11 Ways Bioware Should Have Made Mass Effect Andromeda
How to write a story worth five years and 40 million dollars.
If there was ever any game primed and ready for a "How it should've gone down"-type analysis, it's Mass Effect Andromeda. Because despite the many things fans will appreciate or the more overt ups and downs that come from playing the game itself, this is one of the richest mythologies in gaming history - one Bioware played it very safe with when revisiting.
To that end, Andromeda's main story is a supremely basic 'stop the evil alien' setup, twinned with some (weirdly optional) backstory elements, the notion of exploring and terraforming a variety of planets and getting lost in endless side-missions as you do so. It's not for everyone by a long shot, but thanks to Mass Effect as a mythology being a veritable sandbox of enjoyable alien relations, political posturing and interspecies philosophy, Andromeda occasionally shows signs of genuine brilliance.
They're few and far between for sure, but when you think back on just how much the whole world was flipping a middle finger towards EA back in 2012, how it's taken five years and 40 million dollars to develop, and how the status of Mass Effect as a franchise meant this had to be an immaculate game, there's a TON that should've gone down differently.
Starting with...
--
Note: Full spoilers for Mass Effect Andromeda within.
11. Make It So We Left The Milky Way Directly Because Of Shepard

One of the most enticing and all-round most plausible fan theories doing the rounds pre-launch, was that the Andromeda Initiative was assembled as a direct response to Shepard's various comments on the Reaper invasion. Although said knowledge was mostly kept hush-hush, it's not too big a stretch to assume that a relative of someone in the know got wind of what could be coming and set about putting plans in motion, just as a "What if?".
Now, if you've uncovered all of the optional Alec Ryder memory fragments, you'll know the game DOES go very close to saying this was the case, showing Garrus' father, Castis, informing Papa Ryder of the Reaper discovery, but it happens after the billionaire Jien Garson already has the Initiative underway.
We have a mysterious benefactor (most likely The Illusive Man) helping get funds together since the beginning too, but actually starting the Andromeda Initiative BECAUSE of Shepard's warnings and findings would've provided a much more engaging motive and purpose to the expedition overall.
Leaving under the motives of fear and survival rather than as a glorified science project immediately gives the Initiative a far more defined reason to exist, as in the game, the only real drive to succeed comes from the weight of the expedition i.e. Making 634 years in cryo and 2.5 million lightyears of distance matter.
By cementing the thought process that the Reapers were coming and the Milky Way could then be wiped out, it makes every new step and foothold made in Andromeda count towards a more meaningful end goal - especially seeing as the very last thing Ryder says before the credits roll is, "We did it".
10. Have The Crew Be Fans & Followers Of Shepard (Address The ME3 Ending)

The way Andromeda tackles the events of the original trilogy is to pretend they didn't exist or never happened, the only mention of Reapers, Protheans, Shepard and the old crew coming through optional audio logs or one conversation with Garrus' dad. This doesn't show the requisite confidence necessary to say to the public "Look, we revisited this universe for a reason", but it could've been done if many of the Initiative's members were fully engorged in Shepard's exploits.
I'll get to how they know everything in a second, but think about it: Enough time has passed in the games for the any events back home to fully transpire, meaning Bioware could've designed their crew of space-faring fighters to represent and vocalise all the responses to Mass Effect 3's ending controversy.
The only people that would sign up to such an 'Initiative' leaving the Milky Way in the first place are those who have a fondness for Shepard as the first human Spectre, and/or those that have attempted to keep up with his exploits during the original trilogy.
Flash forward in time and space, and you could have multiple scenes where various characters address the most polarising original trilogy elements head on. You'd have someone singing Shepard's praises, discussing how he did a phenomenal job with what was presented to him, whilst others could call out the 'bullsh*t' of space magic, the rumours of a 'Star Child' - even a joke/discussion on the indoctrination theory and how unbelievable/plausible it all feels, especially in retrospect.
Bioware clearly wanted to have a clean break from the original trilogy as its presented in Andromeda, but they still mention key characters anyway as some way of 'bridging the gap'. The controversy of ME3's ending isn't a ball and chain - it's an excuse to really unravel exactly what the developers were thinking, before using newer conversations to pivot our affections onto an entirely new cast for the future.
9. Have Cora Be The Illusive Man's Daughter

I mean... she kinda already is, right? Full name Cora Harper, assumed daughter of Jack Harper, also known as The Illusive Man?
Going into Andromeda, many fans thought Cora was going to pull off some sort of big reveal where we'd find out she was the daughter of TIM, yet aside from her referring to her father as a "prickly old b*stard" and a "genius" she could be honest with, that's all we get.
As both a neat tie into exploring The Illusive Man's actions outside of the one room we mostly see him in, Cora's access to TIM's archives would be the perfect way to introduce the necessary specifics in regards to Shepard's story, to the wider crew.
You could literally tie the unlocking of the original trilogy's major story beats into Cora going through her father's old archives, having pivotal cutscenes involving the whole crew, who - as both fans of Shepard, the Normandy, science and space itself - would dissect them accordingly.
8. Introduce The Archon's Experiments & Clarify Intentions Immediately

Everything about The Archon is as cookie-cutter as it gets, except the scene where you land on his ship and start to see he's operating on various the Milky Way races, either to cobble together some sort of 'perfect specimen', or just to figure out how to turn them into more Kett.
The scene culminates in an unleashed Kett Krogan boss fight, but then it's totally dropped. We see no more of the Archon's inner workings, no idea what he's doing or what drives him other than some sense of boredom, and after you take him down, there's no attempt made to delve into just how he became the Archon in the first place.
To remedy this, have one of the opening scenes of the game be getting captured by the Archon and his team.
Literally have the overall feel of arriving in Andromeda be "You are just as reusable and analytically viable as every other alien here", resulting in a breakout that would both give your crew members some time to shine, before firmly establishing the Archon as a force to be reckoned with.
Andromeda's various gameplay loops centre around exploration, and the only way the Archon stays relevant is through a constant reminder of what it felt like to be at his mercy. Therefore, make the various large Kett compounds you infiltrate and destroy research labs, and remind the player at regular intervals of this 'bored' antagonist who's treating the galaxy as his plaything.
It wouldn't have the depth of Saren's true allegiance or the notion of playing mind games with The Illusive Man, but at least then, we'd have a defined reason to both fear the Archon and want to take him down for the good of the galaxy.
7. Clarify How Ryder's 'Hand-Tech' Works

As it stands, somehow, Alec Ryder designs an A.I. so advanced, it can decrypt and activate an ancient series of space relics over half a decade in the future, and around 2.5 million lightyears away, all by connecting a hand component to any ancient terminal.
Bit of a reach, no?
The whole sequence only lasts a few moments and happens as you're defending your father's position whilst his SAM 'figures it out", meaning there's no room for exposition or an in-depth exploration of how Milky Way-born tech even functions in Andromeda's Heleus cluster.
There's not much that needs adding other than a few scenes of Ryder figuring out how his implant is working through all the necessary computations that go into unlocking Remnant tech. We do get the option of talking to SAMnode and exploring how the implant has recorded the memories of Alec Ryder, but nothing in regards to how this 'hand console' functions.
Furthermore, towards the close of the game, when this functionality gets overtaken and disabled by the Archon, we're supposed to believe that Ryder somehow continued to power this stuff through willpower alone.
It's... a bit threadbare, to say the least.
6. Use The SAM Implant To Stagger Unlockables

If there was one word to describe all of Mass Effect Andromeda's various interworking systems and preliminary attempts to hook you in, it's 'overwhelming'.
Somewhere along the way, Bioware decided the best way to introduce you to crafting, stat-tracking, planet scanning, race-relations and everything in between, was to throw them all at you in quick succession. To that end, a ton of players have bounced off immediately, as it can feel like there's this thick 'soup' of content to wade through for hours at a time.
Rather than give you an open-ended tutorial with five optional markers, make us play a class for a few minutes, working with select powers. Thematically it fits, as Ryder is fairly new at the whole "commando in space" routine, and after acquiring SAM, it could be played off as a 'calibration sequence' where SAM presents you with a variety of ability and skill setups, before letting you choose from them all at the end.
Crafting too, actually has a tutorial mission, but it's locked away behind squadmate Liam Kosta, who asks you to craft a piece of armour for him.
Make this one of the first things you have to do when getting the Tempest, then have Liam mention the need to keep on top of acquiring resources for even more upgrades. It would encourage players to stick with this portion of the game in a way the base version lets you totally forget about.
5. Make Ryder's Memories Integral To The Story, Or Lose Them Entirely

Fundamentally, there's little point in letting the player customise a character and have agency in their personality, if you're going to make them act a certain way regardless. Mass Effect 3 suffered from this, as you could've played the previous two as a total war-machine psychopath, only to get completely hung up on the death of one child at the beginning of the game.
As such, in Andromeda, Ryder has a completely optional tie to a series of memories that detail his or her backstory, fleshing out father Alec Ryder as someone who struggled to balance his work with his home life, and ultimately, these sequences reveal the assumed-dead mother Ryder is still alive - albeit in cryostasis.
All of these memories are fascinating and ultimately worthwhile, which is why it's baffling they remain optional. Either make them a key part of the story and give us more reason to empathise with Ryder's 'bumbling idiot saves the galaxy' shtick, or lose them entirely and continue the same "the past doesn't matter, but fill in the blanks if you like" Shepard style.
There's a real problem with how malleable Ryder is in Andromeda, as Bioware appear to want to write a defined character they can market and talk about, whilst simultaneously ticking the box of the original trilogy's DIY approach.
You can't have both. It has to be one or the other, to which I'd say, go with the latter.
4. Let Us Save Ryder's Mother

Speaking of all these memories, the biggest reveal is that despite the Ryder kids and Alec accompanying her around the deathbed, once Scott and Sarah have left the room, Alec secretly places Ellen into cryosleep, under the assumption that a cure could be created at some point in the future.
Flash-forward to Alec perishing and you uncovering all this information, and you can actually seek out Ellen's pod to discover she is, in fact, still alive, though still without a cure to her Element Zero poisoning.
I mean, it's stated the Krogan have found a way to cure the Genophage over the 634 year trip, but suffering from 'eezo'? Hell no.
In-game, this mission strand just ends with the Ryder twins saying aloud that they'll have to find a way to save her, and then... nothing. It's possible EA are going to revive Ellen as DLC (which if you tie the morality of a dying woman's life to that of additional content, is both monstrous and EXACTLY what they would do), but why was there no option to seek out the cure and save her?
Doing so would make perfect thematic sense, as a lot of Andromeda is about the Ryders worrying whether they can live up to and fit their father's shoes, meaning that as Alec tried and failed to save Ellen before the trip, carrying on where he left off, fulfilling his work and uniting the family in this new timeline could've felt incredible.
3. Tons Of New Aliens, Technology & Environmental Designs

Back to overarching stuff, and just how the hell do Bioware come up with the idea of travelling to an entirely new galaxy, only for the most 'alien' thing you see being floating rocks?
Literally, there are only four new races (of which only two have faces) a smattering of planets ranging from - wait for it - deserts to neon jungles and ice planets, and alien weaponry that extends to such outside-the-box visuals as... beam weapons.
This is obviously a huge thing to 'fix', but the general approach to a new galaxy should've felt as much. The Kett will occasionally turn into mist versions of themselves, so, y'know, cool, but where's the actual art direction that showcases this approach across the board?
Alien ships that move and fly in a way that breaks our understanding of physics, enemies that don't walk on two legs and speak with where their mouths 'should' be, planets that modulate and move in a fashion that requires specifically crafted equipment to even 'stand' on... Yes, you need some elements to be somewhat relatable or the whole thing is a bit of a mess, but Bioware played Andromeda's take on a new galaxy SO close to their chest, it comes across as utterly uninspired.
2. Explain How Aggressive Terraforming Doesn't Cause The Apocalypse

A huge portion of making the Heleus Cluster of Andromeda viable for life involves terraforming HUGE swathes of it to fit the wants and needs of humans, and nothing else. But... we're arriving in an entirely new galaxy, and we're looking to shift the ecosystems and biospheres of ENTIRE PLANETS, all of which happens in seconds, being you're flicking an underground switch and boom, instant blue skies.
This, well... this would kill untold numbers of lifeforms on their respective planets, who've grown rather accustomed to something like the biting cold of Voeld or the acid rain of Kadara. That's without mentioning the portion of the story where you gain access to Meridian, and set about changing the environment and overall weather conditions of the entire galaxy in an instant.
People would die, 99% of all plant life would also perish, as would creatures, aliens, and any other life form not humanoid or capable of finding shelter. Yet, this aspect of the narrative isn't even touched, we're just supposed to buy that 'ancient alien tech' can terraform multitudes of planets in seconds, with Andromeda never addressing the fairly obvious fallout.
1. Fix The Animations

I can free up some slack towards Bioware as the team of developers behind Andromeda were formerly the head multiplayer unit behind Mass Effect 3.
This was their first triple-A game, not to mention the amount of pressure they'll have been through attempting to craft the next instalment in Mass Effect after everything that happened. But... BUT, something must have gone drastically wrong, for a walking animation to turn into this...

At this stage you've probably already seen the compilation videos showcasing just how often a weird or questionable animation pops up, and whilst the facial renders are by far the worst, they only seem to apply to the human models, whilst the aliens are for the most part, pretty good - save the reuse of Salarian and Asari faces across their entire respective races.
From ape-like arm-dragging walking animations to contorted faces, blank stares during emotional moments or characters straight-up levitating out of frame mid-conversation, there's a marked lack of polish across the board that at least makes someone like Bethesda know it's not just them.
Still, the biggest thing that needed amending before release - and still does, at time of writing - are the conversation animations, from top to bottom.
--
What did you make of Mass Effect Andromeda, and what would you change? Let us know in the comments!