16 Video Games That Would Make Perfect Animated Movies

Live-action adaptations have always failed - it's time to play to some of gaming's strengths.

Fast forward 35 or so years from the chip-tune 2D days to the industry of today, and there's definitely been more of a push towards increasingly realistic games. But while that style has more or less become the norm, there are numerous titles which have evolved to present highly detailed art styles reminiscent of the same qualities one might expect from animated TV shows or feature films. While many think that live action must be the standard for big movie productions, the truth of the matter is that things like jumping two stories from a standing position or throwing balls of energy around don't always fare well in the transition. As a result, several movies which have tried to adapt video games with such features have wound up compromised. In other cases, it's just a simple matter of what looks good in a cartoon style doesn't look so good in live action, and so, the following are 16 such games that are ready and simply waiting for Hollywood to bring to the big screen as fully animated features. Something to note: Titles have been chosen based on how likely realistic an adaptation could actually be, so that leaves some otherwise great games like Journey - whose wordless story would arguably be completely ruined by Hollywood's belief that nothing without some sort of chatter every 20-30 seconds isn't worth doing - off the list.

16. The Legend Of Zelda

You're probably asking yourself right now "why is The Legend of Zelda ranking so low on this list? It would make a great movie!" And you're right: Done properly, it could be one of the best. However, despite the anime style the series sports these days, the fact of the matter is that The Legend of Zelda would just as easily - if not more so - make a great live-action fantasy film, and it's difficult to imagine anyone in Hollywood not trying to skew things in that direction. With three Lord of the Rings and three Hobbit movies making bank, you just know another studio would love a piece of that to call their own, and Zelda could give it to them. That said, there is of course one part of the franchise which indisputably falls more on the cartoony side of things:
The aptly-named "Toon Link," seen in titles such as The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker, Four Swords Adventures, The Minish Cap, Spirit Tracks, and Phantom Hourglass, is of course perfect for an animated adaptation. Not only that, but the unique visual style would help it stand apart from other animated films, whether they be computer animated, hand drawn, or stop-motion.

15. Conker

Originally an all-ages mascot platformer like any other, Rare saw that Conker would potentially be lost in the fold, and gave their latest project a makeover infused with all of the adult humour and themes which were popular with fans of South Park and other 90s fare at the time. The new and more vulgar version of the anti-heroic squirrel would make for an interesting animated feature to be sure, but one that only those 18 and over would be able to purchase tickets for. Conker would be far from alone in the adult-only animated characters club, too. Fritz the Cat, Heavy Metal, Team America: World Police, and the aforementioned South Park have all shown that there is indeed an audience for silver screen animated features which are too mature for a younger demographic. The best part of course, would have to be the potential for musical numbers. Who among us can honestly say they would not love the song of "The Great and Mighty Poo" to become a mainstream hit?

14. Jak And Daxter

Jak and Daxter's games were published by the Computer Entertainment division of Sony, a company which also has its very own movie studio. How convenient is that? What's more, the core Jak and Daxter series forms a complete trilogy with a slight Star Wars flavor to it, insofar as it opens up with a more lighthearted instalment before taking a darker turn in its middle chapter before finally reaching a conclusion in the third. It also bears the hallmarks of a film that would no doubt appeal to kids, starring a cool hero accompanied by a character who seems born to fit the mould of "child appeal," for better or worse. Really, why isn't this already happening?

13. Kid Icarus

After a groundswell of support following his appearance as a revitalized character in Super Smash Bros. Brawl, Pit returned to a starring role in Kid Icarus Uprising in 2012. The result was nothing short of a licensing agent's dream. Our young hero returned to action with much more than a bow and arrow in hand; rather, he had a virtual armory of different weapons and tools at his disposal. Combined with the awesome vehicles he can take control of, he has as many options at his disposal (maybe more) as Batman, but without all the inherent angst. The characters also offer lots of entertaining and informative dialogue throughout, thanks to a script that is better thought out than attaching inane sound clips to common actions. This one might have ranked higher, but truth be told, it feels like an animated film might actually hinder the franchise's potential. While it could be done, it's instead far easier to imagine each chapter of Kid Icarus Uprising being adapted into a television series.

12. Battletoads

Created as something of a game-oriented counterpoint to the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, there is no better time than now for the Battletoads to make the froggy leap to the silver screen. There are some pretty good hints that a new game is on the way, and the Turtles themselves are pretty hot again themselves - possibly the hottest they've been since their original run. As a result, it's the perfect time for Microsoft to jump on the bandwagon once again. That said, something like this could be live action, but with only two human characters (barring the guys who turn into the Battletoads) and landscapes consisting of alien worlds and spacecraft, going animated just seems to make more sense. Plus, the Battletoads' penchant for morphing their bodies into various tools, weapons, and machinery might work more easily with less explanation in animation, too.

11. Kirby

Kirby has triumphed in both video game and animated television series form, so why not the movies as well? Of course, if Nintendo's tough cream puff did make the leap, it's difficult to imagine it being anything other than animated. One neat thing about Kirby that could work for the movies is that more often than not, he faces a different antagonist with each new adventure. Given that Hollywood seems to love ending legendary feuds with someone getting killed, that's a plus of sorts. However, in Kirby's case, his foes sometimes end up reformed and acting alongside him as allies, such as in the cases of fan favorites King Dedede and Meta Knight. Sort of like if Boba Fett threw in with the rebels after being defeated instead of being unceremoniously eaten by the Sarlacc, or when Catwoman joins up with Batman. Plus, as noted elsewhere on this site, the little pink Star Warrior does find himself in some rather intense scrapes that would probably translate well to a bigger screen.

10. Rayman

Did you know that Rayman creator Michel Ancel was knighted by the French Minister of Culture and Communication alongside Shigeru Miyamoto and Frédérick Raynal in 2006? Not only was that the first time video game developers were honored with the distinction, but that puts Ancel and his creation in some pretty good company. There are multiple ways one could go about adapting the limbless wonder for a motion picture. The most obvious of course, would be adapting one of his many games, such as the hit Rayman 2, the more recent Rayman Origins or Legends. On the other hand, a completely original tale would offer some equally interesting opportunities, including the prospect of including Ubisoft's hit Rabbids characters, who have come a long way since debuting alongside Rayman on the Wii (including landing their own animated series on TV). That said, anyone who has played a Rayman game - particularly Rayman Origins or Rayman Legends - knows how animated this hero and his cast of friends already are. Plus, Legends features several musical numbers mixed into the gameplay almost seamlessly: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rhIoidHbWQs This alone would no doubt appeal to certain executives - particularly those who would love to make a killing by selling the soundtrack to the film.

9. Earthbound

Earthbound - and by extension, the entire Mother series - is one of those games that could theoretically be brought to the silver screen by way of a live-action adaptation, but with its Peanuts-esque art style and trippier elements, it's hard not to think it might lose something more in the transition than, say, The Legend of Zelda might. In fact, speaking of Peanuts, it's hard not to look at the new movie and think that it would be the perfect way to animated the adventures of Ness and the gang. While little, if anything, is currently known about the story for the Peanuts movie, fans of the Mother series know all too well that while the art style might be reminiscent of Schulz's comic strip, Charlie Brown and the gang are probably not in for nearly as dark an adventure as what ultimately awaits in Earthbound. The first game is already localized, just unreleased, while fans (under the watchful eye of professional translator Clyde "Tomato" Mandelin) translated the third and are willing to offer their work (with an estimated value of $30,000) up to Nintendo at no charge. Even if Nintendo would rather handle it themselves, it's possible that if partnered with a prominent studio they might help foot some of the bill - perhaps for their own reference/benefit.

8. Pikmin

Could Pikmin make the transition from video game to animated feature-length film? Absolutely. Proof of concept already exists in the form of the three short films directed by none other than Nintendo's Shigeru Miyamoto himself, which debuted at the Tokyo Film Festival and are now available in the Nintendo eShop. Have a peek for yourself: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dTnNdctBvtQ Pikmin is yet another example of a game stylized in such a way that it would risk losing something in a move to live-action. However, unlike others on this list, it could arguably benefit more from a blending of live action and computer animation, given the realistic nature of the environments the characters inhabit. At the same time, seeing as there are rarely any interactions with humans, it's not strictly necessary, either.

7. Child Of Light

Another entry from Ubisoft, Child of Light possesses a unique art style that, while it could translate to live action, would again no doubt lose something along the way. Aurora's trip through the land of Lemuria would do more to capture audience's hearts and imaginations by remaining in animated form, though there might also be potential in pushing the boundaries with something more along the lines of Coraline or ParaNorman. One big draw for such a film would be the vast array of characters accompanying Aurora on her journey. Mice who are archers, fairies who sport beards and Aurora's constant firefly companion could conceivably work in a live-action portrayal, but would undoubtedly be more at home in an animated setting.

6. Star Fox

With Star Trek's reboot bringing in audiences and new Star Wars films heightening the anticipation for space opera, the time seems perfect for Fox McCloud and the Star Fox team to blast off to the silver screen. Interestingly enough, however, Star Fox was itself inspired - at least in part - by a cartoon itself, though not one of the standard fare.
Creator Shigeru Miyamoto has made it known that he is a fan of English puppet dramas, such as Thunderbirds, which led to him creating a series of similar puppets to represent the characters for the box art of the original game. It also led to the simpler open/shut mouth animations used for the characters in the Nintendo 64 remake, Star Fox 64. With that said, if one were to bring Star Fox to theaters, why not do so by bringing the original Thunderbirds vision to life? Not only would it call back to the original games, but it would also ensure that the product is visually distinct from much of the competition.

5. Banjo Kazooie

Besides the aforementioned Conker, Banjo Kazooie is perhaps the strongest card in Microsoft's deck for an animated feature film. Of course, where Banjo succeeds over Conker is that bringing a foul-mouthed, beer-swilling squirrel to movie-going audiences is likely to be considered a lot more riskier thank the almost fairy tale-like story of a backwoods bear and belligerent bird seeking to free the former's sister from a wicked witch. Microsoft has a very strong gaming portfolio, and many of their franchises do possess great film potential. However, when it comes to properties which are better suited to animation than live-action, their options are considerably thinner.

4. Donkey Kong Country

Donkey Kong appearing in his own movie would be nothing short of poetic, as Nintendo had to fight Universal itself for the gorilla's very right to exist. Of course, when it comes to animated film material, it's the Donkey Kong Country series which stands out from the pack. From its creation, DKC was already very cartoon-like, from its highly-animated tie-wearing star to the legions of crocodile-people who opposed him in the Kremlings, and even down to such mannerisms as Rambi the rhino panting like a dog when left alone for a moment. And while the technology then was nowhere near what is available today, some of these elements were enough to inspire an episodic animated television show. Naturally, one would reasonably expect any sort of new Donkey Kong Country feature to more closely resemble the newer games in look. Thanks to the efforts of Retro Studios, that would also mean an opportunity for some interesting visuals for film audiences, such as scenes inspired by the silhouetted stages of Donkey Kong Country Returns and Tropical Freeze.
That said, while the visual style of the newer games is more desirable, the original Super NES trilogy is a much more appealing source for story and characters, such as the crazed King K. Rool.

3. Kingdom Hearts

Does this one really need explaining? It's a bunch of worlds from various Disney animated features tied together. You could call this Disney's version of The Avengers, were it not for the fact that The Avengers is actually already Disney's version of The Avengers. One can only guess as to why this isn't already a thing being some sort of hang-up on Square Enix's end, though with their recent financial reports, one would think they'd be more receptive to an easy source of money from one of their most prominent business partners. So who can say?

2. Mega Man

Mega Man feels like an obvious choice for this. After all, the Blue Bomber himself was inspired by other Japanese animated superheroes such as Astro Boy, though a little bit of American comic book sensibility found its way into the mix as well. Beyond that tie, however, Mega Man is a video game franchise near and dear to the hearts of many. This could not be more evident than by the reaction to Nintendo's reveal that he would be appearing in the new Super Smash Bros. for Nintendo 3DS/Wii U: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtwYIKjmSmQ At this point in Mega Man's career with Capcom's seeming interest in anything Mega Man-related outside of video games, one must wonder if he can transcend his origins and become a bigger star in big screen media. A similar case is Batman, who is known well as originating as a comic book character but whose films, cartoons and video games are each considered larger endeavours overall than DC's comparatively humble monthlies. While no new Mega Man games appear to be in the pipeline, he's starred in four different cartoons over his career to great success. Currently, numerous high-end figures and other merchandise are being created in the image of him, his allies and foes, and successors such as Mega Man X. He even has a critically-acclaimed monthly comic book from Archie which is fast approaching its 50th issue and a second crossover story arc with Sonic the Hedgehog. Perhaps it's time for new frontiers?

1. Super Mario Bros.

This one could not have been more obvious, yet may require the most justification. It's worth noting that the Super Mario Bros. have already already tried to take the box office by storm... but instead ended up as little more than a light drizzle. In the two decades since then, the live action Mario movie starring the late Bob Hoskins, John Leguizamo and the late Dennis Hopper has all but faded from public memory. Its legacy being that of a fixture in lists of the worst movie adaptations based on video games of all time, yet becoming something of a home video cult classic - usually for all the reasons those responsible for its existence wouldn't want it to be remembered. In some cases, younger audiences who know "It's-a me!" more than "Hey, paisanos!" don't even know of the movie at all. What's more, if Batman (and comic book movies in general) could be reborn by now following the bomb that was Joel Schumacher's Batman and Robin, then it's probably been more than enough time for audiences to give Mario and Luigi a second shot in Tinseltown. Who else do you think should have made the cut? Think any should rank higher than they did, or would be better off in live-action, or not as a movie at all? Tell us in the comments below!

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Former Nintendo Power writer, current Nintendo Force writer. Wrote the book on Mega Man (The Robot Master Field Guide). Was once fired by Vince McMahon. Dabbles in video games, comic books, toys, and fast food curiosities. Once had a new species of exotic bird named after him. It died. You can find more of his writings, musings, and other such things on his websites at Nyteworks.net.