Red Dead Redemption 3: 10 Predictions For The Story

Where do Rockstar head next after Red Dead Redemption 2?

Red Dead Redemption 3 Sadie Adler
Rockstar

When the first Red Dead Redemption dropped - all the way back in the bygone era of 2010 - it was instantly hailed as a masterpiece. The story of John Marston's quest for redemption was mature, poignant, and resonant. It hit all the right notes, and set an intimidatingly high watermark for subsequent video game stories to hit.

Then came Red Dead Redemption 2. No one knew for sure what it would be about going in. Sure, there were theories, but no one was certain. Many people thought that the first game's story was perfect, and that it should be in no way, shape, or form expanded upon - be it as a sequel or a prequel.

John Marston's backstory was left vague, with him only mentioning that his gang - then thought to consist solely of himself, Dutch, Bill, and Javier - left him to die after a botched robbery. Who could've predicted that the prequel would surpass its predecessor, letting us play through the tragic redemptive arc of Arthur Morgan, John Marston's quest for liberation, and the fall of Dutch van der Linde simultaneously?

We can only hope that the inevitable next game will rise to the same glorious heights as the first two. But what could the story be?

Some of these predictions will compliment each other, and some won't, but they're all distinct possibilities that merit consideration.

Let's dive in.

10. Jack Marston

Red Dead Redemption Jack Marston
Rockstar Games

The last we saw Jack, he had just exacted his revenge and killed Edgar Ross on a riverbank in Mexico. While it was oh-so satisfying, it represented something truly tragic: Jack just threw away the clean, peaceful life that John - and Arthur - died to give him.

Will Red Dead Redemption 3 be about an adult Jack, potentially in the Prohibition era? Probably not. Don't get me wrong: that'd be amazing. WhatCulture's very own Comics Editor Ewan Paterson has speculated about that very possibility. It's just that at that point, it wouldn't be much of a Western.

But there's this little caveat: Red Dead Redemption 2 was barely a Western, itself.

A hefty portion of the game was set in Lemoyne, which is essentially a stand-in for Louisiana. Traditionally, Louisiana isn't a "Western" location. It's not in the American West, at all - it's in the Deep South. Then you have Roanoke Ridge, which is more reminiscent of Eastern Appalachian states like Kentucky and West Virginia than anything in the west.

Westerns aren't restricted to a certain era. Breaking Bad was technically a Western, after all. It's all about theme, location, and tone. So maybe we COULD see something with Jack in the 1930s, after all.


9. Mac And Davey Callander

Red Dead Redemption 2 Agent Milton
Rockstar

Much like how John Marston's past was only spoken about in the vaguest of terms, the Callander brothers - Mac and Davey - were mentioned in passing more than a couple of times.

That's not a 1:1 comparison, though, as John never gave us a date as to when everything went south with the gang. With the Callander brothers, we know EXACTLY when their stories ended: in West Elizabeth, in 1899. Mac was killed by Andrew Milton in Blackwater, and Davey died en route to Colter as the gang trudged desperately through the snow.

But just because we know how it ended doesn't mean that we won't see them in their prime.

So what do we know about the brothers?

For starters, they were "a vicious pair of bastards", according to Charles Smith. Lenny stated that Davey was "a dangerous fool", and suggests that he may have been a driving force behind the Blackwater job going sideways. Sean noted that they had "fight in them", and Bill declared that they were "heartless", but that they were the kind of guys you'd want to go out robbing with.

Sounds like something worth exploring, especially since they're practically blank slates.


8. Sadie Adler

Red Dead Redemption 2 Sadie Arthur
Rockstar

Sadie Adler was one of the game's standout supporting characters. Players quickly fell in love with this widow-turned-outlaw, and her quest for vengeance - though it arguably brought the gang a disproportionate amount of trouble - was one everyone seemed to get behind.

Sadie got her catharsis with the bastard O'Driscolls toward the end of the main narrative, and then she - along with John and Charles - settled their score with Micah at the end of the epilogue.

If one thing is certain, it's that we won't see a Sadie-centric story set before Red Dead Redemption 2. In those days, she was but a humble rancher, living a quiet life with her loving husband, Jake.

No, anything with Sadie as the protagonist would be set either during her bounty hunter days (post-Van der Linde gang, pre-Micah), or after she left Beecher's Hope.

She mentioned to John that she'd go off and run protection on a gold mine in South America, but who's to say she didn't stop off in Mexico first? Who knows how much time passed between Micah's death and Sadie's departure? A few weeks? Months? Surely enough time to reconsider her future.

We could very well see more of Sadie down the road.


7. Landon Ricketts

red dead redemption landon ricketts
Rockstar

Landon Ricketts was and is one of the most beloved characters in any Rockstar game.

There was just something about him that captured the imagination of players. He's a badass outlaw of legendary proportions. His past is vague and mysterious. John idolized him as a boy, and is immediately awe-struck upon seeing him.

Up until the moment you meet Landon Ricketts in Mexico, you swear that John is an incomparable gunslinger. Then comes this unassuming, mustachioed god among men to show you how it's done. He absolutely schools you, like the greenhorn you are.

Why WOULDN'T fans be clamoring for more of Old Man Ricketts? He's fantastic, and of all the supporting characters introduced in either game, he's the one most deserving of an expanded backstory.

Of course, "deserving" is no guarantor of anything. He's cool, and his past is wide open for a game, but maybe he's more intriguing as a cypher. Maybe his past is better left a myth. His voice actor, Ross Hagen, passed away in 2011, so Rockstar may want to let his legacy rest in peace.

If they DID recast, though, a young Landon Ricketts story could be one hell of a ride.


6. A Whole New Gang/Protagonist

Red Dead Redemption 2 Teaser Poster
Rockstar

Of course, it's distinctly possible that Rockstar will go with a character we've never met, just as they did with Arthur Morgan RDR2. In fact, this is probably the most likely option. There's less baggage that way.

Think about it: we know a LOT about Sadie. We know a LOT about Jack. We know a LOT about Dutch. We don't know much about Landon Ricketts, but we know how and when he dies. We don't know much about Mac and Davey Callander, but they seem more like a couple of roughneck hired guns than compelling protagonists.

Of course, all of this can be circumvented with good writing (of which Rockstar has no shortage), but it might help the player get more invested if the protagonist's past and fate have some degree of mystery around them.

Plus, that would allow Rockstar to completely untether themselves from preexisting lore. Sure, they can tie the third game's story into its predecessor's, and they could do so to great effect. Still, they might want to unbind their hands and give themselves as much creative and narrative freedom as possible.

Start from scratch, so to speak.


5. A New Setting

Saint Denis Red Dead Redemption 2
Rockstar

This is a given.

Yes, we got to revisit some of the original Red Dead Redemption's map, but only in the epilogue. The main story was set 100% in a new location. Gone were the deserts of New Austin, the towering spires of Mexico, and the tall trees of West Elizabeth. In their place, we got the buttes of the Heartlands, the mountains of Ambarino, and the gator-infested swamps of Lemoyne.

It's perfectly reasonable to expect Red Dead Redemption 3 to follow in that tradition, giving us something altogether new and unique. But where?

The game can't go any further east, and it almost certainly won't go any further south. The only choices are north (beyond the Grizzlies), and west (past New Austin and the Redemption Mountains) - maybe even both. We could see cities inspired by Santa Fe, San Francisco, or Deadwood. See our previous list - "Red Dead Redemption 3 - 10 Cities That Could Be On The Map" - for just a handful of the possibilities.

Rockstar could turn us loose to explore landscapes based on the Grand Canyon, Mesa Verde, or the Black Hills.

If anything is guaranteed, it's that we'll be seeing new locales, and that's exciting.


4. The Golden Age Of Outlaws

Red Dead Redemption 2 Valentine Heist
Rockstar

On from the physical setting to the chronological setting.

It seems pretty likely that Red Dead Redemption 3 will follow the trajectory of the franchise thus far and go further back in time.

Here's the exciting thing about that: we'd be broaching a period that's - in essence - the golden age of criminal mischief in the American West. That's not to say that the 1870s to late 1880s were completely lawless, but it's when the West wasn't short on criminal outfits on the prowl.

By the time Red Dead Redemption 2 rolled around, there were really only a handful of notable gangs in New Austin, West Elizabeth, and New Hanover: the Van der Linde gang, the O'Driscolls, and the Del Lobos. Sure, there could've been more, but they were the big ones.

Even if there were others, RDR2 plopped us down in an era when the rapid growth of civilization had lawmen nipping at criminals' heels. It'd be very interesting to see an Old West that's absolutely lousy with outlaw gangs and lone wolf gunslingers, maybe with the occasional overzealous, draconian lawman there to give them a good fight.


3. The Rise Of The Van Der Linde Gang

Red Dead Redemption 2 Dutch's Gang
Rockstar

After the first Red Dead Redemption, we really had no reason to believe that the Van der Linde gang was NEARLY as interesting as it turned out to be.

We knew nothing about Arthur Morgan, Hosea Matthews, Lenny Summers, Charles Smith, and Sadie Adler. John didn't mention the war between the U.S. Army and the Wapiti, nor did he discuss Micah Bell's betrayal.

Rockstar managed to build all of that out of the vagueness of John's backstory. There's no reason to think that they can't do it again.

The gang's history leading up to the Blackwater Massacre is equally nebulous.

What were they like before the Pinkertons had them on the run? We saw how they handled themselves in an unfamiliar land (New Hanover and Lemoyne), but how did they operate on their home turf, where everyone presumably knew the name Van der Linde?

If Rockstar decides to give us a game centered around the Van der Linde crew once more, it'd be the coda of a magnificent trilogy told in reverse, starting with the final death of the Van der Linde gang, and ending with their rosy beginnings - a sort of meta commentary on our romanticized nostalgia for the Old West.


2. Dutch And Annabelle

Dutch van der Linde
Rockstar

Annabelle was Dutch's lover, and that in itself is an enticing prospect. No, we shouldn't expect Red Dead Redemption 3 to be a love story by any stretch, but if it does focus on Dutch (at least in some capacity), it'd go a long way in humanizing the fallen gang boss.

Dutch treated all of his disciples like his children, but it's hard to tell what was sincere, and what was disingenuous sycophancy for the sake of manipulation. To see Dutch in love - truly, deeply in love - would cast him in a new light.

What's more, we know that his darling Annabelle was taken from him too soon. We could see a Dutch van der Linde whose guard was down - whose heart was open, only to have the person he opened up to snatched away from him by the cruel, violent hand of the life he chose to live.

After that, he only ever kept women at a distance, romantically. Molly O'Shea is proof enough of that.

Why wouldn't he allow John and Abigail to leave? This is just speculation, but maybe - just maybe - it would remind him of his own failure to save his beloved Annabelle from his world.


1. Colm O'Driscoll's Brother

Colm O'Driscoll
Rockstar

Speaking of Annabelle... How did she die?

Her life was claimed by Colm O'Driscoll, the man Dutch hated more than anyone in the world. But why did Colm kill Annabelle?

Because - according to Arthur - Dutch killed Colm's brother sometime before, back when the two gangs had a mutual peace. It's never revealed why Dutch killed Colm's brother. Maybe we could find out in RDR3.

Colm mentioned that he never really liked his brother. While that might be nothing but bluster, what if it's true? What if Colm's brother was the one who struck the peace deal between the gangs? What if Colm never wanted peace, and his brother's death kicked off a war that he and Dutch had been just one or two nudges away from engaging in?

Dutch's single-minded vendetta against Colm drove him to pursue Leviticus Cornwall to his ultimate detriment, just as Colm's single-minded vendetta against Dutch led him to kill Annabelle. The two mirror each other, in a way.

Here's the thing: Colm, Dutch, Annabelle, Cornwall... the brother's death was the catalyst for all of it. This seems like too significant of a story for Rockstar to tease and never follow up on.

Hopefully we'll get some answers.


Watch Next


How Well Do You Know Red Dead Redemption 2?

Rockstar

1. The Game's Best Horse, The White Arabian, Can Be Found Where?

Contributor

Dustin is your friendly neighborhood historian, nerd culture enthusiast, and professional wise-ass. Some of his favorite pastimes include writing, philosophizing, and antagonizing stupid people.