Spider-Man PS4 Review: 6 Ups & 1 Down

Amazing, spectacular, sensational - did you expect anything less?

Spider Man Ps4
Sony/Marvel

After two years of teases, trailers and gameplay previews, Insomniac's Spider-Man game is finally here. It's really, really good - spectacular even - and though it isn't without its flaws, just as Batman: Arkham Asylum proved to be a momentous event in the superhero calendar nine years ago, so too has Spider-Man proven to be equally significant.

Everything about it is just this pure, wonderful, affecting love letter to everyone’s favourite friendly neighbourhood wall-crawler, and though it does have a few shortcomings, my lasting impression of Insomniac’s game is unequivocally positive. Every thwip, swing and moment is to be savoured, and for fans of Marvel Comics and Spider-Man specifically, this'll likely prove to be one of the generation's defining titles, providing Marvel with a reply to DC's pointy-eared gaming giant at just the right time.

It's impossible to talk about Insomniac's game without mentioning Arkham, but that need not be a hindrance. There are plenty of similarities between the two games, and as Insomniac's Spider-Man looks set to become just as iconic as Rocksteady's Dark Knight, it's clear that the House of Ideas' most relatable hero could yet provide a defining image of Sony's latest console - not just as one of the true greats of the superhero genre, but of the gaming medium too.


Ups...

6. Insomniac's Take On Spider-Man & His World

Insomniac

By far the most striking thing about Insomniac’s depiction of Spider-Man is, and has been for the last few years now, the new suit. Say what you will about the white Spider, but one thing that cannot be denied is that the suit's innovative, exciting and ultimately refreshing. More importantly, it encapsulates the studio’s approach to the Marvel Universe, providing an image of the web-slinger that feels fresh, but also familiar.

In the vein of Arkham, Insomniac have taken into account dozens of different interpretations of the Spidey mythos to create their own version, lending it an appeal that’s sure to resonate with every True Believer, whether they’ve been reading comics for decades, or just happened to be raised on the nineties cartoon with the Aerosmith theme. This appeal is central to the game, as it taps into the very core of what made Stan Lee and Steve Ditko's original comic so compelling to begin with, while providing a modern update much the same way Brian Bendis and Mark Bagley did in Ultimate Spider-Man.

And - like that comic - Insomniac's take on the wall-crawler has proven to be equally restorative. It effortlessly integrates decades' worth of the character's history all into one, taking into account everything from the Sinister Six all the way through to the introduction of Miles Morales to create a mythos with lasting appeal.

The potential for something bigger is there for all to see, and with a sequel nigh-on guaranteed, it's clear the studio have developed something special.


5. One Hell Of A Story For Fans AND Newcomers

Spider-Man PS4 Sinister Six
Insomniac

Insomniac's approach pays off tremendously in the story itself. Written by Spidey writer Christos Gage, it focuses on a Peter Parker eight years into his career as the wall-crawler; he’s juggling his responsibilities as Spider-Man with that awkward transition into becoming an adult; he has a job (that absolutely MUST NOT be spoiled), him and MJ aren’t together anymore, and Harry Osborn is away in Europe. The gang’s no longer there, and there’s an underlying maturity to the game’s story about growing up, all elevated by a spectacular voice cast headlined by Yuri Lowenthal, whose performance as Peter Parker will no doubt rank among the all-time great Spider-Man portrayals once the dust begins to settle.

The story actually starts with Spidey heading to Fisk tower to take down the Kingpin once and for all. There’s years worth of unspoken history between the pair, and while Spidey believes Fisk's incarceration will spark a golden age for the city as a whole, Wilson's prophesy of everything coming undone is soon proven right by the arrival of Martin Li, the villainous Mister Negative who has dominated much of the title’s marketing.

Factor in the arrival of villains Shocker, Vulture, Scorpion and Rhino, and it soon becomes apparent that Spidey has his work cut out for him. Peter also finds himself in the position of mentoring Miles Morales, and it makes for one of the story’s most exciting sub-plots.

Without spoiling anything either, I will say that the story takes some really interesting and unexpected directions. It’s genuinely affecting, has a great mystery, and for those who’ve come to know Spider-Man inside and out over the years, the journey it takes you on is sure to leave an impact (with a view to multiple sequels further down the line, of course).


4. The New Lore Is Worth Exploring, And Possesses Boundless Potential

Spider-Man Ps4
Sony

Main story aside, one of the most compelling things about Marvel's Spider-Man is its unspoken history. Fans will make it their mission to collect every backpack the game has to offer, and with landmarks and Easter eggs aplenty, it’s clear this is a mythos built to last, and one worth exploring - and already has been explored - in various media going forward.

Like Rocksteady, Insomniac have opted to tell a story about a version of their hero at the peak of his abilities, leaving the door open for prequels but more importantly ensuring that there's a rich history to tease and hint at. It enables the player to piece together their own mythos, and with dozens of Marvel characters having been hinted at in the game itself - whether through landmarks, or through those aforementioned backpacks - it's possible that the House of Ideas could be about to build a gaming universe to rival their cinematic one.

It's important not to get ahead of ourselves just yet, but still, it's been wonderful exploring Marvel's New York. Could more have been done? Perhaps, but just knowing that you're there in this world alongside the likes of Doctor Strange, Black Panther and the Avengers is great - even if the Fantastic Four's Baxter Building is absent from the New York skyline.


3. Combat Feels Great, Taking JUST The Right Amount From Arkham

Spider man ps4
Marvel

Gameplay wise, there are a lot of similarities between Spider-Man and Batman: Arkham. However, while it’s true that stealth and combat work much the same, Insomniac have only modelled their system on the genre’s best, and they’ve even added enough tweaks to make it feel unique too.

While Arkham’s system emphasised power and gadgetry, Spidey’s focuses on verticality, movement, and environmental interaction. The more abilities you unlock, the more satisfying it is to play, with various web-based gadgetry also doing much to set this Spidey game apart from its predecessors.

Taken together, and you have a system that truly lets you embody the spirit of the friendly neighbourhood hero, much the same way Rocksteady did with Batman, only different. You'll be chaining together combos in know time at all, weaponising the environment, integrating gadgets and striking from the shadows.

For all intents and purposes, for the duration of this game, you are Spider-Man. The experience as a whole can only be compared to Arkham because it's just as successful; not because it imitates, but because it innovates.


2. Swinging Is The Best It's Ever Been

Spider-Man PS4 Raft
Insomniac

Then there’s the swinging. It’s simply wonderful, and feels every bit as special as it did booting up Spider-Man 2 for the first time back in 2004. The sense of speed, motion and elegance is breathtaking, and with a boatload of animations and petty crimes to stop, traversal is never without purpose.

Also interesting to note is the integration of a fast travel system. Players can zip straight to a location they've already visited at the touch of a button, at which point they'll be treated to a cutscene where Spidey uses the subway. It's very "The Commuter Cometh" (a beloved Spidey comic written by Peter David), and yet another fun way of showcasing the character's relationship with the wider New York populace - a relationship made all the better through various side missions that see the wall-crawler assist citizens in need.

Without going off on too much of a tangent though, the sense of movement, speed and agility in this game is truly something to behold. Players will have obviously swung around the city as Peter in previous titles, but not to the level Insomniac have managed to achieve this time around.


1. The Open World Is Bursting With Detail

Spider-Man PS4 Swinging
Sony

As for the open world? Well, there are the usual tasks to do.

Wilson Fisk has plenty of old hideouts to raid, you will get addicted to doing all the collectibles, and the Oscorp lab missions all provide their own unique minigames to solve. Add in challenges by the villainous Taskmaster and a few surprise distractions to deal with along the way - one that teases the first piece of upcoming DLC - and this game is in no way short of content.

It's not a case of quantity over quality though - New York is chockfull with detail, a fact made evident by the addition of numerous city-wide landmarks. Players can visit the exteriors of the Sanctum Santorum, Avengers Tower and the Wakandan Embassy, among other locales, and with each district all looking unique in their own way (Hell's Kitchen is dark and gothic, while Times Square is bursting with light), the visual delineation helps to make this version of NYC feel genuinely marvellous.


Downs...

1. Side Missions Can Get Repetitive

Spider-Man PS4 Truck
Insomniac

Unfortunately, this abundance of content isn’t all worth exploring. Some of the side missions can feel particularly repetitive, and though it’s great interacting with the civilian populace, one does wonder whether or not these objectives would've been made more interesting with appearances from various Marvel heroes - the likes of Daredevil, Luke Cage and Jessica Jones the three most obvious examples.

What's more is that much of the game's side content revolves around fetch quests. They're not tedious per se - the payoff for all these missions was certainly worth it - but there was a certain monotony to some of the tasks required of the player.

On the whole, however, Marvel’s Spider-Man is Amazing, Spectacular and Sensational - it’s the Ultimate Spidey experience. Insomniac have created a world players will feel compelled to sit in and soak up, written a story that’ll be discussed for years from now, and modelled a gameplay system that’s undoubtedly Spidey’s best yet.


Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.