Roman Reigns' 10 Best WWE Matches
Big Match Big Dog.
This past Monday, Joe "Roman Reigns" Anoa'i revealed to the world that his leukaemia had returned, forcing him to relinquish the Universal Championship and take a hiatus from WWE to focus on treatment.
In a development that reflects immensely on the wrestling community, Joe has received endless praise, support, and encouragement from fans, wrestlers, and even rival promotions. Needless to say, WhatCulture is 100 percent rooting for Joe to beat leukaemia, as he has before, and return to entertaining fans as Roman Reigns.
Of course, this article is not a pity party about Joe Anoa'i. This is more a show of gratitude. Over the years, the drama of WWE trying to get Roman Reigns over as a babyface has been more interesting than any of his actual storylines. Fans have booed him to bits and resented any attempts WWE have made to get us to like him of our own accord.
But none of that has changed the fact that Roman Reigns has been one of the best big match performers of his generation. Regardless of what you feel about his spot, he has always delivered in it.
This list is a walk down memory lane that, hopefully, will make you say #ThankYouRoman...
10. Vs. Sheamus (TLC 2015)
TLC 2015 was sort of an anomaly. At the time, WWE couldn't have been any worse. Talented wrestlers were dropping like flies due to injury, the shows were becoming increasingly stale and grating, and most offensive of all, Sheamus was WWE Champion.
Yet miraculously, TLC 2015 managed to be a pretty good show, capped off by a whopper main event between Roman Reigns and Sheamus. Not that you would know it at first, of course; given the terrible build for this match, that included Roman cutting promos about Sheamus' "tater tots," the fans were having none of this brawl between Reigns and Sheamus. With chants from "We just saw this" to "We want Cena," it was difficult at first to see that the two men in the ring were having an excellent TLC match for the WWE Championship, featuring intense physicality and dazzling high spots.
Of course, the cherry on top was the post-match. Once again robbed of the WWE title thanks to interference from the League of Nations (remember them?), Roman went absolutely berserk, beating the p*ss out of the League members.
Triple H, the man who orchestrated Roman's misfortunes, came out and attempted to make peace, and Reigns laid him out as well for good measure, storyline hospitalizing The Game. From the first time in months, the crowd of hardcore fans cheered Reigns as he finally embraced the renegade bad boy person people had wanted out of him.
For a time at least, Roman was the most beloved member of the roster.
9. Vs. Daniel Bryan (Fastlane 2015)
So, as a bit of disclosure: throughout this article, you might see phrases like "more experienced" or "led him through" in regards to Roman Reigns' PPV opponents. None of that is meant to imply that Roman's foes simply "carried" him to good matches, because that would be an insult to Roman. It's clear that when it counts, Roman always delivered. However, when discussing the great matches of his career, it's evident that his progress was aided by the true greats of our industry.
Take, for example, Daniel Bryan.
After the disastrous 2015 Royal Rumble at which Reigns was booed out of the building, WWE decided to remedy the situation by putting him one-on-one with the man everyone wanted to win said Rumble for the right to challenge for the title at WrestleMania.
Reigns was put in a no-win situation, essentially. But instead of sandbagging the match and making everything about him, Daniel Bryan helped Roman bring the best out of himself, and the two had a physical, emotional match in the main event of Fastlane. It was here where Roman revealed that, in big match situation as a singles competitor, he could deliver when it counted.
While he was absolutely led by Bryan to such a caliber, this was the on-the-job training he needed to deliver on his own in the future.
8. Vs. Cesaro (RAW November 2015)
Holy moly, that like/dislike ratio.
If you don't remember, back in 2015, Cesaro was really gaining momentum as a singles babyface wrestler. After his tag team with Tyson Kidd ended as a result of Kidd's career-ending injury, Cesaro gained a sizeable amount of fan support with his insane athleticism and amazing wrestling clinics.
In the fall, when Seth Rollins' injury forced the WWE Championship to be vacated, a makeshift tournament was created to culminate at Survivor Series. In this quarterfinal, Cesaro and Roman Reigns faced off in what was perhaps Roman's first truly great match on regular TV. Playing to both men's strengths, the match was perhaps the pinnacle of Cesaro's babyface run. You truly believed he could possibly defeat the Big Dog to advance in the tournament.
For Reigns' part, he absolutely brought his A-Game against one of the world's finest, doing everything he could to portray Cesaro as an equal. While obviously everyone was miffed about the predictable result (15 thousand dislikes, Jeez-Louise), no one could deny what a stupendous match this was.
Reigns has gone on to have excellent RAW matches against the likes of Seth Rollins, Finn Balor, Miz, and Samoa Joe, but here was the start of the Big Dog's matches being must-see TV.
7. Vs. Bray Wyatt (Hell In A Cell 2015)
Roman Reigns has a unique specialty: he's able to take terrible story lines, and beat them with weapons until we forget how bad they are. Meaning: he's able to take bad booking, but if you give him some gimmicks to play with, he can turn chicken crap into chicken salad. That's exactly what he and Bray Wyatt did at Hell In A Cell 2015. In both men's first Cell match, they took their terrible, meandering feud, and blew it off in an epic brawl.
Featuring creative table and chair spots, as well as a Los Angeles crowd willing to buy the dynamic of Reigns slaying the evil monster Bray Wyatt, this match - that looked dire on paper - turned out to be a thrilling contest that was worthy of being inside Hell in a Cell.
6. Vs. The Big Show (Extreme Rules 2015)
In the early part of Roman Reigns' singles career, The Big Show was trotted out as the slow, lumbering cannon fodder to have dull, plodding matches on RAW that presented artificial stakes for Roman to overcome. Needless to say, few if any were looking forward to a Last Man Standing match between the two at Extreme Rules 2015.
However, by the miracle of smart booking and the two competitors performing their roles perfectly, not only did the match get over, it generated the best reaction of the night in Chicago, no less.
Expertly playing the heel, Big Show forewent any sort of weapons-based mayhem, deliberately breaking kendo sticks and tables with his own hands and insisting that, as a giant, he didn't need such gimmicks. This naturally infuriated the crowd, who came to a PPV called Extreme Rules to see some mayhem. Thankfully, that mayhem came at the hands of Roman Reigns, who brought out the crazy spots fans were dying to see, including a moment where he speared the Big Show from one announce table to another to another after leaping off steel steps.
While one could point out the manipulative booking of this match, they can't deny that it worked to a T on this night. And of course, this match remains a joy to watch to this day.
5. Vs. Samoa Joe, Braun Strowman, and Brock Lesnar (SummerSlam 2017)
By this point in his career, Roman Reigns had more-or-less accepted his role: he was the main-eventer who everyone would boo. He would stoically push through that negative reaction and pull off big-time performances. In a way, during the summer of 2017, he somewhat faded into the background, as guys like Samoa Joe and Braun Strowman got themselves over as big-time personalities.
However, when the time came for all three men to face off against Brock Lesnar in a Fatal Four-Way match for the Universal Championship at SummerSlam, Roman put on his working boots, and he played his part in making an instant classic.
A non-stop, chaotic mess of high-spots and power-moves, all four men in this match showed off their strengths and showed no weakness in terms of working ability. But Roman remained the constant presence in this match with his selflessness and ability to showcase the best in his opponents, selling for big moves and not trying to make the match about him. In fact, any time Roman cut off someone's offense to a chorus of boos, someone would immediately get offense back on him to get over.
It takes a lot of skill to dictate the tone of a match while not being the focus of it, and on this night, Roman Reigns did that with gusto.
4. Vs. Kevin Owens (Royal Rumble 2017)
In late 2016, Roman Reigns and Kevin Owens had a dreadful program on television.
Not to say any of their matches were necessarily bad, just to say that the two (or their buddies Seth Rollins and Chris Jericho respectively) seemed to wrestle each other week-in and week-out, making RAW an oppressively dull, predictable, and insulting product. It was this banality that contributed to the fan consensus at the time that SmackDown was far and above the superior show during the early days of the new brand split.
At Royal Rumble 2017, with the Universal Championship on the line, in a No DQ match, Roman Reigns and Kevin Owens decided "F It," and completely erased the ill will built. In a completely unhinged spot-fest, Reigns and Owens brought everything to the table, and then promptly smashed through said table. With Stone Cold Stunners, whacky chair spots, and run-ins, this match stood in stark contrast to the wrestling clinic between John Cena and AJ Styles later in the night, but was nonetheless totally exciting and satisfying in its own right, and added an extra dimension to an underrated card.
Roman Reigns may usually be booked in p*ss-poor feuds, but when he and his opponent are on the same wavelength and ready to deliver, by golly do they deliver.
3. Vs. AJ Styles (Payback 2016)
It was the spring of 2016, and fans were rather cross.
WrestleMania 32 was an oppressively long show full of contrarian booking, capped off by a dull main event that saw Roman Reigns win the WWE Championship to a chorus of boos. Sensing this discontent, WWE promoted Payback as the start of a "New Era," and thus, the main event featured AJ Styles, who was just a few months into his WWE tenure.
Given that this was Chicago, Styles was a beloved former Indy star, and Roman was Roman, the energy in the building was very much pro-AJ and anti-Reigns. The two competitors were able to channel that energy, with Roman playing the big, domineering, almost heelish champion, and Styles the determined, agile up-and-coming babyface. As much as this was a coming-out party for AJ as a headliner, this match was a showcase for how good Roman is at selling for and working with smaller, more agile performers. After shoving Roman into slow, plodding matches with the likes of Big Show and Triple H, it was refreshing to see WWE allow the Big Dog to play to his strengths.
Of course, as good as this match was, it was marred by an over-booked finish that had the match restarted twice.
Then again, Reigns and Styles were able to rectify this weeks later...
2. Vs. AJ Styles (Extreme Rules 2016)
After the screwy finish(es) to their match at Payback, Roman Reigns and AJ Styles were given another match against each other under Extreme Rules at the aptly-named Extreme Rules PPV.
With their match at Payback being so good, expectations were high as to whether or not these two could top it. They did, and then some. This match was basically a cocktail of what makes the best Roman Reigns matches so good: a heated crowd, a more agile opponent leading things, chaotic brawling, insane weapons spots, and dazzling athleticism. Reigns and Styles showed off their incredible chemistry in a match that basically cemented AJ as a top guy despite his loss to Reigns.
The match was so good that it somehow wasn't overshadowed by the post-match angle, wherein Seth Rollins returned after healing a knee injury. People were still throwing out praise for Styles' and Reigns' performance.
Due to the brand split, AJ Styles and Roman Reigns have been kept apart for years now. It's our hope that Joe can recover from his illness and one day have that third match with the man that brought so much out of him.
1. Vs. Brock Lesnar And Seth Rollins (WrestleMania 31)
When WrestleMania Play Button came around, Roman Reigns was heading into the lion's den.
Months of being pushed against the wishes of fans culminated in his first 'Mania main event, and only the third PPV singles match of the young man's career. Fans were expecting a disaster of a match that would end with a chorus of boos as Reigns unseated Lesnar as WWE Champion.
Instead, they got an absolute classic of a main event proving, despite our continual misgivings about Roman Reigns as the top guy, he absolutely delivers when it counts, and this was Exhibit A. Reigns took an absolute beating from Lesnar, receiving suplex after suplex after suplex (this was before such a formula for Brock matches became stale). In just under 15 minutes, Reigns and Lesnar produced all killer and no filler.
And then, of course, came the iconic finish, as Seth Rollins cashed in his MiTB briefcase to make the match a Triple Threat. An intense and heart-pounding finishing sequence saw all three men perform their finishing maneuvers, with Seth picking up the pieces and pinning Roman to win the title.
The match was a work of genius performed brilliantly by all men. Roman Reigns put his coronation on hold and allowed the night to be about his former Shield brother, even taking the pinfall that made his friend champion. What many thought would be a doomed show turned out to be a classic. It's one of the many examples of Roman Reigns going into an unfavorable situation and making the best out of it.
Stay strong, Joe. We're rooting for you.