How AEW Should Debut Drew McIntyre

The former WWE Champion could be the next big name to make the jump, but what awaits his landing?

Drew McIntyre AEW
AEW/WWE

What's going on with Drew McIntyre and WWE?

By the time you read this, that question may already have been answered. 'The Scottish Warrior' has been AWOL since WrestleMania 39 and is contracted until early 2024, but it's been left ambiguous whether or not one of SmackDown's top babyfaces is simply licking the many wounds sustained in that triple threat Intercontinental Championship match, or considering his options outside of the company completely.

There's smoke to that particular fire - there have been multiple reports about the uncertain status of the former WWE Champion, which have furthered the narrative that he may be exploring his options. It's a big summer to do it too. His current employers will hit the O2 in London for a sold-out Money In The Bank pay-per-view, while AEW has shot beyond that with the mammoth All In from Wembley Stadium two months later. Three years ago and with WWE flag firmly in hand, McIntyre wouldn't have missed one or the other for all the money in the world. He wanted the market leader to run a proper Premium Live Event in Great Britain, and he wanted the opportunity to be a major part of something resembling the SummerSlam.

He got both in 2022, but his Clash At The Castle misadventure will be remembered more for awkwardly singing away his heartbreak with Tyson Fury that finishing his own story and dethroning Roman Reigns. The proto-rubber chicken moment, it was the latest high-profile near-miss from the man that is still owed more from his 2020 stint in empty buildings than he ever received when crowds came back.

He knows this too. It's why the rumours persist, the questions remain unanswered, and the post-WrestleMania absence extended.

All of this is infinitely more interesting with Drew out of the WWE spotlight, because it gives people time to consider exactly what he'd look like under an AEW one...

CONT'D...


GUNTHER Drew McIntyre
WWE

There are many divisive figures in professional wrestling, but said stars are often divisive because they're difficult or messy or hang their dirty laundry out in public. Drew McIntyre is none of these things, but he finds his offering debated as if he was.

McIntyre's a multi-time WWE Champion who has main-evented against Roman Reigns in the last calendar year while also having perhaps the most critically acclaimed company match of the last 12 months. He's a 6'5 super-heavyweight with a cleaner dive than people half his size who's still south of 40 in an era where wrestler prime is only getting older. He's chameleonic enough to play cold-hearted killer heel or WWE gameshow host babyface, and in fact, turned his career around pivoting from one to the other almost overnight in 2019.

The WrestleMania 39 Intercontinental Championship triple threat that also featured Sheamus and Gunther was universally acclaimed during and after the battle, and was elevated to contemporary classic as 'Der Ring General' celebrated his win. Cagematch.net's contributors marked it a 9.4 out of 10 based on the democratic voting, then the Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer gave it the full five stars. 'The Show Of Shows' contest was no fluke after several years in similar high profile spots.

He's also a wrestler that plenty of AEW fans would probably (politely) take a pass on. Is that a him thing, a company thing?

Anecdotally, it appears to be a bit of both.

CONT'D...


Shinsuke Nakamura Miz
WWE.com

It's simply too easy to take wrestling regulars and company mainstays for granted in the content super-service era.

This is the case with both WWE and AEW in 2023, but was a problem long before the latter even launched. It's a good thing that the industry has gradually shifted to preserve the health and well-being of its most important individuals more than ever, but the reverse ageing process on the wrestlers has the opposite effect on them as consistently captivating television stars.

It's not fair, really; if you somehow assembled a career like The Miz you'd probably want to recite your Wikipedia page off once a week too, but 52 promos a year about all the different title defences during those two Grand Slams aren't going to make people remember them as fondly as The Ultimate Warrior's singular World Heavyweight Championship win, or Stone Cold Steve Austin's three WrestleMania title triumphs, or even the over-praised but fondly remembered JBL WWE Championship stranglehold between 2004 and 2005.

This is the way now. Not a week goes by where another full-time WWE wrestler doesn't double or treble the amount of years The Rock spent on the roster. Roman Reigns' recent 1000-day milestone is undeniably impressive and a couple of excellent SmackDown numbers speak to the objective financial successes along the way, but the cultural footprint of his four-figure stint with the top prize won't be anywhere near as deep as the ones left behind by Hogan, Bruno Sammartino or even Madison Square Garden mega-draw Bob Backlund.

McIntyre fell into that trap in his original 2008-2014 run, going from Vince McMahon's "Chosen One" to somebody saying goodbye to forgotten Intercontinental and Tag Team Title runs. It's happened again (albeit on a much higher tier), and those looking for a little more spice on Wednesday (and/or Saturday!) nights might not realise exactly what McIntyre could bring to the table.

CONT'D...


Drew Galloway
WWE.com

The Drew McIntyre that wrestles outside of WWE reflects more about what helped launch All Elite Wrestling than the average 2023 edition of Dynamite.

McIntyre - who from here on out will be referred to as Drew Galloway because this will definitely be his branding anywhere he works away from the market leader - wrestled with a point to prove from the moment he was released in 2014. From figuring himself out bell-to-bell as a contemporary power-and-pace guy, to significant aesthetic changes, to dropping some tasty four-letter flourishes to developing a keen grasp of what those attending local/small/rival shows wanted, indies-and-Impact era Drew Galloway was a rare case of a wrestler serving multiple masters and succeeding.

Especially because the main master was the one that had sent him packing once before. Galloway wasn't doing those hard yards with the expressed purpose of going back to WWE, but he's spoken in the years since about his desire to prove the original release to be the wrong call. The fruitfulness of his return has always scanned as vindication, even if the goals eventually changed and he constantly felt like a performer falling just short of the rewards he was owed.

AEW are about to run Wembley Stadium, disproving once and for all that WWE is the only place to get WrestleMania-like reactions from WrestleMania-like crowds. And they could do worse than following up on that by eventually setting Galloway up for the major United Kingdom win he never received with the market leader.

CONT'D...


WWE.com

There's been a lot of conversation about British wrestlers getting the opportunity to work All In, and while it's rooted in reasonable sentiment, it's hotdogging and opportunism more than because it makes creative or commercial sense.

Everybody's got a favourite, but from Will Ospreay to Zack Sabre Jr, even the very best in the world from this side of the Atlantic aren't the main reason Wembley Stadium sold 65,000+ tickets before a match was even announced. The UK audience are starved for All Elite Wrestling, not wrestlers they've already seen before wrestling on an All Elite Wrestling show. The same will be true when the organisation are under pressure to follow it up after the summer spectacle.

Drew Galloway - as a p*ssed off and entitled heel bullying his way onto the card - would thus be perfect for the company's UK post-Wembley return in 2024.

He's considered a WWE Superstar more than a Brit-done-good at this point, so it'd be easy to have him brought in as an atomic bomb none of the roster could have prepared for. With his aforementioned skillset, he'd be a dream to watch mix it up with the likes of Kenny Omega, MJF and especially Hangman Page, and watching him reconnect with old rivals Jon Moxley, CM Punk and Chris Jericho under a new banner has more novelty value than many others that have crossed the divide.

He'd need a fresh babyface to fight and beat, and there'd be few better than Orange Cassidy. Especially if 'Freshly Squeezed' happens to still be the International Champion. A guy screaming the F-Word at the top of his lungs and melodramatically screaming his anger into Cassidy's face is about as far away from the relaxed workhorse legacy the titleholder has already established.

Drew Galloway can tell before he shows, then show anyway when the big night arrives.

CONT'D...


Orange Cassidy
AEW

Effectively stealing a spot on the card, Galloway could brutalise Cassidy on his debut with the intent of taking the International Championship and "restoring its prestige", or however he wants to reframe and justify his violence.

Over the weeks leading up to the show, a sinister motivation could reveal itself; he never got his big Championship moment in front of his "home nation", and he's found a shortcut. Heeling him against his most loyal supporters might seem counterintuitive, but it'd only take weeks of the big Scot shooting on UK fans specifically for patronising him during his cursed 2022 run at Roman Reigns. The whole thing playing as one big riff on the "these shows need UK acts" refrain works even better when the highest profile UK act making the trip is booed out of the building against a company original and arguably the character most associated with AEW's unique creative flair.

Whomever eventually beats Cassidy is elevated by that alone, so the momentum would be with him after the fact. The localised heat could subside, replaced by the actions of an ex-WWE killer monster towering over his challengers and clinging onto the belt as if it was the Universal Championship he was never able to claim.

AEW are great at putting runs together, and Drew's with this title would carry on Orange Cassidy's incredible reign. Cassidy may even be the man to win it back, but if nothing else, it adds value to the roster without that perpetual question hanging over so many signings over the last few years - were they really worth the investment?

Like he did in WWE on the cusp of an unprecedented global pandemic and across an independent industry not predisposed to embrace performers like him, he'd answer that with a resounding "F*CK Yes".


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.