Mass Effect 5 Wishlist: 10 Major Risks Bioware MUST Take
Bringing back the finest sci-fi franchise of all.
BioWare seems to be on its knees right now, but all it will take is one great game to get them back on top. After Andromeda and Anthem both flopped, the developers need to claw back some credibility, and fast.
Dragon Age 4 is apparently next on the cards, but that is slightly insulated from blowback due to Dragon Age: Inquisition being BioWare’s last great game. Fans are a little concerned, certainly, but Mass Effect is the title which really feels in danger.
If BioWare is brave enough to go again, they’ll have to take some major risks.
Neither Andromeda nor Anthem were irredeemable, but in a world where games are either great or terrible, both games had enough wrong with them to land on the scrap heap. Anthem had far too many dull spots, including a ridiculous midgame grind to stretch things out, and literally set consoles on fire.
Likewise, Andromeda’s buggy facial animations made it an internet laughing stock. It’s actually fun in places, although the uninspired story didn’t help and the characters were short of the original trilogy’s quality. Hopefully the fifth will right those wrongs.
10. No Live Service Model
This one perhaps feels like less of a risk than it is a no brainer.
However, games as a service models are definitely here to stay, and publishers EA know that when they get it right, they can make a lot of money. One of the first questions EA allegedly asks of their new games is ‘where’s your Ultimate Team’ and the truth is, Mass Effect doesn’t really have one.
It’s a single player game which doesn’t really have much in the way of loot drops or cosmetics, and that’s how it needs to stay. If they end up making squadmate skins purchasable, that’s not going to cause any issues, but that seems a bit meh, really.
Online mode in Mass Effect 3 was surprisingly solid, while bugs put paid to Andromeda’s before it ever really had a chance. Live service for an ME3 level online mode wouldn’t be too bad either, but at its core Mass Effect is a solo player experience.
DLC at the quality of Lair Of The Shadow Broker or Citdael would be a good use of monetisation, but locking a key squadmate like Javik behind a paywall or cutting content like Quarians for DLC would only generate more controversy.
9. Anthem’s Flying
The players, the developers and everyone else connected to BioWare may want to seal Anthem in a vault (and throw the vault into the sun), but it needn’t be all doom and gloom.
The flying in the game was spectacular, and surely needs to be salvaged even if Anthem never sees the light of day again.
There’s certainly improvements to be made. The overheating system could probably be done away with all together, but if not needs to work much slower so as not to roadblock your fun unnecessarily.
The ease with which you can completely miss huge sections of the map needs tweaking too, but that might be more to do with how empty Anthem felt and forcing you to return to base after each mission.
At its heart though, the flying was a blast, offering a unique experience and standing head and shoulders above everything else as the best thing in Anthem. Borrowing anything from that game will surely be a risk, considering the bridges (and consoles) burned.
It definitely fits Mass Effect’s aesthetic, and it would be a real shame to see it disappear.
8. Andromeda’s Combat Mechanics
Though perhaps slightly less so than Anthem, Mass Effect: Andromeda still represents scorched earth for BioWare. As such, incorporating anything from the game marks a bit of a risk, despite it being part of the same franchise.
A hard reset is probably what’s needed (more on that later), but baby and bathwater and all that. Mass Effect’s shooting mechanics had been increasing in quality through the original trilogy, and Andromeda was a surprising continuation of that.
With both the range of powers on offer and the gunplay itself, Andromeda offered a tight shooter experience, even if the rest of the game lacked that sense of polish.
One of the best aspects though was the ability to switch between ability classes, even mixing and matching.
Mass Effect has always had Combat for by the numbers shooting, Biotic for the energy pulses and Engineer for more technical abilities. You could go for pure focus or split between two at the start of the game, but Andromeda allowed you to either switch between or combine all three consistently throughout the game.
This and the possibility to choose between whichever individual powers you want needs to stick around.
7. Ditch Frostbite
Various stories persist regarding BioWare’s continued use of Frostbite. Some claim it is BioWare’s preferred engine, drawbacks be damned, while others feel they’re simply giving into EA pressure. Certainly though, moving forward they need to ditch it.
It’s not too dissimilar to confusion over BioWare making a live service, always online shooter in Anthem, while fellow EA subsidiary Respawn move forward with an open world RPG. Surely it makes sense to switch those around, but the official story is that both development teams chose their projects of their own volition.
Frostbite was built by DICE, and has since become EA’s property, and therefore is the go to for any developer under their umbrella. The problem is, it just isn’t flexible. It was designed to be used in DICE’s FPS games, and never factored in issues which might arise in other genres.
Frostbite can be gorgeous. Despite facial animations being meme fodder, isolated screenshots of Andromeda are beautiful.
As far back as Dragon Age Inquisition, BioWare have struggled with Frostbite’s features. The engine has no built in tools for codex entries or inventory. And it’s being used in an RPG... why?
It’s cheaper. But as a flagship, Mass Effect is worth pushing the boat out.
6. Don’t Go Human-Centric
Despite Mass Effect stretching far and wide across the galaxy, the game has always been very Human-centric. It’s not just about you playing as a Human (though there’s more on that coming up), but the whole focus of the game in general.
Human squadmates outnumber the other species so much that there’s almost more Humans than every other species combined. There’s also The Illusive Man, Anderson, the creepy kid whose ghost guides you to the final choice... and being part of the Human ark in Andromeda only made things worse.
There’s so many rich stories in the universe, and through say, Tali’s side missions, we get to see what life is like for the Quarians. Even though the original trilogy is really well put together, these tales of other species felt like we were just dipping our toes in the water. Far too much revolved around Earth and humanity.
Initially, there’s more relatability with Humans than aliens, so you can understand the decision.
Four games in though, it needs freshening up. For exactly how to do that, one way offers a very quick fix...
5. Playable Races
This one shouldn’t really be a risk, given it’s a highly requested feature (far and away the most requested, in fact) and already works in Mass Effect’s sister game, Dragon Age. However, given that Mass Effect has always factored in your humanity as part of some major plot points, offering up more options feels like a bit of a risk.
It’s the best kind of risk, though. Implementing this feature gives them an instant win, and as long as it’s planned from the start, any negative effects can be easily mitigated.
Asari, Turian and Quarian squadmates are always popular, so you feel like those three are dead certs, with question marks over some of the others.
Dragon Age allows for four, with Human, Elf, Dwarf and Qunari, so that doesn’t feel beyond Mass Effect’s capabilities. Other games offer far more (Skyrim, for example), but there it’s all about character abilities and perks, with less emphasis on the personal stories that come with each race.
Mass Effect has allowed players to be different races previously, though only online. Having it in fully fledged single player would wash away the funk from Andromeda.
4. Paragon & Renegade
Paragon & Renegade is a staple of Mass Effect. You can criticise it, sure, but it is unmistakably a huge part of the game. It needs to stay.
The arguments against Paragon & Renegade are that it can be a bit of a restrictive system. As you get points for leaning one way or the other, it's difficult to have a fully balanced playthrough.
For example, being middle of the road in ME2 means picking between Jack & Miranda, as well as Tali & Legion for loyalty, which also puts romantic options at risk. A full scale Paragon or Renegade can keep them all, but play safe and you miss out.
This system means you might not be fully getting into the whole 'role play' part of an RPG. The complete lack of Paragon & Renegade's importance to the trilogy's ending came in for criticism too.
Andromeda ditched it for a personality response system, where you could be logical, emotional, etc. That was just Dragon Age's with some new paint though, and felt completely out of place. Returning to Paragon and Renegade won't be a backwards step, but instead a course correction.
3. New Races
For all the complaints about Mass Effect Andromeda, this was probably the most egregious oversight.
The big appeal for the game was that it was a fresh start, with a new galaxy to explore, but Mass Effect just didn’t take advantage.
Despite the huge range of species in the original trilogy, Andromeda served up just one new species in the Angara. Yes, they were different in both design and personality to anything we’d seen previously, but just one is far too paltry.
Even the uninspired enemies were just evil versions of the Angara, or killer robots that weren’t too far removed from mini Reapers.
Whatever Mass Effect does with the fifth game, you have to think that introducing new blood is on the priority list. Certainly there’s more to learn about the existing species, but for truly new discoveries, we probably need more Angara style introductions.
Timeline and location plays a big part in how easy that will be, but again, if planned from the start, this feature wouldn’t cause too much of an issue.
2. Develop Old Races
While there definitely needs to be some fresh faces, BioWare also needs to risk turning their backs on old favourites to give some lesser known species a run out. Mass Effect has room to explore more on the Quarians, Asari, Turians and even the Geth, but they really need to look elsewhere for a truly original take on the series.
Throughout the four games so far, we’ve met three Drell; Thane and his son, plus Liara's assistant in Lair Of The Shadow Broker. That's one squadmate, his relative who's in at most three scenes, and a minor character in one scene of a DLC. By some species' standards though, having a squadmate makes the Drell the stars of the show.
As another example, can you name a Hanar who isn't Blasto?
There are a few of them scattered around, but they're mainly used for jokes. Ditto the Elcor and Volus. That was fine in the early games, when everyone was still being established. The little moments of humour were and under appreciated part of what made Mass Effect great.
Now though, the joke's over. Those species, plus the likes of the Vorcha, the Batarians and even the Yahg need some spotlight.
1. A Completely New Era
Andromeda at least tried to get this one right. Even without the controversial ending, the original trilogy had a sense of finality to it. Now though, anything in Shepard’s vicinity feels like scorched earth.
Whether Mass Effect 5 goes way into the future or heads into the past depends on how many of the key features it can get in there. The First Contact War has been touted before, but this lacks the sweeping scale of the games and again becomes Human centric. With a good story, it could work, but it’s far from the only option.
Going even further back changes the complexion of the galaxy, lowering the influence of Humans and raising the stakes of now minor races. It makes it harder to introduce new species, but remains a viable option.
Way into the future could dredge the ending fiasco back up.
Andromeda went to another galaxy to get away from that, but Mass Effect can’t really expect to pull off the same trick twice. A new setting or period way in the future means an entirely new piece of world building though, in exchange for making a fresh start.
Whatever they do, it provides quite a risk, but also a massive opportunity.