Diablo 4: 10 Huge Things It Must Fix From 3
Thought Diablo III was lacking in many areas? You're not alone...
The Diablo franchise has been one of Blizzard’s most iconic creations. Each edition of the dark-themed hack-and-slash dungeon exploration game has shattered sales records and has earned great distinctions. The original was one of the most popular games of its time, and was a pioneer in online multiplayer gaming. Its successor, Diablo II, featured improved graphics, better character mechanics, a longer and more in-depth storyline, and considerable replayability.
Then, there’s Diablo III. What should’ve been an absolutely epic game was met with widespread criticism over a myriad of factors. It should’ve been better than Diablo II in every respect. Instead, it had people either booting up D2 instead, or simply turning away from the franchise altogether.
Thankfully, Diablo made many crucial changes with the Reaper of Souls expansion that had many people thinking that this wasn’t so much as an add-on per se, but a completely different game. That said, RoS does feature many of the same elements as the original Diablo III, and many of them are what make the game - in some respects - still inferior to Diablo II.
Blizzard, being Blizzard, will eventually release another game in this franchise. When they do, it will need to have certain features that made the franchise famous in a positive way, and none of what painted Diablo III as such a laughing stock amongst longtime fans.
10. Oversimplified Equipment Mechanics
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHPucUlQS1sThis is a great example of Blizzard removing players’ freedom to experiment in the game.
In Diablo III, Blizzard removed stat requirements for items, except for level requirements. While this made sense on a practical level, it completely did away with the importance of Strength and Dexterity attributes. Now characters only needed Vitality and their primary attribute, with the other two being considered useless for those classes.
In the game’s predecessors every attribute mattered, which added many layers to both gameplay and preparation. Having these stat restrictions was part of the fun; it taught players the importance of careful planning and decision-making.
Furthermore, in Diablo I and II players had the freedom to have their characters use any item they wanted, even if it looked silly (e.g. a Necromancer wielding a great sword, a Paladin with a bow & arrow, etc.). Diablo III puts restrictions on several items, including ones that aren’t even class-specific, robbing players of the ability to make truly unique characters and just have fun doing whatever they want in the game.
Thus Diablo IV should go back to the old system where weapons and armour have realistic requirements, whilst retaining the plethora of magical bonuses and unique item abilities found in Diablo III.
9. The Lack Of Spell Synergies
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RelUHhR5w2UWhat made character-building in Diablo II so interesting was the addition of spell synergies starting with patch 1.10. This meant that, the more points you put into one skill, if it was connected to another spell, there would be mutual benefit. These decisions made every skill point crucial to a character’s success, leaving no room for error (until the skill and attribute reset came to effect in patch 1.13).
In Diablo III, each spell is more or less standalone, with all damage being dependent primarily on weapon damage. Although they get skill runes, these only change the effects of that single spell, and don’t allow more interesting spell combinations. Players have to rely on items to make their skills more powerful, and skill runes add other effects to each one. That makes making each spell more powerful a bit too easy, whereas Diablo II taught players the importance of making key decisions at each level.
For Diablo IV, Blizzard should re-introduce this synergy system and skill points, which would allow for certain skills to get stronger and allowing for specialised character 'builds'. At the same time, the ability to reset skills should likewise be available from the beginning, instead of being limited to only three per character. That way, players can strengthen the skills they want, while still having the freedom to create new builds.
8. Restarting Boss Fights, Cutscenes & Enrage Timers
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JC_8IuQ7cLQFor some strange reason, Diablo III features a cutscene that then requires players to fight major boss characters with only one life. While this made the fights more exciting, and resurrecting allies more challenging, it added several problems when playing in multiplayer. There were timers on accepting the boss fight, and waiting for other players could be a major hassle.
But if you were unfortunate enough to die during a fight (or, in multiplayer, if all of you died), you had to start again from the very beginning. This made some encounters extremely irritating (instead of, you know, fun), especially when their Enrage Timers ran out and they became even more imbalanced.
Imagine trying to fight a major boss several times because you keep dying once the three-minute mark was hit. This begs the question, why was Blizzard trying to make boss fights on Torment difficulty short? Shouldn’t the battles be longer to encourage more excitement and personal self-satisfaction once they are defeated?
To remedy this, let's see a return to the old 'free' battle system of Diablo II, where players could keep fighting bosses without having to restart completely if everyone died. Furthermore, the Enrage Timer should be an optional feature instead of a built-in aspect of Torment-level fights, because going up against something so overpowered only satisfied truly committed gamers, whilst irritating everyone else.
7. Poor Plot And Storytelling Elements
There was something in Diablo III’s storytelling that seemed rather lazy and uninspired, especially for a game series that boats such a rich and detailed in-game universe like Diablo. Apart from the aforementioned killing of a beloved central character, the story in D3 was too reminiscent of World of Warcraft, in that it featured more ‘fetch quests’ and uninteresting story lines.
Adria became a central character by Act II, yet it was obvious that she had ulterior motives. Azmodan was considered Hell’s greatest general, yet he was always telling you what he was going to do next. Finally, the quest structures for the first three acts saw a lot of build-up and terrible pay-offs (e.g. you spend so much time resurrecting Zolton Kulle, only to kill him shortly thereafter).
Thus, the next Diablo game should have a very detailed storyline that doesn't have so many plot weaknesses, repetitive quests or illogical character developments (Azmodan is a prime example of this failure). Considering how Reaper of Souls ended, Blizzard has a myriad of different directions they can go in, and as long as they build Diablo IV's storyline more carefully and with better pacing (i.e. don't kill off a major character and delay that murderer's death until the second act), they can pull off a better game all round.
Oh, and it would also help if they stopped the trend of making Act II the longest and most boring part of the game.
6. Ridiculously Imbalanced Monster And Mob Ability Mechanics
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S8u5JwA-lE0Diablo II was simple in its monster mob mechanics. Each time players encountered a unique enemy (a random monster with minions and a special characteristic), it would be one of the following: Fire/Cold/Lightning Enchanted, Spectral Hit (combo of Fire, Cold and Lightning), Extra Strong/Fast, Aura Enchanted, Cursed Stone Skin, Knockback or Mana Burn.
In Diablo three, they took these possibilities and amplified them to never-before-seen levels of difficulty: Fire/Cold/Lightning/Arcane Enchanted, Plagued, Jailer, Reflect Damage, Shielding, Waller, Wormhole, Vortex, Thunderstorm, Frozen Pulse, Extra Health, Desecrator, and the worst of all, Invulnerable Minions.
Many of these abilities provide players with a frustrating gaming experience instead of a challenging boss to fight. Even some of the most skilled players would often end up being murdered by a mob of enemies with those combinations, especially when they had combinations such as Jailer/Horde/Invulnerable Minions/Vortex. These ability combinations were so imbalanced that even the most skilled players would get killed quite easily, whether in single or multiplayer.
The next Diablo game should have much less absurd monster abilities. Though many of Diablo III's current abilities are fine on their own, certain combinations shouldn't be added to future games. In particular, Blizzard should remove any abilities that hinder a player to fight bosses by themselves (i.e. Waller for ranged characters). That way, even on higher difficulties, single player characters won't keep running into monsters that completely hinder their ability to do damage.
5. The Music Was Nowhere Near As Good As In Previous Games
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AoTDngh-d2EBoth Diablo and Diablo II were more than just hack-and-slash RPGs; they were very dark games that featured genuinely nerve-wracking and eerie ambience. Both games’ scores did more than make you excited about playing a game; they really pushed the idea of a bleak, demon-infested world where you were the only hope of salvation.
There are some players who enjoy a game for the background and the sense of fear or atmosphere just as much as the actual gameplay, which was sorely lacking in Diablo III. For an ideal comparison, let’s look at the opening themes to each game. Both Diablo I and II had ominous, low, eerie music that emphasised the ‘evil’ elements of the game; whereas III featured a more ‘epic’ score that was more about battling and less about the struggle of good vs. evil in the game’s universe.
Without the work of maestro Matt Uelman, music-wise Diablo III fell flat. The score lacked depth of different sounds that made each act identifiable and dungeons didn’t feel scary, even though that’s supposed to be the point of a single player wandering in the dark to fight evil. If the musical score for Diablo IV were to be composed by Mr. Uelman, it's guaranteed that it would be much closer to the original, dark atmosphere that made Diablo famous.
That alone will be incentive enough for some former fans to return to the franchise.
4. No More Map Randomization
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XzME2Yw-yOEBoth Diablo and Diablo II used a Havok game engine to create almost completely random dungeon maps when players began. Though a select few locations always had the same format, these were usually reserved for towns, small dungeons or boss fights. The major wilderness was vast, and players spent a lot of time exploring, looking for the location needed to complete their quests.
In Diablo III, however, Blizzard used their own game engine, and so most of the maps followed the same generic structure and rarely brought anything new to the direction that players had to follow.
For example, during the final part of Act III in Diablo III, the players had to go through the ‘Sin Hearts’, a tower with multiple levels going through Hell. The only thing that really changes are which kinds of monsters will appear on which levels; everything else, general direction, waypoints, story points, are all in the same locations. Thus, the whole notion of Diablo III being a repetitive game gets taken up a notch.
This made the entire process of completing quests predictable and repetitive, which really hurt the game’s replayability factor. A big part of the enjoyment in Diablo I and II was the randomness, a feature which will have to be reintroduced in Diablo IV. Forget Blizzard's own engine; the Havok engine of Diablo III's predecessors was a much better feature that made the exploration aspect so much more worthwhile, even if it did take longer.
3. Bring Back The Dark Graphics And Atmosphere
The Diablo franchise is part of the ‘dark fantasy’ genre. However, part three threw this categorisation out the window when Blizzard removed many of the ‘dark’ background elements. Basically, Diablo III’s graphics became too much like those of the Warcraft family, thereby being completely out of touch with the first two games.
There are many reasons to support this claim. First, Diablo III was the first game that didn’t feature the ‘light radius’ concept. This small-yet-crucial detail made exploring dungeons more realistic, as the player couldn’t see beyond their own line of sight, which meant more surprises as you journeyed further in.
Secondly, in the earlier games day, night, sunshine and rain were randomised features, changing how the player explored. In contrast, Diablo III had several locations with set weather features. These tiny weather and time-of-day elements were essential to adding to the ambiance during a quest.
Finally, the background art was more cartoon-like and lacked any true gore or detail that made the game about fighting demons. In Diablo II, for example, you found dead bodies, pentagrams, trails of blood and other such details that made the evil atmosphere come alive around you. Even though Diablo III had some of these details, the graphics were done in such a way that they didn’t add to the atmosphere whatsoever.
This is a critical aspect of the franchise that needs to return to the next Diablo game. It needs to feel dark, and that can only be achieved with the same colour palette, traditional lighting system (and light radius), grittier graphics and background details. Diablo needs to feel like its own game, not like a darker version of the Warcraft franchise.
2. The Auction House
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hx99RjlvGx8The Auction House was an online market in which players could bid on and purchase other people’s items, with Blizzard receiving a portion of players' payments. This feature was available using both in-game money and real currency. In other words, on top of paying for the actual game, you had players with deep pockets who simply bought the best gear.
These mechanics soon expanded to encompass virtually everything in the Diablo III universe: weapons, armor, crafting recipes, dyes, and even gems could be bought and sold on the Auction House, which completely ruined the point of actually playing the game, exploring dungeons, and searching for loot in the first place.
This led to outlandish charges and unbelievable bidding wars on items. Since there wasn’t any kind of moderating authority to monitor player behaviour, players could charge virtually anything, with a cap of 999,999,999,999 of in-game gold, and US $250.00 for any single item.
Although Blizzard removed the Auction House just before the release of the expansion, the damage was done: gaming fans everywhere saw through their attempt to milk their fans of their money, which led to Diablo III becoming an even bigger embarrassment.
No matter how strong the temptation might be to re-introduce the Auction House (because Blizzard must've made a hefty profit off of that part of the game), it should never, ever be done again. Because nothing kills the motivation to go explore and hunt for loot than buying the same object that someone else did all the hard work for.
Diablo should be about enjoying the hack-and-slash experience first and foremost, not using clever EULA manipulation to get more money out of longtime fans.
1. Constant Internet Connection Required
Though multiplayer gaming always has its benefits (and faults), almost every gamer out there loves to, from time to time, play by themselves, disconnected from the rest of the world. Unfortunately, Blizzard completely threw away that option, as Diablo III required players to be online all the time, including for the private, single-player experience.
This was a crippling blow to the game’s reputation, and naturally, this had a snowballing effect on the game’s servers. Since people couldn’t enjoy the game without being connected, Blizzard's servers crashed constantly over the first few days of the game being live. It was such a persistent problem that it dominated Diablo III’s media coverage, the term ‘Error 3007’ becoming an in-joke of its own.
Even after Reaper of Souls, if you want to play Diablo III by yourself, that means having a constant and strong connection; otherwise you can expect significant lag and errors. And God help you if Blizzard needs to update the game; all the servers shut down, and you'll find it very cumbersome to get back online.
That is why, when Blizzard makes Diablo IV game, it will need to have the same old sandbox single player mode that does not require an internet connection, like Diablo I and II. There have been too many spectacular failures on Blizzard's part when it came to managing servers and update issues, and hopefully they've learned from their mistakes to not repeat them in the next instalment.