10 Biggest "What If?" Questions In NBA History

NBA history is filled with tantalizing "What If?" scenarios, but which are most worth asking?

Michael Jordan
KIRTHMON DOZIER/AP/Press Association Images

"What If?" questions are like cocaine for sports fans. Sure, we love discussing tangible things, like current events, upcoming games, or WHY CAN'T THE KNICKS JUST BE A NORMAL BASKETBALL TEAM!? You know, the kind of things that turn polite conversations into shouting matches. However, the idea of the unknowable, of completely hypothetical, alternate timelines, pique the interest of sports fans more than anything based in reality.

Every sport has its own massive "What If?" questions. Baseball: what if Babe Ruth played in the modern day, with minorities and no whisky in the dugout? Football: what if Bo Jackson hadn't broken his hip? Soccer: what if Americans weren't d*cks and had just named their bonkers fight club sport anything else? All of those are unanswerable, but still really fun to think about.

Basketball has its fair share of "What If" questions too. Throughout the NBA's 71 year existence, a number of seismic events have drastically altered the course of the sport and have left hoops fans the world over forever wondering what could have been. If we're really lucky, someone will invent Dr. Farnsworth's What-If Machine so we can get some concrete answers, but in the off chance that Elon Musk isn't working on that very project at this very moment, we'll have to answer these questions ourselves.

10. What If... Tracy McGrady Hadn't Left Toronto?

In reality, Tracy McGrady and Vince Carter's egos couldn't exist side-by-side and T-Mac, desperate to prove how great he was, fled Toronto to sign with the Orlando Magic in 2000. Although both men would go on to have cherished individual careers, they experienced little-to-no playoff success. Could that have been different if they were able to rein in their egos and play together in the North?

McGrady and Carter are among the most dynamic scorers to ever play basketball; a back court of them in their primes could have been one of the highest scoring duos ever. They would have complimented each other well: T-Mac could have taken the toughest defensive assignment every night, while VC's three point shooting would have demanded constant attention from defenses, allowing T-Mac to drive to the basket at will. Also, Toronto undeniably had a better built team, as they were able to take Allen Iverson to the brink in the 2001 Eastern Conference Semi-Finals.

It's impossible to say whether they would have won a championship together, especially with Shaq and Kobe running the league, but a working aliance of T-Mac and VC would have been incredibly fun for the entire NBA.


9. What If... Shaquille O'Neal Hadn't Left Orlando?

FILE - This Dec. 5, 2005, file photo shows Miami Heat's injured center Shaquille O'Neal saluting a fan during the game against the Los Angeles Clippers, in Los Angeles. O'Neal says on Twitter that he's
KEVORK DJANSEZIAN/AP

This one has been explored for nearly two decades, including in an excellent ESPN 30 for 30 documentary, This Magic Moment, but it's no less fascinating to think about: had Shaquille O'Neal not left the Orlando Magic in 1996, could he and Penny Hardaway have won a championship together, as they had come so close to doing in 1995?

The Shaq and Penny-led Orlando Magic famously suffered a humiliating sweep at the hands of Hakeem Olajuwon and the Houston Rockets in the 1995 NBA Finals. The next season, they were ejected from the playoffs by the almighty '96 Chicago Bulls. However, despite those losses, they were still young and were playing at an astonishingly high level. Had they grown together, Shaq would have developed into the bruising monster he became in Los Angeles and the extra help would have allowed Penny to better preserve his body. Add in some team building by the front office and the Magic definitely could have snagged a ring or two in the post-Jordan era of 1998 and beyond.

Although Shaq went on to achieve great success in Los Angeles, it's hard not to think he left something truly special on the table in Orlando.


8. What If... Bill Walton Hadn't Succumbed To Injury?

Many big men experience foot injuries in their careers; their feet have to carry their massive frames and can only handle so much wear-and-tear before they succumb to something. In Bill Walton's case, foot injuries derailed what looked to be one of the most promising careers in NBA history, forcing Walton into limited minutes for the rest of his time in the NBA. Given his early success, including the 1977 NBA Championship and the 1978 NBA MVP award, what heights could he have reached had he been able to stay healthy?

People fail to appreciate how great Walton was because of his extremely short prime, but you only have to look at his numbers from the 1977 playoffs to understand his impact: 18.2 points, 15.2 rebounds, 5.5 assists, 3.4 blocks, and 1.1 steals per game, on .507% shooting. Those are video game numbers and he pulled them off at the age of 24. It's safe to assume had he stayed healthy, those numbers would have improved. Walton could have challenged Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Moses Malone for the big man throne well into '80s.

Bill Walton was a truly transcendental player and there was no limit to what he could have achieved.


7. What If... The NBA Hadn't 'Fixed' Game 6 Of The 2002 Western Conference Finals?

Sleep Train Arena Sacramento Kings
Wikimedia

It's widely believed that the NBA rigged Game 6 of the 2002 Western Conference Finals in favor of the Los Angeles Lakers, forcing a Game 7 that would inevitably be won by LA. Fans point to the fact that the Lakers shot 27 free throws in the fourth quarter, many given on brazenly incorrect calls against the Sacramento Kings. Meanwhile, Kobe Bryant elbowed Mike Bibby in plain sight and received no repercussions. Worst of all, the Lakers only squeaked by 106-102, leaving many to wonder what could have been for the Kings and Chris Webber had the refs called the game down the middle.

The 2001-02 Sacramento Kings were a special squad, a combination of great shooting and the peak of a troubled, but supremely talented Chris Webber, and they were the best team in the NBA. Had they beaten the Lakers, they would have gone on to face the New Jersey Nets, who ended up being swept aside by Los Angeles. The Nets were the beneficiaries of a bad Eastern Conference and the Kings would have stomped them as hard, if not harder, than Shaq and Kobe did. This would have given the Kings their first title since 1951.


6. What If... The NBA Hadn't Vetoed Chris Paul's Trade To The Los Angeles Lakers?

Los Angeles Clippers Chris Paul is shown during an NBA basketball game against the Cleveland Cavaliers Thursday, Feb. 5, 2015, in Cleveland. (AP Photo/Tony Dejak)
Tony Dejak/AP

In 2011, the league vetoed a trade that would have sent Chris Paul to the Los Angeles Lakers. The league owned the New Orleans Hornets at the time and they vetoed the trade on the grounds that the Hornets would be better off keeping Paul. However, less than a week later, they approved a trade sending Paul to the Los Angeles Clippers. That's shady as hell and now we can only imagine what would have come from a potential alliance of Chris Paul and Kobe Bryant.

Kobe was coming off two NBA Championship victories in 2009 and 2010, and that championship squad was still largely intact. Had the Lakers acquired Chris Paul, and kept that core mostly together, they would have had enough fire power to make another run at the Larry O'Brien Trophy, and Kobe's coveted sixth ring. It certainly would have been a better move than acquiring Dwight Howard, who clashed with Kobe and only lasted one season in the City of Angels. However, it's impossible to say if Kobe's body would have fared any better in this scenario, and his injured body would have made the hunt for gold largely moot.


5. What If... Michael Jordan Hadn't Taken A Two Year Baseball Sabbatical?

FILE - In this June 11, 1997 file photo, Chicago Bulls Scottie Pippen, right, embraces an exhausted Michael Jordan following their 90-88 win in Game 5 of the NBA Finals against the Utah Jazz, in Salt Lake City. An auction company says Jordan's shoes f
JACK SMITH/AP

Everyone knows the story: on 6 October 1993, 'His Airness', Michael Jeffrey Jordan, after leading the Chicago Bulls to three straight NBA Championships, retired from professional basketball, a decision influenced by the death of his father a few months prior. In 1994, he attempted a short-lived minor league basketball career with the Chicago White Sox. Although he returned to the Association in 1995 the G.O.A.T. lost two seasons of his prime and fans have wondered ever since what could have happened in those years had Jordan stayed on the hardwood.

It's easy to simply say he would have won the 1994 and 1995 NBA Championships, but would he have? Those were won by Hakeem Olajuwon and the Houston Rockets, and they were a better squad than anyone Jordan had faced in the Finals up to that point. Center was the Chicago Bulls biggest weakness and Hakeem would have rampaged over Bill Wellington. Not to mention, the Shaq and Penny Orlando Magic would have been in their way, so even if they did make the Finals, the Bulls would have been worn out by then. In fact, that level of sheer exhaustion could have effected their three title wins between 1996-1998.


4. What If... The Portland Trail Blazers Had Selected Michael Jordan In 1984?

Chicago Bulls Michael Jordan holds the trophy after the Bulls 108-101 win over the Los Angeles Lakers in game five for the NBA championship in Inglewood, California, June 12, 1991. (AP Photo/Reed Saxon)
Reed Saxon/AP

In 1984, the Portland Trail Blazers made possibly the greatest blunder in NBA Draft history when they selected Sam Bowie second overall instead of Michael Jordan. Jordan's talent was clear, but Bowie was a big man and back in the day, good big men were all-important. Plus, the Blazers were plenty confident in their shooting guard of the future, Clyde Drexler. Hoops fans have wondered since that day what potential golden windfall 'His Airness' could have bestowed onto Portland.

The biggest issue Jordan had in his early career, besides a foot injury, was a lack of help. His early Chicago Bulls teams weren't very good and he was basically a one man show. Being on the Trail Blazers would have changed that, as a duo of Clyde Drexler and Michael Jordan would have been phenomenal. Drexler was one of the most versatile players ever and while he certainly wasn't Scottie Pippen on defense, he was good-to-great everywhere on the court. Having Drexler right off the bat would have accelerated Jordan's winning ways, but could have hurt him later on when Drexler fell off. It also could have hurt the Bad Boy Pistons, who defeated Portland in the 1990 Finals.


3. What If... The Los Angeles Lakers Hadn't Traded For Kobe Bryant?

Los Angeles Lakers guard Kobe Bryant (24) drives with the ball during the first half of an NBA basketball game against the New Orleans Pelicans, Wednesday, Jan. 21, 2015, in New Orleans. (AP Photo/Jonathan Bachman)
Jonathan Bachman/AP

It's so difficult to picture Kobe Bryant in anything other than Purple and Gold that it's easy to forget that he wasn't drafted by the Lakers. Originally, he was drafted by the Charlotte Hornets and the Lakers traded Vlade Divac to obtain his rights on draft night. Although he never even came close to playing a game in Charlotte, had the Lakers not wanted him so badly, he easily could have wound up somewhere else, an almost impossible scenario to imagine today. The consequences that could have had on NBA history are immense.

The biggest question is: would Kobe have won any championships? While he likely wouldn't have won as many, he would have won some, because 'The Black Mamba' doesn't have a passive personality. The only thing that kept him on the Lakers during the down years was his love for the franchise. If he didn't like, say, the Hornets as much, he would have ditched them for a more capable team without a beat. Unfortunately, this hypothetical timeline means Shaq and Kobe would likely have never teamed up, depriving NBA fans of inarguably the most talented duo in NBA history.


2. What If... Len Bias Hadn't Passed Away?

On 17 June 1986, Len Bias was drafted second overall by the defending champion Boston Celtics. Two days later, he died of a cocaine overdose. Bias' passing was a tragic loss for his family, his friends, and the basketball community as a whole. Bias was a truly special talent, one who had drawn comparisons to Michael Jordan, and the Celtics had planned to make him the future of their franchise, as well as have him shoulder some of the burden for an aging Larry Bird.

In the summer of 1986, the Celtics were coming off a championship win with arguably the greatest team ever assembled. Unfortunately, Larry Bird's body was beginning to break down due to the extreme workload he put on himself. Len Bias was drafted not only to one day inherit the franchise, but also to help slow the ravages of time from bringing down Bird. Had Bias played, he potentially could have split Bird's minutes in half, prolonging 'Larry Legend's career well into the '90s, allowing the Celtics to continue to contend even when the Bad Boy Pistons and the Chicago Bulls started knocking on the Eastern Conference door.


1. What If... Drazen Petrovic Hadn't Passed Away?

On 7 June 1993, Drazen Petrovic was killed in an auto accident in Bavaria. His death resonated throughout the basketball world; Petrovic was, and still is, considered by many to be the greatest European player ever, and at the time of his death, he was finally finding his footing in the NBA. In fact, he had been named to the All-NBA Third Team shortly before his passing. Petrovic possessed such transcendental skill, he was so ahead of his time, that he could have changed the NBA forever had his life not been tragically cut short.

Petrovic was known for his maestro-like scoring abilities and nothing in his arsenal was quite as special as his three point stroke. In an era where the three point shot was still finding its footing, Petrovic was taking an advantage of it like no one else before him. In 1992 and 1993, he shot .444% and .449% behind the arc, respectively, which was unheard of given the volume he was shooting at. Had he continued on this path, he could have revolutionized the NBA, putting an added focus on the value of three point shooting more than two decades before Stephen Curry did.


Contributor
Contributor

Virgil Atkinson hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.