10 Worst Video Games Of 2018

The Quiet Man was just... WOW.

The quiet man
Square Enix

As many great games as have been released in 2018, what would the masterpieces be without the dumpster fires to distinguish them?

While there's a greater incentive to steer clear of terrible games than, say, awful movies given the greater cost and time investment, sometimes curiosity wins out regardless and you find yourself burned for ignoring those not-so-hot reviews.

But of course, that's what rentals and Steam refunds are made for. When it comes to Sony and Nintendo, though, good luck getting your money back.

Nevertheless, of the dozens of games we've pored over and play-tested throughout 2018, these are the 10 that left us feeling resigned, depressed, infuriated and exasperated.

From wildly disappointing new VR titles to a stunning AAA disaster nobody saw coming, so-bad-it's-good games you have to see to believe and everything in-between, gaming didn't get any worse than this over the last 12 months.

Above all else, these 10 duds are a potent reminder of just how tough it is to make even a basically entertaining, well-crafted game...


10. The Inpatient

The Inpatient
Supermassive Games

Though 2018 was overall a pretty damn solid year for PSVR with the release of quality titles such as Moss, Sprint Vector, Firewall Zero Hour, Astro Bot: Rescue Mission and Beat Saber, it sure got off to a rocky start.

The Inpatient was hyped up as the next big horror hit from Until Dawn: Rush of Blood developers Supermassive Games, so what a disappointment it was that the end product was so shockingly devoid of atmosphere.

Despite its strong visuals and sound design, The Inpatient never rose above mildly creepy due to the nothing story, forgettable characters and molasses-slow, consequence-free gameplay with only a few late-game fail states.

Following the nerve-shattering rollercoaster ride that was Rush of Blood, The Inpatient's two-hour experience was intensely underwhelming in almost every way.


9. Fallout 76

Fallout 76
Bethesda

While Fallout 76 is certainly the most high-profile AAA failure of 2018, it wouldn't be fair to call it the very worst game of the year. With that in mind, Bethesda's sloppy shambles of a multiplayer Fallout game is a wildly inept misfire across-the-board.

Despite the promising concept, Fallout 76 quickly outed itself as a lazy cash-grab with its piecemeal story, woeful lack of NPCs, sparse interactions with actual human players, boring PvP and "world events", choppy frame-rate and howlingly low-res textures.

Oh, and because it's always-online, any connectivity issues can pull you out of the game at a moment's notice, erasing significant amounts of progress in the process.

Mildly amusing if played with friends but still fundamentally rubbish, Fallout 76 is a staggering testament to publisher hubris and a legion of loyal fans who finally had enough.


8. Agony

Agony Game
Madmind Studio

This survival horror romp at least deserves some measure of credit for being one of the best-looking trainwrecks of the last few years. Unlike Fallout 76, it can actually hold a stable frame-rate and the slick textures are pleasant to look at.

But that's basically where the praise stops.

After an atmospheric opening sequence, Agony quickly drops the pretence and confirms itself to be a bland bore entirely lacking any discernible personality. Even if you're left unfazed by the game's rather flippant approach to sexual violence, the core gameplay just isn't fun.

Focused largely on a repetitive glut of stealth set-pieces hampered further by insta-death and sparse checkpointing, Agony at least lives up to its title.

Hopefully the team members responsible for the sound and visuals at least landed on their feet, because their genuinely strong work deserved so much better than...this.


7. Shaq Fu: A Legend Reborn

Shaq Fu A Legend Reborn
Big Deez Productions

This crowd-funded reboot of the infamous 1994 beat 'em up Shaq Fu is at least a worthy follow-up, in that it's a similarly lousy game you absolutely shouldn't play.

This re-imagined, monotonous three-hour side-scroller surely suffers through the most problematic identity crisis of any game released in 2018.

On one hand fundamentally self-aware of its own lame plotting and throwback gameplay yet also shamelessly racist without even the faintest wink or nudge, the new Shaq Fu has no idea what it wants to be nor who it's trying to appeal to.

In addition to being gross it's also thoroughly boring, forcing the player to battle against not only repetitive enemies but also the game's own stiff combat.

Checkpoints are sparse and occasional difficulty spikes are infuriating, while voiceover work from the man himself is laboured at best, and the game's over-abundance of outdated pop-culture references quickly becomes tiresome.

At least there's a mildly amusing DLC where you play as Barack Obama, but that's about it.


6. Bravo Team

Bravo Team
Supermassive Games

Supermassive Games sadly went 0-2 in 2018, by following-up The Inpatient with an even lazier, lower-effort VR offering in Bravo Team.

Widely hyped as "Rainbow Six for PSVR", even the basic thrill of using the headset's brilliant Aim controller was rendered mostly moot due to the game's flat visuals, awful locomotion mechanics, boring campaign and unresponsive controller tracking.

Without even basic online PVP functionality, Bravo Team was dead-on-arrival and rightly panned by critics, before Eurogamer posted a fascinating expose of the game's troubled, rushed development.

Thankfully headset owners got their quality Rainbow Six experience a few months later with the release of the effortlessly superior Firewall Zero Hour. Supermassive, meanwhile, hasn't announced any PSVR projects since, and it's probably for the best.


5. Overkill's The Walking Dead

Overkill S The Walking Dead
Overkill Software

Taking the Left 4 Dead formula and pasting it into a licensed The Walking Dead game might seem like a cynical move, but it's also one which should prove at least cursorily effective.

Payday developers Overkill Software demonstrated that's easier said than done with this dreadfully boring, roughshod co-op survival horror game.

Announced over four years ago and released on PC with a suspicious whisper last month, expectations weren't exactly high, yet Overkill's The Walking Dead can't even capture the simple thrill of squad-based zombie slaughter.

Hurling players into an array of painfully generic missions and locales, there's absolutely nothing unique about anything the game has to offer, which generally alternates between killing waves of Walkers, building defences and foraging for resources.

Gunplay is the game's most passable asset, but visually it all looks rather dated - even when played with Ultra settings in 4K - and unsurprisingly turned out a commercial flop for publisher Starbreeze.

What a waste of an IP filled with so much tie-in potential.


4. Past Cure

Past Cure
Phantom 8 Studio

Don't feel bad if you haven't heard of Past Cure, because this mystery action-thriller was dumped on Steam this past February with barely a peep.

Neither entertainingly bad enough to win a cult following nor intriguing enough to be even remotely memorable, Past Cure might be the single blandest video game released in 2018.

A garish, gaudy unwanted child of Silent Hill, Alan Wake and the infamous nightmare levels from Max Payne, Past Cure's opening 10 minutes alone are so aggressively offputting it's hard to imagine many pressing on for hours more. Again, Steam refunds are a God-send.

With its drab visuals, snooze-inducingly self-serious tone, agonising stealth gameplay and total lack of anything approaching a personality, the only thing this'll cure is your insomnia.


3. Hello Neighbor (Nintendo Switch)

Hello Neighbor
Dynamic Pixels

Released on Xbox One and PC late last year, this intriguing yet divisive survival horror stealth game was ported to PS4, Switch and mobile platforms this past summer.

As perfectly-suited to the Switch as the game seemed on paper, the console's limitations make an already rough game actively painful to play.

The goal is to sneak inside your creepy, suspicious neighbour's basement without being caught, which is naturally much easier said than done.

The game's frustratingly shaky mechanics and logic notwithstanding, this is one of the few Switch ports possible of giving the atrocious WWE 2K18 port a run for its money.

The frame-rate is tolerable, but the general image quality is absolutely repulsive, and despite the obvious portable appeal of the Switch, this probably should've never been certified for release.

And if all that's not bad enough, it costs a clinically insane £35.99 from the Nintendo eShop. Yikes.


2. The Quiet Man

The Quiet Man
Square Enix

As embarrassing as Fallout 76 was coming from a major AAA publisher, you can at least see what they were going for.

The same can't be said, sadly, for The Quiet Man, a cinematic beat 'em up in the vein of The Bouncer which was quietly (heh) sneezed onto storefronts last month.

There is the basic seed of an interesting idea here - to experience an entire game from the perspective of a deaf man - yet the execution is so misguided and haphazard it's been earning justified comparisons to Tommy Wiseau's disasterpiece The Room.

From the cringe-worthy FMV cinematics to the inconsistent treatment of sound in the protagonist's world, the confusing plot, appalling camera and frustrating fighting mechanics, it's impossible to see what Square Enix saw in this one.

At least it bothered to be so-bad-it's-good, and though completing the game unlocks a New Game+ with all the audio restored, how many people truly hated themselves enough to play through this damn thing twice?

And in any other year, The Quiet Man would decisively take the gong for the very worst game of the last 12 months, but 2018 somehow managed to go one worse...


1. Super Seducer

Super Seducer
RLC Training Inc.

Super Seducer is a game balanced perfectly on the precipice of being either an unimaginably awful all-timer or one of the most accidentally fascinating video games ever made.

Intended as a tool to help hapless men seduce women, Super Seducer hasn't a fleck of self-awareness about the grossness of the pick-up "industry" or the sliminess of treating interactions with women as mere feats of psychological arbitrage.

As you work your way through a series of puzzle-based FMV pick-up scenarios, you'll likely chuckle heartily at the low-rent production quality and howlingly bad acting.

But as a self-help utility for those genuinely craving help talking to women, it's wildly misguided at best and dangerously toxic at worst.

Thankfully YouTube is jam-packed with "best of" and "cringe compilations" from the game, so if this actually makes you mildly curious, you don't need to spend any of your own money.

A surprise sequel was released a few months ago which apparently tones down the misogyny and creepiness a tad, and so Super Seducer remains the crowned king of dumpster fire gaming in 2018. Good luck trying to top it, 2019.


In this post: 
Fallout 76
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.