10 Terrifying Wrestling Moments That Still Scare Adults

Hoak Hogan beware, you're in for a scare.

Ultimate Warrior Halloween
WWE

Obviously, this list doesn't include harrowing, nausea-inducing moments. This is Halloween Content.

So it will not incorporate that time Matt Hardy narrowly avoided death on an AEW pay-per-view, Sid's fibula snapping in two, nor the idea that Randy Orton, who debuted precisely one year removed from WWE's last days as a mainstream concern and those two events perhaps are related, is entering his 18th year on top while cutting promos *even more slowly*.

Fear is a very difficult emotion to elicit in the pro wrestling arena, which is why the archetype has all but faded into view. Bray Wyatt's work descends into laughable shlock. That very opinion will enrage certain fans of his, but realistically, has he ever truly frightened you?

"Oh no! I fear he has ruined my chances with Alexa Bliss!!!" does not count as real fear, sorry.

The Dark Order weren't remotely scary, and so AEW reimagined the stable as a gaggle of endearing would-be babyfaces terrorised into a heel role by their monster of a leader.

The supernatural gimmick no longer works in an industry that is threatening to age out of itself - with one incredible exception...

10. Seven Scares Child Through Bedroom Window

Seven WCW.jpg
WWE Network

Seven is mostly hilarious, but he's also terrifying.

Because of the implication.

Seven quite literally scared adults; Turner Standards and Practices nixed the persona under the very reasonable presumption that he was a child abductor. Dig deeper into the verbiage, and it scans as even more disturbing.

In a vignette screened before this insane Dustin Rhodes repackage, a man, or an entity, or Ole f*ckin' Anderson, given that hilarious gruff voice, spoke to a young boy through his bedroom window. "What's under your bed? What's in your closet? Who is in your window? Come to me and live forever."

So this was weird, but the new character wasn't necessarily a n*nce. Perhaps Seven simply saw the face of God in children and nothing untoward was going on at all! But then Seven said "Join me in complete bliss, mmm, that's right!"

"Mmm, that's right" is what male pornographic actors say when their eighth inch is getting gobbled. What else could whoever have wrote this meant by "bliss"?!

"Awake my son," Seven said.

"My" son.

Was this even worse than the worst possible thing?

It was WCW in 1999, so most likely yes.


9. The Ultimate Warrior's WrestleMania VI Build Promo

Ultimate Warrior
WWE

In hindsight, it's no wonder the Ultimate Warrior didn't get over as the WWF's top babyface in 1990.

This might have something to do with him cutting the most sinister f*cking promo imaginable shortly before he was to assume the role, the dumb bugger.

Hulk Hogan reacting like God himself had just purchased the last remaining bottle of sun tan lotion before a visit to the beach with his daughter didn't much help. In the post-match, he conveyed the idea that he wasn't bested but just desperately unlucky.

The very best promo the Warrior ever cut, nonetheless, this was awesome because it stood in chilling contrast to his usual demented gibberish. Everything he said was as decipherable as it was disquieting.

Making awful, otherworldly sounds, as if he'd just manifested from an alternate dimension unthinkable in its evil, Warrior created a scene in which he compared the challenge in front of his opponent to a suicide mission. Was Hogan willing to "dispose" of the pilots? Was he willing to assume the controls?

Was he willing to SHOVE THAT CONTROL INTO A NOSEDIVE, HULK HOGAN?

That quiet/loud dynamic remains arresting in its power.

Still doesn't make the top 100 list of evil things Warrior ever said, which is...impressive?


8. Randy Savage Gets Bitten By Cobra

savage cobra
wwe

A seminal moment that traumatised the youth watching, everything about the angle was so perfect that it retains a sort of timeless power, all these years later. Some men are terrifying, and contrary to the intro, some retain the power to terrify in the pro wrestling arena - provided, ironically, that they aren't dressed for that purpose. Minoru Suzuki's facials, as an honourable mention, work as well as his stiff brutality to evoke that feeling.

None can inspire the same primal fear of a wild animal disturbing the order of civilisation.

In a superb escalation, Jake Roberts' heel character of the early '90s introduced here a cobra instead of the python. The old snake was a more symbolic threat. This cobra was something else; attacking in terrifying, random patterns its human prey was unable to register, that prey was a legitimately terrified Randy Savage who, while a master of conveying anguish, didn't much need to work. The cobra is uniquely terrifying because it is deadly, but its darting lunges are so fast that it feels, beyond the lens, capable of jumping back through it. And he he bit the man, too, in what was an expert work.

One of the all-time great heat angles, this continues to lunge through the numb husk the older wrestling fan develops to inspire fear three decades later.


7. The Gangstas Do Not Give A F*CK In Smoky Mountain Wrestling

New Jack
WWE

Such an awesome, dangerous energy radiated from the Gangstas in Smoky Mountain Wrestling.

An old-timey territory in philosophy far more than content, this was all positively futuristic. What an inspired pairing of act and promotion. SMW was the white picket fence. The Gangstas were the unwanted force that knew they weren't the evil. The fence obscured the real evil. This collision created a throbbing, ever-present friction engineered with a genius carny impulse. This was heat so palpable it was almost too assured.

The footage remains shocking to watch back now. Even though you know the animosity never did spill over from the bleachers to the ring, it still somehow threatens to. Everything is charged. New Jack knows that some of these people were predisposed to disliking him, and he dialled up that latent tension to prove it and inform his character.

Performance informed perception, and perception informed performance.

It all felt inexorable. New Jack would show his cheekbone to the braying front row with a grin, and the punch - and the riot - still seems moments away.

"Violence to you is a figure-four. Violence to me is taking a can of gas, pouring it on you, and setting it on fire!"

New Jack was the gasoline.


6. Brock Lesnar: Concussion Facilitator

brock lesnar randy orton finish
WWE.com

"That's a safe enough looking blade designed to open up a shallow cut...be a shame if...somebody didn't bother to use it, and instead used their trained elbow to open a legitimate hole in a human being's head, and then give them a concussion."

Why did WWE do this?

Obviously, the answer was to depict Brock Lesnar as the most credible and dangerous star in all of creation, with the ultimate aim of having Roman Reigns conquer him.

Lesnar had already squashed John Cena and ended the Undertaker's WrestleMania Streak. This was as unnecessary in the fiction as it was in reality. "This" being Lesnar raining down elbows onto Orton's skull and leaving him a jellied, concussed mess. It was a genuinely unsettling scene.

A secondary aim, Christ almighty, was to set up Brock Lesnar Vs. Shane McMahon. The idea of Shane McMahon avenging the man, the full-time decorated pro, that he himself couldn't even land a punch on was hysterical, or it would have been, had it not inspired utter nihilism.

"Ah man that's sick, that's sick!" Shane might have said, as Lesnar mutilated him.

A more accurate hypothetical scenario is that jumped-up little sh*t making Lesnar sell his shapeless triangle.

Lesnar, aware of this, bantered the idea off.


5. Doink The Clown Unsettles The Kids

Doink RAW
WWE Network

Before the descent into whacky midcard sh*te, with Ray Apollo underneath the paint, Matt Borne was incredible as the original Doink The Clown mostly lost to reduced history.

It was the perfect creepy gimmick because it was tethered to reality. Doink did not possess the supernatural powers that always look so hokey in a live arena and are never applied in a way that is to their benefit.

Doink was a skeevy degenerate who wore the clown paint, one was allowed to infer, because he was sinister and warped enough to simply want to make people uncomfortable. He was a very accomplished wrestler - his peak RAW matches were astounding, by the standards of the time - but like the best heels, he did awful things just to do them.

Bourne would locate the hard camera and stare into it with dead eyes, haunting the children on the sofa. He'd wear the smile on his face and then subvert it with a sick leer, as if to convey the idea that humanity itself was a decorative facade just because his own was lost within the external husk.

Doink was an effective daylight horror who knew that the real fear resided in the places we assume to be safe.


4. The First Mankind Vignettes

Mankind original
WWE

In contrast to Doink's unnerving quotidian horror, Mankind was shrouded in almost complete darkness when first introduced to WWF audiences in 1996. Though more traditional in horror tropes, Foley's deeply unnerving performance transcended them.

Christ, this company used to be amazing.

So f*cking amazing that they would lovingly apply artistic detail to a character's presentation to make them believable even in their own, heightened context. Here, Mankind's squeaking ranting - it was as if he perceived himself to be the rat that accompanied him - was soundtracked by a dripping tap that worked to engineer a feeling of lingering dread.

The promo is tremendous. At one point, Mankind, blaming you for his ugliness - of which he was the manifestation - scream-whispers "It wasn't me it was someone else, it wasn't me it was someone else!"

He reads it more like "Itwasn'tmeitwassomeoneelse, itwasn'tmeitwassomeone else!"

The effect was chilling; Mankind seemed to imagine the victim of his awfulness saying this to him in panic to bargain for their safety.

The framing was inspired, too. You could barely see what was coming, and were encouraged to torment yourself in the theatre of your own mind.


3. Magnum TA Almost Takes A Man's Eye

Magnum TA Tully Blanchard
WWE Network

Sometimes the mutants have a point. In some ways, wrestling was better then than it is now.

A trade-off has happened, and it's not that pro wrestling, which has never looked real, looked any more real then. It felt realer then. Perhaps that's because we remember it through a childhood lens that will always inform how we receive it as adults. Perhaps it's because, and this isn't pissing and moaning about "psychology," there is so much more content in a modern wrestling match that it's difficult to engineer a tone of pure animosity. There's little scope for primal hatred - of the sort that makes a man do something simple and ugly because it's the most efficient way of f*cking somebody up - when crafting a long and complex match. This is what the audience wants now.

This is why pro wrestling has evolved as it has. A match like Magnum TA Vs. Tully Blanchard wouldn't get over because you can't sell the audience on that theme, much less realise it with such brutal economy.

But Christ, it's so great. It's so great, and it builds so well that one can actually believe Magnum has been driven to puncture Blanchard's eyeball. He quits before it can be done, but the horror lies in the conviction of the performance.

He was certain, or so it seemed, to do it.


2. Mae Young Gets Sent To Hell

RIP Mae Young
WWE.com

There's a perverse amusement involved, because of course there is.

This infamous spot functions as a wonderful, blackly funny sight gag, for Bubba Ray Dudley powerbombed a folk hero octogenarian off the stage and through a table. In a further, expert layer of unconscionable cruelty, Mae Young was wearing a neck brace and had to rely on a wheelchair in the fiction.

But, even equipped with the knowledge that Mae was completely fine afterwards, and was always going to be, since she is tougher than most half her age, watching it back now remains a distressing experience even if it was played with such over-the-top ham. It's a quintessentially Attitude Era moment - how far could this deranged stunt show go?

There's a moment in the arc of the bump - which Bubba performed so perfectly, incidentally - in which it looks like Mae is going to take the impact right on her neck, a body part that, as we have been tragically informed too often, doesn't much care for the limits of human resolve. It was a demented risk to take, or at least, it still feels that way. It illustrates the power of wrestling's worked magic.

How did she not crumble into dust?


1. Kota Ibushi Becomes 'Murderboi'

Kazuchika Okada Kota Ibushi
NJPW

Kota Ibushi is a phenomenal professional wrestler who fuses spectacular aerials and a frightening striking legitimacy to get over as basically the best version of every top-tier New Japan talent.

He is incredible artist, but he's also a deeply erratic individual. This is mostly endearing.

Ibushi can't navigate airports. He doesn't trust books because they make him imagine things. Fishing "pisses him off" because "When you get a fish, what happens then?" Ibushi asked KUSHIDA on a 2017 podcast.

Is it...is it possible that Kota Ibushi doesn't know what a fish looks like before it is served to him on a plate?

Ibushi's inscrutable mind further informs his new, massively unsettling (but also awesome) sequence. Affectionately known as "Murderboi", something awful appears to take over. He stops. He becomes impervious to pain and indeed any sensory trigger. He lashes out violently, cracking his opponent flush in the face, with a sickening impact, all while no discernible emotion emerges from his own. It's a tremendous spot because it's a completely random act of cruelty all the more terrifying for how irreconcilable it is. And it's terrifying because Ibushi is so enigmatic.

What if he gets stuck in that puzzle he calls a mind?


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!