15 MORE Failed Experiments From WWE Developmental

Even during NXT's golden era, not every idea was money...

The Revival The Mechanics
WWE

Post-2022 might be the best ever period to have a developmental deal with NXT if the measure of "best" is find even a modicum of a foothold on the main roster.

The 2.0-and-beyond era may not have the charm and beloved sentiment that remains attached to the 2014-16 golden era nor the ratcheted critical acclaim and plaudits received by the 2017-2019 work rate peak, but it's got components that outstrip both ideals; objective success, and the clearest through-line to Raw/SmackDown supremacy. 

Thanks to a strong relationship with the USA and latterly CW Network, NXT is now an established television brand on Tuesday nights, as opposed to the online/Network favourite it once was, and the slaughtered victim of the Wednesday Night Wars it became. It also boasts Shawn Michaels as its chief, and the relationship with fellow DXer/former lackey Triple H has created the smoothest possible transition to the market leader main stage yet. It's not an exact science, and never will be, but in an industry still predicated on the cream rising to the top, so too will the very best talent without fear of having their gimmick or aura strip-mined by an ancient sociopath that doesn't get the appeal.

These are the good old days, unlike when pushes died on the vine for...

(Get 76% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here)

15. Blue Pants

Leva Bates Blue Pants
WWE

It was the best of times.

A white hot brand hidden within the walls of a market leader clinging on to hardcores based on little more than habit during a decade-and-a-half of a monopoly, NXT was at long last some WWE-coded product that exhausted WWE fans could actually enjoy. The booking was logical, simultaneously traditional and progressive, and the Full Sail locals gave every act the best possible chance to look and feel like a star. 

Enter Leva "Blue Pants" Bates.

The usual "cult hero" tag doesn't really do justice to just how remarkably over she was, or she was the biggest cult hero in the history of the show. Take your pick but whatever you do, don't sleep on watching her scant moments of magic back. 

She wrestled just 10 times on the show in 2015, introduced as somebody for Carmella to beat with her then-partner Big Cass improvising a Price Is Right song that became her theme, and lost all but one of her matches before the two sides fell out over speculated-upon attitude issues and backstage heat. 

But the deepest of deep connections was best exemplified not by a match but a surprise appearance alongside The Vaudvillains at TakeOver: Brooklyn in August. The biggest crowd in the brand's history up to that point went utterly berserk for her as the counter to Alexa Bliss' interference and had her cameo not been followed by Sahsa Banks and Bayley changing the face of North American women's wrestling forever later on the card, she'd have been the most over female in New York that night.


14. Lana

Lana NXT

Remember Lana's dancing gimmick on WWE's main roster in 2017, and just how over that briefly got her? Remember how part of that might have been to do with the killer theme that impeccably served this new role? Remember how SmackDown Live really was the "land of opportunity" it purported itself to be and Lana was a genuine beneficiary of it for a time?

Things might have gone differently for the 'Ravishing Russian' had the first crack at of the gimmick made it beyond the Largo Loop. In a fan's phone video that has now seemingly been scrubbed from the internet, a denim-clad Lana appears to improvise a dance to the ring rather than entering the normal, stopping awkwardly for high fives while jankily moving from one uneven step to the next. Wrestlers have an unbelievable ability to remain impervious to cringe, but even memories shared of those that actually saw it can't discuss it openly without crumpling like a prop trash can.

Fitting, because that really is where that first draft belonged. 

The above image shows the result of an immediate retooling, with a ballgown and chair far more in keeping with what the theme and persona needed, and virtually a like-for-like of what made it to the blue brand shortly afterwards. 


13. Marcus Louis Goes Bald And Goes Mad

Marcus Louis Solomon Crowe
WWE.com

NXT was extremely close to perfect during it's 2014-16 golden era, but even in an almost-perfect wrestling world, not every single character can get over as a massive star. That's not to say wrestlers can't still fulfil important roles of course, but if there comes time for a sacrifice of some description, expect these ones - the not-quite-tippy-top guys - to pay the penalty.

That's what the transformation of former Legionnaires tag wrestler Marcus Louis was forced to face following a loss to Enzo Amore during a feud between the pair about looks, hair and the latter's entire loudmouth aesthetic. It wasn't just the top of his head and eyebrows that suffered the consequences either - the cartoonish "hair removal cream" robbed him of his follicles and any kind of push.

He was booked to go insane in-part due to how he looked, a la Kane and/or Gene Snitsky during the mid-2000s main roster doldrums. He turned on partner Sylvester Lefort and feuded with Tyler Breeze at the end of 2014, but came out on the short end of everything he was involved in and entered the brand's hottest year as just about the only television regular without any discernible momentum.

The pattern continued, leading ultimately to a 2016 release that happened - as opposed to just about every story surrounding NXT at the time - almost completely free of any fanfare. 


12. Angelo Dawkins

Angelo Dawkins
WWE

Angelo Dawkins has been at this a long time.

Longer than that. Longer than you think. 2012, to be exact. Angelo Dawkins has been in the market leader's system over 13 years. It's a story of perseverance, patience and consistency, and quite honestly a story more interesting that most of the ones the Street Profits have been given for the bulk of over half a decade on the main roster.

Before having to contend with pandemic bin monsters, a woefully undercooked stable with Bobby Lashley and a years-long gap between title reigns, Dawkins was a singles wrestler who was a very literal happy-to-be-there loser. Full of beans as he entered, gimmicked up to the nines with backpack and headphones, he'd smile and dance his way to the ring before being carted out of it after yet another defeat.

Historically, the gimmicked jobber is - if nothing else - something that often opens other doors, and that's presumably what Dawkins was doing here. By at least getting noticed in singles and tag defeats, he kept himself visible until the pairing with Montez Ford finally rescued him from the churn.


11. Nikos Rykos

Nykos Rikos

Remembered more for his extremely distinctive and patriotic gear than any kind of extended run on the black-and-gold brand, Nylos Rikos was a one-and-done lights inspector for Keith Lee during the 'Limitless One's breakout 2019 in NXT.

He took a good beating from Lee on the show either side of a prolific run on the indies, stopping only to get one more shot for the market leader as half of the inadvertently hilarious "East Hampton Polo Boys" on a Monday Night Raw later that year. The Mean Street Posse-esque jobbers took a pummelling from The Viking Raiders in a match that existed as much to show the physical and stylistic differences between the two sides.

Despite finding himself overlooked by WWE (and, when it launched, AEW), Rikos has appeared semi-regularly on the circuit, working just under 50 matches for various organisations over the last several, including two shots in the second half of 2025 for Titan Championship Wrestling in New Jersey. The dream of once again making it back to NXT may be over, but the Sparta, New Jersey native has clearly been able to stay busy with wrestling as a side hustle at least. 


10. Oliver Grey

Oliver Grey Adrian Neville British Ambition
WWE.com

As one half of "British Ambition", Oliver Grey was positioned as the being on the same level as future megastar PAC (then billed as Adrian Neville) when the pair became the first ever NXT Tag Team Champions in 2012.

The duo somewhat unexpectedly defeated The Wyatt Family in a tournament final in February 2013, but Grey's time with the title was devastatingly short-lived. The Brit tore his anterior cruciate ligament a little over a month into the reign, forcing Bo Dallas to step in as a makeshift champion in order for them to drop the belts to Luke Harper and Erick Rowan in May.

By the time Grey returned a year later, the landscape of NXT had changed so drastically that his sad release felt inevitable. Neville had gone on to become Heavyweight Champion of a brand that was being held up as WWE's most critically acclaimed product since the turn-of-the-century creative boom. He fell short in a Battle Royal to determine a number one contender for his former friend's gold that didn't even air until he'd already been released. 

It brought about the end of a two year run in the system having also spent time in FCW, but Grey - working as Joel Redman in the aftermath - continued his career unabated, He remains at large, clocking well over 400 matches for multiple independents as well as All Japan since his exit. 


9. Tim Wiese

Tim Wiese

Former Bayer Leverkusen youth, Kaiserslautern and Werder Bremen goalkeeper Tim Wiese wasn't the only former football/soccer player to give WWE and pro wrestling in general an earnest try once his time on the pitch came to an end, but he did appear to be making headway the quickest when he was offered a spot in the Performance Center at the exact point he was retiring professionally from "the beautiful game".

The 2014 career change didn't result in him immediately reporting to Orlando, but he did keep tabs with Triple H during 'The Game's time as top brass in NXT, and the relationship blossomed further when Wiese joined Sheamus and Cesaro in defeating Bo Dallas and The Shining Stars at a Munich house show in 2016. 

He'd gotten visibly bigger as part of his training and potential superstar development but those that were in attendance that night got more of a collector's item than they'd bargained for. The match turned out to be the beginning of the end though - the one and done was enough for him to reconsider and he was done with the organisation completely by 2017. 

The timelines were such that had he held on a bit longer - or even just dropped in a little sooner - he might have gotten paired with or against...


8. The ORIGINAL Ascension

The Ascension Original Kenneth Cameron
WWE.com

Headline-makers in the early days of NXT hailing from its familiar Full Sail University digs in the early-2010s, The Ascension were as difficult to pin down for the three count as they were as an act. A stable in FCW had become a tag team on the black and gold brand, with Conor O'Brian and Kenneth Cameron left as a duo just as the market leader vastly overhauled its system. 

With an entrance that impressively (for the time) spliced pre-recorded b-roll with the live footage walking menacingly to the ring, a solid television foundation was created underneath the act that set them apart enough from the rest of the field that it took main roster fly-ins to give them something to do. A mini-feud with The Usos filled a lot of their time in 2012, in-between absolutely decimating smaller makeshift/jobber teams along the way. 

Though the characters were perhaps a little too undefined for the original push, the messaging that they were there to completely dominate was clear enough, and their size advantage in the smaller-feeling developmental made them look readier than most for a main roster run should the opportunity ever present itself.

Ultimately, by the time that call was made, the act had been completely retooled...


7. The Ascension 2.0

The Ascension Dominant
wwe.com

Kenneth Cameron's release due to an arrest in November 2012 resulted in a complete rethink for The Ascension, but the act itself had enough credit in the bank to unexpectedly get a second proper NXT run (and third including FCW!) when Rick Victor scouted the now-single Connor O'Brian and helped him find the Road Warrior-esque squash monster within.

As the rebadged Viktor and Konnor, everything clicked in a major way. A new look and entrance gave new life to The Ascension, doubling down on the dominance they'd held prior. They took very little time to plough through the majority of the competition, and were fixtures of early WWE Network Takeover specials as unbeatable and unstoppable NXT Tag Team Champions.

Booked as heels but beloved as babyfaces in the Full Sail home of the brand, the team held the gold for one day short of a full year, putting over Kalisto and Sin Cara, getting them over as bold underdog babyfaces while facilitating a shift to a more obvious heel role for the monsters in order to provide opposition for debutants Hideo Itami and Finn Bálor.

A disastrous main roster run in the aftermath of a positive time on NXT was the rule rather than the exception for acts making the jump in the mid-2010s, and just like that, they were ancient NXT history.

More's the pity. Tag wrestling on the show was once again about to ascend...


6. The (Literal) Mechanics

The Revival The Mechanics
WWE

It turns out that Dax Harwood has been leaving something off of his infamous list of things he loves.

The world has been updated quite enough over the years on how much he cares about his family, his tequila and this gatdang great sport of ours, but how could the artist formerly known as Scott Dawson forget to let us all in on how much he loves cars?! Likewise for Cash Wheeler (FKA Dash Wilder) - the pair of them liked nothing more than going under the hood of an automobile before going over inside the four walls of Full Sail University. 

Well, not really, but right around the time they started finally gaining traction as thriving tag team specialists in NXT, they allowed a "Mechanics" tag to take on a  double meaning thanks to Dusty Rhodes' penchant for the character-heavy days of the industry, the pair's iron will to do anything to get over, and some oil-slicked denim.

'The American Dream's pairing of their obvious skills with some cartoonish threads didn't last, but the idea did - by the time Dash and Dawson started to go by The Revival, they were well established as a deadly throwback duo who could out-wrestle, out-think and - if necessary - out-cheat their opposition. Alongside Rhodes, they'd finally gotten the motor running. 


5. Sarray

Sarray new look
WWE

A victim of bad timing and even worse creative, Sarray's NXT run went from bad to worse despite NXT rescuing itself from the self-imposed death-grip of the Capitol Wrestling Center.

Following a 2021 where she got her killer finisher over but little else, Sarray re-emerged in 2022 with an extraordinarily reductive schoolgirl gimmick, noting that a return to Japan had given her time to start again. Not perfect, but it got worse. She noted how she was gifted a medallion with magic powers from Grandma, and that it would be this that took her to the top of the industry. 

This was January, and she'd lost on LVL UP by February, almost as if a magic medallion wasn't as effective as a seated missile dropkick. She had to pretend it was though, particularly when Tiffany Stratton stole it to trigger a feud that Sarray also lost. This wasn't where all this nonsense ended either - she came a special portal when she entered that transformed her from the version we'd seen in the vignettes to the wrestlers. It was stupid and very literally unbelievable, and only worked as a gag when Chase U were also bizarrely affected by it too.

For the good of the rest of her career, she left in 2023.


4. Hugo Knox

Hugo Knox WWE NXT
WWE

The weather was at least an improvement for Stuart Tomlinson when he made the move from the UK to Orlando, Florida to follow his WWE dreams in 2013.

Tomlinson had played in goal for Crewe Alexandra, Burton Albion, Barrow, Port Vale and Altrincham and with it built enough size along the way to look like he belonged amongst the best and brightest at the Performance Center.  After a year of getting to grips with the career change, he made it into the ring after a year and notched up an impressive 62 matches before ultimately getting released in 2016.

He'd struggled to connect with audiences in that time, despite briefly sneaking onto television for a loss to The Vaudvillains alongside Tucker Knight. Less of a failed experiment and more noble failure, "Hugo Knox" was a nothing-or-something gimmick name that suited neither him nor the NXT heart-on-sleeve style of the time. 


3. Duke Hudson: Poker Player

Duke Hudson
WWE

Duke Hudson: Poker Player did't exactly make sense in its own context. However, there was such a bizarre normality to a wrestler having an outlandish gimmick around the time he was at the tables that the chintzy nature of it all didn't exactly have folk clutching pearls like they would for a Canadian Destroyer not being sold long enough several years earlier.

Perhaps they should have done.

In the 2.0 era, Hudson had already been used as a guy who was constantly DTF, but as approximately 80% of the roster ostensibly had the same gimmick at the time, he was recast as a man who very literally held all the cards. We learned this through vignettes, and even those sitting in the free Performance Center seats could infer that his poker skills were transferrable when the bell rang. And that's if they'd forgotten all about his entire main roster run as Brendan Vink during the pandemic.

Alas, it didn't translate all that well - particularly when he hosted in-ring card games and lost most of the time! Historically, fans back winners, and that extends to whatever side-job the pro wrestler keeps alongside being a pro wrestler. It was back to the drawing board and eventually back to school for Duke, who became the best hot tag in the business as part of Chase University before his enormously perplexing 2025 release. 


2. Jason Jordan Fails In Tag Teams

Tye Dillinger Jason Jordan
WWE.com

There have been select cases in WWE history where a wrestler has just not been the type to play well with others, breaking up or abandoning unions simply because the single life just makes sense. 

Stone Cold Steve Austin's "DTA" catchphrase extended to almost all of his tag team title reigns. Shawn Michaels, Dude Love and The Undertaker were under no false pretensions about how they stood just as much a chance of getting a Stone Cold Stunner as the opponents. Meanwhile, the equally ornery Bad News Brown was so terrible at co-existing with his colleagues that he walked out on two Survivor Series elimination matches in back-to-back years. To many and indeed most, it's just not a team sport.

That didn't prove to be the case for Jason Jordan. Before his deeply unfortunate career-ending injury in 2018, the talented amateur had found his kindred spirit in Chad Gable in NXT. American Alpha burned brightly for the short time they were permitted to, and Jordan's last match proper was as a doubles Champion alongside Seth Rollins.

This took a while.

A prodigious talent that just couldn't quite find what fit him, his teams with CJ Parker and Tye Dillinger fell away, and never in a way that made a split storyline all that captivating. It did at least give his origin story with Gable some juice - Chad had to campaign hard to convince him that this time, it might just work.


1. Liv Morgan

Liv Morgan
WWE.com

A true Performance Center/WWE success story, Liv Morgan has never wrestled a single match outside the auspices of the market leader, never had an independent run, and spent several years figuring out how to take herself from the creative outhouse to penthouse. Subsequently, she has on her resumé an NXT stint that isn't particularly covered in glory.

Working originally by real name Gionna Daddio, she eventually landed on the name she'd take to the top, but branding was realistically the least of her concerns during a tricky time to be paving her way.

Emerging from a rebuilding phase for the black-and-gold brand following the loss of the likes of The Four Horsewomen and Asuka, Morgan's babyface New Jersey character had two key problems despite the connection she was able to forge with the Full Sail regulars. Her matches weren't of the standard expected thanks to those that had come before her, and her character felt too close to that of Carmella, another NXT alumni that had been beloved in Orlando before getting the main roster call. 

The ceiling and standards were thus extremely low, and ultimately but Morgan plugged away without any key storylines until WWE's Riott Squad idea brought her and Sarah Logan to Raw in December 2017 just in time for the women's division's biggest ever year. 


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.