10 Video Game Ideas We're GLAD Got Cut
Thank goodness these ideas were ditched!
In an ideal world, every shred of creativity, every droplet of ambition, and every crumb of intention would be soaked up in the final product of a video game. But sadly, we do not live in an ideal world. No, we live in a world of crushing deadlines, technical limitations, corporate meddling, and E.A. As such, it's not uncommon for great ideas to be cut from video games.
Naturally, when you're playing a title and find out that there are ideas or content that have been removed from it, you can't help but think, "Damn, I wish I had got the chance to see it." The fear of missing out is intense as you really want to know if/how these cut ideas would have worked. That said, there are some cuts that should leave you jumping for joy.
The following ten entries are prime examples of this. Each of these games came with removed ideas that you wouldn't have wanted to touch, some because they would have ruined the gaming experience and others because they would have made you need a change of pants.
10. Stalking Anglerfish - The Outer Wilds
Anyone who has played The Outer Wilds would agree that this space-faring adventure is a mostly peaceful game. That said, if you bring up Dark Bramble, you'll see those same folks sweat. Why? Because they'll be thinking about those damn Anglerfish.
These alien menaces are terrifying creatures that devour any explorers they hear. Thankfully, they only appear on the strange planetary remnant, Dark Bramble, meaning you never have to worry about them unless you're there. However, that wasn't the case in the game's pre-alpha build.
Dark Bramble was a very different place before the game moved out of the prototype stage. The biggest difference was that the Anglerfish could leave the planet and stalk the player across the system. Many gamers would have put their controllers down forever if that had stayed until the final release, as these relentless beasts are anxiety-inducing to the max.
Here's a little message to the Outer Wilds devs - screw you for creating these monsters in the first place, but thank you for keeping them in one place.
9. The Monstrous Mother - Alice: Madness Returns
Alice: Madness Returns, the sequel to American McGee's Alice, asks the bizarre question - what if Alice in Wonderland was fifty shades of messed up? The thing is, while the game is pretty freaky, it could have been a lot worse. In fact, there's one cut feature that dove so far down the gore and horror rabbit hole it would have left players gagging.
When trolling through The Art of Alice Madness Returns book, you'll find an assortment of concept art that never made it to the game. The vilest and most grotesque of these lost ideas was a nightmarish NPC, a giant princess forced to give birth to a collection of monstrous babies (pictured here). This NPC would have been mercy-killed by Alice in a bloody execution, with the concept art looking less like Wonderland and more like a Terrifier movie.
The game's Art Director, Ken Wong, claimed the concept resulted from pushing the "nice, pleasant" artists to go darker. Well, they certainly did that, with Wong himself claiming they "went too far" here. Gee, you think?
8. Jimmy’s Acid Bath - Bully
Despite the worrisome name, parents don't need to be too concerned about the content found in Rockstar's Bully. This bonkers title is a harmless display of juvenile humour, controlled chaos, and playground fantasy, with nothing too extreme or violent tying it to the studio's more infamous GTA series. Still, while the game is entirely devoid of death and killing, there was a particularly twisted demise that almost snuck its way in.
When digging through Bully's unused assets, you can find a selection of dialogue recordings (compiled here) hinting at a terrible fate for the game's protagonist, Jimmy. So, was he going to be pushed off a building, or run over by a car, or something like that? Oh no, he would have been tossed into a burning vat of acid and dissolved to death. Yikes.
Yes, this was a legitimate outcome that would have occurred during the "Showdown at the Plant" mission in the boss fight against Edgar. It would have likely been a death animation for failure during the fight. Either way, there's no denying it would taken the game from goofy antics to horrifying violence so fast you'd get whiplash.
7. Stormy Ascent - Crash Bandicoot
Okay, so the Crash Bandicoot masochists would have likely preferred it if this idea had stayed in the game. But, for everybody else, not having to get through this legendary nightmare of a level was a huge blessing.
"Stormy Ascent" is a level from the original Crash Bandicoot. At least, it was supposed to be before the devs decided to remove it from the game. What was their reason for doing so? Well, to put it plainly, it was way too hard.
Most of those who have strolled through this hellish ascent will happily agree that it is one of Crash's most challenging stages. It's a brutally punishing level that requires pitch-perfect platforming, features a tonne of unfair enemy placement, has minimal margin for error, and goes on for so long you'd think it was a JRPG.
Those who did want to play this level could do so via a Gameshark cheat device for the original game and through DLC in the N. Sane Trilogy. Still, the PlayStation 1 would have seen countless broken controllers had Naughty Dog kept this in the original main release.
6. The Baby Cry - Silent Hill 3
When you hear that something was cut from a Silent Hill game for being too disturbing, your mind will probably start racing. Too disturbing? What on Earth could be too disturbing for this freaky-as-hell franchise? Well, it might be hard to believe, but the lone sound of a crying baby, that's it. It sounds like nothing but read on, and you'll see why it had to go.
If you've played Silent Hill 3 and defeated the final boss, you might have wondered why the following cutscene ends with Heather Mason turning towards the camera as if reacting to something, before the screen fades to black. Well, the original cut featured the distressed cries of a baby. The implication was that the final boss had been reborn as an infant, linking to the consistent theme of rebirth in Silent Hill.
What makes this so disturbing, however, is that Heather would have ditched the baby. There's undoubtedly more nuance to it, given the godly reincarnation implications, but ending a game with your protagonist leaving a crying baby to die is something nobody wants. Ambiguity was undoubtedly the better choice here.
5. The Host Monster - Evolve
Say what you will about the failure of Evolve, but this monster vs hunters game led to many hours of fun for those who picked it up. Part of the fun was the variety of the monsters you could play as. Do you want hulking strength? Pick the Behemoth. Speed and stealth? Hit the Wraith up. Fire breath and power? Go Goliath. You get the idea.
However, while the reliable tactics of those beasts made sense, how does flinging AI minions and letting them do all the work sound? Not so fun, right? Well, it nearly happened.
The Host was a scrapped monster that would have featured a unique combat approach. Rather than relying on its own strength, it would have summoned various parasites to send into battle against the hunters.
Now, the idea of having little minions do your bidding sounds fun, but dear god, this monster would have sucked. It, by design, would have had you relying on NPCs to win. What's the point of playing as a big monster and letting little monsters do the smashing? You're a big monster - just smash.
4. Kim Kitsuragi’s Mean Side - Disco Elysium
One of the crowning achievements of the stellar Disco Elysium is the relationship between the protagonist, Harry Du Bois, and his partner in crime (solving), Kim Kitsuragi. Harry is a wild and, depending on how you play, entirely unpredictable chaos goblin, whereas Kim is a level-headed, soft-spoken, rational man. The delicate balance of this dynamic duo sells the story, which is why it's so bizarre to learn that it nearly wasn't that way.
During the game's earlier drafts, Kim was not the reverent and kind cop he was in the final product. In fact, he was far more aggressive and confrontational, acting far meaner and often going against his eventual by-the-books style. This was evident in the judgemental way he spoke to Harry and through actions he could perform that the eventual Kim would never even dream of, like drinking on the job or lying on RCM reports.
The switch-up in Kim's character saved not only him but also the game itself. Good job on that one, Robert Kurvitz; it was close.
3. Kratos’ Puppy - God of War
Even the toughest, scariest of people need a best friend. Well, what can be better than a dog? These loveable little creatures bring joy wherever they go and can melt the hearts of even the most heartless people. That said, the legendary God of War protagonist, Kratos, might not be the most responsible dog owner, especially in his early days.
When looking through the old concept art for Kratos (as recounted here), there comes a point where Santa Monica decided to pair him up with a little pup. The idea seems cute at first, but it's much better that this duo didn't meet. With Kratos being as he was, there's no doubt this dog would have found itself in near-constant danger. The chances of them making it out alive would have been minimal. Hell, knowing how edgy the old GoW games were, you'd have likely had to fight and kill the puppy yourself.
Kratos is great with dogs (or technically wolves) now, as seen in his interactions with Speki, Svanna, and Fenrir. But he's a remarkably changed man, and old-school Kratos wouldn't have been so canine-friendly.
2. Talking Juvenile Scholars - Elden Ring
Are you a gamer who hates creepy enemies that give you the heebie-jeebies? If you answered yes, then you'd best avoid Elden Ring like the plague, as this FromSoft masterpiece is chock-full of them. One of the most twisted examples is the Juvenile Scholars, the malformed offspring of Queen Rennala, who she created through her power of rebirth.
You only encounter these tragic creatures in the Rennala's first phase as they sing nursery rhymes and sling books at you. However, as seen in cut dialogue assets (shown here), the Scholars actually used to talk. What did they say? Well, as the name suggests, these Juveniles spoke like children, babies even, wondering if you were there to play with them and assuming the whole fight was a game.
Look, these little creeps are unsettling no matter how you slice it, but hearing them talk like children would have made them fifty times creepier. Plus, it would have made you feel fifty times worse for killing them. Their song may have been grating, but it's better than what could have been.
1. Minthara’s Pregnancy - Baldur’s Gate 3
When it comes to romances, Baldur's Gate 3 leaves you spoiled for choice. Do you fancy a Gothic cleric? A hunky, nature-loving druid? A freaky frog-like lady? A charming vampire? A muscled-up Tiefling? A literal octopus person? Take your pick because you can romance them all. Of course, for those who like their partners to be as cold as ice and don't mind minimal romance, you can go for the terrifying Minthara.
This Drow villain-turned-comrade only has minor romance options compared to the significant subplots of others. However, this wasn't always the case, as the original plans would have taken things a lot further.
Minthara used to have a whole subplot based on her relationship with the player. This side story even came with the chance to impregnate her, leading to what you can assume would have been some pretty uncomfortable scenarios. There's no doubt Larian Studios would have handled this story with class. Still, given the dangers of the world, the character's personality, the nuances of such a delicate story, and more, it's easy to see why this was an idea destined for the chopping block.