15 WWE Pushes That IMMEDIATELY Backfired
WWE really needed to think these major pushes through first. They backfired!
Wrestling survives or thrives on the perpetual desire to try new things on a 'you never know' basis. That's what the humble push is all about. Without pushing new wrestlers to the top and attempting to create new stars, business would simply stop. WWE has to be a constantly evolving hub of freshness. However, there's a clear difference between thoughtfully mapping out new pushes and throwing things at the wall to see what might stick.
If creative minds begin to operate under hope that even those that don't really stick will slide down slowly enough to buy them time, then they'll always be trapped in that mindset. Worse, promising pushes fans did want to see have been totally wrecked by some stupid booking decisions that undermined them or made it impossible to overlook flaws.
The taste in fan mouths was too strong to ignore, basically, so they didn't/couldn't.
You'll see some familiar faces in these pages. They range from some of the biggest names in industry history to those who only carved out a chapter in biz lore for themselves because everyone pitied their push after the fact. A few were even mocked and veered perilously close to being featured on popular legacy site WrestleCrap. That aggregates "the very worst of pro wrestling", if you didn't know. Says it all!
All of these pushes backfired on WWE to some degree. They should be neatly packed into a guidebook for newbies joining the writing team. Marking them as cautionary tales on how choosing the wrong wrestler at the wrong time, or how even one single misstep can cause disaster, would be wise.
Prepare to say "EEK!" a lot.
15. Nathan Jones (2003)
EEK! See? Right, that's enough of that.
Impressive physical specimen Nathan Jones was a Vince McMahon dream on paper. He had muscles on top of muscles, was close to 7ft tall, and he was completely fresh. That's where the upsides ended. Jones made his in-person debut on the 10 April 2003 SmackDown, beat Bill DeMott, and was quickly stuck in the role of protege to The Undertaker. It was a dream gig that'd quickly turn to a nightmare.
'Taker and Nath were feuding with Big Show and A-Train heading into WrestleMania XIX, but WWE realised how rough Jones was in-ring and pulled him from the match before it happened. They turned the affair into a handicap bout instead, which didn’t make much sense or make the heels look particularly threatening. At least they had the sense to let the raw newcomer run in to help his mentor on the night, eh?
That was the last fans would see of Nathan for a while. WWE sent him down to OVW after 'Mania for seasoning. Erm...shouldn't that have happened first? Apparently not. The company couldn’t deny Nathan’s look, but he was nowhere near ready for such a lofty spot. In fact, his attempted push created one of the most forgettable matches from ‘Taker’s streak. Yes, even more forgettable than 'The Deadman' beating King Kong Bundy in 1995.
WWE's rush job came back to bite them immediately. They tried to be bold, but that wasn't the best plan during such a crucial period of the year, or with a legendary name such as Undertaker. Back to Boggo Road, Mr. Jones. So to speak.
14. Liv Morgan (2022)
Today, Liv Morgan is rightly considered one of the best female stars on WWE's books, but it's been some journey for the one-time jobber turned World Champion. Back in 2022, the creative team finally seemed ready to elevate Liv up the ladder. Literally. She won Money In The Bank, then cashed the briefcase in that same night to take the SmackDown Women’s Title from ex-MMA brawler Ronda Rousey.
So far, so good, but things fell apart after that crowd-popping moment. WWE’s follow up booking for the pair's one-on-one showdown at SummerSlam was awful - Liv tapped out during the pin, yet escaped with the belt by the skin of her teeth. Then, her wishy washy promo explanation on TV was greeted by boos, and that started a painful roll towards dropping the belt back to Rousey at October’s Extreme Rules.
Morgan's popular MITB win and cash in had been hot, but then WWE’s characterisation spoiled everything. She started to come across as somebody who was both lucky to be in the position she was in and a little bitch who basked in that idea. It was too arrogant to fly in the babyface role, and it wasn't really doing much to make Liv look on par with someone such as Ronda either.
Who thought any of this was going to turn her into a beloved baby?!
WWE should've had a license to print money when they heard fans roaring with approval for Liv at Money In The Bank. Instead, due mainly to their own silliness, the promotion had to sit and watch Morgan get booed then play before smaller and smaller reactions until losing the title. Great work, everyone. 11/10 for that first chapter. 3/10 for the rest.
13. Rocky Maivia (1996-1997)
Many fans would regard Steve Austin and The Rock as 1-A and 1-B of the heralded 'Attitude Era'. So, it's fascinating to look back on late-1996 when a beaming Rocky Maivia debuted to realise something else: Literally nobody could've seen that coming. 'Stone Cold' was already on the rise towards main event fame mid-feud with Bret Hart, whereas poodle-haired Rocky was very-much on the undercard as a new blue chip prospect.
This "blue chip prospect" smiled. He also high-fived. Did we mention that he smiled and high-fived? Maivia was a throwback to babyfaces from the 1970s, and that didn't really fit with the emerging rebel spirit pervading through a changing wrestling scene. The nWo brought cultural cool to WCW's product on the other channel, and Austin was an anti-hero in waiting who'd already charmed many.
Then, there was The Rock...who wasn't quite The Rock as you know him yet. Vicious chants of, “Die, Rocky, Die” and “Rocky Sucks” started to follow him around during matches, which had to hurt. Here he was trying his best as Vince McMahon and Jim Ross put Rocky over as the next big thing, and those pesky fans were rejecting him faster than 2025 would reject another Hulk Hogan title run.
Going hard with Maivia as a retro-style babyface backfired on the WWF. The core audience just didn't want to see it. They fancied watching characters with a little more edge and menace, not some punk kid who mimicked his dad's dancing from the 70s and used a bloody shoulderbreaker as his "devastating" finish.
Thank God for that 1997 injury and resultant heel turn. It saved The Rock and helped him build a career properly.
12. Braun Strowman (2020)
No, this isn't a text-based takedown of Braun Strowman's first major push in 2016. That was perfectly fine, and it helped usher in the return of 1980s-style squash matches to WWE television. Those weren't for everybody, but they worked for this kind of fan. 2020 was a different animal; Braun's push that year was sudden and flimsy.
Being fair, WWE needed a hasty contingency plan once Roman Reigns made it clear he wouldn’t be at WrestleMania 36 to work with Goldberg. So, Braun was put in that match instead, and he won the Universal Title from Bill. Cool, but the plan afterwards was to make Strowman a gentle giant who worked in comedic spots vs. The Miz and John Morrison. It was dire.
Tweaking Braun's presentation backfired on WWE, and it turned his title reign into a joke. Not a funny one either! It's depressing to realise that this prank-heavy pain persisted right through until his feud with Shane McMahon in 2021. WWE got some good use of that green gunge/goo they presumably bought by the truckload in 2020. They were determined to use some of it up as often as possible during Strowman's stinker of a revived push.
He'd become more of a nuisance to fans from 2018 onwards. Holding titles with 10 year olds at 'Mania, going the kid's morning TV show route with Miz and Morrison etc. Yeah, many of Braun's biggest "highs" were actually screaming lows masked as good clean fun for all the family.
The Universal belt went from Kevin Owens > Goldberg > Strowman. What a nosedive in quality.
11. Bret Hart (2010)
Bret you didn't expect to see the 'Hitman' grace this list of duff pushes gone wrong, but here he is. Things become a tad clearer upon realising that it's 2010 going under the microscope and not anything from Hart's peak run in the federation between 1984-1997. Post-Montreal Screwjob and suspect WCW run, Bret surprisingly returned on the 4 January 2010 Raw to make amends with Shawn Michaels and Vince McMahon.
That fed into a startling angle with McMahon kicking Bret in the balls, which really should’ve led to something special...if this had happened at any point before he'd stepped away from wrestling in 2000. Setting up an admittedly must-see match between these old rivals backfired on WWE in the end. Hart was a shell of his former self due to health issues by then, so his match vs. Vince at WrestleMania XXVI was abominably bad.
The legend couldn’t take bumps (any bumps), and the match was so poor that a one-sided beating almost turned McMahon babyface with the live crowd. That took some doing, but it goes to show just how limited these fellas were heading into the biggest show of the year. This wasn't a patch on Vince's scraps with other top liners in years gone by.
WWE tried to brave face things by bizarrely sticking the United States Title on Hart afterwards, but nobody was fooled. He couldn't bump, struggled to move around the ring freely, his promos had lost some fire, and Bret was generally just 'Hitman 0.5' rather than 'Hitman 2.0'.
McMahon would reason that he had to circle back to Montreal when he had the chance. Fair enough, but that doesn't mean Bret's last big push was any use.
10. Vader (1996)
What’s that? (Big Van) Vader was an excellent addition to the WWF roster in 1996 and had several big main event matches over the coming years? It’s true, he did, but Vince McMahon’s impatience scuffed the big man’s credibility overnight. Vader told the boss he was injured and thus wanted to wait until healthy to debut, but McMahon stuck him in the Royal Rumble anyway and had him work 11 minutes before being eliminated by Shawn Michaels.
The next night, Vader attacked Gorilla Monsoon and was kayfabe suspended. He’d return soon thereafter and launch into a going-nowhere program with Yokozuna. It was an inauspicious, messy start to life in the promotion, to say the least. Rushing Vader into things whilst injured was a stupid move, but Vince was desperate for stars and likely figured the Rumble needed some more star power.
Being totally honest, it didn't really. Shawn's second consecutive win carried things, and there was plenty of star quality elsewhere like Bret Hart, The Undertaker, Diesel, Razor Ramon, Owen Hart and others. Vader was a welcome addition overall, sure, but it wasn't smart to risk injuring him further, and the Michaels spot was arguably avoidable so he retained some killer edge.
Now, within 11 minutes of ring time, WWF fans had been conditioned to view Vader as somebody who was dangerous but could definitely be beaten by smaller, nimble workers like HBK. That'd come back to haunt McMahon when he put Shawn vs. Vader in the main event slot at SummerSlam later in the year.
Patience is everything.
9. Billy Gunn (1999)
Something worth saying before getting stuck into this one: Whomever sequenced WWF The Music: Vol 3, may you burn for putting Billy Gunn's 'AssMan' right after the run of goodness starting with Mankind's 'Wreck' from tracks 6-8. After Christian's under-rated banger 'Blood Brother', here comes Billy to tell you how he literally likes to "pick" bottoms. Wash your hands after meeting him at an AEW show, people. Be warned. Stay safe.
Gunn's obsession with all things rear end pinned down his 1999 push. 'Mr. Ass' won the '99 King Of The Ring tournament, then was immediately launched into a headline program against top star The Rock. Behind the curtain, the WWF wanted Rocky to bring Billy up to his level, but that was an arduous task. If anything, that Rock feud exposed him as somebody who lacked sufficient in-ring skills and promo chops when put up against the best in the promotion.
Worse, his main event push was abandoned so the WWF could reunite him with New Age Outlaws partner Road Dogg by the end of the year. His KOTR win had been a complete and utter waste of everyone's time. Previous winners like Steve Austin, Triple H and even 1998's Ken Shamrock had benefitted to different degrees, but Gunn? Barely.
Rock sent him tumbling back down to the tag-team division, and Billy's singles stardom dreams were over until the company tried again with him in late-2000. Generally, pushing someone is supposed to bring out their strengths, not shine a stark spotlight on their weaknesses.
"Everybody still thinks that I absolutely suck".
8. Lex Luger (1993)
You've got to feel for recent WWE Hall Of Famer and reborn nice guy Lex Luger. He was never signed to become the "next Hulk Hogan". Luger was brought in as a high profile ambassador for the WBF. Once that bodybuilding side project flopped, Vince McMahon decided it was time to try Lex on as a wrestler. Fair enough, but who knows what he was thinking by trying to piggy back on Hulk with somebody less charismatic who screamed self-obsessed heel?
Hogan had just departed the promotion following his latest run on top, but Vince wasn't satisfied. No, it wasn’t the dumbest idea in the world to attempt a recreation of some sort, but fans weren’t as into Luger in the role as McMahon was. So, his sudden change from 'Narcissist' to 'American Hero' and huge push heading into SummerSlam trundled along, then the Lex Express drove into a wall once Luger beat Yokozuna by countout but didn’t win the WWF Title on that pay-per-view.
He was realistically cooked after that.
Lex limped on in the main event scene until WrestleMania X, but a loud show of support for Bret Hart during the 1994 Royal Rumble’s finish spoke volumes about what the audience really wanted. Spoiler alert: It wasn't Luger marching around waving a flag like some sort of toned up Jim Duggan. The whole experiment reeked of, 'I'll just make another Hulkamania - how hard can it be?!' from McMahon.
He'd already tried to replace Hogan with one muscle man in the past (The Ultimate Warrior), but this was a clear bid to play on patriotism and the whole 'Real American' vibe. It didn't work. WWF fans wanted Bret more than they wanted Lex.
7. Ludvig Borga (1993)
It's easy to imagine that several faces dropped when people backstage in the WWF realised that new heel butt-kicker Ludvig Borga had a Nazi tattoo on his leg. Jim Ross has described via his 'Grilling JR' podcast that few could believe what they were seeing, and most generally distanced themselves from Borga after that. The writing was on the wall for his push before that horrible discovery anyway.
Look, Ludvig was a Finnish environmentalist who detested the wasteful United States way of life. Seriously. This, for some reason, was supposed to make fans despise Ludvig and view him as an ideal enemy for 'American Hero' Lex Luger. As aforementioned, Luger was struggling to convince as a babyface too, so sprinkle a lukewarm heel who'd started to fluster people behind the scenes into the mix and it was a recipe for disaster.
Borga debuted in 1993 as an antagonist for Lex, but he'd never properly get going in the federation before being cut from the roster in January 1994. In total, his push had lasted since July the previous year, and it was hardly a thrill ride. Ludvig wasn't as capable as Vince McMahon would've wanted him to be in-ring, and he wasn't very well liked in the locker room either.
Plus, the ranting promos about environmental issues fell flat with the viewing audience who wanted a little more bang for their buck than some big European dude talking about sewage. Borga's boring character and questionable antics away from the ring combined to make this a major misfire from the company.
Check out Ludvig's 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode for some truly harrowing tales.
6. Sin Cara (2011)
WWE held a heavily-covered press conference in Mexico City on 24 February 2011 to announce the signing of Mexican stand out star Mistico. There, they revealed that he’d be called Sin Cara from now on, and he was all set to become a mega-star who’d supplant Rey Mysterio as the premier masked man in the company. Several standard cameo appearances on TV followed, then Cara wrestled his first match on the 11 April Raw.
It wasn’t a spectacular outing whatsoever.
In fact, none of Cara’s matches were all that great, and his aerial work didn’t stand out as anything special or particularly bespoke. Those expecting the next coming of Mysterio were left thinking WWE had signed a dud. It was hard to shake that feeling when following Cara's first forays onto TV, to be honest.
A Wellness Policy violation in July didn’t help him, but the push was tanking before that anyway and everyone watching knew it. Sin Cara's trampoline-assisted entrance sometimes went awry and made him look clumsy rather than acrobatic. Think Rey Fenix if he fell down or slipped 5 out of 10 times he scaled the ropes for some flashy aerial work - people would soon get sick of those botches.
Instead of becoming Mysterio's successor, Sin Cara became somebody who needed rescued by a casting change. Mistico was out, and the ex-Hunico was in. He did a better job with the gimmick than predicted. It was never going to be headline material again, but at least it wasn't a crushing disappointment and occasional laughing stock like it had been before.
5. Mordecai (2004)
Few could point the finger of blame at WWE for trying to extend The Undertaker's reach. After all, he'd been one of the most successful characters of all time in his own right, and 'Taker had even opened the door for the offshoot Kane gimmick. Maybe, just maybe, they could make more magic with 'The Deadman' and give somebody else a push off the back of his star power.
Or not.
In 2004, vignettes began airing for Mordecai. They were very Undertaker-y, but with a twist. Instead of hiding in shadowy darkness, big Mord basked in harsh white light. In effect, he was a lighter version of 'Taker, and WWE went overboard trying to push that he was here to cleanse the company from sin. This, in theory, should've let to 'Darkness vs. Light' (albeit with Mordecai surely in the heel role).
Undertaker had just returned to the classic supernatural gimmick himself, so it made sense, but then Mordecai wrestled Scotty 2 Hotty at Judgment Day '04 and all bets were off. The match was a flat affair, one so nondescript and dull that WWE quickly lost interest in pushing their new creation. Honestly, did anybody stop to think about the nuances of pushes/characters like this before introducing them? It was flinging stuff at walls to see what might stick, then giving up at the first hurdle if everything didn't run smoothly.
Mordecai turned from possible-Undertaker rival to big, clumsy guy who needed to go back down to developmental for a bit more work. It happened fast. Like, lasted 3 months fast.
4. Muhammad Hassan (2004-2005)
Looking back, the entire premise for Muhammad Hassan was ghastly from the off. It preyed on people's fears after 9/11, and the guy behind the gimmick (Marc Copani) was asked to sink to increasingly xenophobic depths in order to garner heat. At times, as revealed during the 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode analysing his run, Copani was uncomfortable with this, and understandably so.
Here's the thing: Fans did boo Hassan when he debuted in late-2004, but it quickly became clear that the character just made folks distressed or sucked them out of the fantasy land they wanted to be in when watching Raw/SmackDown; not in a pro wrestling heel way, but more in a 'yeah, this is something too real and grim to work as escapism' way. Again, Hassan himself wasn’t cool with some of what WWE had him do.
Things were going wrong months and months before the infamous attack on The Undertaker in July 2005, but that's typically pointed to as the breaking point. It certainly was for execs at UPN. They were horrified by WWE's booking in light of terror attacks in London, and they demanded that the character be taken off TV. Sadly, it was Copani himself who took the hardest hit here.
He wasn't afforded the luxury of a repackage job or any patience at all from WWE. His wrestling career was pretty much over.
The company had wanted to stir patriotic sensibilities in the aftermath of 9/11, but they went too far with it. It says everything when Marc was confronted by angry Muslim men when touring Australia. They weren't happy with how the gimmick portrayed their faith. Copani was spooked by that altercation. Rightly so!
3. Mabel (1995)
Legend has it that, if you download a 'King' Mabel CAW in WWE 2K25 and try to push him to the top in Universe Mode, then the game immediately crashes, uninstalls and the disc (if you have one) flies out of your console into the nearest bin. This feature has been included in the new patch. Obviously not, but it's hardly like anybody is going to do something so insane anyway.
Vince McMahon did it for real back in 1995. Let that sink in for a minute.
Slow tag-team powerhouse Mabel somehow became King Of The Ring that year despite stars like Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker being in the same tournament. Sure, most get that the WWF wanted to create fresh upper card attractions and a monster for Diesel to work with as champion, but they clearly hadn’t been paying attention to his matches - Diesel was at his best when working with smaller, more dynamic wrestlers like HBK and Bret Hart. In his own words, he “needed movement”.
Mabel was never going to give him that, and he was a clumsy oaf who recklessly injured others without learning lessons from his mistakes. During his nightmare of a push during the second half of the year, Mabel hurt Diesel’s back and shattered ‘Taker’s face...all whilst working some of the worst matches fed fans had ever seen. Top job!
To recap, he was the least wanted 'King' yet, hurt a lot of guys with his reckless behaviour, and he wasn't somebody fans really wanted to watch anyway. Where was the upside here?
2. ‘Dr. Death’ Steve Williams (1998)
In 1998, someone had the not-so-bright idea to sign known grappling hard man 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams and prepare him for Steve Austin by putting him in a shoot-fighting/boxing tournament against a collection of ragtag WWF midcarders. What a ‘Brawl For All’ inspired nightmare poor 'Doc' suffered. He needed to be protected, not laid bare as an aging veteran with knackered knees who was past his best.
Choosing to mire your new signing (one you've got grand plans for) in a dreadful shoot tournament that became infamous in 1998-1999 for hurting talent and boring fans senseless was some decision. Williams beat Quebecer Pierre via TKO in the first round, but then got knocked spark out by surprise package Bart Gunn on the 27 July ’98 edition of Raw in the quarter final. That was the end of his push.
Gunn went on to win the tourney, but was bizarrely punished for beating ‘Dr. Death’ and derailing creative plans. Man, if only WWF television was scripted and they had the power to create any outcome they wanted, eh? It was entirely possible to book Williams as a thuggish monster who'd be a threat to 'Stone Cold' without having one of the bloody Smoking Gunns make him look like a loser nobody should pay attention to.
It really cannot be overstayed just how stupid the 'Brawl For All' was. Others like Steve Blackman have revealed how restrictive it was (Blackman wasn't allowed to throw kicks), and the whole thing was total trash from start to end. On top of that, it egregiously nuked a possible main event program.
Bonkers creative.
1. Scott Steiner (2002-2003)
“Gimme the f’n mic!”.
One line from a fired up Scott Steiner was all it took to let everyone know that 'Big Poppa Pump' had arrived in WWE. His work towards the end of WCW's lifespan was thumping, urgent and dangerous (in a good way), and it's a shame that the company was on the way out. So, following his fabulously intense debut at the 2002 Survivor Series, it looked like Scotty would continue his excellence on a grander stage.
Steiner was a hot ticket straight away, but his physique and presentation masked injury troubles that’d be laid bare in back to back stinkers vs. Triple H at Royal Rumble and No Way Out 2003. Unfortunately for Scotty, this was also the same period of time when Kurt Angle and Chris Benoit were working scorchers for the other top belt over on SmackDown’s side. That only made his bouts with Hunter look even worse.
They were truly rotten. Steiner was having trouble with one of his feet due to a lingering health issue, and he was never 100% throughout his stint as a main eventer. It felt like a sick joke that he'd been one of wrestling's most dynamic workers for a generation, but couldn't live up to his own hype now he finally had a physique Vince McMahon would pay attention to. That sucks!
WWE didn't get the 'Big Booty Daddy' who had ruled latter day WCW. They got a broken version of that guy, one who was never going to look worthy during a poor section of Triple H's career (he wasn't moving freely himself) whilst super-workers like Angle and Benoit produced classics.
What other WWE pushes backfired spectacularly? For more like this, check out 10 WWE Name Changes That IMMEDIATELY Backfired and 12 Misconceptions About WCW You Probably Believe!