6 Most Insane Wrestling Reports Ever Published

When wrestling was literally unbelievable: featuring Vince McMahon, the Ultimate Warrior, and more…

By Michael Sidgwick /

Pro wrestling is a secretive and gossipy industry that locks up with the rumour mill on a never-ending spot show loop. You’ll read wild, borderline unhinged stuff every single day. WWE replaced the Ultimate Warrior with a doppelgänger in 1992! CM Punk banned the joshis from appearing on AEW Collision! TNA will overtake AEW as the number two promotion in the United States!

Advertisement

None of this stuff is supported by a paper trail. People just like to make stuff up for attention. The stories contained herein, however, are different. 

Note that this isn’t a collection of the most shocking news stories that have ever broken. You won’t read about the Chris Benoit double murder suicide here, as heartbreaking and earth-shattering as it was. This is a lighter list with two qualifying factors for entry: 

1) There is no way that the story described could have ever happened in a million years, but

2) either the subject or the reporter believed that it could have. 

This is a list covering the stories you can’t believe anybody ever believed. 

Another thing needs to be made very clear: the Wrestling Observer’s Dave Meltzer is the architect of this space. This wouldn’t be written without his influence; you probably would not even be here if he hadn’t shattered the veneer of kayfabe in the 1980s with his groundbreaking and exhaustive work. Nobody is sh*tting on Dave here. You’d have to be very misinformed not to recognise the brilliance of his best work. 

However, the guy has on occasion burst through a wall, dropped his glittery stormtrooper helmet, and fell flat on his fooking arse…

6. Raising The Dead

You’re a wrestling fan. This information might be confidential to you, because it’s a bit embarrassing. You don’t want people to think you are dumb enough to think it’s real, even though you don’t. It’s best to just avoid the topic altogether. If you do disclose your hobby of choice, you are invariably met with two questions:

Advertisement

1) You know it’s fake, right? 

2) Is the Undertaker still in it? 

The second, more polite question is posed by a lapsed fan who dropped out when they reached adolescence. This person usually does not know their asshole from their El Hijo del Vikingo, but they mean well. At least they’re not calling you thick. This person has no knowledge of the current scene, but this person is also amongst the most influential people on it, because this person is a high-ranking Saudi Arabia official who, according to the May 3, 2018 edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, requested two specific names for the titular Greatest Royal Rumble - the first sportswashing exercise in the Saudi Arabia relationship. 

Proving that even disgusting promotional tactics have their funny side, one official requested that Yokozuna, the Ultimate Warrior, and the Undertaker appear at the show. There was just one problem: the Warrior and Yokozuna had been dead for a combined 22 years. This official was supposedly so adamant about Yokozuna that, according to whispers, WWE basically plucked an imposter out of fat air and called upon Hiroki Sumi to do the honours. Sumi wasn’t even a Performance Center prospect or anything. He was just a sumo wrestler, presumably the first to agree to the payday. 

WWE didn’t bother trying to get anyone to play the Ultimate Warrior for the night, but if this happens again, and they need somebody who is worse than useless but popular with children regardless, they could always attach some tassels to Jey Uso.

5. WHO Thought Vince McMahon Died In A Wrestling Angle?!

Every adult knows that professional wrestling is a work. We all just play along like others do with movies and TV shows. 

Advertisement

Kids are either told this by a spiteful schoolyard peer, work it out for themselves, or are let down gently by their parent or guardian, who might fret over the idea of their darling child getting bullied for being such an oblivious idiot mark.

Most of the time, wrestlers don’t get bruised despite absorbing repeated strikes to the face. They go several conspicuous years without blading, depending on which demographic the promoter is chasing. Wrestlers stand around waiting to catch dives instead of simply moving out of the way. When a wrestler in WWE gets punched, they theatrically throw themselves to the mat and immediately pop back up, several times, to take yet more strikes. This is dumb enough as it is, but it’s even more stupid when one considers that colliding with the mat otherwise is meant to really hurt and incapacitate them. The thing about wrestling is that, the more you think about the mechanics of it, the less it makes sense. You have to be attuned to its wavelength. You have to ignore how stupid that it fundamentally is when you are swept up by its strange magic. Nobody past a certain age thinks that it is real - with the unfortunate exception of the profoundly influential leader of the free world. 

When Vince McMahon was blown up in the abandoned limo explosion and death angle, nobody believed it. If this had actually happened, and the cameras just happened to very conveniently catch it, you still wouldn’t have seen it; the several-seconds tape delay would have spared you. In addition to that fact, it was the most obviously staged ratings grab imaginable. 

Donald Trump believed it, and it wasn’t just Dave Meltzer reporting that; Triple H confirmed years later that a panicked Trump called WWE to check whether Vince had survived. 

“It was a big explosion, wow. They’re saying it was the biggest explosion. Vince was very strongly blown up, like a firework, high in the sky. Now I want to know who did it. There are very bad people in WWE, very bad. You know some of them break the rules. That Carlito, he’s crooked. Referee turns his back, and he cheats, it’s terrible. Very terrible. Very dishonest. He does not play by the rules at all. One of the great sleazebags of our time.”

4. Oh, Dave

Back in 2017, Kenny McIntosh, of Inside The Ropes magazine and live events, attended a WWE house show in Glasgow, Scotland. He tweeted a joke. When the show arrived at half-time, and the production staff displayed an ‘INTERMISSION’ graphic, the WWE logo was positioned above it. It looked not unlike a pay-per-view logo, which Kenny had a bit of fun with, jesting that WWE had announced what would have then been the first canon pay-per-view on UK shores since SummerSlam 1992. 

Advertisement

This was a joke. It did not even qualify as a hoax because the word ‘Intermission’ is almost the antithesis of a cliched wrestling show name. ‘Intermission’ is close to an antonym of ‘Action’, which is what promoters tend to go for when naming an event. Without second-sourcing the tweet nor stopping for a solitary second to consider what the word ‘Intermission’ means, Dave Meltzer blabbed it as fact on Observer Radio before he was roundly buried and forced to issue the funniest correction of all time. No, WWE wasn’t going to run a pay-per-view that would consist entirely of breaks. That would not happen until WrestleMania 42. Poor Dave fell for what wasn’t even a hoax.

This wasn’t the only social media gag that Dave thought was real, either. One NJPW fan was jazzed when Kazuchika Okada tore off his flared trousers to reveal the return of the trunks at Wrestle Kingdom 2013. In an exaggerated meme post, they inserted the trunks reveal over footage of fans in a pub throwing their pints in the air in celebration of an England goal at the Euros. 

Dave must’ve thought Okada was as big as Matt LeBlanc in England. 

3. The Ultimate Warrior’s Last Promo Was Nearly EVEN MORE EERIE

The Ultimate Warrior’s last public words were infamously haunting. He cut a promo on the Raw after WrestleMania 30, immediately out of breath and looking an alarming shade of red under an ill-fitting child’s replica mask, and spoke as if at peace with his own mortality, resigned to and even accepting of the inevitable. 

Advertisement

“Every man’s heart one day beats it final beat, and his lungs one day breathe their final breath - and if what that man did in his life makes his blood pulse through the body of others, and makes them believe deeper in something larger than life, then his essence, his spirit, will be immortalised.” 

Warrior’s promos were never not strange, but this was different. He wasn’t talking about intergalactic combat mumbo jumbo. He was performing a eulogy for himself, when he was alive, and died the very next day. It was one of the most eerie moments in wrestling history. It was almost even more ominous. 

According to the Warrior’s agent, Stephen Wilton, who spoke with the Caiman Show in 2021, Warrior wanted to do “this Undertaker thing” either at WrestleMania or on the subsequent Raw. Wilton was vague, but stated that Warrior wanted “to be like carried away, gong, and the Ultimate Warrior wouldn’t be there anymore”. Triple H refused Warrior’s request, reasoning that WWE had only just welcomed him back into the fold. A symbolic onscreen death would have prevented Warrior from making further appearances, or at least made writing around them a tricky process. 

So in essence, the Warrior performed his own eulogy on the Raw after WrestleMania - but actually wanted to stage his own funeral a day before his actual death.

2. BREAKING: MEGA DREAM MATCH CONFIRMED FOR WRESTLEMANIA 40!!!

Dave Meltzer is getting on a bit and essentially built the pro wrestling media empire, like a dirtsheet Rikidozan, by himself. He did this pre-internet. At one point very recently, he still used a computer monitor that was bigger than JD McDonagh’s head, and he still likes to use a pen to make his notes. His office floor is more papered than SummerSlam 2026. While the Wrestling Observer Newsletter is distributed only in digital format these days, Meltzer doesn’t seem to be the most tech-savvy guy in the world - which might explain why he got worked by a YouTube thumbnail in 2024. 

Advertisement

Dave covered the WrestleMania 40 press conference in Las Vegas, in which the Rock turned heel after his Bloodline powerpoint presentation and essentially owned the fact that returning to take Cody Rhodes’ place was a wildly misjudged idea. But Dave had a scoop! WWE had actually filmed a confrontation between the Rock and Triple H in which both men, face-to-face, said they’d love to run it back at WrestleMania, in front of a gigantic crowd, one more time. This didn’t air on TV, but it was all over social media. 

Holy sh*t! Triple H is going to wrestle despite being forced into retirement after his life-threatening cardiac event in 2021 - and he’s going out in style, against the Rock! That is absolutely huge!

Nope: Dave stumbled upon a backstage interaction between the Rock and Triple H on SmackDown. In a YouTube clip. A YouTube clip from 2014, which was basically them setting up some talking bullsh*t at WrestleMania 31. Dave might go on YouTube next, confuse an old match for something that just happened, and report that Roddy Piper has come back to life.

“It’s like, I’m not sure if he’s still got it. A lot of his stuff won’t fly today. And I mean a lot. But, you know, we’ll see.”

1. They Took Shibata’s Brain

At NJPW Sakura Genesis 2017, Katsuyori Shibata aimed a headbutt at Kazuchika Okada in their seminal match - a match that was literally too good, in that it was so violent and gripping that it wasn’t worth it. It crossed a line into both otherworldly drama and life-threatening reality. As Okada crumpled to the mat, the camera closed in on Shibata’s face. Blood trickled down his forehead as he adopted an instantly iconic, ultra-hard pose. This show of badass posturing obscured that Shibata had split his head open internally. The subdural hematoma he suffered, in tandem with severe dehydration, caused him to lose feeling in the right side of his body. His life was only saved when he received immediate emergency surgery after the bell rang. 

Advertisement

According to the NHS, there are two ways in which this surgery can be performed; either a small section of the skull is removed to enable the removal of the hematoma, or the hematoma is sucked out through some small, drilled holes. Not that you need to Google this within seconds to find out, but this surgery does not necessitate the removal of one’s brain. That is because the removal of one’s brain would result in the rapid collapse of every function, leading to near-instant death. 

Dave Meltzer reported in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter that Shibata’s November 2022 return was more improbable than most because, when he underwent the procedure, the surgeon had to remove his brain before putting it back in. You literally do not need to be a brain surgeon to know that this is impossible. What an incredible mental image Dave conjured with this.

This was one of Dave’s most embarrassing ever moments. It is the dumbest thing he’s ever said - amongst the dumbest things anybody has ever said - and yet, people still give him grief for his supposed anti-WWE bias. 

“Sure, Dave said that somebody got their brain removed during surgery - but it’s even dumber that Kurt Angle never had a five-star match!”

Advertisement