10 Wrestlers AEW Stole From Under WWE's Nose

'Switchblade' Jay White picked AEW over WWE, but who else actively chose the challenger brand?

Jamie Hayter
WWE

It's been fascinating to watch the pendulum of public opinion swing between WWE and AEW since the latter company formed in 2019.

Not that there's ever been a singular or solitary take about the quality of one over the other - in spite of both organisations experiencing waves of financial or creative momentum at various points, tribal fans have used the mere existence of an alternative to wage unwinnable wars against one another rooted in lousy patter and even worse analysis. Which is probably why it’s worth including a disclaimer on the title here - “stole” is being used in the figurative sense.

News has broken about that sort of thing happening for real in the shadows, but this isn’t about that. This is a far gentler glimpse into wrestlers seemingly set and ready for life under Vince McMahon before the monopoly-smashing new competition stepped in.

Tony Khan has signed a lot of wrestlers in the four years he’s been business, but what of the ones that slipped through WWE’s fingers? Who actively chose to chance it on the challenger brand rather than staying out with the market leader?

10. Jay White

Jay White AEW
AEW

That Triple H and William Regal were extremely interested in Jay White before WrestleMania and WWE's sale to Endeavor suggests that 'Switchblade' could have almost certainly signed for the market leader had (lots of) plans not changed when they did.

Amidst rumours of a hiring freeze and nobody really knowing exactly who hires and fires anymore, the company suddenly looked remarkably different from the outside, and on the inside, there were reports about "communication" issues that seemed to put paid to any hope of having the former IWGP Champion as Raw or SmackDown's newest recruit.

The move to All Elite Wrestling full-time was relatively seamless. Having made brief appearances in 2022 ahead of the inaugural Forbidden Door pay-per-view, White (and Bullet Club) felt part of the team already. His debut attack on Ricky Starks made it official, and the Bullet Club Gold unit with Juice Robinson has put him back in the group having been booted from New Japan Pro Wrestling's core unit by David Finlay.


9. Christian Cage

Christian return
WWE

Christian (Cage)'s Royal Rumble 2021 return was in keeping with a theme of much of his career - slightly lower key than the way Edge did it, but arguably a lot more entertaining.

In his gear and fully fit inside The ThunderDome, absolutely nobody had 'Captain Charisma' on their bingo cards going into the PLE, and thus also couldn't have forecast that he'd be properly back for it too. A reunion with the 'Rated-R Superstar' was sweet, and some moments here and there with old and new rivals generated lots of conversation of potential future angles.

Conversation that promptly turned to an entirely different set of wrestlers when he signed for All Elite Wrestling at Revolution 2021.

Cage was promoted by Tony Khan as one of his dream signings, and became Impact World Champion during a mini-feud with Kenny Omega before getting into the guts of a longstanding programme with Jungle Boy Jack Perry and Luchasaurus.


8. Dr Britt Baker DMD

Nia Jax Britt Baker
WWE.com

The AEW Women's Division stalwart was already more than "Adam Cole's girlfriend" in canon when, in 2019, WWE needlessly put her face on television during the the titular main event of NXT TakeOver: WarGames.

There, she was selling the damage being absorbed by Cole, but she'd sold beatings of her own on WWE television at various points between 2016 and 2018, most notably taking beatings off future WWE Women's Tag Team Champions Nia Jax and Shayna Baszler respectively. The latter squash in particular came at quite a key time for both performer and nascent promotion; Baszler defeated Baker by arm-breaking stoppage on the October 17th edition of NXT. Less than three months after that date, she was announced as the first signing in the AEW Women's Division by Brandi Rhodes as All Elite Wrestling formally launched.

Having proven her mettle in the ring, being known as one of the indie wrestling standouts and having an in-built gimmick, Baker seemed a lock for WWE. Instead, she paved a brand new and just as lucrative path, and has been front and centre of the company ever since.


7. Adam Cole

Adam Cole
WWE

It was deemed an Inevitability that Adam Cole would finish up with NXT and move straight to All Elite Wrestling when his contract expired - such was the radically different landscape of wrestling in 2021.

Crowds had returned to buildings and Dynamite was rocking thanks to an on-fire Elite saga and the incredible return of CM Punk giving the company unfathomable momentum. Conversely, AEW’s former black-and-gold rival was on its last legs, and despite headlining it for several years, Adam Cole’s main roster follow-through scanned like parody.

Never particularly fond of the call-ups from the era, Vince McMahon allegedly wanted to make Cole Keith Lee’s manager. Celebrated-wrestler-entering-wrestler-prime Cole was excited to reunite with so many of his friends in AEW that surveying the landscape wasn’t that crucial - but the prospect of that pitch curtailing his trajectory on Raw or SmackDown as it had done for so many likely double sealed the deal.

He finished up his epic (arguably too epic) feud with Kyle O’Reilly, even signed a brief contract extension to make it so, and parted ways amicably. Sweetheart stuff as usual.

And as it transpired, he wasn’t coming alone…


6. Kyle O'Reilly

Kyle O'Reilly Von Wagner NXT WarGames 2021
WWE.com

Following on from his former and future stablemate Adam Cole, Kyle O'Reilly landed in All Elite Wrestling on December 22nd 2021, having spent the last few months in WWE on the first few months of the new NXT.

2.0 wasn’t for everybody (to say the least), and O'Reilly felt too linked to the old world during a drawn-out feud with new prospect Von Wagner before his departure.

Unfortunately, his AEW run was blighted with equally dicey storytelling and a desperately unfortunate injury. When a do-over of The Undisputed Era alongside Cole and Bobby Fish didn't generate drama with The Elite from the off, the group suddenly felt as though they were coasting, and after just 15 matches, he was out with a long-term injury.

In that time, Fish left the company and Adam Cole - having spent time on the shelf himself - has turned babyface upon his return. O'Reilly will hopefully follow suit, if only so AEW doesn't bring about a return to the lengthy and dangerous matches with Cole that took such a toll in 2021.


5. Daniel Garcia

Danny Garcia
WWE

As "Dany Garcia" and "Dante Rios", the Jericho Appreciation Society man worked twice on TV for WWE via 205 Live and NXT during his formative years, but the prodigious young star never earned a permanent deal with the market leader.

Not uncommon, but as with Dr Britt Baker and others on this list, the relatively short time between Garcia's last WWE appearance and first one on the other channel is remarkable. With the Rios moniker, Garcia lost to Tyler Rust on the January 21st 2021 edition of NXT. He was working Dark: Elevation by May and Dynamite by August. The critical acclaim existed long before the debut too - Garcia had earned kudos for his work on the indies as scenes recovered from the pandemic, but the professional wrestler lurking under the Sports Entertainer facade obviously wasn't what WWE wanted at the time.

The market leader's loss was the challenger brand's gain - Garcia's spent almost all of his television time in significant storylines, and appears to be one of the few wrestlers on a loaded roster that can survive periods of being overlooked.


4. Serena Deeb

Serena Deeb
WWE

Wrestling is dated and weird and sexist and ageist and should be better and there's perhaps no better mainstream illustration of that than the perpetually mismanaged AEW women's division.

From even before All Elite Wrestling was a thing, women's wrestling has been an afterthought. 2018's ALL IN had one fatal four-way with no story, several similar contests took place when the company launched in 2019, and Dynamite remains the home of one solitary women's match a week as of April 2023. Such limited time means limited exposure, which is particularly jarring when a performer gets over enough to warrant presence on a far more regular basis.

Serena Deeb was all of those things in 2021, and kicked so much a*s that a series with Hikaru Series commanded committed television time even if it didn't stand to get either woman any closer to a title or another story afterwards. But at very least, she got that - 'The Professor Of Professional Wrestling' was employed by WWE as a 32-year-old coach between 2018 and 2020, having worked the 2017 Mae Young Classic several years on from her Straight Edge Society run alongside CM Punk. Still early into her wrestling prime years, she remains one of the best pick-ups in the division's short and difficult history.


3. John Silver & Alex Reynolds

Beaver Boys
WWE

Dark Order lifers John Silver and Alex Reynolds were brought in to All Elite Wrestling in late-2019, first to be beaten up supposedly terrifying group they'd later join, before extolling the virtues of being taken in by the corrupting influences.

A strange way to kick off a run that has now lasted four years and helped them cultivate personalities as tenured television pros, but even stranger was that they were on WWE screens just weeks before AEW Dynamite transformed the landscape of the weekly wrestling world.

Eating a squash loss to Heavy Machinery on a Madison Square Garden edition of SmackDown in September, the pair weren't picked up by the market leader and quickly went from making up the numbers to making it onto pay-per-view for the brand new opposition. As the warm body taking the most abuse, Silver in particular shone, but the slick tag outfit that lay beneath the local enhancement aura was deemed surplus - or extra - to company requirements at the time.


2. Jamie Hayter

Jamie Hayter
WWE

AEW knew what they had with Jamie Hayter.

It was a difficult road to the top of the company for the (as of writing) Women's Champion, but Tony Khan presumably knew Hayter was worth the wait.

Losing - rather appropriately - to Dr Britt Baker DMD on the fourth edition of Dynamite and appearing just once more two weeks later in 2019, the same incarnation of Hayter's gimmick lost on NXT UK in April, but WWE elected not to go with her ahead of an impending Wednesday Night War.

Hayter was a terrifically entertaining presence, even if that gimmick was nowhere to be seen when she returned to screens alongside the Women's Champion in 2021. In that time, she'd kept the reps up in spite of numerous pandemic restrictions, working for Stardom and RevPro whenever shows were available. The AEW return instantly felt different though, and her time as a heater was destined to be short-lived when fans immediately gravitated to their doomed partnership.


1. The Elite

Cody Young Bucks Being The Elite
WWE/AEW

Were Kenny Omega, The Young Bucks and Cody Rhodes possibly going to go to WWE before All Elite Wrestling even formed?

Probably not, but the company tried as hard as they ever had to make the move happen, possibly with some knowledge that they were stopping the formation of a competitor as well as hiring some top talents?

As Nick Jackson himself put it in "Killing The Business";

"It was a three-year deal worth millions, for each of us. On top of that, we were also given the option of signing, and if we weren't satisfied with how things were going we'd be given a special clause in our contracts that would allow us to leave the company in three months no questions asked. He also inquired about making a deal to put All In on the WWE Network...we never asked for more money or more perks...WWE seemed extremely interested in having us on their team - or were these attempts at stopping a movement before it really got started?"

In the end, it all wasn't enough - the group followed their plans all the way through, but the deal remains relatively unprecedented several years later.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.