10 Video Games EVERYONE Gave Up On
Nope. I'm out.
At the risk of saying things that are extremely obvious: there are a lot of video games right now. Like, a lot of video games. As a result you can’t be expected to play them all nor can you be expected to finish the ones you do play.
This list is dedicated to the latter thanks to the ever reliable stats from HowLongToBeat.com telling us how many players ‘retired’ from various games. Or to put it plainly, decided “Nope, I’m over this.” and stopped playing before the game was over.
To head this off at the pass, naturally games released on Game Pass will have many more players picking them up and deciding it’s not for them. That caveat considered, these games have some of the highest retirement stats on the site as a percentage of users who reported picking it up and then told HLTB, “Nope, I’m out”.
Of course not everyone gave up on the following games but we’re extrapolating that if this percentage of people bothered to mark the game as retired, chances are loads more of you gave up on it, too.
10. Loop Hero
Loop Hero is a little indie game from developer Four Quarters that came out in 2021. It is a roguelike, but bear with me, because it’s a roguelike that does have a campaign that you can complete.
Well, it has a campaign that can be completed. Whether or not you pull it off depends if you fall into the camp of those who put it down or not.
The game does what it says on the box, you walk around in a loop gradually earning resources and gold, building stuff, taking on baddies, and trying not to die. Inevitably you will, but you’ll hang on to 30% of your stuff or more if you bail out before the encounter. Its difficulty shouldn’t be understated, though, as you need to be clever about your strategy and playstyle, being careful to consider your equipment, and know your limits. It stands to reason then that this little Game Pass offering wasn’t just retired by 11.1% of those who recorded played it, but it was also the second most retired game on the site in 2021.
The only game that was marked as retired more times was Twelve Minutes, which, if you know anything about Twelve Minutes, checks out.
Though some found it to be entertaining, even knocking out the hidden boss, it wasn’t everyone’s cup of tea as players said they gave it up for being too repetitive, boring, or frustrating.
9. The Last Case of Benedict Fox
Lovecraftian metroidvania, The Last Case of Benedict Fox, came in at the fourth most retired game of 2023 as a percentage of those who played it. Another Game Pass offering which no doubt bolstered the number of people picking it up and then noping out, this one currently has a retirement stat of 12.3%. The game is only 11 hours long so it begs the question of why people didn't want to see it through to the end.
Mostly, players said they were getting stuck. Either due to the difficulty of the puzzles or because they were so inundated with bugs, some of which were game breaking.
The game has been described as messy with imprecise, slow combat, and it suffers from the cardinal sins of stuttering and input lag. So, yeah, this one checks out.
8. Darkest Dungeon
Another roguelike here with Darkest Dungeon which came out in 2016 to pretty glowing reception. Fans and critics alike praised the game’s atmosphere, brutality, art, and gameplay loop which absolutely rewards the mastery you’ll have developed over the course of the game.
There are a lot of different elements at play between the affliction system stamping your heroes with massive debuffs, to strategizing combat and balancing your character classes.
It’s a satisfying core gameplay loop but not one that doesn’t come with a base level of frustration. As with any roguelike, you’ll probably find it’s right in your wheelhouse and you’re happy to keep gradually improving, or you feel like you’re beating your head against a wall and you can’t take one more run. Many of those in the latter category made up the game’s 12.4% retirement stat on HLTB. In defence of those who tapped out, the game is 58 hours long between its difficulty and sheer content so that’s a huge commitment to a game this unforgiving. Among the reasoning given by retirees was the classic complaint of repetition as well as the time investment required and its difficulty.
A couple of the choice comments I enjoyed were someone saying the game is too hard for their small brain and another who wrote “no way in hell am I beating this, lmao.”
7. Getting Over It With Bennet Foddy
In the Redfall camp of games I’m sure you aren’t surprised to see pop up on a list like this, the infamously tricky yet hugely popular indie game, Getting Over It With Bennet Foddy, takes no prisoners. Few have seen it through to the end despite it clocking in at 6 and a half hours.
This is probably because you either get its extraordinary bizarre charm or you figured out really quickly it was not for you and thus contributed to the 13.2% of HLTB users who said “no more,” opting not to get over it, and instead to go do something else.
Impressive as the review scores are, it's not too surprising that a significant number of players decided that the game about getting a man in a pot up a pile of crap without falling while finessing intentionally tricky controls wasn't for them. Though it charmed plenty of gamers, HLTB users who decided to ditch the excessive climbing exercise expressed a level of raw fury that it would be inappropriate for me to repeat.
As I'm also a gamer with very little patience, if you made it to the top you have my admiration.
6. Super Meat Boy
From the maniacal minds of Edmund McMillen and Tommy Refenes, platformer Super Meat Boy caused quite a stir when it came out in 2010. Not because it case you in the role of a cube of meat who would regularly jump into rotating saws and get blasted to smithereens but rather because it was so freaking hard. As the industry turned away from difficult games and toward those with difficulty settings and clear objective markers, this exercise in personal torture was on a personal mission to reject that and ultimately proved that gamers did want a proper challenge.
Well, a lot of them did. But not a lot of them seemingly finished this game.
Clocking in at just under 10 hours there’s a sizeable slice but not an overwhelming one for those who rolled credits on the journey to save your girlfriend made of bandages. Despite that, 13.3% of HLTB players reported putting this one down for good largely because the later levels proved to be just too difficult and it came time to simply admit defeat.
A number of comments also stated they lacked the skills while two got a little more specific saying "I suck too much” and “too old to git gud”.
5. Redfall
Redfall is the reason this list is called “games everyone gave up on” and not “games you wouldn’t believe everyone gave up on” because it probably doesn't come as a particularly big surprise that not everyone who started Redfall decided to finish it.
This was a rare miss for Arkane Studios who are most known for Dishonored, Prey, and Dark Messiah of Might and Magic. Okay that last one was mostly for me, but how cool was that game? The premise was intriguing albeit worried some people as the gameplay and story structure came off a little thin, even in the pre-release hype trailers. You’re let loose in a town overrun by vampires and can select out of a series of playable characters each with their own loadouts, backstories, abilities, and personalities. Even better, you’re encouraged to do so in PvE with a handful of friends. Unfortunately, what should have been a good open world FPS peppered with story missions, side-missions, and interesting big bads to take down, ended up being even thinner on content and intrigue than we thought.
As a result, the game snagged itself a retirement score of 17.7% as of the time of writing which may not seem like a lot but, again, you have to factor in this is just the audience on HLTB who logged kicking off the game in the first place and then went to the effort of very officially putting it down.
Given the game can be knocked over in as little as 12 hours this is also a bit of a cringe moment for Arkane as this was the most retired game of 2023 before it was overtaken by two of the other titles on this list. Those who marked it as retired left comments that ranged from the game lacking a hook and being too buggy, to one comment that just wrote in all caps that it’s the worst game in existence. That person logged a single hour which I can only assume was a deeply regrettable 60 minutes.
4. Amnesia: The Dark Descent
If you’re wondering why a game so fantastic has been abandoned by so many, a good handful of you might already be nodding along realising that it harkens back to that ‘horror’ bit. It’s simply just way too scary.
Now, I, too, gave up on Redfall and Amnesia: The Dark Descent. While Redfall was scary in that I can’t believe Bethesda pumped out a game that bad, Amnesia was just too much for my cowardly little heart to take. I primarily blame the god-forsaken prison level where the gatherer enemies are just bloody everywhere, it’s pitch black, and if I gave it any more time I would have had a heart attack. If you can power through Amnesia The Dark Descent is actually only 8 hours long so you’d think that those who picked it up and told HLTB about it would know what they were getting into and be primed and girded for whatever developer Frictional Games was going to throw at them.
Well, given the 9.3% retired statistic it’s safe to say that wasn’t the case. This is also a game where we have another stat thanks to the NOPE achievement players can only get if they boot the game up and then instantly quit out in the first cutscene.
This has been grabbed by 59% of players and while it’s safe to say some of that will have been seen as an easy win by achievement hunters, seemingly lots of people including yours truly probably got it organically. The comments from HLTB retirees back this up with some claiming they gave up on the game because it was boring, while the vast majority said it was too spooky, called themselves a wimp or a chicken, or, in my favourite case, one comment simply said “Stupid prison.”
And I’m not sure if I’ve ever related to anything more. Stupid prison.
3. Minecraft Legends
Given it tops out at a fairly tight runtime of 8 and a half hours and spawned from the best-selling game of all time, earning a 17.9% retirement rate when this thing came out less than a year ago is not a great showing from Mojang Studios. The reasoning here seems to be that the game was just deeply average, like completely middle of the road, fairly repetitive but not much to write home about.
It’s worth noting this one was available on GamePass so, like some of the other games on this list, it makes sense that more people might pick it up even if it’s not their thing but that doesn’t account for the resounding ‘eh’ this one got from players.
One of the title complaints is that it felt Mojang had just totally abandoned its player base once the game launched, resulting in an experience that just threw you back into the same uninspired loop over and over. The players who decided enough was enough and dropped a comment on HLTB saying why they didn’t want to play any more of it said the immediate shine wears off quickly and sledged it as straight up boring.
2. Forza Motorsport (2023)
Now, this is a funny one to include as given the nature of its genre being a simulation racer with multiplayer online modes, you’d expect people will naturally choose to be done with it, especially when a sequel comes out, the game gets too dated, or they’re loads of hours in and have done everything they want to do. For example Animal Crossing: New Leaf has an 18.7% retirement score but that game came out in 2013 and even then loads of comments said they only gave it up because New Horizons came out.
Comparatively, Forza Motorsport came out in October of 2023, just five months ago, so we can’t give it the benefit of the doubt on its release date, what we do have is its critical reception and the 19.6% retirement stat.
To be completely fair, some people who decided they were done with the game may well have had their fun with it and chosen to move on and one comment on the site does say it was enjoyable but simply taking up too much console space. At a wild 132 gigabytes on the Series X that’s a pretty fair reason to call it. While the critical response was fairly good, players decried the controls and progressions system, while those who officially abandoned their time with it on HLTB said they didn’t like the changes made to the formula or it was too buggy and unfinished. Now, there is a tug of war between those whose experience with the game has been a technical nightmare versus the claim that the negativity is coming from bandwagoning.
1. Don’t Starve
Ending with a game that is almost universally considered to be not at all shit, 2013 indie darling Don't Starve comes in at what may seem like a surprisingly high retirement rate of 19.6%.
So what did this charming, atmospheric survival game do to earn a percentage even higher than Redfall and matching Forza Motorsport? Be really hard, mostly.
The majority of retirees said they just couldn't see themselves making it to the end of the game's story mode due to the difficulty of the survival gameplay. This is in large part because it requires quite a high level of clever strategizing, particularly in learning how to best use the tools available to you in the extremely tricky story levels. Wrapping up the Adventure Mode even if you do have the patience is likely to take you dozens of hours. On the other hand there was also a decent contingent of gamers who marked themselves as done with Don't Starve because Don't Starve Together came out.
If you decided to stop fighting with this one and go make a snack you don't have to scavenge for under the threat of being maimed, that's understandable.