Super Mario: Every Game Ranked From Worst To Best

11. Super Mario 3D Land

Super Mario 3D Land
Nintendo

There's a quixotic, dream-like aura to Super Mario 3D Land, and not one which leaves you bolt upright after turning up to school naked with half your teeth falling out. It's a lot more pleasant.

Patient 3DS owners were blessed with Mario's finest portable platformer, a halfway house between traditional fare featured in the 'New' offshoots and the three-dimensional obstacle courses of Galaxy. The stereoscopic sections add little and it's a tad on the easy side, but its post-game sees the difficulty sprout higher than a secret beanstalk, offering immense satisfaction through its devious new problems. It's a bitesized chunk that wouldn't quite fill a chain-chomp, but a beauty nontheless.


10. Super Mario 3D World

Nintendo Super Mario 3d World
Nintendo

Depending on whether you consider Breath of the Wild to be a Wii U game or not (I mean, it literally is), Super Mario 3D World is unquestionably the best the system has to offer. But is that saying much?

Given the limited install base for Nintendo's underwhelming eighth-gen console, Super Mario 3D World may just be the most underrated entry in the long-running series as well. The game is essentially a WADA-contravening Super Mario 3D Land, inflated, extended, and improved in every possible way, albeit with edges soft rather than chiseled. The multiplayer mayhem of the New Super Mario Bros. titles is present with the potential frustration filed away, and that colour-bursting artistry only Nintendo's paintbrush can produce is present in every pixel.

Had Super Mario 3D World landed in more populated waters than the Wii U's, it'd have made a much bigger splash. A shame it didn't, as its absolutely awash with enjoyment.


9. Super Mario Sunshine

Super Mario Sunshine
Nintendo

Mario should have learned from his previously aborted holiday to Sarasaland that work never stops. Yet again, speedos and sunglasses had to be quickly stuffed back into suitcases as a fortnight in the sun soon devolved into disaster, the poor plumber framed for the wanton vandalism running amok on the idyllic Delfino Isle. Lad literally can't catch a break.

Just as Mario paid his debt to society by cleaning the island's graffiti, it's time to erase some misconceptions about Mario Sunshine. Following Mario 64 was like Jesus coming up with a better trick than resurrection, so no matter what Nintendo delivered in dungarees to the Gamecube in 2002, it was going to be underwhelming. And yes, Sunshine isn't as good as its groundbreaking forebear, but it is a wonderful game on its own terms. It takes the winning formula and evolves it, not, er, revolves it, adding in the intriguing new FLUDD mechanic, brilliant bonus stages which'd form the basis of Mario Galaxy, and one of the series' most exotically enduring environments.

Has water ever looked so lush? A shining star lost in the shadows of its bigger brothers.


8. Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island

Yoshi's Island
Nintendo

Jurassic Park! Yoshi's journey across his dinosaur domicile is a lot more cuddly than Alan Grant and co.'s near-fatal expedition to Isla Nublar, but no less treacherous. Though ostensibly the sequel to Super Mario World, Yoshi's Island is a stark departure from its predecessor, thanks to an often-annoying baby-ferrying mechanic which makes it basically gaming's longest ever escort quest.

Throw in some egg-flinging action, and it becomes a question of whether this is really a Mario game at all. But it is - and not just because the Brooklyn bambino is in the saddle. It's those other hallmarks - immaculate level design, overflowing originality, and faultless control - which let you know this is sprinkled with magic Mushroom Kingdom dust. The charming pastel-daubed visuals and impeccable soundtrack complete one of Mario's prettiest pictures. Could do without the squawking baby though.


7. Super Mario Bros.

Super Mario Bros.
Nintendo

They say the first step is always the hardest, but not for Shigeru Miyamoto's gamboling, Goomba-hopping plumber. Mario was running and jumping like a champion without ever learning to walk.

OK, if we're being pedantic, Super Mario Bros. was technically an evolution of Donkey Kong, but the arcade classic was but a spoke in the wheel Nintendo eventually invented. It may not have been the first side-scrolling platformer - it was beaten to the punch by Sega's Jump Bug - but so astutely realised was Miyamoto's vision that it defined the genre.

Not a single thing was out of place, as Nintendo delivered a masterclass in game design before the industry was out of its infancy. Super Mario Bros. didn't move the goalposts so much as warp them to another field. Unlike most iconic titles of its era, time has not fettered the face of the Famicom's finest one jot - a true testament to its timeless brilliance.


6. Super Mario Galaxy

SI Wii SuperMarioGalaxy
Nintendo

With the Gamecube roundly spanked by the chic-stylings of Sony's sleek PS2, Mario decided to leave the confines of Earth for the one place not corrupted by capitalism... SPACE!

Being shot into the outer reaches of the universe might have seemed like a punishment for Mario's 128-bit under-performance, but for video game lovers jaded by an increasingly cynical, annualised industry, Super Mario Galaxy was Nintendo's reward for their loyalty. Half a decade of gaming's accumulated grit and mud were swept away as Mario soared into the skies for his vibrant return, a positively life-affirming romp which reminded us all why our eyes turned to pixels in the first place.

Mario Galaxy abandons any pretense of non-linearity, instead presenting what is in effect a series of themed Mario Sunshine secret stages. In other words, it took the tastiest hors d'ouvre of an already delectable buffet and made it the full course. Throw in a boundless orchestral soundtrack and you have a cosmic accomplishment which skyrockets beyond everything that came before it.


5. Super Mario Galaxy 2

Super Mario Galaxy 2 Normal
Nintendo

Mario Galaxy 2 was everything wonderful about Mario Galaxy, but stripped of all the fannying about and now with a spaceship shaped like the eponymous hero's bonce. It's difficult to couch it in terms more laudatory than that.

Our hero strapped himself back in Yoshi's saddle for the first time since his tropical tour of Isle Delfino in between buffing his fluff as a wispy white cloud, but these charming gimmicks are not the highlights of Mario's second voyage into space. Instead, it is level design to make Le Corbusier cry with envy, and a difficulty curve so pure it could have been pulled from Euclid. Only Nintendo could take one of the best games of all time and make it better. And not for the first time.


4. Super Mario Bros. 3

Super Mario Bros 3
Nintendo

By this point, we're entering air of such a rarefied nature that even a top-class Bolivian football team would be left gasping. The quality of this final quintet is simply breathtaking.

Super Mario Bros. 3 is platforming perfection. An astronomical leap from the early foundations laid by Shigeru Miyamoto's original side-scroller, Mario's third excursion took everything great about the vintage forerunner and distilled it into a indefectible cabernet. The controls were tighter, the adventure longer, and the levels bolder, resulting in the finest game on the NES, and one which went platinum 11 times over.

If Super Mario Bros. was Michelangelo's Creation of Adam, its second sequel was the Italian maestro's David, an exquisitely sculpted, flawlessly refined masterpiece, albeit wearing a raccoon suit.


3. Super Mario World

Wii remote
Nintendo

A dice-roll is the only reason Super Mario World leaves the podium with bronze around its neck. At this point, quantum physicists would have to divise a whole new particle to describe the infinitesimally small margins separating inhabitants of Mario's haut monde.

If Mario Bros. 3 was Michelangelo's David, logically Mario World can only be some sort of unattainable vision of perfection briefly visiting the Renaissance dauber in a swiftly forgotten dream. Miyamoto and chums managed to make such a picture of paradise a tangible reality, firmly planting their flag atop the platform genre mountain and rendering most others passé in the process.

It didn't matter that the Super Famicom launched with just two games in Japan - over three million people snapped it up in its first six months, eager to taste a spoonful of gaming ambrosia. Whatever Mario 3 did brilliantly, Mario World did more so, with each and every pixel painstakingly considered for maximum enjoyment. It may have boasted 96 exits, but no-one could escape Super Mario World's beguiling spell.


2. Super Mario Odyssey

Super Mario Odyssey Title
Nintendo

A child had to be born, grow up, and be legally allowed to drink alcohol within the United States before we were allowed a true sequel to Mario 64. It was worth the wait: when Mario Odyssey finally dropped anchor in our lives, it made us feel like one again.

It's really more Banjo-Kazooie than Mario 64, but unlike second-rate sequels amongst the bird-and-bear's three, Odyssey is Goldilocks's expansion to the greatest game ever made: just right. The levels eschew the prevailing mentality that bigger must be better, giving way for continuous discovery over tedious travelling. Not that traversing the inventive, colour-soaked locales is ever a chore; Mario moves like a liquid ferret, a constant pleasure beneath the thumb. It's the sweetest of platforming porridge.

People who bemoan it as an excessive collect-athon have missed the point entirely , because that is the point. Not all 850 moons were made equally, and some are right arseholes (one can skip right off), but the fun never dries up even as the space shards start to. Plus you can play as a manhole cover. I mean, come on.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.