South Park: Every Game Ranked Worst To Best
Not all South Park games are created equal.
South Park is a franchise that no longer feels like just a cartoon; it's a brand in itself.
Trey Parker and Matt Stone have made it clear that their mission with the snowy mountain town is to turn it into an entertainment property before selling it off (which explains their recent purchase of Casa Bonita). Making good video games is a big part of that.
Back in the Day, a video game/cartoon tie-in was never particularly promising. Sure, you had a couple of classics that slipped through the woodworks. But for every "Simpsons Hit & Run", there was a "The Simpsons Skateboarding".
Naturally, South Park's ventures into the playable sphere have been just as hit and miss, but the evolution of the games have seen a drastic incline.
On the surface, South Park seems like the last series that needs a game, as the show's fun comes from the main characters playing off each other in quick pacing, and that never seemed possible in the virtual world.
With that said, the legacy of South Park video games is one fascinating rollercoaster ride.
8. South Park (1998)
As the first South Park game and a loose tie-in with the movie (at least scheduled to release alongside it), this game had a lot to live up to. Did it succeed in that?
Well, in the words of Eric Cartman, "Oh hell no".
This 1998 Playstation 1 title was a first-person shooter, giving you control over one of the four leading boys. After a comet made of pure evil approaches the Earth, the town is set upon by mutant turkeys, aliens, deformed South Park inhabitants, and more. It's up to you to save South Park by pelting those enemies with snowballs.
As you can see from the image above, the game has not held up well and was considered ugly even for its time. The novelty of being in South Park has its charm, but you lose it very quickly as the awful aesthetics and lacklustre FPS gameplay make it quite a slog to get through.
The move to 3D might also have been a mistake, as although it's clearly South Park, you don't feel like you're actually there. Plus, the poor voice acting makes it truly frustrating, thanks to repetition and lack of passion. Not even a multiplayer mode could save this mess.
7. South Park: Chef's Luv Shack
As the first South Park game that stuck to the 2D imagery of the show, it's safe to say this one felt a little more appropriate. But, despite the slightly more on-brand image, it's still an ugly and highly flawed game.
"Chef's Luv Shack" is a simple quiz game that mixes a few minigames into its runtime. You'll answer general knowledge questions with a little bit of showmanship from Chef. Then, you'll be subjected to games reminiscent of Asteroids, Balloon Fight, Paperboy and more, all with a South Park coat of paint.
It's a very run-of-the-mill title that does what it says on the tin, with little passion about it. The comedy falls flat every time, as it's awkward and ill-thought-out, which makes sense as Trey Parker and Matt Stone had little to no involvement in it.
There is a little fun in the minigames, but not enough to make it a worthwhile play. Plus, it's exclusively multiplayer, with no in-game AI at all, so if you wanted to give this one a go, you'd have to find people who are also willing to subject themselves to it.
Good luck with that.
6. South Park Rally
Everybody loves a good kart racing game. The likes of "Mario Kart", "Crash Team Racing", "Team Sonic Racing" and countless others have made it clear that you can bet big bucks on the success of a popular franchise giving it a go. The idea of South Park jumping into this world too was exciting, but the execution left a lot to be desired.
There's not much to this one, as the "story" centres on the Mayor of South Park's decision to hold a kart-racing rally, which your favourite characters take part in. It's fun to see less favourable names get some time to shine (such as Pip, Tweek, Marvin Marsh and more), but the novelty of the South Park identity wears thin once you start playing.
It's a horrifying mess of poorly controlled karts and ugly as all hell graphics that lack a sense of colour, charm and pixels in general. Plus, the game's poor procedural generation makes you feel like you're playing something entirely unfinished, steering way clear of the standard you'd expect from South Park.
It's such a fantastic concept, wasted on a poorly made game.
5. South Park: Tenorman's Revenge
Creating a fully interactive story is, naturally, entirely different from something that plays on TV.
Making a video game fun and entertaining requires not only solid storytelling but gameplay that keeps you engaged. While this game certainly gives the story a good crack, it doesn't do well with the interactive elements.
"Tennorman's Revenge" is a 2D platformer where you and three friends (if you choose) take control of the four central boys and travel across space and time. The plot follows as the titular villain steals Cartman's Xbox hard drive, and you're tasked with getting it back.
It's easy to say that the game gets repetitive as it continues. The changes of scenery - going from places like the future to heaven - are fun but the lack of variety in the gameplay makes it repetitive. Seeing as it sits at an average playtime of eight and a half hours, that is rather damning for the title.
You'll jump and fight, but there's very little challenge to it, and the slow pacing makes it feel like you're moving at a snail's pace. It certainly does fine and feels like the prototype for the movement in Stick of Truth, but that doesn't save it from mundanity.
4. South Park: Phone Destroyer
Seeing South Park storm the Freemium iOS/Android market seems hypocritical, and that's because it is. The show itself has poked fun at the immorality of mobile games with in-app purchases plenty of times. But, as far as soulless cash-grabs go, this one is somewhat worthwhile.
"Phone Destroyer" sees you play as "The New Kid" introduced in the mainline gaming titles and follows as the children of South Park argue about what game they should play. They bring you into the debate, and create a grand game for you through your phone.
The gameplay consists of you building decks of cards featuring the characters with varying stats and abilities and fighting against enemies. There are even PVP battles as well, which can be pretty fun.
It even features three alternate endings depending entirely on how much money you spent on the game. It's the right amount of tongue-in-cheek self-awareness you'd expect from South Park but doesn't wholly remove its unapologetic money-centric purpose.
Still, you do get a lot of bang for your buck with it, and if your options are between spending money on "Candy Crush" or "Phone Destroyer", then you might as well go with the one that works a little harder for your admiration.
3. South Park: Let's Go Tower Defense Play!
On the surface, this one might seem like another simple attempt to slap a South Park logo onto a different gaming genre. But, it's actually one hell of a great Tower Defence game.
As the first South Park video game in nine years after the release of South Park Rally in 2000, it really showed that the brand still had hope for a life in gaming.
The game follows as an endless barrage of enemies attack the town, and the boys battle in a collection of defence play matches. The story has a tonne of creativity to it, as the boys continuously search for the "main villain", finding each person to be just another pawn. Without spoiling it, the big bad is a hilarious twist and a great piece of meta-humour.
However, a charming story isn't the only thing this game has going for it, as the defence gameplay itself is incredibly challenging and faced-paced. There's a great learning curve to it which gives you a lot more than you'd expect. But, it also adds the ability to control the characters individually and attack enemies, adding some exciting additional action to the title.
It's a game that surprises you with its high quality and truly resurrected South Park games.
2. South Park: The Fractured But Whole
As the follow-up to the incredibly popular and well-received "Stick of Truth", this game had a lot riding on its shoulders, and it lived up to that expectation - for the most part. There's plenty to love about it, as it improves many elements from its predecessor, but there's also a feeling of lacking that makes it not quite as special.
In "The Fractured But Whole", you play as the same "New Kid" from the previous game and find yourself enthralled in yet another ridiculous plot, this time involving time travel and superheroes.
Like the first game, it's full of ludicrous moments and rival factions vying for your attention, and it's a lot of fun.
The improvements on the game come from the gameplay as the classic one-turn based combat from the previous outing is given a new sense of motion. Now, you're tasked with moving around a grid with new challenges and requirements. Plus, you can include up to three members in your party, giving you the chance to involve all your favourite characters.
However, while the story is more coherent, it lacks the sense of spectacle the previous game had. It's far more predictable and relies heavily on continuity from the show rather than fresh ideas, which brings it down a little.
1. South Park: The Stick Of Truth
It's hard to explain to non-South Park fans just how delightful it was to play this game for the first time. If you were a fan of the series, then you'd probably spent most of your life wishing you could stroll around the iconic streets of South Park. It seemed we'd never get the chance, but then "Stick of Truth" came along and delivered.
"Stick of Truth" took the ever-popular South Park Game of Thrones/Lord of the Rings parody and gave you a role in it. You took control of "The New Kid" and played a major part in the quest to gain the Stick of Truth. Alongside that came Nazi zombies, aliens, governmental conspiracies and all the ridiculous things you'd expect from an epic South Park experience.
Sure, the combat was a little rudimentary, but the simplicity encouraged you to enjoy the levelling system and hone your skills at the interactive attacks. But, the real highlight of this one was the ridiculous story and set-pieces.
Fighting Underpants Gnomes beneath your parents having sex, using your butt as a weapon on an alien spaceship, shrinking and jumping inside Mr Slave; it was the full South Park experience - so long as you didn't live in a country where much of the content was banned.