologies and making use of their unique abilities to help meet various win conditions.
With all of history's most infamous leaders amassed together, a number of fans have come up with the theory that the Civilization series actually takes place in the afterlife. These leaders are able to live on together forever, establishing lucrative trade routes, setting up embassies and waging their wars for all eternity.
One of the biggest pieces of evidence for this comes from the fact that all these leaders can live for thousands of years and survive everything from barbarian raids to nuclear bombings.
It certainly changes things up thinking about all of the troops and buildings being ethereal beings in game, but should at least help the more bloodthirsty players out there feel a little bit less guilty about the atrocities they commit, knowing that the people they're taking down aren't exactly on the mortal plains.
5. Harley Quinn Lost A Baby Because Of Batman - Arkham Series
One of the most interesting and complex recurring antagonists from the Batman: Arkham series is the Joker's favourite fangirl, Harley Quinn. The series shows her transformation from hardworking psychiatrist to the insane baseball bat-wielding baddie everyone knows and loves to this day, but there's also a level of depth to this particular take on the character that most adaptations have glossed over in the past.
In Batman: Arkham City, players can discover a room containing some of Harley's old nurses uniforms, a cheaply constructed crib and a rendition of Harley singing 'Hush Little Baby' will play over the game's final end credits. What's more, returning to this room during the 'Harley's Revenge' DLC will greet players with the sight of a number of negative pregnancy kits.
The DLC focuses a great deal on the relationship between Harley and Batman without Joker being around, which has led to more than a few fan theories circulating over whether or not Quinn had been pregnant and who the father might have been.
One theory in particular speculates on whether or not Harley might have been pregnant during the standoff at the church, and whether Batman hitting her might have even triggered a miscarriage.
Heavy stuff, Bats.
4. Uncharted & The Last Of Us Are Set In The Same World - Uncharted/Last Of Us
With both these stellar titles being developed by Naughty Dog and published by Sony, players of both franchises probably wouldn't have been too surprised to see the odd Easter egg or reference popping up linking the two series. However, this overlap has also birthed one of the most interesting fan theories in the world of gaming.
Both games have similar gameplay and similar mechanics, but their stories and settings couldn't be further apart. Uncharted features stunning visuals and exotic landscapes, whilst The Last of Us is set in a post-apocalyptic wasteland.
But there's a theory circulating around that these two worlds might just be one and the same. The evidence for this theory comes from a particular newspaper article that players can stumble upon in Uncharted 2. This newspaper opens with a headline warning its readers of a deadly fungal virus that has been sweeping around the world.
Given the backdrop surrounding The Last of Us and its abundance of zombie victims to a world-ending plague, it's definitely a theory that is worth stopping for a second and thinking over.
Could this be another playful Easter egg sandwiched into a franchise known for them? Absolutely. Could it be a message from the developers hinting at something far deeper? Also absolutely.
3. Pokemon Is Set In A War-Torn World
Whenever players dive into the world of Pokemon, they're always greeted by light vibrant colours, warm characters and plenty of messages around looking out for one another. But, could one fan theory prove to be all a smokescreen for something much darker?
Pokemon is aimed at a certain demographic, and that's fairly reflected in the majority of children and young teenagers running around the place. Whilst there are a few professors, nurses and trainers, they are so disproportionate to the amount of children that it is certainly enough to raise suspicion.
And the age gap between those adults and children is also a strange point of concern.
Some fans of the franchise has speculated that the world of Pokemon is actually set in the aftermath of a bloody generational conflict. The age gaps between the adults and children is one thing, but the abundance of orphans and single parent households suggests that something bad could have well happened in the years gone by.
It's certainly a deliciously dark take on a franchise that took up so many people's childhoods, and definitely adds a layer onto the characters seen in each game.
2. Skyrim And Fallout Are Set In The Same Universe - Elder Scrolls/Fallout
Both the Elder Scrolls and the Fallout franchises have more in common than most gamers might think. Both carrying the Bethesda charm of unpolished glitches and meme-worthy features, their true success has come from the vast open worlds both franchises have created over the years. From Morrowind to Skyrim, the fantastical elements of the Elder Scrolls have become iconic, and the post-apocalyptic worlds of Fallout have given birth to some seriously eerie locations of their own.
Two very different sets of worlds to be sure, but could one fan theory point to there being more being buried underneath the surface?
There's a small plant found on Prydwen, the airship commanded by the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout 4 that looks remarkably like the Nirnroot plant from the Elder Scrolls. The research entries on this experimental plant are labelled as 'NRT' and actually heal the player should they choose to ingest them, just like Nirnroot does when used in a potion in the Elder Scrolls.
It's unlikely that Bethesda are ever going to push the boat out too much and launch a Fallout/Elder Scrolls crossover any time soon, so this might be the best any fans of the two franchises are ever going to get.
1. John Marston ISN'T Jack's Father - Red Dead Redemption
The little asterisk hanging over Jack Marston is one of the most discussed and debated points in the Red Dead Redemption universe. Red Dead 2 has teased enough to its players for fans to begin amassing their own theories that things are indeed not as simple or straightforward as they seem.
For starters, there's the fact that John left Jack and his mother for a year due to thinking that his 'son' could have very well being the result of Abigail's sex work. In fact, it is spelled out by Dutch that practically everyone in the Van der Linde camp had been with her and that John was only special because he ended up 'putting a ring on her'.
There's also a couple side comments and observations noted over the course of RDR2 that suggest Jack looks 'more like a Williamson or maybe an Escuela' rather than a Marston. A few fans have pointed out that some of his facial features look more like other camp members than they do John, with Javier in particular being singled out amongst the community as the likeliest candidate.
If anything though, this theory actually strengthens John's development as a character. Legitimate or not, by the end of RDR2 he's embraced his family and would sacrifice everything for them, a notion which comes to a head at the end of the first game.
Watch Next
How Well Do You Remember Red Dead Redemption?