Batman: Arkham Insurgency - 10 Things It Must Learn From Knight

If the rumours are true, what else needs to happen?

Batman Arkham
Rocksteady/Warner Bros.

Now the dust has finally settled Arkham Knight, it's easily the most controversial entry in the franchise overall - perhaps an even bigger conversation-starter than Origins. On the one hand, yes, Rocksteady gave us 'more Batman' - knocking the visuals out the park in the process - but thanks to a misleading advert campaign, some off-kilter Batmobile tank segments and a major plot twist you could guess from the opening scenes, there was a lot to mark Arkham Knight down as the worst of the bunch.

Now in 2017, plans have leaked in regards to a variety of game details for what appears to be titled, Arkham Insurgency. We're apparently going to see a grand unveiling at E3 in June, as like with Arkham Origins, Warner Bros. Montreal are once again going to be developing. If the leak is true, we're getting a prequel Batman & Robin story that uses Arkham Knight's immaculate game engine, revamps the basic combat model and even hints at the possibility of a side-story focused on how Hugo Strange discovered Bruce's true identity - something that was never truly answered in Arkham City.

All that said, Arkham Knight was far from perfect, and if WB are going to press ahead regardless (we always knew they would) the following bugbears and suggestions would go a long way to making Insurgency truly worthwhile.


10. Ditch Riddler's Raceways & Give Us A Pay-Off To Tracking Him Down

Batman Arkham Knight Riddler Trophy
Warner Bros.

Nobody wanted them, nobody truly enjoyed them, and yet Rocksteady still included a number of bonus 'raceways' as part of Arkham Knight's Season Pass. Even the idea of Riddler somehow having the means to set up a series of large-scale underground racetracks was a reach, despite Edward Nigma's substantial intelligence and prowess.

The only logical conclusion is to can them, but if that's not going to be the case - and if the leak is correct, it isn't - WB Montreal must deliver this time round on the pay-off of completing all of both them, and Nigma's other puzzles.

In Arkham City, finishing all of Riddler's challenges meant you got a badass scene where Batman dragged Edward through the floor of his surveillance room, planting boot to face before handing him over to the GCPD. Arkham Knight then... put him in a big ol' mech and forced you to have a totally out-of-place battle instead. Super.

For Insurgency, if Riddler is yet again going to be a large presence in Gotham, we need a satisfactory, sky-punching resolution that perfectly rewards the occasional busywork of bringing him in. More "I'm sick of your sh*t, Nigma!" controlled anger Batman, please.


9. Remove The "It All Happens On One Night" Setup

Batman arkham knight
Rocksteady

Like a weird hangover from Arkham Asylum, each subsequent game has taken place across one night - assumedly as some way to ratchet up the tension and really push Batman to the limits of his capabilities.

Thing is, it's utterly unnecessary, and by the time we got to Arkham Knight, with its mishmash of Most Wanted missions, travel-time, main story and tank battles, there was no way in hell all those things happened within the spate of a few hours.

Give us a Batman story that spans a good week, month or longer - give us a scenario that Bruce can't immediately solve, that he has to ponder on for quite some time in and out of the suit, and that he only overcomes after being on the ropes for a good amount of time.

Put simply, the 'one night timeline' setup doesn't work the bigger these games become, and just needs to go.


8. ...But Keep The Most Wanted Missions

ARKHAM knight professor pyg
Rocksteady

The easiest way to dip into the biggest list of Batman's villains in the quickest amount of time is through the 'Most Wanted' missions; small, focused introductions and executions on everyone from Two-Face to Professor Pyg.

Arkham Knight's only issue was each one only took around 10-15 minutes to get through. Two Face's in particular were just three stealthy Predator missions, Hush's was a barely interactive cutscene-cum-fakeout, and even Mr. Freeze's DLC was a glorified fetch-quest. Whilst the base idea of "Here are a bunch of villains loose in Gotham" is serviceable, they have next to no staying power or memorability if they're played off as an annoyance, or something you're checking off a list.

To that end, trim the villain pool and create more memorable missions that get away from the notion of just 'rounding up' what should be a formidable challenge. Arkham Knight implied that all of the Rogue's Gallery were working together, for example, but we never got a sense of that other than Scarecrow and Arkham Knight - more Batman 'taking care of business' like swatting a number of semi-identifiable flies.


7. Get As Far Away From 'Gun-Toting Batman' As Possible

Batman arkham Guns
Warner Bros.

The current incarnation that's doing the rounds on the big screen is quite fundamentally not Batman - mainly down to how incredibly callous he's become in both handling firearms and indulging in total destruction at all times.

You could see a bit of Zack Snyder's 'vision' infect the Arkham series too, as in Arkham Knight, suddenly Batman was levelling street-level thugs with waves of missiles, or was able to plough straight through groups of them - the play-off being "Well, the Batmobile electrocuted them out of the way first"...

Come on. It's clearly an in-game bending of the rules to get more in-line with this:

JUstice League Wonder Woman Batmobile
Warner Bros.

We all know there's no real place for a gun-loving Bat, unless it's part of some "He's lost his way" story, which wasn't earned or really the case in Arkham Knight. If Insurgency's rumours are true it'll be a prequel, thereby restoring Batman to more of a martial arts-focused fighter with less tech, but it's integral that the games don't follow the completely broken incarnation from the DCEU.


6. Let Us Repair The Batsuit As Part Of The Story

Batman Arkham Knight Batsuit
Warner Bros.

I can't be alone in thinking that the repetition of Batman slowly getting more and more degraded as the games went on sort of tarnishes the 'image' of a superhero in the first place. It totally worked in Arkham Asylum as Bruce was 'trapped' on the island until all the criminals were back in their cages, but so many games on, having the 'look' of the Dark Knight get so scuffed up is something that would be better factored into the story.

Remember Arkham Knight's unveiling of the new Batsuit? It was glorious. Let the player earn that suit by checking in on - or hearing about - its development, possibly coming together at the end to facilitate going toe-to-toe with whoever's revealed as the 'big bad'.

We're seeing Injustice 2 introduce the idea of having Batman's suit be composited of a number of different 'loot' components too, and whilst the Arkham series shouldn't devolve into a similarly customisable system, actually taking a role in restoring the image and 'presence' of Batman would inherently be very rewarding.


5. Don't Shoehorn In Another Role For The Joker

Batman Arkham Knight
Rocksteady

You're either sick of him thanks to Rocksteady's "He's not in this one, promise!" being a lie, or you're game for more Clown Prince, whatever the weather. Personally, I think the Arkham games could do with ditching Joker altogether for just one game - if not to prove a team of writers can actually create a worthwhile story without him.

Relating back to the leak, Joker is apparently behind the mass breakout of Arkham and Blackgate that allows everyone to spread out across Gotham, but the same info mentions that he's not a main character - more the Heath Ledger "I'm a dog chasing cars" version.

Either way, for the sake of progression, it would be very healthy for any Batman game to choose more unexplored territory like say the dualism of Two-Face, the 'saving him from himself' fragility of Mr. Freeze or the technologically-reliant likes of Prometheus, as all can provide parallels to how Batman thinks and operates, rather than just the chaos to his order.


4. A Completely Different Set Of Villains

batman arkham knight two face
Rocksteady

Continuing from the idea of writing an overarching story without the Joker, we need some much deeper cuts when it comes to the villain pool. Arkham Knight stretched as far as the twisted Professor Pyg, but for the most part it was business as usual.

The leak mentions that WB Montreal are looking to include "Maxie Zeus, Dollmaker, Killer Moth, Anarky, Two-Face, Blockbuster, Ventriloquist, Cornelius Stirk, Tweedledee & Tweedledum, Dusan al Ghul, Mad Monk, Dala and The Riddler", meaning only a handful crossover from before (Anarky, Two-Face and Riddler), yet the likes of Dusan could allow Batman's relationship eith the al Ghuls to be explored far more.

In Arkham City, we see that Bruce has more than a fondness for Talia al Ghul, going so far as to choose saving her over Gotham itself, yet this affection comes out of nowhere, isn't explained and never comes up again. Not even in the Ra's al Ghul portion of Arkham Knight's Season of Infamy DLC.

Being Insurgency could be a prequel, there's a lot to be explained or highlighted that even the original trilogy essentially side-stepped for the sake of maintaining pace.


3. Do More With The Bat-Family

batman arkham knight robin
Rocksteady

The Bruce Wayne of the Arkham trilogy tends to walk a fine line between being the sole protector of Gotham, and occasionally admitting he does need the help of Robin, Oracle and Nightwing. In Arkham City, he's all but completely dismissive of Robin helping out, remains relatively arrogant in the face of Alfred and Oracle offering advice, and even in Arkham Knight, we only get to feel the 'combined effort' of the Dynamic Duo in a handful of missions.

In the Matter of Family DLC, we got to see Batgirl working alongside Robin to fell Joker's schemes, introducing a solid dynamic that allows the stakes to be raised, before hammering home the notion that our heroes only succeed some scenarios by working as a team. In fact, in Arkham City, Batman will literally die unless you choose to let Catwoman save him - it's that spelled out, yet never capitalised on.

Again, if Insurgency's leaked prequel status hints at Batman and Robin working together for the first time, we might see a refined portrayal of Bruce that's less solo-minded, teaming up with Robin for a variety of encounters and extended missions along the way.


2. Use The Batmobile Intelligently

Arkham knight batman batmobile
Rocksteady

The Batmobile is largely pointless when you've got access to a one-button grapple mechanic that slingshots you across Gotham at a moments' notice. Obviously if this is a prequel, the assumption is that Bruce hasn't developed the necessary tech to enact said slingshotting, hence the possibility of a Batmobile being the main source of getting around.

In Arkham Knight, these uses boiled down to underground raceways, ramming perps off the road and engaging in protracted tank battles - neither of which had been a large part of the character in any other incarnation. For the most part, Bats uses his Batmobile to get to a given place, before doing the rest of his work on-foot. If we're going to see a return of any vehicle, it should be used as a way to get from place to place, to the same degree as we rely on the grappling hook.

Depending on how side missions and other random encounters go, there's the possibility of hopping into the Batmobile to chase someone down, or realising some time-sensitive element needs to be addressed (someone in trouble, a bomb defusal etc.), resulting in a mission going from combat to interrogation, to burning across Gotham to save the day before it's too late.

From City to Knight, no Arkham game has really justified why it had be open-world, other than as a selling point. Arkham Knight came the closest thanks to its Batmobile integration, but even that could be sidestepped if you preferred the grappling hook.

Let's see an Arkham game actually make its open world a key component of gameplay, not just something to slap on the back of the box.


1. Explore Bruce's Psyche At Key Points In The Story

batman arkham knight
Rocksteady

Following on from this lack of teamwork (which admittedly, is more of a new-age thing, thanks to how Scott Snyder has written the comics), is the lack of exploration into Batman as an entity, and Bruce as the man behind the mask.

Telltale's Batman games actually dove into this material with supreme confidence, presenting both the weight of living the double life, with the freeing nature of donning the cape and cowl to "get some answers", go around the law or stretching some morals, should the need arise.

Whilst it shouldn't take up the majority of the game, actually having Bruce analyse a given situation and his own motivations based on the events of the story would be a welcome change from having the 'support crew' tell him what's up or what's next. Yes, he does propel the narrative at key points, but we actually know next to nothing about this version of Bruce, and in Arkham Knight, when he started intoning about retirement and feeling sad about potentially killing himself towards the end of the game, none of the necessary character work had been done beforehand for those ideas to resonate.

--

What would you fix and amend from Arkham Knight? Let us know in the comments!


Watch Next


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.