12 WWE Failures Who Became World Champion

If at first you don't succeed, then try, try again. From WWE failures to LEGENDS.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

Everybody fails at something in life, but greatness is sometimes measured in a person's ability to keep moving forwards towards success. Failure can be temporary, and all that. In WWE, failure has walked hand in hand with success for decades. Not everything is going to work. The XFL, for example, has flopped multiple times. WWE running a sports league properly is one idea we can probably put to bed!

Advertisement

That's a corporate example. For individual workers, failure can be painful and lead to a lot of soul searching. Some toiled through endless duff gimmicks or storylines that made them wonder if they'd ever turn things around, whilst others were cruelly cut loose by the biggest promotion in the land and forced to find themselves on the uncertain independent circuit.

Mentally, that can't be easy. Please know that the word "failure" in this context isn't a personal attack on any of the men and women plying their trade. They should, however, be roundly applauded for striving to improve their skills (whether inside the ring, outside on the mic or even politically backstage). That determination created unpredictable moments and World Title wins they'll cherish forever.

Some reached the mountain top a second time after that initial triumph. A few will never get there again, but they can always tell the grandkids about the time they were one of WWE's top champions. So, in many ways, their greatest achievement was overcoming outright rejection or career collapse to write their names proudly in the history books. 

Consider this a collection of wrestlers who went from the creative outhouse to WWE's penthouse.

12. Kane

Check out the face "Big Daddy Cool" has on the left there. Glenn Jacobs surely knew he was sinking as the cosplay version of Diesel as calendars turned to 1997. Kevin Nash, the original 'Big D', had left the WWF for WCW in 1996, so Vince McMahon stuck the guise on one of Jim Cornette's monsters down in Smoky Mountain Wrestling. It was never going to work, but that dude somehow became WWF Champ.

Advertisement

Granted, Jacobs didn't win the belt as "Diesel". He'd left that gimmick behind for another one by October '97. Kane debuted by ripping the door from Hell In A Cell during The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels at In Your House: Badd Blood (which was interesting considering this was the first Cell match ever!), then smashed his kayfabe bro with a Tombstone and left.

Nobody was quite sure whether or not Kane would be around after Undertaker inevitably beat him at WrestleMania XIV, but fans loved the character and it went from strength to strength. Remarkably, Kane was beating Steve Austin in a 'First Blood' match at King Of The Ring by June. He'd drop the title back to 'Stone Cold' on Raw the next night, but still - Kane had been WWF Champ, and that was something no-one could take away from him.

The same guy who'd been Jerry Lawler's evil dentist Isaac Yankem and who'd dressed up as a literal Christmas tree in Memphis was now holding the biggest title in the biz. He'd traded gimmicky flops and Halloween dress-up as other wrestlers for a niche of his own, and it led to one of the longest/most fruitful runs of any character in WWE history. 

His partner 'Fake' Razor Ramon didn't get the same creative reprieve.

11. Dolph Ziggler

Imagine being involved in one of the most flagrantly racist and unwanted gimmick packages of all time. Dolph Ziggler went through that before he was even Dolph Ziggler! For a spell, he followed Chavo Guerrero's brutally offensive Kerwin White character around as his golf caddy. Hey, a gig was a gig, and young Nic Nemeth wasn't going to rock the golf cart by questioning management.

Advertisement

Later, the caddy became a male cheerleader in The Spirit Squad. That was slightly better, but it was also something WWE's writers were never going to take seriously. Foreheads were palmed once again when Nicky introduced himself as Dolph Ziggler. Then, he introduced himself again. Then again. Then again. Then again. It got old fast, but Ziggler was clearly keen to make a name for himself.

He'd become known as a solid hand, but the stench of those prior failures hung over him like a dark cloud. By 2011, WWE had Vickie Guerrero hand him the World Heavyweight Champion on SmackDown. That was done so Edge could put the heel in his place and thumb his nose at Vickie. Dolph dropped the belt he'd just been handed on the same episode.

Ziggler had to wait until 2013 for a proper World Title stint. It was infinitely more satisfying than his first had been, although a double turn with Alberto Del Rio brought on by Dolph's concussion issues stopped him short of being the lengthy champion he wanted to be. Still, he'd successfully traded carrying golf clubs around for toting the big gold, and that had to feel good for somebody who had grown accustomed to being overlooked by decision makers.

"Hi, I'm Dolph Ziggler" worked. It actually worked.

10. Bobby Lashley

Calling Bobby Lashley a failure for his first WWE run could be harsh, and it's definitely something nobody would want to say to his face, so here's a softer approach: Lashley didn't live up to the expectations management had for him between 2005-2008, but there were loads of shocked faces when the promotion announced his departure in February '08. Big Bob had been on the bench rehabbing injuries, and now he was...gone? Just like that!?

Advertisement

It was true.

Bobby wouldn't make his WWE comeback until 2018. Even then, he sputtered along offering decent (but not great) performances and was involved in some God awful storylines with otherwise awesome workers like Sami Zayn. That whole "Lashley's sisters" thing had to be seen to be believed. It didn't quite jolt Bob's career or hand him the likeable personality Vince McMahon had hoped it would.

Just when it looked like Lashley might be a midcarder for life, he beat The Miz to become WWE Champ on the 1 March 2021 episode of Raw. That was a star-making night for Bobby. He looked like a million bucks en route to winning the big one, and he'd go on to hold the prize for just shy of 200 days.

A second WWE Title reign followed in 2022 when he beat Brock Lesnar at Royal Rumble. That run was shorter (approx 3 weeks), but the first had been so strong that it didn't really matter. Lashley had finally come through on the promise he showed during his earliest months back in '05. WWE bosses had to be pleased they eventually squeezed some value from him.

9. JBL

The hard-nosed grind of the European circuit was fresh on big Bradshaw's mind when he signed on with the WWF in late-1995. Back then, the company was going through a down period, but it still offered more hope to the rough and tumble Texan than low-paying bar-style brawls in Germany could ever hope to. Maybe things were picking up in his pro wrestling career, eh?

Advertisement

Or not. An early undefeated streak gave way to mediocrity as 1996 developed. Vince McMahon's new Stan Hansen rip off was as lower tier as you were likely to get from somebody who wasn't an outright jobber, and there didn't seem to much room for upward movement either. Then, they stuck The New Blackjacks gimmick on him with Barry Windham and the mediocrity continued.

Things did pick up when Bradshaw started a tag-team with Faarooq in late-1998, but it looked like he'd be a tag guy for life in the fed. McMahon's desperate need to create fresh new stars in 2004 led to an unlikely repackage job and main event push. Bradshaw became JBL, and it turned out to be the role he was born to play.

He'd previously failed to get over pre-Acolytes/APA, and now here he was beating Eddie Guerrero for the WWE Title. Not many could've claimed to see that coming in '04, but it happened, and it wasn't a crap call either. JBL was legitimately the hottest heel in the industry for a while, and those dismal memories of jobbing for Savio Vega faded away.

The John Bradshaw Layfield era was nigh. Unpredictably nigh, but nigh nonetheless. He'd ride that train all the way to the WWE Hall Of Fame.

8. Kofi Kingston

Randy Orton called Kofi Kingston "stupid" and WWE gave up on his push. That's pretty much the abridged version of how KofiMania 1.0 fizzled out in 2010. It also shows how one trusted worker's sway with the office can alter the entire trajectory of another's career. Post-Randy feud, Kingston was relegated back down the card and would flit between inconsequential midcard title runs and various tag-teams.

Advertisement

Then, New Day came along. On the surface, that was yet another tag run for Kofi, but it offered him peace of mind both in front of the cameras and behind the scenes. Kingston found best friends in Big E and Xavier Woods, and the trio would go on to shatter records together. Happenstance threw up an unpredictable main event reprise in 2019 as well, which was lovely to see.

Mustafa Ali's injuries forced WWE to change course. Uncharacteristically for Vince McMahon (especially during one of WWE's worst years ever), he decided to listen to the people and go with what they wanted. Thus, the deluxe edition of KofiMania was born, and he'd end up beating Daniel Bryan for the top prize in the game at WrestleMania 35.

That'll forever be remembered as one of the most organically happy WWE Title wins ever.

Kofi had flopped through no fault of his own a decade or so prior. Fast forward to 2019 and he was riding the crest of a wave as one of the most beloved babyfaces around. The less said about the way his WWE Title dreams ended courtesy of Brock Lesnar on SmackDown's FOX debut the better though, right?

7. Naomi

From "Funkadactyl" to "Proceed With Caution" and a cheerful family moment.

Advertisement

That's the lengthy journey Naomi has been on since she danced onto screens as part of Brodus Clay's new 'Funkasaurus' gimmick in 2012. At first, WWE viewed Naomi as little more than Diva-style eye candy alongside her pal Cameron. They were exclusively there to dance and smile as big Brodus tried to mesh Flash Funk with Dusty Rhodes-style charisma. How's that for a combo you didn't expect to see?!

Clay's gimmick had short term appeal, but Naomi stuck around and eventually spun out into Team B.A.D alongside Sasha Banks and Tamina. Once that experiment ended, she actually won the old SmackDown Women's Title in early-2017. That isn't the World Title win needed to grace this list though. No, that'd only come after a lot of heartache and a departure from WWE.

Naomi walked out on the company with Sasha in mid-2022. She'd seek solace in Impact Wrestling/TNA before launching a WWE return in 2024. Being honest, Naomi didn't actually turn a lot of heads when she made her comeback. Some of her matches felt less-than, and it seemed she'd always be stuck in a smiling babyface role.

The Jade Cargill whodunit mystery offered something completely fresh. Naomi was outed as the aggressor, then won the Women's World Title after cashing in Money In The Bank at Evolution 2025. She'd cut her title reign short by announcing her pregnancy on the 18 August Raw. Creatively, that was a shame (she was doing some great work and was poised for an epic run), but some things are more important than wrestling.

Serving up another future Bloodline member is one of them.

6. The Rock

Despite having a top look and being considered a true blue chip prospect internally by WWF figureheads, young Rocky Maivia was on a hiding to nothing in 1996 and early-1997. Fans grew tired of his 70s-style babyface antics very quickly, and it was clear this inexperienced rookie didn't have the smarts to get them back onside. So, he simply continued high-fiving and kissing babies like a traditional good guy would.

Advertisement

Chants like, "Rocky Sucks" and the vicious, "Die, Rocky, Die" ensued, which can't have felt good for The Rock. He'd throw that back in everyone's faces after taking time off to heal up injuries. By the summer of '97, Rocky had returned and joined the Nation Of Domination. Suddenly, he was more cocky than before, and he even started referring to himself in the third person for maximum heel points.

Man was going for the high score.

Being aloof and arrogant did great things for Rock during the second half of the year into 1998. By then, he was really coming into his own both on the mic and inside the ring. At Survivor Series '98, Rocky beat Mankind to bag his first WWF Title. Shortly afterwards, he'd join Vince McMahon as his "Corporate Champ", and that only pushed his star further.

He'd come a long, long way from sucking wind as the painfully chirpy Rocky Maivia just a few years earlier. That experience was rejected so hard that the WWF might've given up on a lesser talent. Thankfully, they realised Rock's potential and gave him another chance to prove himself without pandering for cheers like his dad and Tony Atlas 20 years before him.

5. Nia Jax

The name Nia Jax was enough to send shivers up the spines of wrestling fans pre-2023. To that point, seeing yourself scribbled opposite Nia on the booking sheets must've given a few WWE stars some sleepless nights, because Jax was known for hurting her peers with clumsy ring work and brutal-looking moves at one stage. Generally, she was often pointed to when someone asked: 'Who's one of the worst workers around?'.

Advertisement

Nothing Jax touched appealed to WWE fans for years. She did win the old Raw Women's Title from Alexa Bliss at WrestleMania 34, but then creative bizarrely squashed her body positive message to turn her heel all over again. It was poorly handled, much like Nia's opponents when she'd lift them up for a Samoan Drop or some other such move. 

Groans were audible when Jax returned to the promotion full time in September 2023, but something had changed. Seemingly overnight, Nia had gone from reckless oaf with too much airtime to somebody who was actually contributing to the product. She shone opposite Rhea Ripley, helped make the debuting Jade Cargill look awesome, and seemed to have improved every aspect of her work.

Back to back Queen Of The Ring and WWE Women's Title wins (at SummerSlam) in 2024 told the full story. Nia was a different animal during this second run. Her matches started clicking, her work on the mic was confident and had purpose, and she was even elevating fresh names whilst enjoying some time in the spotlight herself. It was all win-win.

Good on Jax for changing the narrative surrounding her.

4. The Miz

The Miz is WWE's very own Mr. Reliable. Need somebody to go out there and stare at the lights without losing any credibility? He'll do it. Got a struggling young star who needs to associate with someone who has tenure on screen? He'll do it. Need a quick fix champion who won't grumble when he's asked to drop the belt? He'll do it. In short, Triple H could hand Miz a toilet brush and ask him to get to work on cleaning duty at company HQ, and he'd likely leave those bowls sparkling.

Advertisement

Wrestlers with the kind of self-determination spliced with 'know your role' approach The Miz has don't come along every day. That's why he's been able to last so long in WWE, because a lesser person would've said 'sod this' when they weren't even allowed to get dressed for matches in the locker room. That led to several embarrassing exchanges with fans for the would-be star.

Miz had the last laugh when he became WWE Champion for the first time in 2010. His rise must've come as a real shocker to those who'd written him off long before that point, both on the roster and in the stands. His jump over from reality TV for a Tough Enough spot proved shrewd, but it did inflict some agonising self-hype on fans.

People wanted to see The Miz fail. Some probably still do, but he's gone from failed Rock wannabe to one of the most tenured stars in the entire industry and a first ballot Hall Of Famer when he eventually hangs up the boots. You've got to admire the man's tenacity and ability to make the most of everything he's handed.

3. Jinder Mahal

There's no way anybody thought the guy on the left above was ever getting close to the WWE Title. In fact, the only way Jinder Mahal was getting near the biggest belt in the land was if somebody like Brock Lesnar or John Cena happened to walk past him in the hallway. They might brush against Mahal and give him a little taste of what it's like to be on top.

Advertisement

By 2017, Jinder unthinkably strutted down hallways with that title over his own shoulders.

There's no point in beating around the bush here. Mahal will always be called one of the worst WWE Champions of all time, but he does deserve a lot of praise for knuckling down and forcing management to see him differently. Jinder levelled up his physique and his mindset after returning in 2016. That went a long way with Vince McMahon, 'cause it showed that his re-hire was taking things seriously.

Previously, Mahal hadn't been. He was lagging behind in terms of overall look and presentation, and his matches as part of the 3MB faction were nothing to get excited about when he was in the ring. WWE let him go in 2014, and not many thought they'd ever see Jinder back on the roster at all let alone carrying around the richest prize going.

Mahal got his stuff together and earned respect behind the scenes. That lined up with WWE trying to expand into India, which meant Jinder beat Randy Orton at Backlash 2017. His title reign was balls, and Lesnar apparently didn't want to work with him at Survivor Series, but he still got to the top of the industry somehow.

Incredible scenes.

2. Mark Henry

There was a time when WWE higher ups were more concerned about Mark Henry's fixation on McDonald's milkshakes than what he'd be doing as World Heavyweight Champion. Jim Ross has spoken about Henry's trials and tribulations via his 'Grilling JR' show, and it's a fascinating listen. The then-WWF had high hopes for Mark when they inked a deal in 1996, but he struggled to live up to that.

Advertisement

So, Henry floundered whether he was in the Nation Of Domination, being reborn as 'Sexual Chocolate' so he could impregnate Mae Young with a human hand (?!) or performing impressive feats of strength on SmackDown. WWE just couldn't get much bang for their buck with the big powerhouse. Then, in 2011, something clicked. Well, pinning it all on 2011 perhaps doesn't tell the full story.

In truth, Mark had started to show signs of life whilst ECW Champ a few years before that; it's just that few cared for the offshoot ECW brand, and the belt wasn't credible. By beating Randy Orton at Night Of Champions 2011 though, Henry rocketed up that credibility scale. His 'Hall Of Pain' gimmick was fearsome and believable, and it coincided with Mark doing the best work of his entire career.

Finally, some value from the 1996 Olympian.

We're talking about the same man who was sent down to developmental because WWF staff thought he just didn't have a grasp on the fundamentals...4 years after his debut! A full 15 years into his career, that "something clicked" and the genuine strongman proved he belonged in the upper echelons of WWE.

His 2013 retirement ruse was outstanding too, for the record. "You think it's that easy?!".

1. Drew McIntyre

On the left: An under-confident and directionless member of 3MB. Many enjoyed the faction's zany vibe and underdog feel, but running with Heath Slater and Jinder Mahal was a far cry from being dubbed Vince McMahon's "Chosen One" a few years earlier. Come 2014, by his own admission, Drew McIntyre was drinking heavily and understandably struggling with the weight of his mother's passing in 2012. WWE released him into the wilds and he had to rebuild his career on the independents.

Advertisement

On the right: WWE Champion and one of the best all-rounders in the biz. Drew turned his life around to get in the best physical shape he'd ever been in, went on a crusade across the globe outside WWE, and showed that he was very much well worth re-signing. In 2017, he made his comeback via NXT, but it wasn't long before McIntyre was tearing it up on the main roster and winning major championships.

Drew graced a lot of lists looking at 'what might've been' for discarded WWE stars between 2014-2017. It looked to most like he'd blown his opportunity to become the first ever Scottish WWE Champ, but McIntyre maybe needed a kick in the arse to set him on the right path. He deserves full credit for clawing his way back near the top, then for smashing through the barrier to become a multi-time WWE Champion.

The Scot was all over the place mentally and probably physically when he left WWE in 2014, but he refused to throw the towel in on his dreams and has reaped rich rewards for backing himself. Publicly, he's praised his wife for standing by his side and helping him to reprioritise his life.

What a redemption story.

What other WWE failures went on to become World Champions? For more wrestling, check out 15 Exact Moments WCW Booking Stopped Making Sense and 8 New Directions For WWE After Clash In Paris 2025! 

Advertisement