5 Reasons Why Dexter Needs To Call It Quits
When Dexter made its debut in the Fall of 2006, audiences and critics were completely blown away. Based on the novels by Jeff Lindsay, the series followed a blood-spatter analysis expert from the Miami Metro Police Department named Dexter Morgan, brilliantly played by Michael C. Hall. The irresistible catch of course is that Dexter is also a serial killer, who only kills other killers. The series focuses mostly on the double life that Dexter leads and the conflict that comes from that. For several years, Dexter was appointment television, and you tuned in every week to see what was going to happen because the suspense, drama, humor, and horror blended seamlessly into a gratifying television experience. However, as Dexter has just finished its seventh season, the series is starting to show its age. All of the warning signs of a television show that has gone past its expiration are not only present, but glaringly obvious. This article will countdown the top five reasons why Dexter needs to end. It hurts me to write this as I used to be one of the many, many Dexter fans who cancelled all plans Sunday night to see what was going to happen next. However, I think its time to indulge my Dark Passenger and put the series on my table. Also, please bear in mind that spoilers will follow. Youve been warned. Click next to reveal all...
5. Ridiculous (And Unnecessary) Subplots
If Im being completely honest, I could just call the fifth reason on this list Quinn and be done with it. No character in the history of television this side of Kim Bauer from 24 has ever been involved in so many idiotic and uninteresting plotlines. Every year, Dexter fans get together and make bets that this is the year that Quinn finally gets killed. And every year, he manages to survive. The only time he had a remotely interesting storyline was when they tried to make him Doakes Jr. during the fifth season by having him be suspicious of Dexter. Other than that, theyve put him in every cliché dirty-cop-who-means-well storyline they could think of, even going as far as to have him propose to Dexters sister Deb during the sixth season. During the most recent season, Quinn was once again the role of dirty-cop-with-heart-of-gold demonstrated by his desire to free an immigrant stripper from an organized crime syndicate. If Quinn is the Kim Bauer of the Dexter universe, than Sgt. Batista is definitely the Turtle from Entourage of the universe. It pains me to write this because I loved Batista during the first few seasons. However, in the past few years theyve had him date (and marry) the Captain of the police force (LaGuerta) and had him have a mid-life crisis, demonstrated by his purchase of a sports car. This is Turtle territory. What I mean by that is that when Entourage started, Turtle was fine being just the driver for Vinnie Chases group. As that series went on, they kept giving him several stupid business adventures and plotlines that often were just a waste of time including a car service, Tequila business, and trying to get his favorite New York restaurant to locate to Los Angeles. At least Batista never did anything like buy a restaurant. Oh, wait These plotlines often never add anything to the main story that Dexter is embarking on and only take away screen time from the more interesting storylines. Its like the writers have to shoehorn Quinn or Batista into their own plotlines just so the actors can get screen time. An ensemble cast only works when all the plotlines eventually come together in a cohesive manner.
4. They'll Never Top Season 4
As a working stand-up comic, there is a phrase that we often say when performing or writing jokes: If you cant top it, stop it. This means that if a joke reaches a natural peak, there is no reason to try to keep squeezing more laughs out of it; the pinnacle has been reached and anything else will pale in comparison. The writers on Dexter would be wise to follow suit as they will be hard pressed to top the greatness that was the fourth season of the show. Everything was perfect during that season; they had a great main villain in the Trinity Killer (played incredibly by John Lithgow), you had Dexter trying to juggle being a husband and a father, and the entire season was filled with cliffhangers/payoffs that kept you watching. In defense of the writers/creators of the show, they obviously didnt have any idea that the fourth season would be such a perfect storm. They also couldnt just stop making the show since at the time since they didnt realize it would become the most highly regarded season. They also ended the fourth season with a huge punch-in-the-gut cliffhanger that would have been unfair to not follow up on. However, it was abundantly clear how great season four was after they followed it up with the train wreck that was season five. Season five is arguably the worst season of the show (only season three comes close). They tried a similar formula by having a notable guest star be the driving force of the season (Julia Stiles), but relied too heavily on that gimmick and the show suffered because of it. Everyone knew that Julia Stiles probably wasnt going to be on the show for the long haul, so audiences waited for her eventual departure. They went back to the season long guest-star formula for season six (with Colin Hanks), and while that season wasnt completely terrible, it still didnt come close to the 12 episode masterpiece that was season four.
3. Dexters Love Stories
One of the most intriguing aspects of the show when it began was the idea that Dexter didnt have any emotions and only pretended to love others in order to blend in and not raise suspicions about any extracurricular (serial killer) activities. The early focus of the show on this aspect was the relationship between Dexter, his girlfriend Rita, and her two children. You could see that Dexter was concerned for their well being, but you could also tell that he was still putting on a front for the world. This made Dexter a well-rounded and fleshed out character. Several of the series tensest moments would come from Dexter having to juggle being a murderer and still trying to be a good boyfriend/step-father. The warning signs that Dexter love stories were going to turn bad could be spotted as early as season two, when Dexter cheated on Rita with a crazy chick named Lila. Lila was everything that Rita wasnt and accepted Dexter for who he was, going as far as to be drawn to him because he was a killer. Dexter eventually killed her and fans everywhere thought this was the end of any hokey Dexter love angles. Fans really just wanted Dexter and Rita to be together. And they were, for about two more seasons. After Rita was killed by the Trinity Killer at the end of season four, the Whos-Gonna-Date-Dexter Next show began. His first love interest post-Rita was Lumen, played by the aforementioned Julia Stiles. Her character needed Dexters help tracking down some guys who kidnapped her and were planning to kill her. Lumen was also okay with Dexter being a killer. As a guy who had trouble finding a prom date simply because I liked comic books and video games, its a little disheartening to see that women would rather overlook being a serial killer as opposed to liking Batman. The peak of idiotic Dexter love stories was reached during the latest season, after Dexter falls in love with Hannah McKay, another serial killer. Originally, Dexter planned on killing her, but instead, they ended up having sex on his killing table, which one could assume lead to some very awkward pillow talk. The problem I had with this was it was another season with Dexter falling in love being the main focus. It takes away from the entire premise that Dexter is just a shell, trying to fit in a world around him. While the series may be trying to humanize Dexter or show that Dexter is growing as a human being, giving him another serial killer as a girlfriend not only reaches new heights of stupidity, but also discredits any sort of realism that the show tries to create. For someone who cant fall in love or feel emotion, Dexter seems to be smitten with any girl who bats an eyelash at him. The worst part is that this storyline hasnt been resolved yet so we can only assume that even more stupid is yet to come.
2. Dexters Killer Secret Isnt That Big of a Secret Anymore
The whole premise of Dexter was that he was trying to live two different lives: one as a serial killer, and one as a law-abiding citizen who works for Miami Metro. This entire premise is based solely around the idea that Dexter keeps his serial killer identity a secret. If Dexter starts sharing his secret with people, then the stakes are lowered considerably, especially if the people he told the secret too are fine with it. There was no more groan-worthy moment than after the season six cliffhanger when Deb finally catches Dexter in the act of killing someone. The show could have gone is so many different directions after this pivotal moment in the series, after all, this was one of Dexters biggest fears throughout the entire series. Would Deb kill him? Turn him in? Any of those options are realistic, plausible, and would lead to some great television. That didnt happen. Instead, Deb just kind of came to terms with her brother being a serial killer. Essentially, after six years of build up, our payoff was Well, youre my brother, we can work this out. Come live with me. You dont work out a sibling being a murderer like you work out someone eating the last Hot Pocket. This is some serious business that you should probably put some thought into how to handle it. There was some tension built around the situation, but Deb essentially gave him a pass from episode one of the season, so you really werent worried about it. One of my favorite moments in the entire series was when Dexter and Doakes were in the cabin. Dexter could finally be honest with someone about who he really was, a luxury he was normally only afforded before he killed the person on his table. The dialogue exchanged between the two was phenomenal. You could tell Dexter was really getting a weight lifted off of his shoulders. Now, he can just talk to Deb about it or Hannah McKay or Lumen or the drug dealer who killed his mom who seemingly got away towards the end of the season but didnt go to the police. Its only a matter of time before Quinn, Harrison, Astor, Cody, Batista, the taco truck worker and the rest of Miami probably gets to know the secret and they will all magically be fine with it. I guess Miguel Prado doesnt feel so special now, knowing that Dexter has told more than just him his secret.
1. There Is No Suspense Left on Dexter
This is what the previous four reasons were all heading towards - they all build upon each other and have lead to absolutely no suspense whatsoever on the show. When I watched the early seasons of Dexter, you really didnt know whether or not he was going to get out of a situation. The Ice Truck Killer upped the ante by kidnapping Deb; this was followed by Doakes discovering that Dexter was the Bay Harbor Butcher. You felt like there was really something at stake or that Dexter could lose everything. Was there a more spine-tingling moment then when the Trinity Killer walked into the police station and said Hello, Dexter Morgan? Right then and there, you knew that Dexters entire cover could be blown, and that his life could completely change. Now, you dont for one second think that something isnt going to work out for Dexter. Dexter has crossed over in untouchable hero territory. The shining example of this was the kill early in this past season that took place in a crowded airport. Im not one to call shows out for bending the rules of whats realistic and whats not, but I cant overlook something so obvious. If anyone thinks that for one second anyone would get away with killing someone in an airport in this post-9/11 world, I would have to assume that you lost half of your brain in some sort of accident. It wasnt even the actual kill that baffled me the most, was how easy Dexter just slipped past airport security. I had to take my shoes off as I walked through security in a one-gate airport in rural Kentucky last year. If they have that stiff of a security in a fairly low-risk airport, I highly doubt Dexter would be able to get needles through the Miami airport just by telling the worker that they were for his diabetes. Never once have I tried to get a needle through security, tell the guard some crap excuse about diabetes, and have the guard say Seems legit, and pass me through. He then goes on to kill a man in baggage claim (despite cameras being everywhere), and then is still be able to sneak him out with no one noticing. If you can execute an airport kill without even a hint that it isnt going to work out, the suspense that your show once had is completely gone. Also, now that Deb knows that Dexter is a killer, you dont have to worry about the police finding out who he is. Captain LaGuerta confronted Deb with some evidence that would have been damning to her and Dexter, but she gets killed later in that episode, thus killing any sort of suspense that would bring. Dexter is now in a world where he can pretty much get away with anything and not have to worry about any consequences, even random loose ends like Louis (the police department intern and video game designer) get tied up nicely in roundabout ways. Dexter is now no longer a serial killing anti-hero, but rather an untouchable serial killing superhero. In conclusion, it pains me to write so passionately about why one of my favorite shows needs to call it quits. I just cant stand to see the show suffer from poor writing, lack of suspense, and idiotic plotlines just for the sake of putting out another season. Season eight will undoubtedly debut to huge ratings numbers, but in order to keep the audiences attention (and validate even going to eight seasons); the show needs to undergo a drastic change. If you cant top it, stopeven if that means putting Dexter on his own table of cancellation. Agree? Disagree? Think I need to end up on Dexters table for this list?! Comment below!