WWE 2K25 Review: 11 Ups & 3 Downs
The Island may disappoint, but WWE 2K25 is another excellent effort.
With WWE on its annual Road to WrestleMania, that often means one thing for gamers: a new WWE 2K video game release.
On the back of a couple of great games, WWE 2K25 has a lot to live up to, not least with how particularly strong WWE 2K24 was. For some, 2K24 was an all-time classic, and so there's plenty of pressure already stacked on this latest offering from 2K and Visual Concepts. Even more so, the marketing for WWE 2K25 went hard in promoting a brand-new game mode known as The Island, with this Roman Reigns-fronted mode promising to change the landscape of wrestling games.
Speaking of Roman, it's the Tribal Chief and his wider family who take centre-stage in this year's Showcase, as players get to run through some of the matches that shaped the career of Reigns, The Rock, Yokozuna, Umaga, and various other members of the Samoan Dynasty and its offshoots.
Elsewhere, the previously much-maligned MyGM mode is back, MyRise puts you in the middle of a hostile takeover, the opinion-splitting MyFaction is here for those who want the grind, and Universe lets you shape the wrestling business or just focus on the career of one particular grappler. There are new match modes, fresh characters making their series debut, and there's of course the extensive Creation Suite that is so often a major draw for these games.
So with all of that in mind, then, let's take a look under the hood of WWE 2K25 and see what's what.
Downs...
3. Showcase's Timed Objectives
It's only a minor Down, but it's something that's already caught the ire of many. Yes, we're talking about those timed objectives in WWE 2K25's Showcase.
Showcase has long featured objectives throughout its matches, with ticking off these objectives meaning you unlock new wrestlers, new variations of wrestlers, new arenas, new championships, etc. And while the regular objectives are present and accounted for in 2K25, there's the added bonus of one timed objective per match.
For example, as playing as Yokozuna in the first Showcase match, you're at one point given a 30-second window to land a couple of heavy attacks on Hulk Hogan in the corner of the ring. That in itself is pretty straightforward, but things become a little less straightforward if Hogan is out of the ring or isn't exactly cooperating. After all, the Hulkster is there to win a match, not to happily let you throw him into the corner and then launch two attacks on him.
Now, should you run out of time with these objectives, the match carries on as normal, but the catch is that you won't unlock the full selection of unlockable items attached to that particular contest.
Again, the inclusion of these timed objectives is only a minor quibble. More something that can be mildly frustrating rather than something that completely ruins the mode. Well, unless we're talking about the Money in the Bank match that you have to play with Tamina, but the less said about that annoyance, the better...
2. Still Some Iffy Character Models
To put it out there, 90% of WWE 2K25's character models look phenomenal. This is a stunning game visually, and Visual Concepts capture the spirit of the vast majority of wrestlers in truly magnificent, best-ever fashion.
However, there are a few character models that warrant a minor Down for this article. Case in point, take a look at that Chyna model above. The Ninth Wonder of the World did admittedly change up her look at various stages of her career, but that character right there? Yeah, that looks absolutely nothing like the former Intercontinental Champion.
Now, for someone like Chyna, one could make the point that the real-life Joanie Laurer is sadly no longer with us, so it's not like Visual Concepts could get one of their highly detailed facial scans. That said, there are several on-roster WWE and NXT names - Roxanne Perez and Bayley being two who immediately come to mind - that only bear a passing resemblance to their real-life counterparts, having a whiff of a PS3-era character model to them.
There's still plenty of praise to come for WWE 2K25's visuals, but we can't totally overlook some of those more ropey models.
1. The Island
Ahead of WWE 2K25's release, so much was made of the new Island mode.
Here, players would seek a place on Roman Reigns' Island of Relevancy - basically, impress Roman enough to get a WWE contract - in what was an online, open-world setting that would allow you to interact with other real-world players. And to be fair, that is what we've got, but the result is an incredibly frustrating one.
Yes, you can interact with other players. Yes, your aim is to build up enough wins and credit to catch the Tribal Chief's eye. And yes, the actual Island location itself looks impressive. The main problem, though, is that this all feels like the outer shell for yet another soulless cash-grab. As in, we're talking those pesky microtransactions.
The Island is a place for your unique wrestler, and with that, obviously comes plenty of customisation options. While you clearly don't have to fork out for them, so many items require Virtual Currency. How do you get this VC? Why, you of course have to grind, grind, grind, and grind some more, or you can drop your own cash on that swanky jacket or Nike-branded shoes. Now, that choice is up to each individual player, but it just leaves a bad taste in the mouth knowing that you're being offered an in-game piece of footwear for what equates to over £5/$5 of real-world money.
The unique setting of The Island is nicely done - even if it feels like it takes forever to get from place to place - and the quirky storefronts of the likes of Mysterio's Masks or Hurricane's Outfitters are cute, but the truth of the matter is these cute, quirky stores are very real storefronts designed to lure people in to spend their real money on a new mask for their character.
Again, all of this comes down to choice, but for all the hype and hooplah around The Island pre-launch, it all ultimately feels so soulless.
Of course, the WWE 2K series has long featured microtransactions with MyFaction, a mode that was originally going to get its own Down, but that will instead be included here with The Island. MyFaction is the same as it ever was, grinding endlessly in the hope of lucking your way to a pack that includes one of those much-lauded rare character cards - CM Punk 2010 or Rob Van Dam 1997, anyone? - with the temptation being to just splash your own cash on all of that instead.
With those cash-grabs out of the way, then, let's get to the good stuff...
Ups...
11. The Ridiculously Stacked Roster
Daft. Daft, daft, daft.
That's probably the best way to describe the sheer vastness and variety of WWE 2K25's roster.
Seriously, with unlockables, the base game has well over 300 playable characters. When you take into account the already-announced DLC releases set for later this year, that number is closer to 400 playable characters - which, again, is just absolutely ridiculous.
In terms of new additions, the likes of Jacob Fatu, the Guerrillas of Destiny, Oba Femi, Ethan Page, Lola Vice, and Kelani Jordan make their series debuts, while Showcase brings names such as the Wild Samoans, Headshrinkers, and Peter Maivia into play for the first time. And on that front, there's a who's who of wrestling greats here, from Bruno Sammartino to 'Superstar' Billy Graham, to Bret Hart, to Steve Austin, and of course various versions of The Rock.
So, current top stars of this era? Check. The rising stars of tomorrow? Check. The all-time legends of yesteryear? Double-check. Pat McAfee? Err, yeah, he's here, too.
Whatever in-ring style you prefer, whatever time period you prefer, the ludicrously stacked WWE 2K25 roster means there's something for everyone.
10. The Return Of Chain Wrestling
This one is a wider Up, not so much a personal Up.
For many long-time wrestling game fans, they've been clamouring for the return of chain wrestling. Here in WWE 2K25, those fans have gotten their wish, with you now able to lock up in a more strategic grapple with your opponent, partaking in minigames to score an advantageous position or land an attack.
Personally, I can take or leave the chain wrestling stuff - which for players like me, you can easily turn the chain wrestling system off in the Options menu - but on a broader level, this has to be an Up due to the sheer number of gamers wanting to see this brought back. So, consider this a win for the masses.
9. Easy Playability
While chain wrestling is something you can switch on or off depending on your preference, the wider gameplay of WWE 2K25 is just so easy to pick up, so fluid, and so meaty and weighty.
This is the sort of game that's easy to play but will need a little more time to fully hone your skills when it comes to reversals and minigames. And that's meant as a compliment, as you don't want something to just be a total piece of cake the first time you grab the controller. After all, it's rewarding to learn the smaller nuances and master the trickier elements of a game like 2K25.
But to circle back to that meaty and weighty, the action in WWE 2K25 feels impactful. If you're playing as a Gunther or a Sheamus, each blow you dish out feels like it's absolutely brutal. On the flip side of that, if you're, say, Rey Mysterio or Je'Von Evans, you really have to work at it to get one of those larger opponents off their feet or to do damage. It sounds extremely simple and basic, but the big guys and gals feel like the big guys and gals, while the smaller wrestlers feel like, well, smaller wrestlers - quicker, more agile, but with less power behind them.
All in all, the basic match mechanics of WWE 2K25 make the game extremely accessible, bringing a tangible feel to the moves being delivered.
8. Fun New Match Types
The ambulance match - which is once again included here - was a daft amount of fun when it was introduced in WWE 2K24 as a brand-new match type, and WWE 2K25 has brought a couple of other new matches to the table.
Firstly, the Underground match is here, with that meaning no ropes, no pinfalls, wins only by knockout or submission, and a dark, dank setting where crazed onlookers bang on the ring mat as they watch two opponents knock the crap out of each other. And much like the ambulance match, Underground is a lot of daft fun, complete with dramatic intros for each competitor and a raucous party atmosphere as and when someone finally wins.
If Undergound is fun, the Bloodline Rules match is absolute chaos in the best possible way. Pulling inspiration from the brilliantly bonkers overbooked finale of Roman Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes at WrestleMania 40 - as in, appearances from the Usos, Solo Sikoa, John Cena, Rock, and Undertaker - this match offers each competitor the chance to have up to three run-ins for them.
For example, when doing a Jey Uso vs. Gunther match, the Ring General had Ludwig Kaiser run down to interfere. That was countered by Sami Zayn on Jey's behalf, which was followed by Jimmy Uso, only for Tama Tonga and Jacob Fatu to come down and help Gunther fend off Jey, Sami, and Jimmy - which in itself was followed by none other than the Tribal Chief, Roman Reigns, coming out to even the odds.
So yes, you can have up to six computer-controlled players brawling in and around the ring with all kinds of weapons, mirroring the chaotic nature of WrestleMania 40's Night 2 main event. Even better, it's up to you as and when you want to trigger each of your run-ins, with a simple two-button combo leading to someone running down to ringside. It's also nice that Bloodline Rules will have your allies help you out or your rivals help out your opponent.
One other match type that deserves a mention here is the Backstage Brawl. Now, that's not a new mode, but it has been nicely expanded to include some brilliant WWE Archive locations. As in, you'll be backstage in rooms full of so many great WWE Easter eggs, such as the classic SmackDown fist. And let's face it, who doesn't want to gloriously throw somebody from the top of that fist and then dive onto them?
7. Take Control Of Entrances
Sometimes, the tiny, simple things can make all the difference.
Was anybody particularly calling out for players to have more control of how wrestlers' entrances were viewed? Absolutely not. Is it all kinds of fun to tinker with the camera angles as your grappler of choice make their way to the ring? 100%!
At the press of a button, you can enter into a third-person perspective that allows you the ability to rotate the camera and zoom in and out. There's also the option to switch that camera to one of several dotted around the arena, all delivering vastly different views. And with another press of a button, you can revert to the more standard animation-driven entrance we're accustomed to.
This is such a small thing, but it brings so much to the table - not least, it gives you a new appreciation for the work that's gone into creating the game's various arenas or even some of the character models.
6. Universe Mode Is Universe Mode
Universe mode is nothing drastically different to previous WWE 2K releases, with you again having the choice of focussing solely on the career of one particular wrestler or instead going the 'sandbox' route where you essentially take control of the pro wrestling world.
For the latter, you can add and remove brands and shows/PLEs, you can change up rosters, you can book matches, you can instigate rivalries, and you can just generally enjoy yourself playing as a wide variety of characters, with storylines playing out naturally and at random should you opt to not get too involved in that side of things. As for focussing on one single wrestler, that's pretty self-explanatory, with you working your way through the week-to-week wars of the business.
For those who enjoy Universe, you'll have plenty of the same to sink your teeth into in 2K25. Sure, it may not reinvent the wheel, but hey, your writer will always get a kick out of bringing back WCW and putting together a roster of '80s and '90s favourites.
In terms of minor changes, you can now create two-day Premium Live Events, and a slight tweak to the faction listings means, for example, you can have Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa be used in tag team matches while Jacob Fatu and Solo Sikoa are held back for more singles matches. Previously, WWE 2K had a habit of throwing out random combinations in those situations, such as having Tonga Loa and Solo tag up, while Tama became the more featured singles player.
5. Some Stunning Character Models
While this article has made mention of some slightly wonky WWE 2K25 character models, it's only fair that the game's better models get some praise.
To make it abundantly clear, the vast majority of 2K25 characters look absolutely stunning. From facial likenesses to body shape, to hair movement, to outfits, and even to the way a wrestler moves or their wider mannerisms, this release has captured so much of that in pretty perfect fashion.
Not just the wrestlers, though, for the elaborate arenas of WWE 2K25 look magnificent for the most part. It's easy to take for granted these days, but the game manages to translate the size and scope of those big venues WWE is regularly selling out. If you see Jey Uso doing his signature entrance, the crowd looks huge when Main Event Jey gets up on the top turnbuckle and Yeets hard.
Being able to control the camera for entrances maybe also helps in this regard, meaning you can view those arenas from angles not previously available, showing you every nook and cranny and giving you a new appreciation of the work Visual Concepts have put in on these venues.
So yes, WWE 2K25 is a beautiful, beautiful game, be it those venues, its wrestlers, or even the sleek, shiny menus and loadout screens. And if you happen to think a certain wrestler is not up to scratch, well...
4. The Creation Suite
Let's face it, the Creation Suit is something that's pretty much always guaranteed an Up when it comes to the more recent 2K games - and this year is no different.
So, if you notice one of those not-so-stunning in-game character models, chances are that some creative genius has made their own vastly superior version of that wrestler in the Community Creations. Or heck, you could even head to the Creation Suite yourself and see what you can knock out.
Where your skills are concerned, you'll also need to create your own wrestlers(s) for MyRise when you get around to tackling that story. Even then, though, MyRise has an import option where you can instead use an existing creation. Then there's The Island, where you again have the chance to create your own character, but as mentioned, that unfortunately can come at a cost.
For someone who remembers the 'select a head, select an upper body, select a lower body' basics of WWF Attitude or even those initial SmackDown games, it is forever mindblowing to see what the Creation Suites offer up these days. And as alluded to, the amazing creators in that space continue to do the lord's work, with their skills and patience meaning idiots like your writer can add a pitch-perfect CAW at the click of a button.
On that front, the above Ricky Saints from the ever-great Bhangra22man is already causing waves in Community Creations. Even at this extremely early stage, so many jaw-dropping creations have made their way online - be they wrestlers from other promotions, names from decades past, or simply those names, like Absolute, who signed with WWE too late to make the cut for 2K25.
Now, can someone make a great Tatanka already? The New Generation kid in me needs to right some wrongs and put that rascal to the main event spot he deserved...
3. Massive MyGM Improvements
For full disclosure, this writer has found MyGM to be utterly dull since it was brought back for WWE 2K22. This was a game mode, like MyFaction, that I just completely ignored unless I was playing through it for a review such as this. And that was my expectation with WWE 2K25 - spend a few hours on MyGM, see what's what, shrug my shoulders, and never open the game mode again - but man, have I been pleasantly surprised!
MyGM now feels like more than just a collection of numbers and extremely restricted gameplay. Sure, the numbers are still there - after all, the core purpose of the mode is to outdraw your opposition in dollars and ratings - but this feels like night and day when compared to last year's MyGM.
All of the General Managers of WWE 2K24, bar Ted DiBiase, are once again selectable as your avatar, and the game has nicely added Nick Aldis, Ava, Sensational Sherri, Miss Elizabeth, Armando Estrada, Mr. Fuji, and CM Punk as other options. And much like those GM options have been fleshed out, so too has the mode as a whole.
There are way more match types to choose from - some of which need to be unlocked - which means you don't feel backed into a corner to book the same matches time and time again. The challenge-and-reward system, period, just feels so more clear-cut and accessible here as well, as you look to constantly get one up on your competition.
Speaking of competition, a first run-through of MyGM saw Mick Foley's ECW completely kick my ass, but even that didn't take away from what a fun experience MyGM now is. Seriously, if you were one of those like me who had zero time for MyGM in the past, don't be sleeping on this mode in WWE 2K25.
2. MyRise Continues To Impress & Reward
Over the last couple of releases, MyRise has slowly but surely become a major favourite of many gamers, and those gamers won't just have a lot to enjoy in WWE 2K25, but they'll be nicely rewarded as you go.
Of course, those rewards can come in the shape of certain unlockables, but you'll also be rewarded by MyRise having plenty of nods and winks to previous MyRise stories. If you were invested in WWE 2K24's Unleashed or Undisputed, you'll run into several familiar faces and places in WWE 2K25.
Freshening things up, there's a slightly different approach to MyRise in 2K25. Rather than giving you a straight-up choice of playing either as a male or female custom character, those paths are instead intertwined here.
Not to give away any spoilers, per se, but you start MyRise as one character - someone Triple H is looking to lead his new era as the latest WWE Draft looms large - then soon seek backup in the shape of that other male or female character. From there, you can switch between each character with a simple button click, with one being on Raw and the other on SmackDown.
Again, we'll keep this purposely vague for fear of spoilers, but the core story of MyRise revolves around Mutiny, a mystery faction that's targeting the WWE roster and causing chaos on WWE programming. With plenty of twists and turns, it is an absolute blast. And not just that, but MyRise has a whole bunch of replayability due to how vastly different the story can play out depending on what choices you make along the way.
1. A Phenomenal Showcase
While it was The Island that was heavily pushed and promoted ahead of WWE 2K25's release, it's Showcase that's the real star of the, err, show here.
MyRise is so much fun to play through, and MyGM has made some hugely welcome improvements, but it's hard to look past Showcase when looking at the pinnacle of 2K25's modes. Last year's WrestleMania Showcase brought a nice sense of variety - there were only so many times you could play as a version of Rey Mysterio in WWE 2K22 or only so many times you could play against a version of John Cena in WWE 2K23 before things got tired - and variety is again the word of the day in this latest release.
On that front, there's only Roman Reigns who gets two matches - as well as being involved in the Bloodline WarGames - as each contest features someone new, from Yokozuna to the Headshrinkers, to Rocky Maivia, to Peter Maivia, to Umaga, to Rosey and Jamal, to the Wild Samoans, to the Islanders, to Naomi, to Tamina, to Rikishi, to the Usos, to Nia Jax. Plus, there's a nice little surprise waiting for you at the end of Showcase...
It's not just the variety that makes Showcase shine, though, for Paul Heyman does such a fantastic job of setting the table for each match, making each bout feel like a genuine big deal and likewise making each wrestler feel like a big deal. For older fans, it's great to revisit moments from yesteryear, but for younger fans or more casual wrestling fans, Heyman is brilliant in giving you the historical context behind those matches and those wrestlers.
One other minor tweak that needs mentioning, too, is that the 'slingshot tech' has been removed from Showcase this time out. Slingshot was the name used for the switch between real-life historical footage and the in-game action as you played through some of WrestleMania's biggest matches in WWE 2K24. Granted, it was a good idea in principle, but it made the gameplay experience slightly clunky. With that removed for WWE 2K25, things are far smoother now, and the matches have a more natural flow to them.
To summarise, then, WWE 2K25 is a fantastic game that, while let down somewhat by its much-hyped new mode, shines with a stunning Showcase, a hugely engaging MyRise story, a vastly improved MyGM mode, and gameplay that's so easy to pick up but may take a little while to master. Throw in the usual excess brought by the Creation Suite, and this is yet another big win for 2K and Visual Concepts.
If you're after a standard rating, it's an extremely solid 8 out of 10, a 4 out of 5, with the only slight downers being the cash-grab nature tied to MyFaction and now The Island.