10 Video Games That Overstayed Their Welcome

There's ANOTHER 10 hours??!

mass effect andromeda peebee
EA

Video games are a fantastic means of escape in which audiences can lose themselves within limitless worlds for hours on end. During this time players can explore and uncover secrets, take full advantage of a range of abilities and weapons, and battle against foes of immense size and strength.

Tying these elements together (in most cases, at least) is a plot line which drives the action forward. It's within these stories where games can expand upon the world, characters, and perhaps teach some valuable lessons along the way, too. But unlike films where the narratives can be resolved in around two hours, video games need to extend their plots to cover campaigns which can go on for twenty, thirty, or even fifty hours.

While there are plenty of lengthy games out there which sustain their stories at a taut pace (The Witcher 3 being the prime example), not all titles are as successful.

Whether it's due to an overly ambitious narrative which starts to weigh the action down or an abundance of content that gets in the way. These are the games that began to feel a little stale before they reached the final credits.

10. Assassin's Creed Valhalla (2020)

Assassins Creed valhalla
Ubisoft

With the release of Assassins Creed Origins, Ubisoft transformed the stealth-action series into a massive RPG experience. There were numerous side quests, collectibles, and areas to explore on top of a massive revenge plot set within a well-realised Ancient Egypt. The follow-up, Odyssey, was even larger than Origins; but even this Ancient Greek epic was dwarfed by Valhalla.

Set in ninth century England, Valhalla sees Viking protagonist Eivor make a new home for their clan as they work on forging alliances with kingdoms across the country. These meaty sagas take up the bulk of Valhalla’s campaign.

Meanwhile, a subplot revolving around the Hidden Ones, Order of Ancients and Norse gods runs alongside Eivor's main adventure. Though starting off slowly, this plot becomes the primary focus during the late game.

As grand as Valhalla is, it's less successful when it comes to balancing these plotlines effectively.

By the time the plot reaches its final act and unveils potentially game-changing revelations, the pacing takes a massive blow when the narrative switches back to Eivor’s quest to secure power in England. The quest resolving the game-long hunt for the Order of Ancients is an even bigger anti-climax, ending Valhalla on a disappointing low.


9. Mass Effect: Andromeda (2017)

Mass Effect Andromeda 4k
Bioware

While the original Mass Effect trilogy had its share of flaws, BioWare had nevertheless triumphed in crafting an incredible sci-fi tale founded upon meaningful character relationships and rich world-building. And though this marked the end of Shepherd’s saga, fans were nevertheless excited to jump back into the Mass Effect universe when Andromeda was announced.

Unfortunately, this game failed to live up to the expectations set by original trilogy – and this was due to a lot more than a fistful of bizarre bugs and weird animation issues that were prevalent at launch.

Andromeda is simply too overstuffed with content for its own good. Though there are a handful of standout moments to be found here which come close to recapturing the magic of its predecessors, they're quickly lost within a sea of mundane content which bombards the player a few hours into the campaign.

It’s not only that there’s too much to do here, though. Andromeda makes a point of forcing players to run back and forth between within vast, empty biomes to complete variations of the same uninspired side quests. And then there's the monotonous grind of mining resources to improve gear.

The motivation to explore a new galaxy just isn't there.


8. Batman: Arkham Knight

Batman Arkham Knight Batmobile Drone Tanks
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

With Batman: Arkham Knight developers Rocksteady crafted a slick and exhilarating outing which put players in the cowl of the world’s greatest detective. The mixture of combat, stealth, and investigation contained within a singular location made for an absolute blast.

It was inevitable the series would be continued, with Arkham City and Origins each expanding on the gameplay in interesting ways.

However, bigger doesn’t always mean better.

Touted to be Batman’s greatest adventure yet, the game took place within a sprawling Gotham City. And to make getting around easier, the game made the Batmobile one of the main mechanics.

Though speeding down the streets is initially a thrilling addition, the novelty quickly runs thin simply because of how overused the Batmobile is.

A sizeable chunk of of the game is spent in lengthy, slow-paced fights against waves of tanks that never develop in complexity. Coupled with the assortment of times the car is needed in puzzles and uninspired chase sequences, and it's not a surprise that gliding is the preferred way to traverse Gotham.

And this isn’t even mentioning the predictable final act.


7. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

uncharted 4 nate elena
Naughty Dog

If it’s a larger-than-life action game you’re looking for, then look no further than the Uncharted series. Protagonist Nathan Drake’s globe-trotting expeditions capture the same spirit of adventure and discovery as Indiana Jones and Lara Croft, all of which is grounded with the relationships between the cast of lovable characters.

When A Thief’s End was marketed as the last chapter in Drake’s epic treasure-hunting career, fans were expecting their hero to go out in a glorious bang (though his ending proved to be a touching conclusion).

And while A Thief’s End certainly had everything fans were hoping for: spectacular set-pieces, adrenaline-fuelled combat and creative puzzles, and a character-driven story focused on family, Drake’s final outing was far from perfect.

The biggest disappointment came in the form of a lacklustre third act. When Drake and his companions’ quest leads them to the jungles of Madagascar, the pacing is ground to a an almost complete halt thanks to lacklustre enemy encounters and overused mechanics. Rather than searching for pirate gold, this section felt more like going through the motions to pad out the runtime.

Despite an underwhelming final boss, however, the game nevertheless managed to stick the landing.


6. Mafia 3 (2016)

mafia 3 lincoln
2K Games

Taking place in New Bordeaux, a fictionalised version of New Orleans, in 1968, Mafia III sees players take control of Vietnam veteran Lincoln Clay as he works to take down the various gangs controlling the city

Set to a euphoric sixties soundtrack and unafraid to confront hard-hitting themes of race within a post-Vietnam America, Mafia III is a thoughtful and brilliantly written game bolstered by superb performances. Likewise, key missions like a bank heist, infiltrating a river boat, and sneaking through an abandoned theme park help to keep the main plot engaging throughout.

Outside of these major plot beats, though, Mafia III descends into a monotonous and lifeless slog.

Before starting a key story mission, though, the game requires Lincoln to complete the same series of tasks for what feels like an eternity. These involve the standard open world affair of eliminating targets and infiltrating heavily guarded areas to complete minor objectives.

With little variation between each of these throughout the span of the entire game, playing the game becomes an unnecessary chore.

Combined with a lifeless open world that doesn't even have the convenience of fast travel, the standout story missions are barely worth the effort of unlocking them.


5. Days Gone (2019)

Days Gone
Sony Interactive Entertainment

When Sony announced post-apocalyptic zombie game Days Gone at E3 in 2016, excitement started to grow for what looked to be another one of PlayStation’s gritty and grounded, story-driven exclusives. The action was fast and frantic, and protagonist Deacon St John looked to be another gruff but sympathetic hero who audiences could root for.

When the game launched, however, it failed to meet most of these expectations. Despite the picturesque Oregon setting acting as a stunning backdrop to explore whilst hordes of “freakers” made for genuine threats, the overall gameplay loop that Days Gone is built upon isn't as engaging.

Aside from a charismatic performance from Sam Witwer as Deacon, Days Gone takes itself far too seriously for its own good as far as it becomes difficult to become invested in what’s intended to be a hard-hitting post-apocalyptic plot.

The repetitive and uninspired missions alongside an empty open world likewise do little to spark interest in Deacon’s hunt for his thought-to-be-dead wife. And when the plot drags on for up to a whopping 60 hours, it’s understandable why the monotony became too much to endure for some.


4. The Evil Within (2014)

Evil within matches
Bethesda Softworks

When horror video game legend Shinji Mikami created The Evil Within, new studio Tango Game Works crafted a devilishly imaginative survival horror experience filled with visceral gore, disturbing enemies, and nerve-shredding encounters where every resource mattered. It was a welcome return to horror roots, though the tension would dissipate long before players made it to the final boss.

The game begins with gruff detective and player-character Sebestian Castellanos arriving at a psychiatric hospital where a gruesome massacre has just taken place.

From here, it doesn’t take long for the detective to be thrown into a nightmarish hellscape where he must fight for his life and work to solve the grander mystery of what’s going on. Throughout the course of the next 20 hours, this investigation covers repressed trauma, a shady organisation, and a machine that enables people to experience a shared consciousness.

There’s a lot to take within the narrative. As a result, the intriguing tension established at the start gradually gets worn away as The Evil Within buckles under its own grand ideas and ambition.

A bigger issue lies in the dullness of the protagonist. Sebastian's emotionless responses to the mounting horrors aren’t enough to sympathise with his plight.


3. Dark Souls II (2014)

Dark souls 2
Bandai Namco Games/FromSoftware

The Dark Souls series has been championed by many for its tough-but-fair gameplay alongside its blend of horror and fantasy. However, out of these games, Dark Souls II has become the outcast of the three games. Though the sequel has its collection of devout fans who praise the new ideas that were brought to the table, there are just as many who dislike the game for what it did differently.

The main issue with this game is that it’s overstuffed with needless content. Compared to Dark Soul’s 13 bosses, DS2 contains 32 boss fights (not including the DLC). If these fights aren't forgettable encounters with glorified mobs, they’re tedious bouts that employ cryptic tactics like obtaining special items to deplete a monstrous-sized health pool or burning a mill to drain poison. And this is before the DLCs escalated the difficulty to borderline unfair.

The biggest detractor of DS2 is Hidetaka Miyazaki’s noticeable absence from the project. Without his creative spark giving life to the world, everything about Dark Souls II feels like a hollow imitation of the series.

Drudging through this game in its entirety is a bigger challenge than any of the bosses.


2. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain (2015)

metal gear solid 5 the phantom pain
Konami

Metal Gear has never been a series known for its brevity. If anything, Hideo Kojima’s genre-defining stealth series is renowned for its over-the-top storytelling and zany mechanics.

When Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain was announced at E3 in 2013, it was sold as being the biggest and most comprehensive entry in an already massively ambitious series. Fans were naturally thrilled to finally get their hands on it two years later, but nobody could have predicted just how ridiculously big The Phantom Pain was. In fact, this game was a little too big to make the impact it should have.

After completing the drawn-out, hour-long prologue sequence (the first clue how freakishly long this game is), it was time to dig into the Indepth sandbox. And while the freedom the main game offers when approaching objectives results in limitless scope for opportunity, the game's numerous and comprehensive systems will easily overwhelm anyone unfamiliar with the series.

Moreover, when the plot takes a backseat for most of the 45-hour campaign, the momentum to dig deeper into the increasingly complex story and mechanics starts to wane. And for those who did make it to the end, a disappointing finale was hardly worth the effort.


1. The Last Of Us Part II (2020)

The Last of Us 2
Sony Interactive Entertainment

Set four years after the events of the first game, The Last Of Us: Part II sees an adult Ellie set out on a quest for revenge against those who brutally murdered her father-figure Joel in a shocking opening sequence.

Playing alongside Ellie’s gritty tale of vengeance is a plotline which reframes events from the perspective of Abby, Joel’s murderer. Painting her in a sympathetic light, the game uses its disturbing depictions of violence to weave a hard-hitting parable of the fruitless nature of revenge.

The Last Of Us: Part II is undoubtedly one of the greatest achievements of storytelling in video games. By the time both protagonists finally cross paths in the climax, players are put through the emotional wringer before witnessing the tense confrontation.

This conclusion would have been a fitting end to both Ellie and Abby’s stories, but the game had other ideas.

The game picks up one year later with a lengthy epilogue sequence where Ellie once again goes after Abby. Though hammering home its main themes and closing on a sombre note, the epilogue is ultimately an unnecessary re-treading of previous plot beats which didn't add anything you hadn't seen by this point.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Glasgow-based cinephile who earned a Masters degree in film studies to spend their time writing about cinema, video games, and horror.