9 Worst TV Show Fake-Out Deaths
Should have stayed under that dumpster buddy.
Shocking deaths have really become the hot trend on television in the last decade, where a beloved character will meet a sudden, devastating demise. Shows like 24, The Walking Dead and Game Of Thrones have turned this into an art form, and seem to delight in breaking our hearts.
A major death isn’t something a show should approach lightly, however, and if they’re going to upset the fanbase it should be for a good reason. What they absolutely shouldn’t do is pretend to kill that character, have the supporting players and audience mourn them, only to reveal the whole death thing was faked.
It’s a cheap gimmick that hurts the show’s credibility and makes audiences distrustful and angry. It rarely benefits the story either, often being a meaningless distraction. Many shows have tried this out at least once, and sadly it’s a ploy that refuses to just go away. Let’s look at some of the worst examples of fake-out deaths on television, and see how they impacted the show.
9. Brian Being Hit By A Car - Family Guy
While Family Guy’s scattergun approach to comedy rubs some people the wrong way – the creators of South Park included – it’s built a huge fanbase based around this. Unfortunately, in the last few years, it’s become a pale shadow of its heydey, where any sense of character or warmth has been replaced by lazy pop culture gags, mean-spirited humour, and dumb gimmicks,
This includes The Simpsons / Family Guy crossover, and Brian’s death from season twelve. Brian is run over by a car during one episode, which has a devastating effect on the family. Longtime fans were upset too and immediately petitioned to bring him back. He was replaced by a new dog and for a few weeks it seemed the show might stick to this twist; of course, it didn’t last long.
Thanks to some time travel Brian was back soon enough, and fans – already annoyed by the show’s slipping quality – complained loudly about the ploy.
8. Sara Tancredi's Fake Head - Prison Break
The whole Sara Tancredi death and resurrection saga is pretty bizarre. It started in season three when the actress playing Sara got into a contract dispute with the network producing Prison Break. When it couldn't be settled, they decided to kill her character.
Thus, Sara’s head was sent to love interest Michael after he failed a task. The fanbase didn’t take this abrupt demise well, but it sure lit a fire under Michael for the rest of the season. Just when the audience had adjusted to her exit it was announced she wasn’t dead after all, with the villains having faked her death to punish Michael.
There was clearly some weird shenanigans going on behind the scenes during this period, since Sara’s death was clearly meant to be permanent. Her unlikely comeback hurt the already shaky reputation of the show, which was canned soon after.
Interestingly Michael himself died in the final episode, only for an upcoming revival series to break him back too; death isn't that big a deal on this show.
7. Glenn's Dumpster 'Death' - The Walking Dead
This one is worse in hindsight, given Glenn’s eventual fate. If we rewind to season six fans will no doubt remember the moment where Glenn and fellow survivor Nicolas are trapped by walkers in an alley. Nicolas commits suicide on top of a dumpster, and his dead weight causes them both to fall into the horde. Glenn is covered in blood and screaming as guts are ripped out, and he was presumed dead by other survivors and the audience for weeks.
It was eventually revealed he didn’t die, and he crawled under the dumpster to escape. This whole fake out was insanely ill-judged, being used to pad the story for a few episodes and keep viewers hooked. Apparently, the showrunners thought this was an interesting storytelling experiment, to see how viewers would respond to Glenn’s “death”, only to get their wish to see him alive again.
The answer? They were p***ed at being manipulated, and post-Lucille they’re likely even angrier.
6. Scott's 'Fatal' Test - Strike Back: Project Dawn
Strike Back is one of the most underrated shows of modern times, playing like an eighties action movie in TV series form. The show also had bizarre ties to Game Of Thrones, with most of the guest villains being played by GOT stars.
Charles Dance, Iain Glen and Ser Davos himself Liam Cunningham all played baddies, with Cunningham playing a former IRA bomber who forces lead character Damien Scott into a nasty test. He straps a bomb to his chest and gives him a choice; confess he’s a spy, or he’ll let the timer run out.
Scott keeps his mouth shut, sweating it out while the bomb counts down. Naturally, you expect the whole thing is a bluff or his partner will save him, only for the bomb to go off and the episode to end. After picking your jaw up off the floor the next episode reveals the gigantic explosion was pointed away from Scott, so he survived the blast. Strike Back occasionally liked to pull some cheap tricks, and this one was the worst.
5. Sherlock's 'Suicide' - Sherlock
This one was mildly annoying since it was immediately clear it was fake; it would be really hard for a show called Sherlock to continue after the title character’s death, after all. The season two finale has Sherlock leap to his death on Moriarty’s order. We later see his lifeless body after the fall and Watson giving an emotional speech at his funeral, so he seems pretty dead.
Of course, this isn’t the case, since the last shot reveals he’s alive and well. We had to wait till season three to find out how he survived the leap, and even then his explanation has holes. Of all the selections on this list Sherlock just about gets away with this bait and switch tactic, even if did briefly make Cumberbatch fans really upset.
4. Tony's Missed Artery - 24
Generally, if you’re an actor on 24 and you’re not Kiefer Sutherland, you shouldn’t assume you’ll last long. 24 has a long, illustrious history of wiping out fan favourite characters, and over the course of 9 seasons it racked up one hell of a body count.
It looked like Tony Almeida was added to that list too, with Jack’s long-time CTU colleague meeting a tragic end in season five. He’s stabbed in the heart by his wife’s killer and soon dies in Jack’s arms; not a great day for Tony there. However, since he didn’t receive a silent clock – the show’s sign of respect for a fallen hero – fans refused to buy it, even when he’s carried away in a body bag in the next episode.
The creators must have grown tired of fan complaints since he’s revealed to be alive in season seven. This resurrection stretched believability to the max - something about a "missed" artery - and the show rushes past the explanation for his non-death. It was nice to have him back, but it cost 24 some cred.
3. Buffy's 'Sacrifice' - Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Joss Whedon obviously has form killing characters we love, but even for him, it’s unlikely he’d axe the title character. He tried to pull that fast one in Buffy's season five finale The Gift, where she sacrifices herself to save the world.
At the time it appeared this finale might be the actual end of the series, so Joss wrote an episode dripping in emotion. The show was still doing well in ratings, so despite Buffy’s apparent death, the show was quickly brought back. The mere act of renewing the show made it clear Buffy’s demise meant nothing, and she was resurrected with some magic.
In the show’s defence, it did make Buffy’s trauma at being ripped from the grave part of the plot, but it was still ultimately a ploy to drum up interest.
2. Mulder's 'Suicide' - The X-Files
We all love The X-Files but let’s be honest; it regularly played fast and loose with storytelling. It wasn’t above a twist or shock death for the sake of it, and the season four finale is a classic example. The final scene finds an upset Mulder, who after learning everything he believes in is a lie, and Scully was given terminal cancer because of his actions.
We then learn through Scully that Mulder committed suicide that night, and that’s how the show ends. In season five it's revealed Mulder shot a government spy in the face, making him unrecognisable. He then assumed this guy's identity, and for a time the man with no face is assumed by all to be Mulder's corpse.
It’s ridiculous, and not in a fun way. It wasn’t the biggest stretch the show had made, but it was a really limp cliffhanger since no one believed it from the start.
1. Watch Out Jon Snow! - Game Of Thrones
Jon Snow’s murder in the season five was heartbreaking. The character had suffered all season long trying to unite The Wildlings and The Night’s Watch, and for his effort he got stabbed about a million times. Once the shock had faded, it quickly became clear it wasn’t going to last.
The show had previously killed characters when we least expected it, but Jon’s arc was way too important. There were too many unresolved storylines, plus the arrival of The Red Lady during the episode meant he was all but guaranteed a speedy recovery from his mild case of death.
The show teased this out a little longer during season six, but it was really just delaying the inevitable. This cliffhanger was a slightly cynical ploy on HBO’s part, since they hardly needed a fake death to keep fans watching. At least his brief death got him out of his Night’s Watch vows; small benefits.
Can you think of any other fake-out deaths that really annoyed you? Share them with us in the comments.