8 Insanely Different Versions Of The SAME Video Game
Dividing the fanbase from day one.
While the console wars may indeed be a thing of the past that only wisened gamers reflect on while looking into a low poly fireplace and sipping a crisp 25 year-aged Mountain Dew Double XP Edition, we must remember that the battle for supremacy was a very real deal.
Whether it was Sony vs Microsoft, Nintendo Vs Sega or The Atari Jaguar Vs Common Decency, battles raged in every corner of the video game industry, and while many of the fighting was done over who had the most processing power and best exclusives, there was another much more sly battle going on.
For you see just because a video game released on several platforms at once, didn't necessarily mean that the game would be the same, leading to many confused discussions on the playground as people recounted levels, boss battles, and even entire gameplay differences to that which you were playing through at home.
While it's strange to see so much effort go into making each release feel unique, the shared branding of these games sure does make for some interesting reading.
8. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Tournament Fighters
It's not uncommon for fighting video games to differ slightly depending on what platform you play them on.
Well, clearly no one told Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Tournament Fighters this, as the NES, Genesis, and SNES versions might as well be completely different games.
For a start, the rosters outside of the classic pizza-loving turtles wildly differ, with the NES packing a measly seven fighters into the roster against the Genesis's eight and the SNES's TEN. However within the fighters is a world of difference, with each installment getting unique characters based on the comics showcasing that a lot of love went into every iteration.
Hell, even April O'Neil squares up for a few rounds!
The plots diverge heavily as well; in the NES version the turtles battle between themselves to see who is best to take on The Shredder, whereas in the SNES version the Turtles notice that a tournament of power is taking place and that Shredder has entered. Thinking they could defeat him for good, they all sign up.
It's the Genesis version then that actually does something interesting with its plot, as here the battles take place in Dimension X, with the Turtles defeating powerful warriors to locate their Master Splinter who has been rat-napped by Krang.
The differences are so many, especially when you consider the impact the different controller layouts have on gameplay, that the team could have easily released this as three separate games and milked the concept for all it's worth.
7. Gex: Enter The Gecko
When the N64 dropped its big weighty plastic sack onto the table and pronounced loudly "CHECK OUT THIS HARDWARE" the world over dropped its monocle in shock as truly we were witnessing some grey-clad clout. Gorgeous graphics appeared to be the future thanks to Nintendo's new beast and we all prepared ourselves to see the best the industry could offer.
However, when it came to Gex, the N64 had a total meltdown, offering up a much more inferior version to the PS1 counterpart, to the point where the fanbase has collectively agreed that this iteration of the classic platformer is the worst experience in the series.
For a start, all of the bonus levels were scrapped in this version, as well as a huge amount of dialogue and all of the cutscenes, meaning you won't have a clue as to what's going on in the N64 version apart from it being "Tail Time" apparently.
And what bonus it does offer, an exclusive level based on The Titanic is an utter nightmare! Why? because it's a water level and when have these ever been fun? All of this stips the title of its charm and only highlights its shortcomings.
6. Aladdin
While it would be very easy for me to sit here and just point at the fact that Aladdin has a freaking sword in the Genesis version of the game as to how this version differs wildly from the SNES installment, I am a professional and thus I've prepared a more detailed explanation.
The actual biggest difference, outside of the old pixellated poker, is how these games approach their central playing experience. For example, the Genesis version sticks much closer to the film on which it's based, following key plot points and adding in more levels to better reflect the flow of the narrative. Therefore you end up feeling like you're playing through the movie, rather than a game using elements from the cinematic output as inspiration which is the route the SNES version goes down.
That's not to say it's a bad experience as a result, as in fact, the SNES version is arguably a better game, focusing on level design rather than retreading the source. This coupled with a slightly easier challenge makes the SNES version a supreme platforming game in its own right. Either way, there's a version here for whatever tickles your fancy.
5. Alien 3
While it's pretty safe to say that Alien 3 is one of the worst movies in the illustrious sci-fi franchise, the video games it spawned we anything but the confusing mess we witnessed in cinemas. However, it does seem that the project's infamous studio meddling and confused throughline does seem to have resulted in a pair of titles that share the same name but very little else.
Alien 3 for the Snes and Genesis couldn't be more different an experience, with the former playing much like a Metroid game, focusing on exploration, puzzle-solving, and the constant building of a tense atmosphere, and the Genesis version preferring instead to dial up the action, hitting players with enemies around every corner and pushing them onwards with hectic time limits.
This actually provides a really interesting examination of the creation of "fear" in video games, as the SNES version draws out its set pieces and as such allows the threat of the Xenomorphs to build fear slowly within the player. On the other hand, the Genesis entry slams the player with danger and uses the time limit to make every action carry consequences, resulting in a frantic rush!
So depending on how you like your horror Alien 3 has got you covered!
4. The Adventures Of Batman & Robin
When it comes to the Batman franchise, there are so many good games to pick from. The Arkham games are pure bliss, The Lego Batman titles are a hoot, and even the VR title impressed fans with it's attention to detail. Yet there's actually one title in the bunch that is actually two great titles and that's The Adventures Of Batman And Robin.
The core experience varies widly depending on whether you got this for the Genesis or the SNES, as with SEGA you get a game that looks and plays an awful lot like Contra, which is by no means a bad thing, and for the SNES you get a stylised love letter to the animated series with outstanding graphics and side scrolling beat 'em up goodness as your bread and butter.
It's one of the few examples where owning both titles is reccomended as each offer something truly worth playing. The bullet hell sweat-a-thon of the Genesis version is tight and tense in all the right places, and the visual glory and satisfying THWONK of the SNES counterpart is a joy to play through. You can't go wrong with either option really.
3. XIII - Exclusive Multiplayer Modes
Ever since Goldeneye basically performed the biggest Mic Drop possible with its insane multiplayer offering, other FPS titles have been scrambling ever since to try and replicate even a fraction of its creativity and fun. Some found their own success, others settled into just one mode and drilled down hard, and then we have the strange case of the almighty comic-caper XIII.
For some reason, XIII decided that the best way to approach the concept of multiplayer, which if correctly handled can elevate even a mediocre game into the halls of couch party sessions, was to create multiplayer modes that were EXCLUSIVE to each console it dropped on, namely PS2, Original Xbox, and Gamecube.
Now while this doesn't affect the core gameplay on each console, it has huge ramifications for the longevity of the title, especially for the Gamecube which didn't support online modes. Why not give the little purple blob all three modes to make up for it? As a result, the Xbox and PC versions stormed ahead of the competition thanks to higher player caps and arguably better modes, leaving the PS2 and GC fanbase lamenting at a choice that was made for them.
2. The Pirates Of Darkwater
Back in the heyday of Saturday morning cartoons, every company going was trying their best to tap into the sugar-crazed youth market with colourful, over the top and outlandish tales of action and adventure, and in their quest to grab attention however they could we saw the rise of some utterly insane formats.
Captain Bucky O'hare, Street Sharks, Mummies Alive, Gargoyles, and so many more decided to be as utterly off the wall as possible in order to make kids actually pay attention for ten seconds. Therefore the altogether less insane Pirates Of Darkwater seemed to sail off into the fog without much notice such was its more grounded approach of pirates and sea fairing shenanigans, which is a huge shame because this show actually had a pretty engaging central plot concerning hidden treasures and great evils looking to dominate the High Seas.
Still, it was popular enough to spawn it's own video game, well technically two because despite sharing an IP the Sega Genesis and SNES versions differed drastically. The SNES iteration was an utter wet fart of a title, aping the likes of Final Fight and Streets Of Rage and doing so with none of the charm and quite possibly the most ear-bleeding of soundtracks.
Therefore it was up to the Genesis to save the reputation of Darkwater and did so by incorporating RPG elements into a platforming game to much greater success. The jump in terms of quality is night and day, and it's a shame that the cement shoes of the SNES version drowned any chance the Genesis game had of keeping the franchise afloat.
1. Sonic The Hedgehog 2
Now I know what you might be thinking, "Wait did Sonic The Hedgehog 2 appear on a rival console without me even realizing it? This is huge! Maybe the Console Wars with Nintendo was an inside job! A scam to create artificial demand for video games and a plot by both companies to tag-team wrestle the money from our wallets!"
Well, slow down there champ, as no Sonic didn't jump ship to Nintendo until the Smash Bros. Series came knocking at his door many years later. Instead, we have an odd example of SEGA releasing Sonic The Hedgehog 2, rightly regarded by many to be the finest game in the entire franchise, on two self-owned consoles that ended up being wildly different.
Making matters even more strange is finding out that the Master System version of this game actually dropped a full year before the Genesis counterpart would rightly steal the stage.
While the original isn't anything to sniff at, it differs wildly in level layout and plot, this time focusing on rescuing Tails from Dr Robotnik by paying him a ransom of Chaos Emeralds. The graphics naturally look much more simplistic on the Master System when compared to the lush vibrancy that the Genesis hits with, and you're left with a pair of games that look like the before and after photos of a bodybuilding transformation.
It's still a great game but feels decidedly Tesco Value when compared to this high calibre killer of a Genesis title.