Big Finish Just Altered Doctor Who's Biggest Moment!

Big Finish are at it again, altering one of Doctor Who's biggest moments.

Doctor who Big Finish
BBC

Big Finish are about to play with the history of Doctor Who in a big way!

Released this month, Unbound - Doctor of War: Genesis alters a huge moment in the show's canon. The series is headed up by Colin Baker and also features Tom Baker, Geoffrey Beevers, Nicola Bryant, and the powerhouse Nicholas Briggs as the Daleks. The overall series synopsis reads:

Times have changed. A choice was made and the universe diverged. And now all of history is at war.

One man stands at the centre of it all. But whose side is he on? Is he with the angels? Or the demons? And does anyone even know which is which? He was a Doctor once, but now he is Doctor no more. He is the Warrior. The Doctor of War.

This release also came with a gorgeous trailer by Chris Thompson which you can see below:

This change, which will be discussed in a moment, has resulted in a Marvel 'What If' scenario, and a new universe of stories has opened up. So let's take a look at how Big Finish just altered Doctor Who's Biggest Moment! Big spoilers for this set to follow...

10. Original Universe Context

Doctor Who
BBC

So what happened in the original timeline?

Genesis of the Daleks nears its climax with a very iconic scene. The Fourth Doctor, Sarah and Harry are deep within the Kaled bunker, on their mission for the Time Lords to stop the Dalek's creation, or to avert their nature and make them less aggressive creatures.

This mission comes to a head when the Doctor reaches the Dalek mutant incubation chamber and has the plan to blow it up. But at this final moment he hesitates, the Doctor of our universe is no killer, this scene shows it.

Could the Doctor just wipe out the Daleks? Has he that right? If he did, he would become like them, becoming the killer if he chooses to wipe them out when they are defenceless and before they've even properly become Daleks. The Doctor even says that some worlds will thrive through their fear of the Daleks, but is that worth all the potential lives lost in the process?

Take a look at the moment below:

It's no exaggeration to say this is one of Doctor Who's most iconic scenes of all time.

So how does Big Finish change this...


9. "Do I Have The Right?"

Doctor Who BBC
BBC

Simple really. The Fourth Doctor chooses to wipe out the Daleks.

As shown in the clip in the last entry, the Doctor wrestles with the conflict of what to do. But in this version of history (beautifully recreated by Tom Baker, Sadie Miller, and Christopher Naylor) the Doctor decides he can do this. The Doctor literally holds all the power in his hands, "just touch these two strands".

The original moment is clearly contentious, with the Doctor weighing up the outcome, but what does the Doctor become when he picks the more violent option?

Surely there are two options. You've wiped out the evilest creatures in the universe, you can stop now, you've done the bad deed, but for the right reason. Or, you keep going on that slippery slope, and take these big decisions into your own hands. What will this Doctor pick?

In the original universe, as in this alternate, Sarah Jane is actually very vocal to the Doctor in trying to convince him that this is the right thing to do. But what are the consequences of that?


8. Death Of Sarah And Harry

Sarah Harry Doctor Who
BBC

The first consequence of this change is the deaths of the Doctor's two companions, including Who icon Sarah Jane Smith.

Doctor of War opens with a prologue, beautifully recreating the original 1975 moment. Tom Baker returns as the Fourth Doctor for this guest appearance, with Big Finish's Sarah Jane Smith and Harry, portrayed by Sadie Miller (Liz Sladen's Daughter) and Christopher Naylor. This scene already really gets the hairs on the back of your neck standing on edge, but then the consequences happen...

After destroying the incubators, the Doctor, Sarah and Harry are faced with one of the already operational prototype Daleks. And this isn't a Dalek who's hanging around. Without hesitation, the Dalek guns down these two much loved companions, much to the Doctor's heart break.

For a series to open on such a power moment, to kill off some of the shows most beloved characters in a heart beat is a quite a way to get our attention at the changes to come.

However, we aren't allowed much time to dwell on this, as there is a greater consequence to the Doctor's actions. The main consequence that creates the back bone of this series...


7. The Warrior

Doctor Who
BBC

After committing the act of destroying the incubation chamber, and the consequences of that, the Doctor is brought back to Gallifrey. But is he still the Doctor?

Having also being shot by the prototype Dalek, the Fourth Doctor starts regenerating, being prompted by an Elixir made by the now wiped out Sisterhood of Karn, similar to the events of the Night of the Doctor. As a result the Doctor's life is changed...

With this regeneration, the next incarnation emerges (portrayed by Colin Baker), an incarnation who is no longer the Doctor, but now the Warrior. This new incarnation is determined to finish his mission and wipe out the Daleks. In simple terms, this basically creates a Doctor if the War Doctor incarnation came earlier, and the Time War is a direct ripple effect of this moment.

Sometimes, it's arguably frustrating that the moral scruples of the Doctor get in the way of them doing what is maybe best for the universe. Moments where this has happened include the Sontaran Atmos Invasion, countless times fighting the Master and the aforementioned Genesis. But imagine the outcome had he not held back?

Should the Whoniverse be a safer place, at the cost of the Doctor not holding back?

Forgetting your feelings towards this original period of the show, if you breakdown each incarnation, if there was ever to be an alternate War Doctor, the Sixth Doctor definitely tops that list.

But this isn't the only version of the 'Doctor' in this series...


6. Doctor Variants

Doctor Who
BBC

Similar to the variants of the MCU, this altering of the time creates many aberrant timelines, and therefore many Doctors.

Time has basically splintered as a result of the chaos caused by altering time in such a monumental way. The tampering of time has left many possible futures exposed, such as if the Doctor's life remained on track.

The first story, Dust Devil, also features the more familiar Sixth Doctor, still travelling with Peri, but they come across this breaking time. Whilst on one of their usual adventures, the world around them starts to break up and the Doctor can see his own death.

To deal with these "aberrations", the Warrior sends two 'temporal bullets' to deal with his doppelgänger. This is a very clear declaration of intent. The Warrior wants to wipe out any potential threats to his power, and goes to the extent of hunting down his own variants.

In order to try and avert this threat on his life, the Doctor must seek out his own death, to confuse the 'temporal bullets', but in the end this is a failed attempt and he dies anyway.

But all this thus far has only been the first adventure of the set, what about the rest?


5. The Twin Daleks

Daleks Doctor Who
BBC

I've said it before, and I'll say it again, Big Finish master Dalek variants. Whether it's the Time Controller, Strategist or Overseer, they make the Daleks so original even after hours and hours of content with them.

This second tale features the Unified Skaroan Alliance Military and heading up their ranks is the Twin Daleks. As it says on the tin, the Twin Daleks literally consists of two Dalek mutants within one shell. This Dalek even claims the Warrior as their creator, being forged in the fire of the incubation chamber destruction.

The forces now amassed on Skaro, no longer at war with themselves and consisting of much fewer Daleks, are the direct result of the Doctor's actions destroying their incubation chambers. As a result of this, the Daleks never become the future of Skaro, but it does put a target directly on the 'Doctor That Was'.

Also, due to the Doctor being saved when he was picked out of time, his original method of escape, the Time Ring, was left on Skaro to be used to their advantage. With this, the Unified Skaroan Alliance conquer time, and go on to win the Time War.

And when we say conquer time, that includes Gallifrey itself...


4. Alternate Trial Of A Time Lord

Doctor Who
BBC

So with an unstoppable Skaroan Alliance, how do they get past the immovable object that is their arch nemesis, the Warrior?

For the second adventure of the set, the Warrior is placed on trial, but he is unsure why. An elaborate plot unravels, where he figures out what is going on, and who is behind this.

Placed on trial, similar to the Sixth Doctor's Season 23, the Warrior is set to be 'contained' in his own timeline due to the Genocide he committed on Skaro. It is revealed the Celestial Intervention Agency itself is working for the Alliance after they conquered Gallifrey.

In the end, this timeline is contained by the Warrior, working alongside his oldest friend, the Master. The two of them trap this universe within a Carrisent Particum, the device the Alliance planned to contain the Warrior in, allowing the events of the story to never take place.

As a result, the Warrior sees visions of this potential event, allowing him to potentially navigate his destiny away from it. Once again, this Doctor That Was is stirring up time.

So with further catastrophe avoided, what does it look like when the Time Lords remain the ultimate force to beat in this Time War?


3. The Difference Office

Doctor Who
BBC

Gallifrey in the main timeline of Who has always been a shifty place, but Gallifrey is so dark in this universe that Time Lords seek to kill themselves, in the past.

To tackle this, the CIA (Celestial Intervention Agency) starts the Difference Office, a branch of Time Lords who seek out and remove Time Lords who attempt to kill themselves. However, these 'suicides' do not take place in the present. These Time Lords seek to tackle their present guilt, by eliminating their past.

The Difference Office is set up at the request of the Warrior, now Lord President of Gallifrey. It's creation definitely hints this version of the war is far worst than that in the main Whoniverse.

One such victim of the Difference Office is much loved Big Finish spin off, Gallifrey, main character Narvin. Like many victims of this shady organisation, Narvin wished to stop his own horrific actions in this Time War, changing the past to change the present.

This department is even partially led by an alternate Romana, a version of the Time Lady who obviously never travelled with the Doctor. She was uncomfortable with the work but still carried out the orders of her Lord President.

But the plot of the finale for this set, is how and why is there another man on Gallifrey with the face of the Warrior?


2. A Different Android Invasion

Doctor Who
BBC

For this finale, the Warrior appears to being troubled by yet another doppelgänger, but why are they on Gallifrey?

This story combines two Tom Baker stories, the Android Invasion and the Invasion of Time. The two stories crossover by the android duplicates of the Kraals invading Gallifrey, all as a part of the Dalek's plot in this Time War.

In their original timeline, the Kraal's are not a huge threat. They're basically just a villain of the week and not considered a species to rival the Daleks, Cybermen or Sontarans. So how do they invade Gallifrey arguably so easily? Are the Time Lords weakened due to fighting this new Time War? Or is the deception of using an Android with the Warriors face simply distracting enough to blind them?

In the end it's revealed the Kraal leader Styggronis working for the Alliance and the Daleks, and even offers to fight them to end the war. However, the Warrior instead chooses vengeance, and kills him, hammering home one last time, the Doctor is no more.

This new Whoniverse is brutal. And whilst we've seen forces amass to take on Gallifrey before, it's arguably never been to this extent. So we'll see what happens in the next series.

With the alterations to this new Whoniverse covered, how does this series actually fare?


1. Review

Doctor who Big Finish
BBC

So, we've dived into this release and what it's done to the Whoniverse, but was it worth it?

Short answer: Yes!

This is Big Finish at its most intelligent. This series craves relistens because the story is so mind-blending, but also gripping that you'll just want to revisit it.

Some stories bog themselves down by trying to be too complex or overly smart, especially when it comes to time travel, but these stories make you think. You'll definitely want to re-listen to this piece revelations together.

Granted, these moments now take place in a different, 'Unbound' universe, but that just opens up a brand new sand box for Who to play in. With new rules, this allows for a different scope for this series to take.

This set has really allowed Colin Baker to flex his acting chops, bringing in so many exceptional performances as both the Warriors, and these other Doctor variants. The rest of the cast are also on the usual Big Finish top form, bringing the words of the script to life marvellously.

This is certainly a new classic for Big Finish, and one of their most exciting releases to date!


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a simple man, trying to make my way in the universe