How I Met Your Mother: 10 Unforgettable Running Jokes

Coming up on two months after the finale, the show is still as hilarious as ever.

How I Met Your Mother recently ended a nine-year journey in which millions of viewers eagerly waited for Tod Mosby to finally wrap up his meandering anecdote to his kids. When it finally came to an end, the result was more than a little shocking. Now that the dust has settled on what many fans saw as a disappointing finale, it's worth taking time to reflect on the series' strong points. It's no accident that, nine seasons and 208 episodes after it first aired in 2005, How I Met Your Mother endured for such a long period of time while enjoying ratings that consistently exceeded eight million viewers per episode. Like its spiritual predecessor Friends, the show's strength lay in its focus on an incredibly engaging group of friends, while the overarching story-within-a-story framework was utilised so well that viewers often couldn't help but feel like they were part of the gang. Added to this was an ever-growing arsenal of running gags, catchphrases, and quasi-scientific musings that rang true in so many social situations for those watching at home. Many of these recurring elements inevitably involved joker-in-chief Barney Stinson, but even his more outlandish moments wouldn't have had such an impact without the group dynamic of the other four main characters. This list takes a nostalgic look back at the series' finest running jokes, ranging from major plot points to nonsensical asides. In each case, they showcase the irresistible balance between sincerity and silliness that became a hallmark of the show and kept fans coming back for more. For those of you who are starting out or currently making your way through the series, be warned that there are SPOILERS ahead. Before we move on, here are some honourable mentions: Puzzles (why would you name a bar €œPuzzles€? That's the puzzle!) Tantrum! High Fives The Five Doppelgangers (especially Moustache Marshall) Barney's Job (€œPlease€) The Proclaimers

10. Glen McKenna

First appeared in: 'Intervention' Call it formulaic, but the classic sitcom trope of breaking a priceless object is pretty funny when it's taken to the extreme lengths it is here. Let's face it €“ watching expensive stuff break can be hilarious, and pricey single malt scotch whisky Glen McKenna is no exception. We saw bottle after bottle of the expensive beverage shatter on the floor over the years. Ted and Barney each dropped one during their stay at the Farhampton Inn, while Robin and Lily were forced to improvise a substitute out of chocolate syrup and hand sanitiser after breaking one during a Princess Bride-inspired sword fight. Fortunately, there was always enough comic timing here to prevent repeated instances of this joke from becoming stale. After half a season spent trying €“ and failing €“ to secure an intact bottle for Barney and Robin's wedding, this shaggy dog story provided a final flourish when Darren, the slimeball lead singer of The Mother's band €œSuper Freakonomics€, bumped into Ted to send yet another one flying. The result was a neat bit of narrative closure during an otherwise chaotic season, as Ted's response (read: a right hook to the jaw) prompted The Mother to buy him a drink out of gratitude before they had even met. Her choice? A glass of 35 year-old Glen McKenna that, to the group's surprise, had been available at the bar all along.

9. Telepathic Conversations

First appeared in: 'Mary the Paralegal' It's safe to say that the How I Met Your Mother gang were incredibly close. So close, in fact, that they possessed the ability to carry out entire conversations without saying a single word. And even though the quintet were virtually inseparable for most of the series' run, each member of the group occasionally felt the need to discuss something without the knowledge of anybody else who happened to be present. This gag acted as a reminder that the show's writers were never afraid to stray outside the limits of reality, making the idea of telepathy seem as ordinary as a casual chat over a cup of coffee. Soon enough, these conversations even began to involve people from outside the gang, with one highlight coming in the form of the telepathic dialogue between Ted and Gary Blauman as both tried to impress the same girl €“ with their knowledge of Teddy Roosevelt's autobiography, no less. The gang were still at it by the time season nine came around, with Barney, Ted, Lily and Robin all fawning over Darren's flattery via the dialogue taking place in their heads. This gag came across as little more than an amusing curio when it was introduced, and yet it seems that the gang's inexplicable telepathic link hadn't faltered by the end of the show's nine-season run.

8. The Pineapple Incident

First appeared in: 'The Pineapple Incident' In season one, the How I Met Your Mother gang did a 'Hangover' four years before that film had even been released, presenting Ted with the assorted remains of a drunken one-night stand that he couldn't remember. Among them were a burn on his coat, a sprained ankle, and a single pineapple on his bedside table. Of all the questions that lingered on fans' minds in the lead-up to the finale, The Pineapple Incident remains an enigma to this day. During the episode, Ted was left piecing together scattered memories of his night as a result of drinking five shots of €œRed Dragon€, a blood-red concoction created by McLaren's bartender Carl. While he was able to determine that the girl in his bed wasn't Robin (and that, to his relief, his record of being €œvomit-free since '93€ remained intact), the secret of the pineapple was left unsolved. Creator Craig Thomas has allegedly hinted at a potential video that could clear up outstanding questions surrounding certain elements of the show. Could this mean that the Pineapple Incident will finally reach its long-awaited conclusion? The answer could well be hidden away in an upcoming DVD release or the series' hotly-anticipated alternate ending. For now, though, the mystery lives on.

7. Barney's Catchphrases

First appeared in: 'Pilot' While this entry isn't strictly speaking a joke, Barney Stinson's backlog of mottos, mantras and verbal witticisms simply had to be here. In fact, he has so many memorable catchphrases that they could make up a list of their own. From How I Met Your Mother's very first episode, his cocksure approach to money, romance and laser tag earned Neil Patrick Harris' character a legion of fans that earmarked him as one of the most €“ ahem €“ awesome aspects of the show. Before long, viewers around the world were imitating his turn of phrase, referring to things as €œlegendary€ and even throwing in the occasional €œwait for it€ for good measure (in the show, Barney even used this technique to bridge the gap between seasons two and three). Whether he was feeding his competitive streak with the declaration of €œchallenge accepted€ or suffixing his ridiculous narratives with a curt €œtrue story€, Barney undoubtedly provided one of the show's most consistent forms of comic relief over the years. It's refreshing that, even when Barney mellowed in later seasons, these lines kept popping up from time to time. It's part of what made his growth one of the most satisfying feats of character development in recent sitcom memory, toning down some of the his more juvenile playboy tendencies without dulling his sense of fun €“ or his eternal willingness to €œsuit up€. Then, of course, there's the small matter of his fateful involvement in the plot of the pilot; after all, where would How I Met Your Mother be if Barney had never uttered €œhave you met Ted?€ to Robin in MacLaren's pub?

6. Interventions

First appeared in: 'Intervention' How I Met Your Mother's protagonists weren't without their faults. Really, what made the group function as a unit was their ability to hone in on their friends' moments of weakness and set things straight €“ usually in the form of a good old-fashioned intervention. The trend started with an attempt to help their mutual friend Stuart kick his drinking habit in season two. It turned out to be such a success that, from that point onwards, interventions became the remedy of choice for almost any worrying habit within the group; Barney's magic tricks, Lily's British accents, Robin's spray tan habit, and Marshall's excessively tall Dr. Seuss-style hat were just some of the obsessions that prompted the banner to return to its familiar spot above Ted's fireplace. Eventually (and perhaps inevitably), the gang's obsession with the procedure even led to €“ you guessed it €“ an €œIntervention€ intervention. Allegedly Josh Radnor's favourite running gag of the series, it's hard to beat the moment of realisation when it dawns on each of the characters that it's their turn for the intervention treatment. Heavy-handed or not, it addressed something that How I Met Your Mother was ultimately all about €“ a bunch of friends all looking out for each other €“ with the show's characteristically offbeat charm.

5. The Naked Man

First appeared in: 'The Naked Man' The Naked Man is the Hail Mary of romantic advances €“ a move so crude that even Barney didn't come up with it before its discovery by the group. Instead, this joke was the product of Mitch, who gave it a try when Robin stepped outside to take a phone call after their blind date. As the name implies, the idea was to strip off while his unsuspecting date was in another room, before relying on the resulting mixture of surprise and pity in order to convince her to sleep with him €“ a technique that Mitch so eloquently referred to as €œshock and awww€. It's absurd, of course. And yet in the skewed world of How I Met Your Mother, it somehow worked €“ two thirds of the time, to be precise. That patchy success rate was later confirmed by failed attempts from Barney, sleazy news anchor Don, and Mitch himself. Bizarre blind dates aside, this technique helped Ted get €œback into the game€ after Stella left him at the altar, seemingly setting him on the path to recovery and even prompting a Dark Knight-esque monologue for his saviour Mitch. It also makes this list by virtue of spawning Lily's equally funny list of €œ50 Reasons to Have Sex€, which includes entries like €œto time an egg€ and €œbecause they have air-conditioning and you don't€.

4. The Bro Code

First appeared in: 'The Goat' For fans of How I Met Your Mother, the Bro Code is gospel. According to history (or at least Barney's warped version of the past), Barnabus Stinson was compelled to invoke the book's rules by a dispute between Benjamin Franklin and George Washington in 1776. Today, you can buy a paperback copy at any good book shop. Articles of The Bro Code include such sage pearls of wisdom as the Three Days Rule (waiting three days after getting somebody's number before calling), the Lemon Law (the ability to call off a first date within the first five minutes), and the Hot/Crazy Scale (stating that a potential date is only allowed to be as crazy as they are attractive). It also features a tracklist for Barney's iconic €œget psyched mix€ €“ an essential component of any legendary night out. The Bro Code was the subject of grave conflict in the series' later episodes, sitting at the centre of a particularly strained moment in season nine's 'The Broken Code'. When Barney discovered the extent of Ted's ongoing feelings towards Robin, he retaliated in passive-aggressive fashion under the stipulation that €œa bro shall not have a weird moment with another bro's fiance€. In doing so, he hit upon the finer points of How I Met Your Mother's nuanced love triangle in a way that only The Bro Code could.

3. The Playbook

First appeared in: 'The Playbook' The Playbook: because one iconic book just isn't enough for Barney Stinson. Like The Bro Code before it, this piece of literature is littered with Barney's unique brand of rules and advice, offering a lengthy backlog of tricks for wannabe pick-up artists. After emerging as a coping mechanism for Barney's initial split from Robin, The Playbook represented everything extravagant about Barney the player, from elaborate costumes to fake backstories (Swiss opera singer and balloonist Lorenzo Von Matterhorn is a particular standout) that were as finely-tuned as they were fantastical. This gag undoubtedly reached its zenith when months of planning and preparation culminated in an intricate scheme known simply as €œThe Robin€. Spanning multiple episodes, it employed hidden cameras, mistletoe, and a fake relationship with Robin's arch-nemesis Patrice as part of the elaborate wedding proposal that paved the way for season nine's nuptials between Barney and Robin. Rather appropriately, Barney went on to pass on the wisdom of the Playbook (in napkin-form) to a pair of aspiring young letharios on the night before his wedding €“ a simple gesture that had monumental implications for a character that once clung so tightly to his repertoire of tricks and gimmicks.

2. Robin Sparkles

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IY_bhVSGKEg First appeared in: 'Slap Bet' Robin first hinted at a mysterious secret from her past in season two, prompting a high-stakes bet between Marshall and Barney in the process (more on that later). Even the most ardent How I Met Your Mother fans would have struggled to predict just what that entailed at the time; of all the possibilities, a career as '90s teen pop star Robin Sparkles was a far cry from the Robin who would later spend her evenings breaking noses at the Hoser Hut. Upon its discovery, this really was the joke that kept on giving. First, there was her breakout hit 'Let's Go To the Mall', which introduced us to a robot sidekick and an inexplicably catchy chorus. Then came the forlorn follow-up 'Sandcastles In the Sand', which boasted truly inspired lyrics like €œyou're good at pull-ups and have radical hair / I hate my dad, he's so unfair.€ On top of her questionable grunge transformation as €œRobin Daggers€ and the cheesy Canadian TV show 'Space Teens', this entry also had a part to play in more serious aspects of the plot, kick-starting Barney and Robin's relationship after a night spent mercilessly mocking her music videos. Mostly, though, this gag will be remembered for representing How I Met Your Mother at its most surreal.

1. The Slap Bet

First appeared in: 'Slap Bet' Barney and Marshall weren't always the closest characters in How I Met Your Mother's social dynamic. In fact, during its opening run of episodes much of the pair's dialogue seemed to centre around competing for the title of Ted's best friend. So when the Slap Bet came around in season two, it added another dimension to their relationship while acting as a study in maintaining and dispelling tension over the years. Here's how it worked: when it transpired that Robin's secret related to her musical past rather than a career in the adult entertainment industry (as Barney had assumed), Marshall earned the right to slap Barney five times at any interval €“ a total that Barney then raised by a further three slaps in exchange for ridding himself of the Ducky Tie. Make no mistake, Lily's role as €œSlap Bet Commissioner€, along with Marshall's legal background and Barney's general love of rules and regulations, made sure that this wager was taken very seriously by all parties involved. Cue multiple seasons of build-up to each impending slap and a series of side-gags including the yearly ritual of €œSlapsgiving€, a self-titled family-friendly board game "for ages 9-99", and the celebratory power ballad 'You Just Got Slapped' (not to mention the delightful cover by Boyz II Men). Things were rather less overblown when this joke finally came to an end, with Marshall slapping Barney one last time in a bid to help him focus before getting married. As far as wedding gifts go, it was a thoughtful one, freeing Barney from the fear that had plagued him for almost seven seasons while calling time on a gag that will be missed almost as much as the show itself. Did we miss any great ones? Let us know in the comments?

Contributor
Contributor

History graduate, writer, and long-suffering Spurs fan interested in all things music and sports-related. Once briefly held the title of world's youngest person. You can follow me on Twitter here: https://twitter.com/sgfcarter