Could Claras journey be that of the failed companion? Weve established that an encounter with the Doctor changes a person but that doesnt mean its always for the better. In the series eight episode Into the Dalek Clara calls herself the Doctors carer. He replies Yeah, my carer. She cares so I dont have to. But does she care anymore? Every time we see Clara this series shes a little bit harder, a little more willing to use other people to achieve her own ends no matter the consequences to their safety. When Cass calls her on this Clara declares Ive learned from the Doctor how to get done what need to be done. Contrast this with Amy from the series seven episode A Town Called Mercy, also written by Toby Whithouse. When the Doctor picks up the gun and decides to become judge, jury and executioner Amy is the voice of reason and compassion. She is the one who brings the Doctor back from the slippery slope of self righteousness. I dont believe Clara would have stopped him. She may even have leveled the gun herself. We pick and choose what we take from the lessons we are taught. Amy ended her life as an artist but Clara is well on the way to becoming a general. ODonnell references a Minister of War in her conversation with the Doctor, might that turn out to be Clara? While Before the Flood is not as solid as the previous three episodes it is filled with intriguing themes and thoughtful commentary. Other than the Fisher King, the characters are well written and well played. The death of ODonnell was heart breaking especially since it occurred so soon after her giddy reaction to traveling in the TARDIS. Bennetts quiet fury at the Doctor is realistic and thought provoking. Purposeful and character-driven, series nine is a strong one so far and I continue to look forward to what we will see in the future.
Mary Ogle is the author and illustrator of “Orangeroof Zoo” a whimsical tale of magical realism told through the pages of a coloring book for adults. Working as a professional artist in the digital medium, Mary’s commissions have included everything from fine art to fan art, book cover design, illustration and book layout. Find more of Mary’s work at www.maryogle.com. Mary currently finds inspiration in the Ojai Valley, residing in a snug little cottage with a recalcitrant cat.
