Harry Potter: Wizards Unite Review: 7 Ups & 4 Downs

You're a wizard! (Just don't get hit by a car)...

Hp Wizards Unite Hero
Niantic

You're a wizard/witch, 'Arry and the Wizarding World wants to welcome you back again.

Wizards Unite has now been out for a couple of days (after a confident early release, in fact) and there's a new pretender to Pokemon Go's throne as the most popular location-based augmented reality game. Not a very nice mouthful that, so it's no surprise that everyone's calling it the Harry Potter Pokemon Go game.

Therein lies a bit of a problem for Wizards Unite, because that's a mighty benchmark to aim at and even with the behemoth Wizarding World fanbase behind it and likely to respond very enthusiastically, this really isn't the open goal it might seem. The game is a great addition to the marketplace, but it's not perfect and it's important to look at both sides of the coin.

First, the positives...

Ups

7. The Graphics

Harry Potter Wizards Unite
Niantic

While there have been some complaints that the graphics here are a little "early Playstation Harry Potter games," such accusations are ridiculous. The game is beautifully designed and wonderfully observed.

The likenesses on established characters are great, the rendering of familiar Wizarding World elements is equally impressive and all of the new things fans of the movie won't have seen (even when we've had some knowledge of them existing) are totally in keeping with the aesthetic and magic of this world.

In short, it looks exactly as you'd want it to.


6. The Story

Wizards Unite Phoenix
Niantic

The decision to lean into story as a means to overcome the learning curve here is a smart one, because the story is actually very well conceived. Sure, it's obviously geared towards explaining the Foundables element in a way that allows for characters from the original series, artefacts and elements to be scatted across the world in a slightly contrived way, but it works.

The central mystery of the Calamity is also a nice replacement for a general Death Eaters/Voldemort story (even if it's somewhat inevitable - and wholly welcome) that they'll explore that sooner or later. In short, it's a clever way to keep you engaged even beyond just exploring and collecting, because it's an invitation to uncover another Harry Potter story.

Quite how long they'll be able to spin the same mystery remains to be seen, BUT there is a lot of potential here for the entire narrative make-up of the game to organically shift into new chapters and whole new stories if this one loses its appeal or reaches a natural end.


5. The Create-A-Wizard Function

Wizards Unite Create A Wizard
Niantic

If you're a dyed-in-the-wool Potter fan, you've already dressed up. It might not have been in public, but there's a very big chance you've put robes on, or even just glasses and drawn on a scar and proclaimed yourself a wizard or witch. It's just part and parcel of the fandom.

There's also a HUGE community of social media users who hungrily eat up any opportunity to play around with filters (and not just the ones that shave pounds off your chin and tune you up from being a 4/10 to a solid, slightly out-of-focus 7). So having a built-in wizard dress-up filter to change your profile picture - or simply to play around with endlessly saving pictures to see if you really would suit a beard is great fun.

And more generally, it's only a single part of a customisation and personalisation mechanic that makes you feel like an important part of this world. From choosing your House through to deciding on a profession (and progressing through training and skills in exchange for collectibles), there's lots of elements you can play around with.


4. The New Lore Elements

Wizards Unite Flipendo
Niantic

Every time JK Rowling deems it necessary to tell us how wizards poop or the length of every Death Eater's penis or something, eyes are rolled across the world. But the key thing to remember, even when people feign fury at such things, is that Harry Potter fans lap that sort of new information up like its Bertie Botts Every Flavour Beans.

Speaking from personal experience, new Wizarding World lore is a great thing. It's why there remains so much goodwill towards the Fantastic Beasts franchise and Pottermore despite them being far from flawless. It's also why The Cursed Child continues to sell tickets the way it does.

So to have new things (not least Confoundables and Foundables) and new characters introduced to a world so well lived in is a huge selling point. Plus, the likelihood of more lore expansions through narrative changes, bolt-ons and events is even more exciting.


3. Portkeys

Portkey WU
Niantic

Because Pokemon Go was the innovator in this model, Wizards Unite had some pressure to add in its own "second generation" innovations and easily the most clever and best-worked is the Portkey function. In place of Pokemon Go's eggs, portkeys can be collected, combined with keys to open them (gotta add another level of gamification there, kids) and then opened by travelling the required distance.

The reward isn't then simply another collectible: rather elegantly, a portkey transports the user to a magical location from within the Wizarding World. A portal opens and you're thrust into a part of the universe you've grown up loving, as if it's part of the real world.

Not only is it a nice spin on the "walk to open" function, but it also dials into the need of most Potter fans to have some hint of that magical world's existence.


2. The Old Comforting Familiarity

Harry Potter Wizards Unite Hagrid
Niantic

There's a reason the Harry Potter fandom made this game an absolute slamdunk opportunity for the developers: as a community, they're about the most voracious of all fandoms. You bring out something that extends the Wizarding World and it will get as much attention as the nonsense additions to the universe's lore that JK Rowling keeps needlessly peddling.

And while it was important that we got some new stuff, the more crucial agenda for Wizards Unite was delivering on the familiar. And they have managed it with aplomb. Yes, the characters are older (apart from the strangely everygreen teachers, for some reason) but it's still the likes of Harry Potter and Hagrid and Hermione Granger.

And best of all, as you're walking around, the simply wonderful soundtrack from the movies is your constant companion. It's like being actively within the Wizarding World and it's enough to make even the most cynical of fans lose their minds in glee.


1. The Concept Is Still Great

Harry Potter Wizards Unite
Niantic

Look, anything that gets kids (and also lazy online journalists whose idea of sport is playing 5-a-side once a month and then complaining for three weeks about the aching results) out and active is not a bad thing. Pokemon Go was a revelation in that respect.

Wizards Unite is a similarly welcome addition to the marketplace and it's one that arguably has an even bigger fanbase to appeal to, which means more KMs walked, more calories burned and more activity in general.

And now on to the negatives...


Downs

4. Having To Log-In Using Facebook/Google

Wizards Unite
Niantic

Why is this necessary? Why can't fans simply set up an account within the game itself and not have to link up to social as a mandatory element?

Obviously, the developers want an in-built mechanic that helps advertise the game - this is mobile gaming, after all - but being forced to tie to either one of these accounts feels outdated and unnecessary. Without any sort of justification built into the game, it also adds a slightly ominous feel. Ignorance in a vacuum, after all, is an awfully fertile breeding ground for suspicion.

A third option of just setting up an account and linking to an existing phone number or email address (if ENTIRELY necessary) needs to be added.


3. You'll Burn Through Spell Energy WAY Too Quickly

Gringotts Wizards Unite
Niantic

And it feels rather cynically geared towards making you spend your coins and then buying more as you go along. You might be able to level up pretty quickly initially - which is always key for getting over any learning curve - but if you find yourself in a particularly densely populated area for collectibles, you'll find yourself repeatedly out of juice.

There's nothing quite as frustrating as picking up a Foundable and discovering something neat from the Wizarding World that you want to interact with and then not having any spell energy.

At that point, you'll be invited to drop 100 coins on 50 magical energy, which - in the grand scheme of things - is not an awful lot. By that point you may have 100 coins, but you'll realise quickly that the game consciously makes it difficult to mine lots of coins or energy quickly. And that's fine, because it means you'll hit the road more, but being invited to buy coins becomes quickly frustrating.

When 120,000 coins costs £100, people will burn through too much money if they're allowed and it's a little cynical, particularly when it will appeal to younger players. YES, it's optional, but it's also irresponsible that have that level of in-game purchasing and that much potential to burn through the thing you'd likely buy most of.


2. If You Live In A Remote Area, You're Screwed

Wizards Unite Dead
Niantic

No matter how keen you are to be active in this game, if you happen to have lost the Wizards Unite postcode lottery, you're sh*t out of luck, my friends.

While some areas like major public parks are littered with lovely rewarding collectibles every few steps, other areas will inevitably be barren. Look on social media already and you'll see people decrying their lack of opportunities to get Foundables and lagging behind in the XP stakes.

Obviously, the game HAS to have some set hot zones, but it's still a frustration that there hasn't been some consideration to working on a level playing field for EVERYONE. Which is exactly what someone who lives somewhere barren would say. I should know, because I do.


1. The Spells Element Is A Little Limited

Wizards Unite Spell
Niantic

The Pokeball element in Pokemon Go was always fairly rudimentary, but it fit with Pokemon lore. The biggest problem for Wizards Unite is the spell casting play element, because it has nothing to do with the magic and spell casting complexity of the books or movies.

Tracing your finger over different shapes is fairly limited, unfortunately (particularly when it's surprisingly hard to do even the more simple ones above a "Good" rating) and it feels like a massive missed opportunity not to give players the chance to choose their own spells at the very least.

Nobody is advocating for phone swishing to reflect wand work, but even that would have been more welcome.

What do you think of Harry Potter: Wizards Unite? Share your reactions below.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.