9 WWE Matches That Fell Apart On Live TV

Mistakes, missteps and missing the point of the WrestleMania main event...

Jade Cargill
WWE

Poor Jackie Gayda.

The woman became an entire generation's shorthand for "worst match of all time" thanks to several quite horrendous and business-exposing botches during a tag team match alongside Christopher Nowinski against Trish Stratus and Bradshaw on the July 8th 2002 edition of Monday Night Raw.

But on reflection, was she really at fault?

The guiltiest exchanges with her and Stratus are indeed woeful. The miscommunications are obvious, booed loudly in the building, and evidently aggravating to her colleagues. But what chance did she have? Her Cagematch profile is one page long and the aforementioned stinker is her sixth entry on it. Not sixth match with WWE or sixth match on television - her sixth match ever. Her partner (Tough Enough alumni) Chris Nowinski had just over 30 matches himself by then. Even Stratus - considered a veteran by the era's ludicrous standards - was only two years into her career with half of that time spent working gimmick matches before WWE took a passing interest in women actually wrestling again. 

As the lone experienced hand, Bradshaw could only do so much from his side of the ring too, and was the one least likely to get it in the neck thanks to political sway and the general rounding on Gayda in the aftermath. 

The promotion should have protected the talent and accepted blame here. It shouldn't have even been on TV for the world to see. It's not like they'd book something this weak as the WrestleMania main event...

9. Roman Reigns Vs The Undertaker (WrestleMania 33)

WWE WrestleMania 33 The Undertaker Roman Reigns
WWE.com

The WrestleMania main event. Unequivocally the biggest match in all of wrestling, and that's exactly how WWE want it. The biggest company puts on the biggest show and the biggest show ends with the biggest match. In an industry where so much is subjective, this cannot be argued.

That's what made The Undertaker's last ever WrestleMania headliner (to date) such a calamity. 'The Deadman' not only failed to lift the crowd from their slumber multiple hours deep into the show, but he failed to lift the younger Roman Reigns up to the level needed desperately at the time, and by the end failed to even lift him up for the Tombstone.

Reigns attempted to create movement around his knackered foe, but it was for naught on multiple counts. The fans didn't get back into the action around the botches that broke their immersion, and - driven by a hatred for 'The Big Dog' that was going nowhere - didn't get into his "babyface" dominance anymore than Undertaker's tepid and laboured comebacks. 

In a way, both men did their best, but the younger wrestler wasn't in a position to perform the salvage job, while the older one - by his own admission latterly - simply didn't have the engine to keep up.

It's not like they were both in their prime...


8. Brock Lesnar Vs Roman Reigns (WrestleMania 34)

Brock Lesnar Roman Reigns
WWE.com

The WrestleMania main event. Unequivocally the biggest match in all of wrestling, and that's exactly how WWE want it. The biggest company puts on the biggest show and yada yada at this point you get the deal even when WWE seemingly didn't. 

Vince McMahon was failing at the creative side of his job so spectacularly that a top babyface had a push laying in ruins, a top heel got cheered throughout a complete bludgeoning, and the WrestleMania main event itself was - rather than being the aforementioned highest level - becoming the most poisoned chalice in the entire industry. 

Roman Reigns was a babyface so loathed that fans loudly and angrily protested his attempts to end the tyranny of Brock Lesnar. 'The Beast' really did have a stranglehold on the Universal Title from the comfort of his part time schedule, but this was the extent to which audiences were prepared to reject 'The Big Dog' in his latest attempt to end it. A comical amount of F5s couldn't end it. A shoot bloodletting couldn't end it. One last F5 did end it - itself a hilariously poor finish in the circumstances - bit the disparate state of things across the board highlighted that this was just the start of the company's most wretched era yet.

How could it feel like the end of anything anyway? Neither man was going anywhere. It's not as if you could market this as the retirement of your biggest star...


7. Hulk Hogan Vs Sid Justice (WrestleMania VIII)

Papa Shango GIF
WWE Network

The WrestleMania main event. Unequivocally the biggest match in all of wrestling, and that's exactly how WWE want it. The biggest company puts on the biggest show and oh by the way Hulk Hogan is retiring forever on it.

Not really obviously, but Hogan and many of his ilk were about to exit stage left from a company that was fighting a losing battle to look as if it wasn't taking a commercial kicking from a falling public interest and lots of overdue media discussion and investigation into multiple behind-the-scenes scandals.

Front of house, the shop was looking as sloppy as the backstage area sounded. Hogan and newly-turned heel Sid Justice had a total stinker out there, made even worse by a fumbled conclusion that called for Justice to shoot kick out of Hogan's leg drop when newcomer Papa Shango catastrophically botched the timing of his run-in. 

Whatever cue he'd been given had been missed, so he was nowhere near the ring when called-upon to break up the fall. He was nowhere near the ring seconds later when, upon finally emerging in front of the crowd, he stopped and looked around first before at long last giving Sid a helping hand to trigger a languid show-closing disqualification finish.

Look at the above clip - he still looks as if he's taking a wrong turn even when the year's biggest spotlight shines down on him. On commentary, Gorilla Monsoon and Bobby Heenan don't call what they can't see, and only the Ultimate Warrior's surprise return bails it out from being an all-time stinker.

Good run-ins can do that. Bad ones though...


6. Cody Rhodes Vs John Cena (WrestleMania 41)

John Cena Cody Rhodes
WWE

The WrestleMania main event. Unequivocally the biggest match in all of wrestling, and that's exactly how WWE want it. The biggest company puts on the biggest show featuring two performers who are comfier in the spot than most others...but one more could have done with turning up instead of his inexperienced rapper mate.

Not that The Rock replacing Travis Scott in a like-for-like switch would have repaired the damage already done to the WrestleMania vibes by Cody Rhodes' almost devastatingly bad WWE Championship defence against John Cena. The pair were given something of a poisoned chalice in the spot, thanks to an iconic Cena heel turn that had already started to veer off course in the weeks hence, and a go-home promo spat in Las Vegas that had somehow created a split crowd all over again.

The match itself didn't suffer from a visible or terrible botch, but simply felt like one never-ending one. Cena stomped and punched away, Rhodes at various points made comebacks to scattershot reactions, Cena slowed it down, Rhodes came again, and the whole thing wore on and on and on as the live crowd optimistically pined for a grand finale and those at home voted with their social posts. 

An appearance by The Rock - the man Cena sold his soul to, remember - was going to be the difference between creative catastrophe and narrowly-averted disaster, so when Travis Scott filled the spot (albeit with one last play of the epic FE!N) and guided 'The Champ' to his "never-seen seventeen", the former was bleakly apparent. 


5. Triple H Vs Scott Steiner (Royal Rumble 2003)

Triple H Scott Steiner Royal Rumble
WWE.com

The point of calling yourself 'The Game' is to put yourself so far above everybody else on the show that no wrestling nickname or moniker can compete with it. That was a smart call by Triple H, but he created a ceiling for himself that - within two years and one quad injury of creating it - he simply couldn't reach.

Never was this clearer than during his "reign of terror" between 2002 and 2005, where a cycle of dreadful matches underpinned by nepotistic booking expedited the end of the prior commercial boom. Everything favoured him at all times (or at least the times that mattered) as he jobbed and showed ass tactically and selectively, ensuring that nobody was good enough to take his spot until he simply couldn't justify clinging on to it anymore.

Scott Steiner had Hunter outstripped in size, aura and arguably star power, having mostly been absent since WCW's closure in 2001, and the 'Big Poppa Pump' character carried a believable sense of danger that Triple H had long been drained of. In real life, Steiner was also working hurt, but that's the stuff somebody like 'The Game' should have been good enough to hide. He failed profoundly at that, succeeding in his mission to ruin any chance Steiner ever had of being considered a big deal. 

Their 18-minute long Royal Rumble 2003 stinker was the beginning of Scott's time in WWE and the beginning of the end of his headline role. The challenger only had a gassed suplex to his name, Hunter made him look like a weakling for it, and the non-finish resulted in a rematch the following month where he got to put him down and out for good.


4. Charlotte Flair Vs Nia Jax (Raw, August 30th 2021)

Nia Jax Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

WWE's 2021 return to live crowds following the pandemic was, creatively, an unmitigated disaster.

Fans were glad to be back in buildings and wrestlers looked positively overjoyed to be free from the shackles of the ThunderDome, but Vince McMahon's rotting and rotten creative was as awful as ever and with no better direction to suit the circumstances, familiar problems bubbled to the surface. In this case, it was evident in the work of two performers who've never been shy of causing a bit of controversy. 

Nia Jax and Charlotte Flair were in the middle of a match on the September 30th edition of Monday Night Raw, until...they weren't. A breakdown of communication of some description resulted in several years of a professional relationship breaking down in front of everybody, all to the tune of a host of potatoes and sandbagging attempts. It was a bit like when a match isn't going too well and wrestlers attempt to work their way out of trouble, only nothing was a work and it was as if they were looking for some kind of surrender from the other before they returned to the regularly scheduled programming. 

The exchanges looked abysmal on account of them not being remotely collaborative, and they eventually pulled it around to the point where they were booked in a rematch the following week. That was the only saving grace; having generated almost zero buzz in the run-up to the Autumn series of shows, it took something that was fundamentally the opposite of pro wrestling for WWE to finally have something resembling a hot hand.


3. Goldust Vs The Ultimate Warrior (In Your House 7: Good Friends, Better Enemies)

Ultimate Warrior

Perhaps it's unfair to include this.

Not unfair to Goldust and The Ultimate Warrior, nor WWE, but to the very meaning of the word "match" considering how little action played out over the excruciating eight minutes the pair spent out there not wrestling on account of the Intercontinental Champion's injury and the Warrior's man-out-of-time return to the company in 1996.

For those uninitiated with In Your House lore thanks to much of it being ignored by documentaries and archivists over the years, the "contest" was anything but. The pair stalled for so much time, Warrior smoked Marlena's cigar (much to the chagrin of Vince McMahon on commentary trying to deny what was literally happening in front of everybody's eyes) while sat in his director's chair wearing his robe, beat up an usher (TAFKA Mantaur, randomly selected for the one-night-only role) and won by count-out.

This was damning on all fronts. Warrior was being paid truckloads of cash that WWE simply didn't have, which may be why Vince McMahon was happy to promote this over absolutely nothing when it came to selling the B-Show. He'd have been better off going with the latter - it left the sourest of tastes for both acts and the company itself on a night where new WWE Champion Shawn Michaels and top challenger Vader saw off Diesel and Razor Ramon respectively as Kevin Nash and Scott Hall set sail for WCW. The new beginning couldn't have looked more like the same old slop.


2. Chris Jericho Vs Neville (Raw, March 14th 2016)

Chris Jericho Neville Charles Robinson
WWE.com

Future AEW colleagues Chris Jericho and PAC were already familiar with one another when they worked together on the March 14th 2016 edition of Monday Night Raw, but 'Y2J' and Charles Robinson certainly looked like total strangers when it came to (mis)communicating on the geordie's deeply unfortunate injury midway through the match. 

Neville hurt his ankle early doors during a routine slide through Jericho's legs, and despite attempting to carry on in the immediate aftermath, he ultimately had to pull up when it was clear things were wrong. Jericho appears to communicate to Robinson that he'll make the cover to end things, but Robinson seemingly doesn't hear and only registers a two, leading to an extremely heated exchange between the pair live in the middle of the ring on the flagship show. 

As evidenced elsewhere on this list, how exactly referees are supposed to behave when things go awry seems to change depending on who's on the headsets passing on instructions, but Robinson was determined to treat everything as a shoot to such an extent that Jericho ultimately ate a disqualification due to how hard he pushed him while screaming "HE'S HURT!" mid-chaos. 


1. Tiffany Stratton Vs Jade Cargill Vs Nia Jax (SmackDown, 26th September 2025)

Jade Cargill Nia Jax
WWE

A series of worst case scenarios, the conclusion to the Tiffany Stratton/Jade Cargill/Nia Jax triple threat WWE Women's Championship match on the September 26th 2025 was so multifariously botched that no finish would have fully made sense by the end - including the one that played out on television.

Things first took a turn when Cargill was busted hardway after being thrown into the steel steps by Jax, though early concerns that she may have suffered a concussion and missed another cue were unfounded, and as good as confirmed by Cargill liking a tweet saying as much days later. Everything really fell apart when Stratton failed to break up a cover attempt by Cargill on Jax, forcing Nia to kick out only to layout for a three count seconds later when Stratton made the fall. Because this would have looked unrealistic, referee Daphanie LaShaunn pulled up the count despite Jax not moving her shoulder.

Time stood still before Nia eventually put a shoulder up, but by then the crowd had completely turned on the entire match. Stratton wrapped it up with the Prettiest Moonsault Ever, but nobody escaped how ugly all of this ended up.

(You can still watch WWE - albeit with some of this stuff hurriedly cut out from repeat broadcasts - on Netflix internationally and/or enjoy a host of other benefits from having NordVPN with 76% off and three months for free when you sign up here)


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.