Dying Light 2: 10 Crucial Things It Must Improve
How to make killing athletic zombies even MORE fun.
2015's Dying Light flew under the radar, for the most part. Written off as yet another zombie game in a year saturated with such brilliant titles as The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, Fallout 4, and Batman: Arkham Knight, Dying Light's run was largely unremarkable. Which is a shame, because it is one of the most lovingly crafted games in recently memory.
Dying Light included two huge open-world maps, consistently added free DLC, developed one of the most expansive paid DLC offerings ever, and featured an incredibly addicting online multiplayer mode, to say nothing of the stellar combat, traversal, and setting.
It came as a bit of a shock when a sequel was announced at the 2018 E3. Dying Light 2 looks like an incredibly ambitious title, featuring branching choice narratives and faction warfare. All of this sounds like a recipe for a truly incredible game that finally gets its due.
However, the original game had its own set of flaws, all of which should be addressed to make it the fully realised masterpiece that it definitely has the potential to be.
- MINOR SPOILERS ahead -
10. Rework Weapon Degradation
Weapon degradation has largely been a blight upon games. Notably, it's considered almost universally to be the one thing keeping The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild from being an absolute masterpiece. While it does add to a game's "realism," it does subtract from the fun.
Dying Light also suffered from this. Players would find an incredible weapon capable of slaughtering hordes of zombies, only to stick it in their inventory and forget about it, forever to be used "later." This is because every single weapon in the game came with a preset number of fixes. Once those were used up, the weapon was a pile of scrap metal.
This also had the added downfall of discouraging players from modifying their weapons. Why spend all the materials and money needed to make an electric katana when it will become unusable in a few hours?
One fix is to combine systems from the previous game with something like Witcher 3. Weapons are still given a set number of fixes... in the field. However, weapons can be brought to an in-game specialist and have their fixes reset for a cost. (in-game currency, not microtransactions, don't get any ideas)
This would provide a helpful balance between creating something immersive while maintaining the fun of using, again, an electric freaking katana.
9. Remap The Controller (Or Let Us Do It Ourselves)
A tip for all game designers: do NOT make R1 (RB for Xbox One users) your jump button.
As a result, in Dying Light, all those complex and cool parkour combat combos you can do become incredibly tricky to pull off, due to the fact that the vast majority of actions have been mapped to the four trigger buttons. For example, a flying dropkick requires the player to press R1, then L1 in quick succession, an action which never feels natural.
Traversal can feel downright awkward at times, because it just doesn't feel right using a trigger to perform such a basic and necessary action, especially in a game revolving around parkour movement.
This, probably more more than anything else on this list, is the easiest fix of all. Simply switch the jump button with one of the face buttons. Problem solved.
Failing that, give players the opportunity to map actions themselves.
Additionally, a dedicated button to showing all available weapons and equipment would be hugely beneficial. Dying Light had players awkwardly cycling through, or using a radial menu that only kind of worked, in order to use the weapon they wanted for that situation. This was time spend that would way too often lead to a grisly death.
8. Improve The Main Character
Dying Light's main character Kyle Crane was... fine... in a vacuum. An American government agent assigned to retrieve a data file from a warlord, Crane quickly contracts the zombie virus upon landing in the fictional Middle Eastern country of Harran, and must learn to balance his loyalties between helping citizens and fulfilling his duties. Inevitably, he must prevent the entire country from annihilation.
Very cliched, but it was ok. Except for the extremely glaring issue that it was yet another bland white guy saving a nation of non-white people. Essentially, it served as the textbook definition of the White Savior. It's been done to death, and only gave potential players another reason not to check out that new zombie game.
Luckily, based on the trailer for the sequel, the main characters is probably not Crane anymore, being replaced in favor of a voice actor with a slight accent, perhaps signaling that the new protagonist will at least be a citizen of the country he is trying to save (heavily believed to be in Eastern Europe).
This is already an improvement upon the original, so as long as the writers and the voice actor can give the new guy a little more personality and depth, and be much less whiny, we'll be all set.
We're not expecting Joel and Ellie here.
7. Write A Three-Dimensional Villain
Along with creating a more likeable good guy comes the necessity of making a better bad guy.
Rais, the main antagonist from Dying Light, was a bad guy that did bad things (cue Harley Quinn reference here). He spouted off cliche dialogue occasionally, or tried to act really menacing, and he just came across as a big pile of "meh." Rais was not really a human, merely a caricature of bad traits, like if Saturday morning cartoons had more brutal zombie executions.
Once again, nobody is really expecting Pulitzer Prize award winning writing here for the villain, but a little bit of humanization can go a long way. Perhaps making the antagonist a leader of a rival faction, who clearly cares about their soldiers and other citizens, but is willing to do whatever it takes to protect them, including standing in front of the player.
Suddenly, the bad guy is at least believable. They aren't doing bad things because they can, but because they must if they want to survive with the ones that they care about. It has the added benefit of showing that a zombie apocalypse takes a psychological as well as physical toll.
At the very least, ditch the trope of having the bad guy execute their own soldiers to show just how evil they are. That's just lazy writing.
6. Redo The Game Economy
Easily the most nitpicking entry on this list, it should be addressed nonetheless:
There is virtually no reason for an economy to operate on cash during a zombie apocalypse.
In Dying Light 2, the trailer makes it clear that it's been 15 years since the city fell to the zombie plague. That's enough time for all paper money to become most useful as kindling.
One suggestion is to use a bartering system (with potential upgrades acting as perks), where each item is assigned an arbitrary value. When the value of the items you want to sell is within range of the items you want to buy, a transaction is complete. Items change hands, but no defined currency is exchanged, as would likely be the case should a zombie apocalypse actually break out (probably).
Another suggestion to just wholesale copy-paste Metro's bartering system, which used high quality bullets as currency. With ammunition becoming a scarce commodity, it would surely be of great value, as well as creating a market for lower quality bullets that can be used for shooting. Similar to the Metro series, high quality bullets can also be used in a crisis as actual firepower, although doing so would actively deplete your money.
Whichever system is chosen, or a different one altogether, would really help with immersion into a desperate world.
5. Increase Leveling Speed
Leveling in Dying Light, even when use XP boosters, is an incredibly arduous process.
Because of this, many of the games awesome skills are locked until you reach the end of the story and begin to run out of sidequests. Or, you know, when these awesome skills aren't particularly useful anymore.
Although the addition of New Game Plus did significantly improve this, there's no reason the leveling system should be so restrictive. It's one thing to not get every single skill in the tree until after the story, it's another to not obtain a grappling hook until you're 80% of the way through the main story.
Additionally, the skills need to be better redistributed. Advanced combat mechanics, such as improved damage on a heavy windmill attack, are one thing to only achieve later on, but jump kills, dropkicks, and the aforementioned grappling hook are so important to the flow of the game that it almost feels as though the player should start with those skills at the beginning, if not earning them within the first 10 hours or so.
It says something when the max level is 25, and most players can only expect to achieve this after multiple full playthroughs on New Game Plus. Better get to grinding!
4. Overhaul The Menu
Dying Light's menu system is a pile of hot garbage.
Sure, the map is serviceable enough, even if PS4 users quickly became irritated by the fact that even slightly brushing the touch pad brings up the map. The real mess lies in the inventory and, in particular, the crafting system.
There is little in the way of sorting through the literal hundreds of crafting recipes you'll accumulate through your playthrough, the majority of which you won't even touch. Worst of all, the most popular formula you'll use in the game (creating medkits, because zombies are dangerous and there's minimal auto-healing) was left near the very bottom. While, yes, crafting didn't happen in real time life it did in The Last of Us, it still gets incredibly tedious.
The inventory also suffers from simply being a giant list, but less so, as you can only hold a certain number of weapons and equipment items at a time. Even this feels awkward, with swapping weapons out of your backpack into your inventory does feel clunky, especially as the weapons are not sorted very well, with a custom painted machete that's also on fire somehow being placed between two broken gas pipes you picked up on accident.
Creating a cohesive menu can be hard, but at least it can't get any worse. (Right?)
3. Better Voice Actors
It is admirable that Techland attempted to have Middle Eastern characters inflect an accent to represent their country of origin, but the result was that so many ended up sounding... Australian?
Honestly, better voice actors is not the only solution to his problem. Considering that Dying Light 2 is believed to take place in an Eastern European country, and Techland itself is based in Poland, it shouldn't be too difficult to find some actors that can do whichever accent is chosen some justice. Or, at the very least, completely throwing the accents out, and just remove a small bit of logic from the decapitating zombies game.
Of course, spending a little more money on the main characters would build quite a bit of goodwill. Kyle Crane was supposed to be a compassionate soldier, but often came off as whiny and entitled. Rais, a literal warlord, had some truly unintentionally comical lines, and at one point screams the hero's name like he just finished his transition into Darth Vader (he DID just lose his hand, so it kind of fits?).
What we definitely don't want is some terrible, Metro-esque, accents that detract from the experience instead of adding to the immersion.
2. Revamp Stealth
It's hard to definitively state whether or not Dying Light actually had a stealth system. Outside of staying out of vision cones (only featured on the map) and using a fun but hilariously overpowered camouflage system, stealth was almost non-existent.
This should be introduced as a potential option for players. Firecrackers could be used as a diversion in Dying Light, but were largely inconsistent in execution. While the potential for murdering your way through a room packed to the rafters with zombies should be an option, players should also be given a chance to completely avoid this altogether, perhaps by some careful sneaking, using noise distractions, or finding an alternate route. This way a player is never forced into either a combat or stealth situation, and can play to their own strengths. Which downside is worse at the moment: the chance of dying or not gaining XP?
There were a few too many quests in Dying Light that locked players in an unclimbable room, then filled said room with wave after wave of biters. This takes away the freedom of choice, and makes the game less enjoyable. In games like Far Cry 5, players were given a vast open world, and multiple ways to explore and destroy it.
Something similar here could really crank up the quality.
1. More Intuitive Combat
This is probably the entry that would require the most amount of effort on behalf of the developers.
Combat in Dying Light, while fun, was often wildly inconsistent. Sometimes zombies would go down in one hit, other times it would take multiple shots to the head with a weapon. The bow and arrow was worse, as it was not uncommon to see a zombie with 4 arrows in its head still ambling around as if nothing had changed.
This could be much improved, however, with more intuitive, targeted combat. The original dabbled in this, but it felt more luck based than anything. Essentially, where you aim at a zombie matters more. Shots to the legs slow them down, hits to the arm prevent them from grabbing you, and strikes to the head do the most damage, but also have an added mechanic where your weapon may take longer to remove, and therefore leave you more exposed.
Doing this would an extra layer to a relatively simplistic combat system. Suddenly, players must think more strategically, adding to the tension that made the original so great. Added in with targeted kicks, and the entire system feels much richer and more robust, providing a better experience overall.
Because at the end of the day, that's why we're all here: to kill some f&*#ing zombies.