5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (23 Oct - Results & Review)

Raw problems come to SmackDown for Sami Zayn; 'Last Man Standing' grudge match set.

Blake Monroe Giulia
WWE.com

All systems are go on Blake Monroe's WWE push...finally!

The blonde bombshell defeated Giulia in a spirited 'Street Fight' on this week's SmackDown, but Friday was also a big night for the likes of Cody Rhodes, Randy Orton, Michin, B-FAB, Chelsea Green, Roxanne Perez and Trick Williams. How's that for a Survivor Series team?!

Seriously though, WWE booking does feel a little so-so overall right now due to the tepid PLE known as Crown Jewel. Nobody really gives much of a toss about the token belts they hand out on that show, meaning the writers have to find ways to keep top champs busy and spice things up on the midcard.

Opinions will vary on how well they're managing that on the blue side of the fence. However, this week, we got a 'Last Man Standing' announcement for Saudi Arabia, confirmation on CM Punk vs. Kevin Owens, a title change, a Money In The Bank cash in tease, a cracking title defence and even one of Raw's top names coming over to lend his star power.

Penta really does feel like he's been elevated since MITB, and there's a clear bid to get Trick Williams to that sort of level too.

Overall, this was a much improved edition of SmackDown compared to last week. That sagged. The jury's still out on how well Danhausen's comedy will fare as he hosts a spooky Halloween episode next time out, but here's all the good and bad from WWE's latest to tide you over until then.


Downs...

4. This Was A Waste Of Time

CM Punk Kevin Owens Nick Aldis
WWE.com

Kevin Owens and CM Punk were right when they said that their backstage sit-down with Nick Aldis was a waste of everyone's time. Another match between the pair has been signed for 2 weeks on SmackDown, but we didn’t need this pre-amble. If anything, these guys shouldn’t be able to sit in the same room together at this point.

Their dialogue was fine enough, admittedly, but the segment reeked of just trying to squeeze both onto the show by any means necessary. Surely there was a better way to go about things than this? Putting Punk or KO in the ring for a hard fought match would've been one idea - they didn't say anything in the sit-down that pushed things forwards anyway.

We get it: Owens doesn't like Punk because of things that were said in an ROH locker room 20 years ago. Then, they've been getting involved in one another's matches since Kev returned to the roster, and both cost one another the chance to win at Money In The Bank. Repeating that over and over and over and over again isn't doing anybody any favours.

The sooner this match hits the ring, the better.

Aldis often talks about keeping his biggest bouts wrapped in cotton wool so nothing jeopardises them. Cool, so why did he put a duo who clearly can't stand one another on opposite sides of the world's smallest table? That made no logical sense, especially considering how antsy Nick got about the thought of Cody Rhodes and Randy Orton throwing hands on the same show.


3. Why Didn’t Tiffany Cash In Anyway?

Tiffany Stratton Chelsea Green
WWE.com

Sure, Raquel Rodriguez dragged Liv Morgan out of the ring, and Roxanne Perez was there too, but Liv was ripe for the pickings and Stratton had backup to help. There was nothing really stopping her from cashing in MITB and winning the Women's World Title. Nothing at all.

Hopefully, we don’t get more teases this clumsily handled. Also, WWE needs to quit it with the age old trope of pretending the ring ropes are some impenetrable fortress. They won't, but it'd be nice to see some switched on babyface realise that they could simply exit the squared circle and go get the foe they've been hunting down.

Yes, this is a minor ‘Down’ for sure, but one worth mentioning. There's a higher chance of Tiffy cashing in on Chelsea Green following a "shock" heel turn than there is of her cashing in the briefcase on Liv, so we don't need tease after tease to get there. Further, when are we actually gonna press play on a Judgment Day split?!

That story is right there waiting to happen. Perez and Raquel would have ample reasons to give Morgan the cold shoulder, but WWE doesn't seem particularly interested in running with that. Thus, Liv is in real danger of spinning her wheels during this title reign...yet again.

Stratton looked a wee bit like an idiot for taking so long to cash in her case. That's another annoying thing this company does with faces who hold MITB. They're so slow on the uptake, and they let easy opportunities slide on past.


2. The Men’s Tag Division Is A Mess AGAIN!

MFTs Bakusai
WWE.com

Tag-team wrestling in WWE? In the toilet.

Bron Breakker and Austin Theory haven't defended their gold since winning the belts in July over on Raw, the Women's Tag Title scene is a mess (more on that to come), and the SmackDown men's division is no better. MFTs vs. Bakusai was announced for this week, but WWE scripted a brawl between both teams when Kyoki stole Haku's walking stick.

Tama and Talla Tonga didn't take kindly to that. Instead of calming things down and getting the match in the ring (which has happened a million times), officials waved this bout off and moved on with the show. Hmm, it's obvious that this brawl happened because WWE knows the rivalry isn’t interesting and live crowds don’t care.

Things will likely end in a title change, probably, but the creative team has already thrown the towel in on Bakusai, and they’re hardly coming through for the Tongans either. There's no meat on the bone to any of this. The storyboard could be written on a post-it note, and WWE has decided that Kyoki acting all weird is enough character development for he and Shinsuke Nakamura.

Spoiler alert: It bloody well isn't. Promotions are supposed to give audiences a reason to invest and care about seeing fresh acts win titles. Where do we go from there if Bakusai beats the MFTs and takes tag straps no-one really gives a damn about as it is?

Does Triple H just hate tag-team wrestling, or something?! His handling of it is rather shocking.


1. A Complete & Utter Waste Of A Title Reign

Jade Cargill Michin B-FAB Baddies
WWE.com

So, Alexa Bliss and Tatum Paxley lost the Women’s Tag Titles after 2 weeks to Michin and B-FAB in a nothing 7-8 minute match. What are we even doing here? Tatum and Alexa could’ve had something good going on as champs, but now Jade Cargill’s Baddies have the straps for some reason.

This is why it’s really hard to care about these belts. Nothing ever means anything. If WWE stumbles on something fun with the women’s tag division, they're almost guaranteed to ruin it almost immediately.

Friday's match wasn’t even good. Making matters worse, it was newbie Tatum who took the fall, so you just know that's something Charlotte Flair will drone on about once she returns; 'Blisster, I told you that she wasn't ready blah blah blah'.

Michael Cole may win whopper of the year by saying: “You felt like it was only a matter of time for this group”. No, you didn’t. Cargill, Michin and FAB have been pushed into the background because Jacy Jayne's Fatal Influence group has been more dynamic and more impressing since debuting earlier in the year.

Now, nonsensically, Michin and FAB have gone from barely being involved in anything serious to winning the belts. On a personal level, good on them. You could see how much it meant to both, but we're supposed to be producing compelling television here not just handing out titles like gifts.

Paxley looks like a lowly rookie who's in over her head instead of a game-changing friend to Flair and Bliss. Great...


Ups...

5. The Clever ‘Last Man Standing’ Tease

Randy Orton Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes called Randy Orton the “last man standing” from his OVW class. That was laced early in his promo about being “unafraid” of Randy despite the threat he poses, and it was done deliberately as a teaser to what was coming next.

Nick Aldis saying the match would take place at Crown Jewel instead of on free TV got booed, naturally, but this was solid setup for a blowoff showing between these guys. Rhodes effectively announcing the gimmick before announcing the gimmick (if that makes sense) was smart, and the way he managed to tie that into Orton's old developmental days? Priceless.

The announcers also provided an update on Baron Corbin's status after he was punted in the head by Cody last week. According to Cole and Corey Graves, Corbin will be "out indefinitely" after suffering a few kayfabe injuries. That'd be for the best, because it'd suck if Baron roared into view over in Saudi and got involved in this grudge encounter.

It's vital that WWE lets Randy and Cody do their thing without unnecessary distractions. They've got some making up to do after Pat McAfee's unwanted involvement heading into WrestleMania 42, and it's hardly like they need any extra bells or whistles in the form of Corbs.

In isolation, this was an intense bit of matchmaking. Within the context of the broader story, it told the story of Rhodes 'going to the darkside' in order to beat someone who's willing to go there at the drop of a hat. The segment was much stronger than that Punk vs. KO sit-down, that's for sure.


4. Some Mic Shine For Fenix & More

Sami Zayn Trick Williams
WWE.com

Show-opening, revolving door promo skits can be a chore sometimes. SmackDown was an example of how to do it well.

Rey Fenix interrupted Sami Zayn’s speech when his brother’s name was mentioned. Things didn’t boil over between these acknowledged pals for no good reason, which is appreciated - it’s always nice when wrestlers act like real human beings. Trick Williams came out to cut a better promo than recent efforts on Sami, then Zayn fired back by saying Trick needs to stay in his lane.

That led to Williams grabbing Johnny Gargano by the throat when he stepped up, then Nick Aldis setting up a tag match between all 4 guys. Oh yes, this was perfectly acceptable set-up. Sami is pure gold on the mic when he’s in this sort of mood, and there was more fire from Trick that he's shown recently.

If Williams is going to survive (as Zayn puts it) in the headline pack, then he'll need to be as feisty as this as a general rule. He doesn't have the 'on tap' charisma that The Rock once possessed, so running down opponents and saying things about how much they literally stink won't cut it. When Trick Willy is this fired up and focused, he's much, much better.

It's also notable that WWE handed Fenix some time on the mic as well. He grabbed that chance and made some relevant points about not knowing whether Penta will cash in Money In The Bank on Roman Reigns or Sami. Neat way to get Rey involved in a top plot line and line up SmackDown's main event.


3. Penta Adds Extra Value To 6-Man Main

Penta Rey Fenix Lucha Bros
WWE.com

Then, that main event f'n ruled.

Sami Zayn and Johnny Gargano vs. Trick Williams and Rey Fenix had been lined up earlier in the night, but Ricky Saints attacked Fenix before things could get going. That led to Penta rushing out to turn things into a 6-man tag, which was a welcome addition. Penta feels like a legit star after winning Money In The Bank, and it was lovely to see a mini Lucha Bros reunion.

If you tend to skip watching SmackDown from start to finish and only catch up with clips or reports, then do yourself a favour by checking this headliner out. That's doubly true if you loved what the Bros did over in AEW before jumping to WWE. There was a sweet double dive spot you kinda need to see.

Giving Trick the pin makes sense given he’s challenging Zayn next week too. Saints took the fall, but he'll be alright. Ricky isn't really an ongoing concern for the company at the moment, and he's been going after Rey Fenix' AAA Cruiserweight belt, so having someone WWE fancies sticking at the top of the card beat him is absolutely understandable.

The live crowd came unglued for Penta, which is a proper good sign he's on the up and up. Personally, this writer would prefer to see a series of matches between the masked man and Sami rather than Penta and Roman (even though their Raw scrap was ace), but maybe we'll get there after Crown Jewel.

Zayn bumping around for Penta sounds like a hoot.


2. A Fine Women’s Title Bout

Roxanne Perez Chelsea Green
WWE.com

Both top 'Ups' involve the women's division.

Chelsea Green defending her gold vs. Roxanne Perez was a fun watch. It’s obvious that Roxanne is ready to break out of Judgment Day’s shadow and stand on her own merits, but we’ll get there. Chelsea was excellent when fighting from underneath then capitalising on the way interference from Raquel Rodriguez and IYO SKY around ringside distracted Perez too.

This was a really tidy match from start to finish, and it'll be internally viewed as a nice title defence for Green. It's the kind of defence she needed to establish herself as a key figurehead in the division. Anyone who previously thought Chelsea was all character and no in-ring sizzle should study what she did vs. Perez.

Green doesn't need to dominate matches or 'get her s*** in' to be a star. In fact, she's much better when she's letting heels take the lead to show what they can do, whilst cherry picking some of her own spots that get a cheer out of the crowd. There's nothing wrong with Chels being an in-ring underdog against workers like Roxanne.

Nothing at all.

It'd be a surprise if Green vs. Nikki Bella matched what we got here when they clash. Perez looked like a million bucks at Money In The Bank (fittingly), and she's developing a sneaky ring general vibe to her work that's certainly worth talking about. Despite this loss, Roxanne can be real proud of how she's progressing.

Green vs. Perez wasn't the best match on the show though, which is saying something.


1. Blake Monroe Can Finally Get Started

Blake Monroe Giulia
WWE.com

Blake Monroe's ‘Street Fight’ vs. Giulia was another slick watch on SmackDown.

It was the second women’s match in a row that rocked as well. Granted, it’s arguably easier to thrill with all the weapons and distractions in a gimmick bout like this, but that’s missing the point: Blake vs. Giulia has been a stuttering feud and Monroe’s main roster run has never felt like it’s going to get going, so this was a vast improvement for both.

Now, after this performance and win, we can finally say that bigger things are coming for Blake. Lord only knows where Giulia goes from here, but she deserves praise for her work on Friday too and could find a neat landing spot vs. Jacy Jayne or if she moves on over to Raw.

A mirror spot backstage was funky, but they had to finish things in the ring. If you thought Blake and Giulia were done after going all Shawn Michaels and Marty Jannetty behind the curtain, then they had a treat in store. Their superplex spot onto some chairs looked nasty in a good way.

That had to hurt, and it's difficult to know who got the worst of it; Giulia's back smashed into some awkwardly piled chairs, but Monroe's head might've smacked into one of them on the way down too.

Both workers just had the best match either has had to date in WWE. This is the Blake/Mariah May that AEW fans once knew. It's about time management let her show up and show out.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 7 Behind The Scenes ECW Stories That’ll Shock You and WWE's Biggest Booking DISASTER Every Year (1986-2026)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.