Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Ways Rockstar MUST Do Single Player DLC

They're seriously not going to do a Sadie DLC?!

red dead redemption 2 sadie
Rockstar

Red Dead Redemption 2’s online mode was ugly step sister to the story mode when the game first launched. Initially described as a beta, even when fully finished it left a lot to be desired. Since then, there’s been several updates and improvements, but it still feels a way off the calibre of going solo as Arthur Morgan.

More updates are planned though, as Rockstar is relying on Red Dead Redemption 2’s online mode to be the money spinner Grand Theft Auto Online has been. Like Grand Theft Auto V, despite huge sales and critical acclaim for single player, Rockstar have recently confirmed that no solo DLC is planned at all.

It feels like there’s a lot to still be explored, either by breaking out of the canon or delving into some of the side characters.

With the sales figures of GTA and RDR2 plus GTA Online printing literally millions for Rockstar, the possibilities are endless. They could easily produce a DLC to rival Mass Effect’s Citadel Party or The Witcher III’s Blood & Wine, but they seem to want their DLC to be as quick and cost effective as possible.

If they ever change their minds though, Red Dead’s world has a lot of potential.

10. Explain What Happened In Blackwater

Red Dead Redemption 2
Rockstar

Another massive possibility for the third (technically fourth but no one counts Red Dead Revolver) game in the series is that rather than forward with Sadie, they could go backwards, still with Arthur and John. The events of Blackwater inform most of Red Dead Redemption, but we only ever hear about it, and never quite get the full story.

If Rockstar can build the narrative around that and make the Blackwater job the finale, then there’s certainly enough intrigue for it to be an entire game on its own. Knowing the ending to a story makes it infinitely less interesting though, and two prequels in a row going further and further back will start to hit diminishing returns.

All character development from the two current games would be reset again, and while there’s intrigue, there likely isn’t enough content for a full game. As a DLC though, it seems tailor made.

Literally tailor made, in fact.

While Red Dead Redemption 2 hardly lacks for content, it feels like the Blackwater job is being deliberately kept in the shadows, as if to be explored later.

With solo DLC apparently off the table, it feels like a strange move.


9. Undead Nightmare 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 Undead Nightmare
Rockstar/MediaDecided

Undead Nightmare remains one of the most popular DLC packages ever, where John Marston fought off a (strictly non canon) zombie uprising after the main events of Red Dead Redemption but before his untimely death.

Strictly non canon is important, as if we’re going to get to play as Arthur again, Rockstar likely wouldn’t want to mess with the script. With that in mind, why not pay tribute to Undead Nightmare and go non canon in the best possible way, bringing Arthur back from the dead?

The other entries here are more grounded in realism, and by exploring other characters or happening before the ultimate ending, even manage to keep the canon story intact. If you’re going to go weird though, you always need to go really weird. It’s something Rockstar has proved over the years that they understand very well too.

Obviously, it does err a little close to Undead Nightmare, and maybe in this age of prequels, reboots and live action remakes, a microwaved version of a ten year old concept isn’t the best idea. Considering how fresh Red Dead Redemption 2 felt though, surely they’d make it work.


8. Young John & Arthur

Red Dead Redemption John Marston
Rockstar

Quite a lot is made throughout the game of Arthur and John’s relationship as they grew up. As brothers from other mothers (and fathers) they’re the closest family each other have ever known, along with Dutch & Hosea as their paternal influences.

That kind of connection breeds contempt as much as it does love and respect. Toss in their age difference, Arthur’s perceived difference in how the pair are treated plus the poor circumstances which brought them together, and it’s a powder keg. By the end of the game, Arthur grows to see John as his closest friend: his brother.

His resentment towards John is clear to see throughout though, and as a result we get a fairly one sided view of the relationship.

Taking us back through time to a simpler era for the gang with Arthur and John each standing on the border between boys and men could add more context to their adult lives, reframe their relationship and solidify for players just how deep the ties which bind the two cowpokes go.

Of course, taking DLC back in time would mean seeing not just John & Arthur in a new light...


7. Arthur’s New Life

Red Dead Redemption 2 arthur morgan
Rockstar

Of course, if they’re going to go non-canon with it, why not offer a happy ending instead? Not as an alternative to Arthur’s tragic fate - the compelling ending shouldn’t be messed with - but as more of a ‘what if’ scenario.

Whether this be by the gang actually reaching Tahiti or by having Arthur successfully flee the gang are both distinct possibilities. An extra setting may seem like a lot of extra work, but Guarma’s assets could be a stand in for Tahiti, and parts of the main map could be rejigged to trick us into thinking it’s an entirely new area.

It could even just be a timeline where Arthur recovers from his tuberculosis and instead gets to grow old in relative peace in the lands he’s always known. Although Arthur wouldn’t agree, he definitely deserves a happy ending, but all the game really provides him with is a bittersweet one.

Perhaps a DLC can offer us a chance to slip into his shoes again under less tragic circumstances.


6. Charles’ Story

charles red dead
Rockstar

Charles was one of the most noble and stoic members of the gang, always seeing reason rather than following his emotions like the rest of them. He’s the closest kindred spirit to Arthur in that regard, and it’s no accident that he gets increased focus in the epilogue.

However, a little more focus certainly wouldn’t go amiss. Through his connection to the Native American tribes and his greater appreciation for nature, Charles offers us a somewhat unique perspective.

A hugely popular character amongst players, the chance to actually play as Charles would be a massive treat as a DLC. Charles is already in the game with appropriate animations, his story could intertwine with Arthur’s and wouldn’t require a new setting. Everything is there for it to work.

The Native American storyline crashed into Arthur’s as it was reaching its apex, but through Charles we like see it much more thoroughly. Though everyone in the gang is given fair treatment, the wider world would certainly treat someone of Charles’ caste very differently.

With a sequel inevitable (though a long way off), Charles may yet get more spotlight. He’s not the only character whose chance may come later either...


5. Play As The O’Driscolls

red dead redemption 2 kieran
Rockstar

For all Red Dead Redemption 2 has one of the most compelling open worlds and narratives of any game anywhere, there’s a few small parts which cut corners. Most of the tension and character comes from within the gang itself, with the rest of the characters given less focus.

Nowhere is this more noticeable than with the O’Driscolls.

Longtime rivals to the Van der Linde Gang, the O’Driscolls never really elevate themselves above being generic baddies. They’re a plot device to introduce Sadie, and Arthur’s capture is one of many fun set pieces, but they don’t offer all that much in terms of development.

They’re bad guys. The end.

By having Kieran in your ranks, there’s an opportunity to characterise the O’Driscolls a little more. However, it turns out he’s a low level grunt who hates everyone in the O’Driscolls and can’t wait to leave.

The upper echelons would likely remain untouched by DLC in order to keep the narrative solid. Giving us an insight into their gang by playing as ‘their Arthur’ might help flesh them out while keeping them as the main villains in the solo story.


4. Hamish’s Life

Red dead redemption 2 hamish
Rockstar

Hamish Sinclair is one of the most popular side characters in Red Dead Redemption 2, encountered numerous times in The Veteran side quest. He even gives you his trusty horse, Buell, as a parting gift when you complete his storyline.

He’s easily the most suited to a spin off, with his life full of former glories yet grounded in reality. There’s other colourful characters in the game like Marko Dragic or Charles Chatenay, but none that really lead themselves to being a Red Dead protagonist line Hamish.

Possibly the gunslingers, but then surely that would just be a longer version of their own side quest loaded with similar shootouts?

By looking at a younger Hamish, we could get a new perspective on this character and experience things we’d never get to in the core game because of the era. While Hamish is ripe for a spin off, there’s no way he’s going to get a main series game to his own; he’s simply not popular enough. DLC though seems perfect.

Either through listening to Hamish regale you or by reading his diary, we could play as Hamish and actually experience his memories.


3. Micah’s Story

Red Dead Redemption 2 Micah And Arthur
Rockstar

Similar to the O’Driscolls, Micah isn’t the most complex villain the gaming world has ever seen. That doesn’t mean he’s not a great character though. The likes of Lord Voldemort, Ramsay Snow and Emperor Palpatine are all thoroughly irredeemable villains, with limited nuance other than their plans and seemingly bottomless capacity for evil.

Micah isn’t fully on their level, but he is still a great character who manages to get under Arthur’s skin at every chance he gets.

He gives Arthur the thoroughly irritating ‘Black Lung’ nickname which cuts right to the heart of Arthur’s greatest fear: he doesn’t have enough time left to make it all right. He’s a pantomime villain and good at it, but it certainly wouldn’t hurt to flesh him out a little more.

It could focus on him after the main game has concluded but before his death at the end of the epilogue. Alternatively, it could take us back to before the game started, to see through Micah’s eyes before it all went wrong.

Another option would be to have extra Micah missions through the story, to see his resentment towards Arthur grow, his work be overlooked and ultimately what drove him to follow Dutch into the dark.


2. Young Dutch & Hosea

Red Dead Redemption 2 Hosea
Rockstar

With revisiting a young John and Arthur comes a younger Dutch and Hosea too. This might just seem like the same idea as before, but the focus shift makes for a massive difference.

Playing as a young John or Arthur will allow us to see the younger Dutch & Hosea in their prime, yes. With a smaller gang, they’ll likely get a lot more focus than the main game, but through Arthur & John’s lenses, they’d still not get the attention they deserve.

We’d only really see them in fatherhood mode, and we’d miss the private moments between the pair.

Hosea was one of the most beloved characters in the gang, while - unlike Micah - Dutch was a rich and complex villain. Getting to know even more of them could offer up a new and deeper appreciation for the core game.

With Hosea, we can see him (maybe even play as him) at his peak, and see first hand how he tempered Dutch. With Van der Linde himself, we could see the earliest signs of his capacity for self destruction, and learn how crucial Hosea is to his world view.


1. Sadie’s Story

Red Dead Redemption 2 Sadie 2
Rockstar

Assuming Red Dead Redemption 3 will (eventually) be a direct sequel rather than another prequel or a different story entirely, the only character in with more of a shout than Charles is Sadie Adler. She undoubtedly shows the most growth through the game, but her time in the spotlight comes and goes.

Many fans would happily trade in a Sadie Adler DLC if it meant we got a full on Sadie Adler game in a few years. Of course, with all the possibilities still up in the air, wishing for an Adler DLC feels fair game.

Her personal growth is one of the most central character arcs aside from Arthur’s own. However, there’s still a lot of gaps left for us to fill in. A Sadie DLC could happen in tandem with Arthur’s story, or could pick up where her story ends at the game’s close.

Helped no doubt by a lack of comparable female characters within Red Dead Redemption’s universe, Sadie Adler was one of the most evocative characters in the game. A chance to play as her offers even more focus and could solidify her position as one of their greatest creations.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)