Ranking EVERY SoulsBorne Game From Worst To Best
Is Sekiro their best work to date?
The Soulsborne term is not an official moniker, but a fan-created name for the recent run of action games created by FromSoftware, which have been creating ripples in the games industry for the last decade.
Sure, there's a very loose connection of lore subtly linking the games with one another, but what's more telling as a common trait is third-person gameplay and controller-smashing difficulty.
These games are tough. Really, really damn tough.
Therein lies the main hook; an old-school level of challenge, accompanied by a relentlessly obtuse take on storytelling. Yet, with those large obstacles, comes the adrenaline-fuelled thrill of victory for those that persevere.
When FromSoft launched Demon's Souls in 2009, it was a refreshing experience in an era where games held your hand from the get-go. Since then, the team has pushed forward to massive success, iterating and evolving that original formula.
The latest example, Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, shakes everything up more than ever, becoming a radical subversion of the blueprint, while also an acknowledged expansion too. It's both a Soulsborne game, but also something altogether more action-focused.
If that sounds abstract, it goes with the territory. Nothing is easy with this franchise, but let's see how this new challenger ranks with his granite-strong brethren.
6. Dark Souls 2
Dark Souls 2 is the clear-cut runt of the litter when it comes to Soulsborne games. It's hardly a bad game - in fact, it's a pretty decent one - but messy level design, generic lore and unimaginative bosses really make this entry shrivel in the shadow of its peers.
With series overseer Hidetaka Miyazaki absent as game director, his personal touch is evidently missing, with this feeling more like a rushed production made by committee, then a passion project helmed by the Soulsborne guru.
Still, PvP was a great step forward, and the revamped version, Scholar Of The First Sin, did a decent job of improving on the original's flaws. Yet, that was more a case of glossing over potholes than an overall ground-up revamp that makes the entry recommendable no matter what.
Despite the negatives, Dark Souls 2 still manages to be a decent time, but also a highly forgettable and inferior one compared to other titles that carry the Soulsborne badge of honour.
5. Demon's Souls
This dread-filled and taxing cult classic started the whole Soulsborne craze - but how does the title hold up ten years later?
Unfortunately, Demon's definitely shows its age.
With rigid controls, buggy design and a handful of flawed mechanics that thankfully did not make a return in later entries, at present this early title feels like a rough-edged launching pad for the revered Dark Souls, rather than a milestone in its own right.
Still, there’s no denying it contains an incredible atmosphere that has rarely been equalled. The haunting world of Boletaria is both tragic, yet frightening, beautifully designed yet chillingly repulsive. Overall, the lore and style make it one of the most distinct across the entire series to this day.
Regardless of its formula being improved and reworked with every Soulsborne, props must be paid to the one that came first. Demon's Souls was a brave, groundbreaking gaming experience.
The cracks are certainly showing, but it more than deserves your respect.
4. Dark Souls 3
After Dark Souls 1 released to much success, many pretenders followed in its wake. It made sense that director Hidetaka Miyazaki would want to make a return to the main series, the mandate being to create the final word on the Soulsborne genre as we knew it.
In the majority he succeeds, especially as a technical experience, with this third instalment polished and refined to a near flawless level. Controls were finally well oiled to twitch-fire responsiveness, and that puts the earlier games to shame.
With advancements acknowledged, Dark Souls 3 was lacking in certain ways. The Soulsborne franchise lived to subvert expectations and turn the safety of modern gaming on its head. The player needed to always be on their toes because who knew what monstrosities lurked around the next corner?
Heck, even the options menu left you a wide-open target.
Dark Souls 3 delivered the most refined version of the series yet, but it lacked that element of danger and tension. Despite notable highs, the unpredictable had finally become expected, and the once so-fresh formula had become overly familiar.
3. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Despite the impressive polish of Dark Souls 3, it was obvious that if Miyazaki were ever to return to the Soulsborne realm, he would need to radically reinvent the genre for it to be fresh again.
With Sekiro, he's done just that... kind of.
Sekiro is a blatant evolution of the formula started with Demon Souls, whilst also breaking free from the well-worn shackles that eventually weighed on the series.
Set in Feudal Japan, Shadows Die Twice's lore is part real-world history, part batsh*t fantasy madness, taking part of its inspiration from the dev's forgotten Tenchu series. That brings with it new additions of resurrection, stealth, a grapple hook and a singular protagonist (plus a coherent campaign told through cutscenes and actual dialogue). One might think this was an attempt to make Soulsborne more accessible, but they'd be dead wrong.
The campaign is packed with rock-hard duels that will test even franchise veteran's grit as it rewrites the rulebook. There is no RPG flexibility, no armour and no chance of summoning. Plus, you better make the parry function your best friend.
Sekiro didn't water things down, but instead trimmed the fat, resulting in an exhilarating experience that's pure muscle and plenty tough to boot. It made the genre new and unpredictable once again - even if it just narrowly misses the high bar of its forebears.
2. Dark Souls
The classic. The milestone. The one that turned the industry right upside down and back again. All true statements to this day - and let's not forget, this game was hard...
Oh, so ludicrously hard.
Yet, its blatant difficulty was only part of what made it memorable. A rich RPG system, exhilarating action and the obtuse but mesmerising lore were all ingredients in an experience that were a very special brew indeed.
It was a refreshing subversion of modern games. The player wasn't the super-powered hero of an open-world sandbox, but a very small fish in an epic pool of sharks. You'd die and fail, but the strong would brush themselves off and try again. With every triumph, the slightest glint of hope to move forward against some absurd odds.
The coarse edges of Demon Souls were smoothed out as it did away with mechanics that grated, while building on strong elements and bettering them. Most noticeably, this came through incredible boss battles and mind-bending level design that has yet to be surpassed.
It is not all perfect though. Controls and movement can be unreliable, and whilst Blighttown's framerate has been saved by the recent remaster, the last third of the game is still an anti-climatic drag.
Overall though, these are minor complaints about an experience that is nothing short of a landmark.
1. Bloodborne
It's common for Soulsborne fans to not be able to agree on anything, so this might be controversial - but personally, the loosely-linked series has never been better than with this horror spin on the genre.
It was controversial due to tossing out more vast customisation options, then forcing the player to go forth in one method and one method only - fast and aggressive.
Yet, this wasn't limiting. Gameplay threw up it is middle-finger and dared you to keep up. If you could, you were rewarded with one hell of a ride.
The switch from dark fantasy to grimy horror pulp was exhilarating and unorthodox; the ghouls were not just tough but down-right repulsive, in turn, feeling near impossible. But once you mastered the quick dodge, and learned the risk/reward scenario of Regain, you would soon be leaping headlong into Lovecraftian monstrosities without a second thought.
Yes, the recent Sekiro was a welcome rework of the Soulsborne formulae, but its subversion bends the game into something almost completely new in itself. Bloodborne walks the perfect line of paying homage to its inspiration, whilst bringing plenty original to the table.
Add to that the best lore, boss battles and world design, and you have a downright masterpiece experience.