15 Greatest Ever Video Game Anti-Heroes

Moral ambiguity never looked so good.

hitman video game
Warner Bros. Interactive

Everyone loves a hero. They show up, kick ass, defeat evil and get the love interest in the end. They don't take shortcuts, don't kill for immoral reasons and always strive to be the ideal protagonist. As admirable as this all may be, it can't help but get a bit boring.

Sometimes a good villain will pull people in just as easily as a good hero. Everyone loves the Joker despite is psychotic murder sprees purely because of how interesting and charismatic he is.

But what if we combine the two?

The antihero has long been a favourite of all entertainment mediums: Film, television, video games, comic books, wrestling etc.

George R.R. Martin made an entire universe of morally ambiguous characters and it is now seen as one of the greatest shows in the history of TV. There seems to be an undeniable longing to see the bad boy just do the right thing, or vice versa.

The gaming industry has seen many legendary antiheroes entertain the player for hours, whether it is an antihero that is a preset character or in more open-ended games where you can choose to be an antihero. Sometimes the best antiheroes are the sidekicks to the protagonist. We all love a character that just can't seem to keep their hands clean.

15. Marcus - Detroit: Become Human

Detroit Become Human Markus
Sony

Detroit is a vastly differing game depending on the player's decisions. Playing as the androids Kara, Connor and Marcus, the players is forced to make snap decisions that will affect themselves, each other, and the world that they inhabit.

Because you engineer your own ending in the game based on your decisions (and how fast your reactions are for quick time events), it is possible to have each character choose the most honourable option, but when we take into consideration the ending that is deemed to be the 'true' ending, each character must delve into the morally dubious. None of the other protagonists do this quite like Marcus.

Marcus loved his owner, but when he succumbs to a heart attack and Marcus is accused of the murder, he is quickly gunned down and left to decay in an android graveyard. This is the beginning of Marcus' journey.

Marcus partakes in extreme vandalism in a later mission, including breaking into an android shop and turning all of the models in there deviant. He also leads a full-blown rebellion through the city streets, which results in the deaths of many androids and police officers alike. Despite the scale of these criminal acts, the noble message is clear for all to see: the androids will no longer stand for the segregation that they have faced in society.

No one makes it out of this story - the right way - with their hands clean.


14. Morrigan - Dragon Age: Origins

Morrigan Dragon Age
BioWare

One does not have to be the protagonist of the story to be an iconic antihero. Enter the roguish daughter of the Witch of the Wilds: Morrigan.

Encountered particularly early into the franchise debut, Morrigan becomes a companion to the protagonist after the death of many of the Grey Wardens. As the newest member of the order, the player-character must learn to act responsibly and gallantly in his actions as he seeks to destroy the dreaded Blight that has once again ravaged the lands of Ferelden.

Despite aiding in your fight against the evil darkspawn, Morrigan doesn't quite share this moral compass.

Although it is down to the player to decide on, and act out, many of the more evil choices throughout the game, it is always the voice of Morrigan advocating for this outcome. Murder a whole tower of mages because someone summoned some demons instead of trying to save them? Sure. Sacrifice the Arl's wife using blood magic? Why not.

Many fans of the franchise were jumping for joy when the sorceress returned in Dragon Age: Inquisition, but should they have? More often than not Morrigan has shown that she only serves herself. If your needs and hers lineup, then happy days. If not? Start sleeping with one eye open.


13. Vito Scaletta - Mafia 2

Mafia 2
2K

If you thought you could enter a video game named after infamous Italian crime families, assume the role of a member of said gang, and not participate in heinous deeds, then you're gravely mistaken.

Following his service in the American army during World War 2, Vito Scaletta returns to find that his family are in severe debt due to a loan obtained by Vito's late father, and are being harassed by loan sharks. Vito and his best friend, Joe, begin taking on odd jobs for the mafia in order to make some money, but this lands him in prison.

His mother dies while he is incarcerated, and instead of giving up his criminal tendencies, he throws himself deeper into the mob in order to provide for himself and the only family he has left: his sister.

Ironically, Vito's mob connections drive a wedge between him and his sister anyway.

Vito's journey started with noble intentions (alleviating his family's debt), but the deeper he got the harder it was to get out. One could argue that greater powers in both law enforcement and different criminal organisations manipulated Vito into committing so many violent acts, but you know what they say: he made his bed.


12. Ada Wong - Resident Evil 2

Ada Wong Gif
Capcom

Now we see a candidate for possibly the least appropriately dressed character in an apocalypse ever. Sporting a red dress, Ada Wong could also hold the crown for most morally ambiguous ever featured in the Resident Evil franchise.

Constantly popping up in the stories and missions surrounding the illegal business of Umbrella, Ada has both aided and manipulated several of the protagonists of the series. Whenever good-guy Leon Kennedy is in trouble, she wastes no time in coming to his rescue, but her mission for her organisation always takes priority.

Serving as an operative for an unnamed competitor to Umbrella, Ada Wong is sent on missions to steal Umbrella's research so that they may profit off of it themselves.

Ada could generally be described as an evil archetypal femme-fatale when you analyse her shady backstory and many of her actions throughout the Resident Evil canon. Delve a little deeper, however, and we see that whenever the situation calls on her to do the right thing and be the hero, she obliges without hesitation.


11. James Earl Cash - Manhunt

manhunt james earl cash
Rockstar

It's strange to think that anyone in Manhunt could come anywhere near to the title of 'hero'.

James Earl Cash begins the game incarcerated and on death row for seemingly undefinable reasons. He finds himself presented with a strange opportunity on his execution day: if he violently murders his way through the gang-infested neighbourhood he has been dumped in for a snuff film, then he will have his freedom.

The tension ramps up when he is pitted against multiple gangs and mercenaries throughout the city of Carcer. James Earl Cash is clearly an efficient but savage killer, using items such as a brick, broken glass, a plastic bag and a chainsaw to brutally execute his victims.

There is almost nothing making us empathise with this playable lunatic, until it is discovered that members of his own family have been kidnapped to add some twisted drama to this murder porno. Despite being told to free them by the director of the snuff film, they are all later murdered anyway, and Cash is forced to watch their murders capture on VHS.

From here, Mahunt becomes more of a justifiable revenge plot, but after all James Earl Cash had done up to this point for the sake of his own freedom, he is still far from being a good guy.


10. Arthur Morgan - Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2
Rockstar

When it came to weighing up whether to include Arthur Morgan or John Marston in this list, it was a close call, but as John largely killed bandits and bad people in order to save his family, Arthur struck me more as the antihero of the two.

Set in the thriving West, but centring about the dying wild West, we follow Arthur Morgan and co as they aim to pull off one huge heist that will set them up for the rest of their lives. Having been chased out of Blackwater and losing all of their money, Arthur follows his charismatic leader Dutch Van der Linde as he leads their crew through various failed schemes and plots to make them some cash.

Whilst Dutch becomes more and more unhinged, money hungry and gains a lower regard for the well-being of others (including those in his very own gang), Arthur becomes more compassionate, regretting his evil actions and seeking forgiveness in some form.

The conflicting desires of his moral compass against the loyalty to his friends and family creative an incredibly moving character as we play out all of his highs and lows.

Should the player help guide Arthur to the redemption he seeks, then we will watch a gorgeous sunrise alongside a troubled soul that has finally been laid to rest. Truly one of the greatest antiheroes in video game history.


9. Joel - The Last Of Us

The Last Of Us Joel
Naughty Dog

To this day The Last of Us protagonist, Joel, remains one of the most heavily debated yet highly praised characters to ever grace the video game industry.

Although you can argue that many of the enemies that Joel encounters are significantly worse than him (and you'd be right), this doesn't automatically make Joel a nice guy.

Following the death of his daughter Sarah at the beginning of the outbreak, Joel turns to smuggling and trafficking in order to survive in the ruins of whatever society is left. After tracking his shipment of weapons to a group of outlaws called the Fireflies, Joel is offered a trade: he will get his guns back if he transports an immune girl named Ellie to a different arm of their organisation.

During their travels Joel is initially cold and harsh with Ellie, but as they grow closer, Joel learns to care for her as a daughter, almost seeing her as the replacement for Sarah.

When they reach their destination, Ellie is taken to an operating theatre where the Fireflies' plan is finally revealed: they are going to make a cure from the infected parts of Ellie's brain. Realising this would kill her, Joel goes on a murder spree, killing several soldiers and doctors to save her.

Joel chose to damn potentially all of humanity for the sake of one girl. Let that sink in and then tell me he's a hero.


8. Kratos - God Of War

God of war kratos
Sony

Greek Gods are fairly well known for not being the friendliest of fellows - they are reasonably likely to react to the smallest of offences by destroying entire cities - and Kratos is no exception.

Kratos can feel vilified in waging a full-blown war against the Gods, since Ares had him kill his own wife and daughter, but this was as a result of his total loss of humanity and mindless slaughter of innocents in the name of the God of War himself. Kratos' mother and brother were also killed due to the meddling of the Gods, and after refusing to swear undying fielty to his father, Zeus, he is impaled on the Blade of Olympus and banished to the Underworld.

What a family.

Kratos partakes in the senseless murder of many innocents on his journeys. He allows a ship captain to fall into the throat of the hydra and die, lets Poseidon's Princess to be violently crushed in a crank shaft minutes after freeing her from captivity, and sacrifices many followers in order to solve puzzles.

After exacting his revenge on the Gods, Kratos moves to the Nordic land of Midgard, where he fathers a boy named Atreus. He teaches Atreus many things, teaching him skills and important lessons when interacting with the mythical lands they travel, and there seems to be a key theme behind many of these lessons: don't be like Kratos.


7. Agent 47 - Hitman

Agent 47
IO Interactive

If you are literally made in a laboratory to work as a killer-for-hire that carries out hits regardless of the target, can you really have an abject sense of good and evil? I suppose this is what you were always bound to get when you combine the DNA of four criminal masterminds and terrorists, and a psycho scientist.

Travelling the world assassinating targets, the player assumes the role as Agent 47. When he is on task, anyone that stands in his way is expendable. Whether it be aggressor or bystander, if they stand between Agent 47 and his target, they could end up kicking it prematurely.

Whilst in later iterations of the Hitman series Agent 47 is punished for going off-track and killing too many non-targets, there is still an uncomfortable level of acceptable casualties allowed by the International Contract Agency.

Although he largely only targets high-profile criminals and does show genuine compassion to the very few he cares about, it is almost impossible to see past his murderous career path and history of over-the-top violence.

Agent 47 literally dragged a guard out of a window and plunged him into the rocky waters below after the guard had just discovered that he was clear of cancer and began celebrating. Bit dark that.


6. Niko Bellic - Grand Theft Auto IV

Niko bellic gta iv 4
Rockstar

What is it with Rockstar and having multiple antiheroes to choose from in their respective franchises? Much like the Arthur Morgan/John Marston decision, I had difficult choosing between Carl 'CJ' Johnson and Niko Bellic. Eventually, I chose the latter.

Moving to the land of opportunity based on the lavish lies of his cousin, Niko intends to escape the reach of his former smuggling boss, Ray Bulgarin, who believes Niko double-crossed him. Despite the opportunity for a fresh start, Niko become involved in the criminal underworld of Liberty City very quickly after getting off the boat.

Although he does look out for his cousin as he tries to build up his legitimate taxi cab company and pursues the life of a normal citizen through dating and picking up hobbies, it would appear old habits die hard.

In terms of the crimes he has committed, we can tick off escaping police custody, assault, smuggling, bank robbing, aiding and abetting and murder, and his total kill count stands at over 80 people. That's just the named characters of the game, as well, never mind the countless goons and henchmen.

Whilst many of these people will have been criminals far worse than Niko or simply in self-defence, Niko is not a good man.

And he definitely does not want to go bowling, Roman.


5. Johnny Gat - Saints Row

saints row johnny gat
Volition

One of the lieutenants of the Third Street Saints, Johnny Gat is quite a perplexing character. Seeing his home city ravaged by gang wars over turf, Johnny joined the Saints due to their ambitions of ending the violence. Whilst this may be an admirable goal, his violent tendencies certainly make him the most volatile member of the crew.

Resorting to charging in guns blazing makes up the basis of all of his plans, and he even partakes in the assassinations of both Mayor Winslow and police chief Monroe, cementing his status as one of the most high-profile criminals in the world of Saints Row.

Despite all of this he is fiercely loyal to those closest to him, especially to the player-character and his girlfriend, Aisha, and will always have your back regardless of how bleak your situation may look.

In the topsy-turvy world of Saints Row however, by the third instalment of the franchise the Saints and Johnny Gat are idolised in society, with huge merchandising deals propelling the former gang into conglomerate corporation status. Somewhat of a meta-commentary on our modern society and how we seemingly yearn for everything that is bad for us at whatever expense, Johnny strongly opposes the new fundamentals of the Third Street Saints.

Unfortunately, before he gains an opportunity to try and turn the Saints around, he is gunned down. Rest in peace, Johnny.


4. Martin Walker - Spec Ops: The Line

Spec Ops The Line Martin Walker
2K Games

Spec Ops: The Line is a truly brilliant piece of storytelling. In the world's alternate present day Dubai has been almost completely destroyed by a series of dust storms and many people remain trapped there. Colonel John Konrad lead an attempted rescue alongside the 33rd Battalion.

You play Captain Martin Walker, who enters Dubai alongside two fellow Delta operators (Adams and Lugo) in an attempt to find Konrad and his unit.

Walker must make some hellish calls in order to keep progressing forward, and whilst an amount of violence and deadly decision making is warranted, nay, expected, it seemed that Konrad had actually been committing atrocities against the remaining Emirati populous.

Walker is determined to uncover the truth, even after killing some of the 33rd Battalion, and pushes on. This is where they begin to make many questionable decisions under false pretences, including destroying the only remaining water supply in the region and killing unarmed hostages. Later Walker even resorts to using white phosphorous on what he believes is a large group of enemy soldiers.

These 'soldiers' are discovered to be innocent refugees, including children. From here, the message of the story begins to reveal itself: it's not Konrad riddled with PTSD and committing war crimes, it's you. Captain Martin Walker.

The 33rd Battalion were trying to save these civilians, and you have brutally murdered them all. Spec Ops: The Line is a brilliant narrative insight into how PTSD can affect your perceptions.


3. Garrett - Thief

thief Garrett
Eidos

The Robin Hood of video games would be an accurate analogy for this entry. In the 2014 reboot of the franchise, Garret to steal something from the ruler of the City. Garrett witnesses a ritual being performed in the manor, and after a confrontation between Garrett and his partner, Erin, the two are captured.

Garrett awakens a year later to a plague named the 'Gloom' infesting the city, and decides to aid in the attempt to cure it, as well as removing the evil Baron Northcrest from power. Noble right?

At face value, however, Garrett is a skilled thief-for-hire, stealing valuable and treasured property that doesn't belong to him for monetary gain. No matter the reasoning, this is still illegal, even in the fictional City the game inhabits.

Garrett is also shown to have a strong moral compass. When Erin kills a guard that she could have easily avoided or incapacitated, he criticises her for doing so, saying that the man did not need to die.

This is a touch ironic, though. Later in the story you find out that the original ritual was for the baron to gain power, but because it was interrupted halfway through, the Gloom was released on the city.

Maybe if Garrett wasn't a thief for hire, they would just have a powerful baron to contend with, instead of a still-powerful baron and a plague of death.


2. Altaïr Ibn-LaʼAhad - Assassin's Creed

Assassin's Creed Altair
Ubisoft

Master assassin. Skilled warrior. Bit of a dick. All are accurate description of the famed Altaïr.

In the Assassin's Creed universe, their organisation has attempted for centuries to end the Templar threat, but in the premier title in the franchise, we see the assassin's order at the height of their notoriety.

Altaïr is a roguish upstart, who despite his incredible abilities, takes his order's creed for granted. Anyone that has played these titles is familiar with the phrase: 'Nothing is true, everything is permitted'. Altaïr takes the generally ambiguous meaning of the phrase and construes it to fit his own means. This includes murdering an innocent elderly man whilst on the search for a Piece of Eden, simply because he was in their way.

From birth he was trained to become an assassin, but his arrogance quickly led to his downfall: after getting a fellow assassin killed when confronting one of their enemies, he is demoted to novice and sent out into the world to complete nine assassination's and reclaim his rank as a master.

Despite accepting this demotion, Altaïr continues to be brazen and rude to many now higher ranking members of the order that give him instructions.


1. Booker DeWitt - Bioshock: Infinite

Booker DeWitt Bioshock Infinite
2K

A private investigator and former Pinkerton agent, Booker is a drunk and gambler that accepts a job from the Lutece siblings to "give us the girl" in order to "wipe away the debt". This summary right here is almost enough to make him a villain rather than an antihero.

Booker's nicer side comes to light through his travels with Elizabeth, the girl we was tasked with retrieving. She had been imprisoned in a tower by the tyrannical ruler of the city, Zachary Hale Comstock, but upon rescuing her, the two quickly form a strong bond.

No surprise really, seeing as Elizabeth turns out to be Booker's though to be lost daughter, Anna.

An extremely powerful being capable of morphing the very time and space around her, the plot of Bioshock: Infinite is thrown on itself when Booker learns that Comstock is actually Booker from an alternate timeline.

Not only this, but it is revealed that it was Booker that had doomed Elizabeth to her fate all along. What Lutece had said at the start of the game was actually referring to a much younger Booker handing over his infant daughter to them to take to Comstock in the alternative universe.

Booker allows himself to be drowned in order to stop this timeline from occurring, but had too much interdimensional damage been done, all for the sake of clearing some debt?


In this post: 
Hitman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lover of all things zombie. Secretly wishing for the apocalypse, but only on easy difficulty. Top of the world leaderboards for a couple of songs on Pro Drums on Rock Band 4. Can name every world flag. Currently doing my MA in Creative Writing in an attempt to do something with my life.