Star Trek Picard: Every Major Character Ranked

Now that its all over (for the moment) lets see how Picard's new crew all shape up.

Star Trek Picard
CBS

Star Trek Picard has introduced a host of new players to the franchise and for the most part they're winners. There are returning faces and new faces, mentions and callbacks and there's varying levels of greatness. This list breaks down the main players.

Characters like Oh, Riker and Troi aren't here because, great though they were, their scenes weren't enough to rank as major characters. This wasn't the easiest decision, as Number One deserves to wag his tail as the top character on any list.

With the series finale now streaming, there have been major revelations about these characters and a very real SPOILER WARNING is now in effect - do not read on if you are worried about hearing something that may spoil the last episode for you. Though in truth, if you're reading this article, you have probably seen the episode and you know that it was Kirk all along.

Bearing that in mind, the character rankings would almost certainly change as more episodes become available once the second season goes into production. We already know that Guinan will be back for season two and unless they get it very wrong, she's going on a top ten list in a heartbeat! In the meantime, here are the main characters of Star Trek Picard ranked.

16. Data - Special Mention

Data Star Trek Picard
CBS Media Ventures

Data is being ranked separately from the other characters as he is not so much a character himself in this series as he is the catalyst for all of the events that follow. How does one rank that against the others on this list?

Brent Spiner returns to the role that defined him, delivering in the beginning simple and fun cameos as Data. Seeing him play cards in Ten Forward and then painting in France were both fun, touching scenes to share with Picard. His name is on everyone's lips throughout the season and he becomes as much of a driving force as anything else that we have seen in the franchise.

His scenes in Et in Arcadia Ego Pt. 2 however are absolutely phenomenal. The scene in Picard's study where Data pleasantly asks for death delivers on his journey in a profound, moving way. Life, that very life he has always sought, is precious because it is finite. Picard may have been given a new lease but Data has not - and that's fine.

The death of Data in Nemesis, going out in a blaze of glory, drew the ire of many fans, surprising the producers and Spiner himself. Using this as a jumping off point for Picard was a way to both address these concerns and retire the story of the Next Generation. Data is a superb character, played to perfection. He is the spark that ignites this series - he is most certainly not at the bottom of this list. He is the beginning of it.


15. Narek

Star Trek Picard Narek
CBS

Harry Treadaway is a very good actor and given the right material, he can truly make a role shine. His performance in Penny Dreadful is one of the highlights of the show and I predict his star will only continue to rise.

The fact that he sits so low on this list is a reflection of the role he is given. Narek is just - flat. He's not menacing and shouldn't have been written as such. He is supposed to be the big threat to Soji for the season and instead he comes off like an immature, whining mess. His relationship with his sister seems to be fuelled by resentment and anger but, apart from a few throwaway lines, there is nothing to further explore this. Added to that, there is a reference to a brother that died and then being the black sheep of the family and a wash out from the Zhat Vash.

The character just seemed to be written on the fly, rather than fully planned out. His eventual attempt to work with the La Sirena crew to stop the synthetics is a twist that wasn't earned, as tears do not a turncoat make.

If Narek is to return for the second season, it is with the hope that he will be given slightly more to do. His backstory is a flop, so hopefully his ongoing story will be a lot stronger.


14. Narissa

Picard Narissa
CBS

The season's second major villain suffers from many of the same issues as Narek, lacking a decent backstory or much in the way of defining character traits that would engage the audience. With respect to Peyton List, who does a fine job with the material provided, her entire arc appears to be 'Evil', with not much in the way of motivation.

She ranks slightly higher than Narek here due to the revelations in Broken Pieces. We discover in the opening montage that she is not, in fact, evil. She is working to rid the universe of a grave threat to all organic life. She is a good guy, albeit one with a dark moral centre. The writing of this aside, List delivers on this and it only goes to highlight that given stronger material, she could have delivered a much more memorable, scene stealing character.

As this revelation was left so late in the season, what we were delivered was a very Cersei-and-Jamie relationship between her and Narek, with nothing really to build upon. She is duplicitous, that much is sure. She killed Hugh and so she might be out of favour for a while with the fandom, but this is a show where murderers are forgiven easily (more on that coming). It is highly unlikely that she was killed by Seven and so it is assumed she will return for Season 2, however hopefully with a stronger arc to rally behind.


13. Altan Inigo Soong

Altan Soong
CBS

Stepping out of the crowd and into Star Trek history, another Soong is introduced in the series penultimate episode. While it is always a treat to see Brent Spiner back on screen, there was a slight contrivance about the sudden introduction of another member of the Soong family. It is surely not beyond the realm of possibility for there to be more of them out there yet the character was a little forced. His name is good fun all the same.

He effectively exists for two reasons, plot wise and production wise. Plot - he exists to save Picard's life by creating the Golem. Production - he was clearly an excuse to get Spiner out of the make-up that the audience is so used to seeing him in. With the exception of the Golem, he plays a relatively minor role in the series. He may have been the father of the synthetics but it was a role that could have just as easily been filled by Bruce Maddox - there was no need for it to be Soong.

Spiner does what he always does in that he delivers an excellent performance in the time given to him on screen. He is the only character to truly call out Juratti for the murder of Maddox and for this alone he rises above others on this list. While we may never see him again, for a brief moment, the Soong family was alive again.


12. Bruce Maddox

Bruce Maddox
CBS Media Ventures

https://i.redd.it/6jw7zdayu7d41.jpg

Poor Bruce. In the show, he lives to die, spurring the others into greater action. There might be a sense of justice here after his initial treatment of Data, but as a character on a new series, there's no avoiding feeling slightly short-changed.

With the novel The Last Best Hope, there is an expansion on his character and the efforts he went to to aid the Romulan rescue. He is directly responsible for the design of the A500's and is then blamed for their failure. His escape across the stars to join Soong is dubious but understandable and he is the one that manages to recreate Data in a sense, bringing back the man through a single neuron. Yet very little of this is experienced along with Maddox himself and is all added through exposition. The audience is told he was brilliant. The audience is told he had a love affair with Juratti. The audience is told he was on the run. The character gets roughly ten minutes of screentime and it simply isn't enough when so much of the drama happens because of him. This may contrast with the point made about Data but Data had seven seasons and four films to expand on. Maddox was given more weight that felt due.

John Ales does what he can with the few moments of time given to him but if there is any justice, he will return in flashbacks in the next season.


11. Jurati

Star Trek Picard
CBS

Agnes Jurati, as written, doesn't work. Alison Pill is a terrific actress but the arc is all over the place. At first, she is introduced as a brilliant scientific mind (never really expanded on as the season goes on) and then as the hero who feels the need to accompany the new crew. This is a deception that is revealed as she murders Maddox and then allows the ship to be tracked, until she doesn't. Then she turns good and everything is fine.

There was a possibility for greatness in this character. If Maddox had to die, then Jurati could have been the symbol of learning to live with a devastating mistake. Instead, she is light comic relief and moments of dark introspection. There is no development. Her sins are forgiven instantly.

She is shown a vision of a potential future and murders a man in cold blood, then changes her mind through a conversation. Why? Why couldn't there have been more here? If the end point was to have her become a staunch supporter of synthetics, couldn't she have resisted slightly longer. After all, the synth colony does try to wipe out all organic life. The Romulans were right!

Jurati was rushed to the point of sacrificing character development. Pill acts, rather than a tortured scientist attempting to make amends, as a petulant sufferer who has moments of breaking the fourth wall to become the stand in for the audience in some of her questions. This could have been the arc of the season and instead it became a damp squib.


10. Zhaban

Picard Zhaban
CBS

Zhaban, combined with Laris, serves to show to the audience the relationship that Picard has built up with the Romulans he tried to save. This is important because much of the rest of the series does what it can to show that their race almost universally hates him. Zhaban also serves to explain away the inconsistency of the Romulan forehead ridges - he's a Northerner, of course!

The character on his own is somewhat quiet and contemplative, closer in his actions to his Vulcan cousins that to his Romulan wife. Given more screen time, it would be well worth exploring the backstory of this relationship. We know from the prequel comics that both he and Laris were ex-Tal Shiar, and defected to help Picard. He, in fact, was the slower of the two in switching sides but once he did, he fell into place as a firm supporter.

The only issue with his character to date is that we the audience need to see more to get a true understanding of what makes him tick. For example, are there any more relatives out there, potentially offering another temptation to switch again? Through Zhaban, there is the chance to truly explore what is left of the Romulan Empire. We know from the finale that there are at least 218 vessels out there - so where are they staying? Zhaban can be our guide if the producers make the (correct) decision to bring him back for season two.


9. Elnor

Picard Elnor
CBS Media Ventures

The issue with Elnor is not the writing or the performance. The issue here is that there wasn't enough of him! This character was very clearly written to stand in as a son for Picard, struggling first with the rejection he felt as a child and then growing to love the man again through their trials.

On a base level, the show succeeds in pulling this off. However, his lack of screen time doesn't allow the audience to really warm to him other than to have him deliver some funny lines and excellent fighting moments. Evan Evagoria's portrayal is honest and fresh and perhaps moreso than any of the other characters on the show, Elnor is the most consistent. He is what he is.

The moment in Stardust City Rag where he laments the fact he can't be anything other than Elnor should have been given more time to unfold. Rios comments that the kid wouldn't last in the big wide universe, despite the fact he is a killing machine. His vulnerability and openness required more time than was allotted.

These are all issues that could be addressed in the next season so it is with profound hope that he ranks here. Hopefully, the writers don't feel that they have established his character sufficiently, which would be a disservice to Elnor and to Evagoria. There is potential greatness here, given enough material to work with.


8. Hugh

Hugh Picard
CBS

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/proxy/kJ9weqm0d9Yz7S8X5PjK601B3CA_e_0W5Y9y76rp_yd5thuBUnacyItMarSXHvBhWE2z4iQrGK6lsOEc4gNsVYPI4JMSERtLQthA8UTIzd2-J6UlIYKdvCIHEvaj2IyZRA

Upon learning of the return of Hugh, the audience knew that the Borg were going to play a massive part in Star Trek Picard. To an extent, that's true. While they were very much a sub-plot of the season, it was a surprising highlight of the season to see Hugh and Jean-Luc embrace as old friends. While their relationship had been initially frayed in the Next Generation, seeing this reunion was a genuinely lump-in-the-throat moment.

However, Hugh unfortunately suffered a sad fate. He was a tool to maneuver other characters into place rather than one given his own arc. His death at the hands of Narissa was a waste. While it served to move Elnor into his new relationship with Seven, it felt an unnecessary addition to the plot. Couldn't he have been captured or harmed in some other way? Alas the sad fate of Hugh will have to stick but he brought the struggle of returning from the collective to the front in a way that was different from both Picard and Seven. They found their humanity - Hugh adapted what being in a collective was. His genuine anguish at the deaths of the other Ex-Bs was heart wrenching as these were his new family and his children, guided by his experience, snuffed out in a cold, callous manner. It may not have been the conclusion to his arc that fans of the Next Generation wanted but Jonathan Del Arco delivered in spades on what was offered, cementing Hugh as one of the great Trek guest stars.


7. Laris

Star Trek Picard Laris
CBS

Laris earns her spot here for almost contradictory reasons to the ones that have come before. In her short screen time, her character was perfectly defined and played fantastically by Orla Brady. Never has the word 'feckers' been spoken in Star Trek before and I didn't know how much I needed it until that moment.

An Ex-Tal Shiar agent who has turned away from violence and is now fiercely loyal to Picard. That's her character summary in a single sentence and yet Brady manages to take that and imbue the character with such heart and personality that it feels as though we have known her for years. She appears here over Zhaban as she has slightly more screen time and uses that time with more efficiency.

It would be an absolute crime for her not to return in the next season as, not only could her relationship to Picard develop further but she could easily act as a mother-figure to Elnor, teaching him that there is more to life than the ways of the nuns that he was raised with.

Laris is one of the strongest new characters introduced in this show, an example of when the writing is good, it is very good. Her skills are supreme, she clearly cares about the world around her and there is love in her eyes, even as she gives out to Picard like a child. Please, more Laris!


6. Soji

Picard Soji
CBS

This one is slightly more difficult to rank. Soji is a slightly one note character, but Isa Briones manages to flesh that out. She moves between quiet contemplation and serenity, to wild anger and passion with relative ease. There is no real connection at all with the fact that she is borne from a node of Data. Riker says he would recognise that head tilt anywhere - that is stretching to the point of disbelief.

However, there are moments in the show when she rises above these issues. The scene between Picard and her, where they discuss Data, stands as one of, if not the, scene of the series. She works so effortlessly with Picard here that a true love and understanding passes between them. Not for a second did her turn to the genocidal side seem real and that is a failing on the part of the writers.

The confusion that the character must feel though is something that is handled well - it may not have been enough to really get the audience to believe she would destroy everything, but her anger is both well founded and displayed well by Briones. A refreshing choice to make her refuse any of Narek's nonsense of guilt is enjoyable though - there's no consideration that 'he might be a nice guy really'. She wants to end him and it makes sense.

There is the chance for greatness here and one that is hopefully coming in the next year.


5. The Holograms

Picard Rios Holograms
CBS

When we were first introduced to the Holograms, it could have gone one of two ways - necessary addition or farce. Arguably, it comes down in the middle and they are best described as necessary farce. Star Trek Picard is a dark show, even with the moments of optimism and light. People are murdered, families are torn apart and existence is almost ended by mad robots.

But, we have Enoch, Emmet, Emil, Mr. Hospitality and Ian. They shouldn't work but they absolutely do. Santiago Cabrera delivers a masterclass in acting as he plays the five different holograms and, a couple of dodgy accents aside, he shows five distinctly different characters in doing so (not to mention his sixth character, returning later in this list!).

Already debates have sprung up as to which hologram is the best (a coin toss between Emmet and Enoch for this writer) but therein lies their strength. They break the heavy mood of the show without spoiling it in any way. The stand out scene is of course their meeting with Raffi on the holodeck but each of them have their own moments along the way.

Enoch at the conn, Emmet battling the Bird of Prey, Ian....in general, Mr. Hospitality with his clipboard and Emil failing hilariously as an EMH for Maddox - they are unique and engaging, they are the fun that the show sorely needs.


4. Seven Of Nine

Star Trek Picard Seven of Nine
CBS

When it was announced that Seven would be in the show, the collective fandom lost its mind. And for good reason. With her initial appearance startling anyone who didn't watch the opening credits, her first episode proved slightly divisive. The murder of Bjayzle seemed quite out of character but thankfully this is addressed later in the season. The new straight talking, hard drinking Seven was a huge departure from the Seven of Voyager but it works in the confines of this show.

What came out of nowhere was the maternal relationship to Elnor. It was both sweet and surprising - his childlike view on the world versus her battle hardened take on things. She clearly cares for him and if this is a relationship that is to continue, then it is something that could become a highlight of the show going forward.

And then there's Raffi. Seven's romantic inclinations were touched on in Voyager but never explicitly explored. That shot of the two of them interlacing hands - it may become a romance, it may simply be a friendship. What is clear is that both women have seen and done a lot in their time. The two of them would make a strong pair and would be a team unlike any the franchise has seen before.

Seven's stand out moment though is her exchange with Picard. He is the only other person who truly understands her struggle. It is quiet and it is beautiful.


3. Rios

Picard Rios
CBS

The less said about the Irish hologram, the better.

The rest though - Rios is an absolute win when it comes to the new characters in the show. His introduction seems very tongue in cheek. Of course this swashbuckling captain would be smoking and drinking while having a piece of metal pulled out of his shoulder. Sure, why not? Let's be clear - Rios is not Riker and he's not going to be. Which is great, because there is a real character here. He is a pirate because he has to be but, as Picard states so early on, he is a Starfleet man just waiting for the right call back to duty.

He is haunted by what he has seen but that is because it hurt his moral centre. He is not a man who is ok with the murder of innocents and he will defend those where he can, when he can. It is perhaps a bit early in the show to have him portrayed as the OTT hustler in Stardust City Rag but when combined with the various holograms, it's not the most ridiculous we've seen him yet.

Santiago Cabrera has shown tremendous range already in the show, owning each scene that he is in and having an absolute blast while playing the holograms (yes ok, even the Irish one). He clearly cares for Picard and the rest of his crew and is a perfect Captain in the offing. Bring on the second season!


2. Raffi

Star Trek Picard
CBS

Raffi Muskier is the stand out new character from Star Trek Picard. There was a little back and forth in the beginning when they were trying to show her as the damaged but brilliant officer that she really is, but once she settles into the swing of things it is clear that Raffi owns every scene that she is in.

Michelle Hurd is an absolute credit to the show. She is maternal and yet in need of care. She is proficient and yet can ask for help. She is both the Ex-O and one of the crew. She's everyone and she's a cut above the rest. Her relationship with Picard is more honest and open than we have previous seen him engage in. Even the bond we know he shares with Riker and Troi is a very difficult, slightly more separated one. Picard knows that she needs a mission and he gladly accepts her as part of it.

Its hard to give her enough praise. Aunty Raffi, a new favourite title, is just brilliant. Though she seems both angry and bitter in the beginning, she is in fact a deeply caring and kind person. Her son's rejection is a crime that must be corrected going forward, especially with her vindication. It remains to be seen whether her Starfleet commission will be reinstated but what is clear is that Raffi Musiker is a fantastic gift to the franchise so is Michelle Hurd.


1. Jean-Luc Picard

Star Trek Picard
CBS

Now Jean-Luc was always going to be the top of this list but it wasn't simply because the show is his namesake. Patrick Stewart is a world class act and is clearly emotionally invested in every scene that he is. So, criticisms out of the way quickly - he is perhaps too emotional in some scenes.

This is Captain Picard, a man known for his stoicism and clear head, something that this Picard is a little distant from. That's the same criticism though as Picard is not the Next Generation. So, comparing the characters, maybe Next Gen will win this one.

But, the above may seem silly when you consider that Stewart displays such a range of emotion and power in this role that it blows every other character off the screen. His scenes with Data are heart warming and heart breaking. His scenes with Soji show his strengths and failings as a man. His scenes with Raffi show the contrast between his personality and his Captaincy. His scenes with Riker warm the coldest soul.

Star Trek Picard was a mixed bag in terms of quality. When it was bad, it was schlocky and needed work. But, when it was good, it was great and up there with the best of the franchise. Patrick Stewart gets to show everyone why this is the one character that has an entire show named after them. Captain Picard is back, twisting and turning along the way and, no matter what the issues are, that is a good thing.


Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"